"Raising" a child
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 | |
|
Re: "Raising" a child It all depends on your definition of raising. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 10:21 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Ang-Rich I agree with this: Child Raising is the process of raising and educating a child from birth until adulthood. It has recently become a very popular topic due to the necessity of clarifying the process of upbringing a child at home by parents as the opposite to the formal education of a child at school. A teacher-student relationship is different from the parent-child relationship. Therefore a parent's methods of educating a child must be different from a teacher's. At school teachers give a child general literacy and scientific knowledge; at home parents give a child general wisdom of life as parents themselves understand it. SOURCE If the grandparents were involved in the daily care of my children I would feel differently but with a daycare center I feel that the teachers are there to provide care and supervision. For my older son there is an educational curriculum. They are not teaching him their beliefs or customs. They are teaching a set curriculum. My husband and I are teaching our boys to be the people that we are...if not better. We expect them to follow our example and the rules/expectations we have in place. We introduced them to our faith and bring them to church. We lead example...their primary example. Lucas' teacher in his Prepper room last year had a tendency to use the word "stupid" in conversations with other teachers. Lucas used the word once in my presence. It was the first and last time because that is unacceptable in our home. He was reprimanded and I explained why the word was not to be used again. At school when he misbehaves he may receives a time-out or is taken out of the room but the teachers tell ME at the end of the day and I deal with the situation and behavior. It is very different. Any one of his teachers will say that my disappointment carries a reaction stronger than anything they can dish out. For my younger son...with all due respect daycare watches him. They play with him and let him play and explore the room. I put him on a schedule, I worked on sleeping him, I decide everything for him...table food, bottle changes, everything. I am responsible for his overall care and the coordination of it. The teachers watch him while we are apart. While I agree with the "it takes a village to raise a child." I also agree that the word "raise" is really "influence" at the end of the day my children are my responsibility, not theirs.. To say a teacher "raises" my children because they are with them 8 hours a day, you may as well say that their friends at school are raising them too. While daycare teachers & teacher do have a hand in teaching my children, they aren't permanent. They switch classrooms every year. DH & I are the permanent influences in their lives. I consider grandparents as part of raising them as long as they are active in the child's life. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 10:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by nrthshgrl To say a teacher "raises" my children because they are with them 8 hours a day, you may as well say that their friends at school are raising them too. I also believe many people influence the upbringing of a child but this is my main argument against saying a nanny or day care "raises" a child. I don't believe that people would consider an elementary teacher as "raising" a child. They spend many hours with a child and may "influence" them but I don't believe that they "raise" them. I feel the same way about nannys and daycare. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 10:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? Message edited 2011-02-08 11:02:58.800000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child my inlaws watched DS almost 10 hours a day, they had him the majority of the time, so yes I always considered that "raising" him. we had him on weekends and from 630-8 PM at night |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? Perhaps you would not have seen the concept of a current stay-at-home parent 100 years ago, but I would not say that makes it "unnatural". Every social and family construct we have today simply reflects the changing times we live in. I could say it is equally "unnatural" for babies and toddlers to spend the majority of their waking hours cared for by paid employees in a communal setting, while both parents are absent during that time. That is a typical daycare scenario, and a social construct like that didn't exist 100 or 1000 years ago either. But the relative newness of it doesn't make it unnatural or wrong, it just makes it current. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Janice the other boy-i was watching the clock and waiting for payday. so, what I really feel is that daycare providers, not grandparents or family, daycare providers are not raising kids...simply because they really have no vested interest in your child. I really don't like these statements. this bothers me and I am a SAHM |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? Perhaps you would not have seen the concept of a current stay-at-home parent 100 years ago, but I would not say that makes it "unnatural". Every social and family construct we have today simply reflects the changing times we live in. I could say it is equally "unnatural" for babies and toddlers to spend the majority of their waking hours cared for by paid employees in a communal setting, while both parents are absent during that time. That is a typical daycare scenario, and a social construct like that didn't exist 100 or 1000 years ago either. But the relative newness of it doesn't make it unnatural or wrong, it just makes it current. 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by nrthshgrl While I agree with the "it takes a village to raise a child." I also agree that the word "raise" is really "influence" at the end of the day my children are my responsibility, not theirs.. As a FTWM, I don't want to think think that my Mom or daycare is raising my child, it's kind of a blow to me. Maybe I view the word "raise" differently. But I raise my child with his morals, beliefs, etc. . . but daycare/my Mom/MIL influence him from day to day. So maybe the word just has different meaning to people. But at the end of the day DH & I are the ones to raise him all the way to adulthood, we are permanent in his life. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. Oh I see, I agree with this |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? Yeah this confused me too... While I agree "it takes a village" I think it's MORE unnatural for a mother to be away from her child 40+ hours a week.. this is something else you wouldn't have seen 100, 1000, etc. years ago. And I think that's the first reaction FTWMs have when they go back to work, and something you see posted here often. I'm a PTWM so I agree with both sides of the overall post topic...
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. Beth, I agree with the other posters in that I am confused by this post Being a SAHM was much more common 100 ot 1000 years ago, being a working mom is a much more recent event. Or am I reading it wrong?Confusion aside I think that because DH and I are the parents, we are raising our kids - but with a lot of help from our nanny and teachers.
Message edited 2011-02-08 11:55:46.313000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by headoverheels Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. Beth, I agree with the other posters in that I am confused by this post Being a SAHM was much more common 100 ot 1000 years ago, being a working mom is a much more recent event. Or am I reading it wrong?Confusion aside I think that because DH and I are the parents, we are raising our kids - but with a lot of help from our nanny and teachers. I think she is saying back then you most likely lived with grandparents and other relatives. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 11:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. REALLY? ![]() to being unnatural!
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Linda1003 Posted by headoverheels Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. Beth, I agree with the other posters in that I am confused by this post Being a SAHM was much more common 100 ot 1000 years ago, being a working mom is a much more recent event. Or am I reading it wrong?Confusion aside I think that because DH and I are the parents, we are raising our kids - but with a lot of help from our nanny and teachers. I think she is saying back then you most likely lived with grandparents and other relatives. Oh well then that makes perfect sense and I agree
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by JennZ Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. REALLY? ![]() to being unnatural! Jenn, come on... let her explain first before you get mad
|
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:00 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: "Raising" a child ahh. I think what Beth is saying is that nowadays, one parent staying home and being basically isolated or alone or the sole care giver is a new phenom. and I would agree. |
Posted 2/8/11 12:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybesoon Posted by Janice the other boy-i was watching the clock and waiting for payday. so, what I really feel is that daycare providers, not grandparents or family, daycare providers are not raising kids...simply because they really have no vested interest in your child. I really don't like these statements. this bothers me and I am a SAHM well, it is a business. I have never been on the other side of it...but I think if you are unable to pay that month's bill...they end their relationship with your child. That really isn't a vested interest. you left out where i posted how they are nice and care for your children, teach them..comfort them. I know I did all these things, the little boy never cried for his dad in the AMs and always had to be dragged out by his mom in the afternoons. but...it was a paycheck. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by JennZ Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago. REALLY? ![]() to being unnatural! Why is that unatural? Being with your child and being the prime caregiver is completely the most natural thing to do. This is not a debate for SAHM vs. Working moms but I dont see how you can debate that a SAHM is not natural..the word "nature" comes form natural...maybe you meant to say its not the :norm"? IM confused, are you saying people didnt d this 100 years ago? |
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by computergirl Posted by maybesoon 100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim? I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago. Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. Even 100 years ago, yes, while the mother was probably at home, she also had significant help from older siblings, grandparents, aunts, etc. I'm not saying one way is wrong or right - I'm just saying that the "village raising a child" concept, which includes parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and even daycare providers, is not a novel concept. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child When I think of "raising" a child, I think, "Who is ultimately responsible for this child?" No matter how much daycare/grandparent, etc spends with them, the parent is ultimately responsible for how that child turns out. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? I'm sorry but a parent, primarily a mother, being home raising their child couldn't be more natural and up until VERY recently was absolutely the norm. A recent notion??? Huh?? I don't know what planet you live on but even in my generation alone, and I'm only 35, I could *maybe* count on one hand what kids in school had moms that worked. The "norm" up until the last 20 yrs was that a mother stayed home and raised the kids while the father was at work making the money. People didn't have 2 income families, that's a recent development in this country and because of that it was completely the norm for a mom to be home with the kids. And this may cause backlash and feel free to flame away but I STRONGLY believe that IF YOU'RE ABLE TO there is nothing better than being the person that is home with your child day in and day out taking care of them. I understand that people need to work and I'm more than thankful to be a SAHM but please, don't even hint at the fact it's unnatural. A mother being with their child(ren) is FAR more natural than a child in day care 8 to 10hrs a day. Nobody can do a better job taking care of my child then me, plain and simple. I actually think it's a sad state of affairs in this country that maternity leave is so pathetic, that most people HAVE to work in order to survive, and that kids don't have a parent with them all of the time in these formative years. I think things were a lot better "back in the day" before 2 parents HAD to work. I don't know, call me "old school" but for me, being a SAHM was very important. My mom was home with me and my siblings and I distinctly remember liking the fact that someone was home to greet me after school, someone was always there when I was sick or had functions at school, that we always had a homemade dinner on the table, and so on. To me that was very "natural" and I cannot imagine it being any other way for when it comes to my DD. There is something to be said for being a SAHM same as their is for being a working mom. It's an age old argument and at the end of the day, it's one of those things where everyone should agree to disagree on this topic. KWIM? Edit - I also don't believe "it takes a village". I have family and friends but as a SAHM I'm on my own 98% of the time and I'm cool with that. If I moved away tomorrow I would be fine, I don't really rely on anyone other than my DH. Having family and friends around is nice but I don't *need* them to raise my DD. KWIM? Message edited 2011-02-08 13:02:26.593000. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 12:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by maybebaby Posted by Bxgell2 What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago You find it unnatural for a mom or dad to be home with a child until they are ready for kindergarten?? Or am i misinterpreting your post? I'm sorry but a parent, primarily a mother, being home raising their child couldn't be more natural and up until VERY recently was absolutely the norm. A recent notion??? Huh?? I don't know what planet you live on but even in my generation alone, and I'm only 35, I could *maybe* count on one hand what kids in school had moms that worked. The "norm" up until the last 20 yrs was that a mother stayed home and raised the kids while the father was at work making the money. People didn't have 2 income families, that's a recent development in this country and because of that it was completely the norm for a mom to be home with the kids. And this may cause backlash and feel free to flame away but I STRONGLY believe that IF YOU'RE ABLE TO there is nothing better than being the person that is home with your child day in and day out taking care of them. I understand that people need to work and I'm more than thankful to be a SAHM but please, don't even hint at the fact it's unnatural. A mother being with their child(ren) is FAR more natural than a child in day care 8 to 10hrs a day. Nobody can do a better job taking care of my child then me, plain and simple. I actually think it's a sad state of affairs in this country that maternity leave is so pathetic, that most people HAVE to work in order to survive, and that kids don't have a parent with them all of the time in these formative years. I think things were a lot better "back in the day" before 2 parents HAD to work. I don't know, call me "old school" but for me, being a SAHM was very important. My mom was home with me and my siblings and I distinctly remember liking the fact that someone was home to greet me after school, someone was always there when I was sick or had functions at school, that we always had a homemade dinner on the table, and so on. To me that was very "natural" and I cannot imagine it being any other way for when it comes to my DD. There is something to be said for being a SAHM same as their is for being a working mom. It's an age old argument and at the end of the day, it's one of those things where everyone should agree to disagree on this topic. KWIM? Come on guys.... don't go looking for drama. That is NOT what she meant, read above. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: "Raising" a child raise vs influence (the word) not sure since i am not parent but if your child spends a huge chunk of time with any individual they have a huge impact on your child. i am not sure what you want to call it but i see it as it takes a village to raise a child. |
|
Posted 2/8/11 1:02 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is anyone on here raising a bi-lingual child? | LaPetiteSirène | 1/31/07 | 21 | Parenting |
| Cost of raising a child...interesting article | caper24 | 6/15/10 | 4 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mlny | 3/20/10 | 12 | Pregnancy |
| Raising your child Vegetarian | mrsdstowe | 3/20/10 | 4 | Parenting |
| What kind of child am I raising? | nrthshgrl | 2/21/09 | 39 | Parenting |
| Is anyone raising their child vegetarian/vegan? | dm24angel | 1/16/08 | 5 | Parenting |










Being a SAHM was much more common 100 ot 1000 years ago, being a working mom is a much more recent event. Or am I reading it wrong?
I think that because DH and I are the parents, we are raising our kids - but with a lot of help from our nanny and teachers.


to being unnatural!





