Re: "Raising" a child
Posted 2/8/2011 2:32:21 PM by Bxgell2


Posted by beachgirl

but in order for it to really work effectively, a mother needs a large support system in place. T

I really don't understand this statement. Millions of moms stay home and take care of their kids by themselves every day and have been doing it for years and doing it very effectively - I am a product of a household where my mom had to give up her career when she got married and she stayed home BY HERSELF and raised 8 kids, and it did not traumatize her in any way. What outside sources would they need in order to do it effectively?



Ok, I think this is the last post I'm going to make to try to clarify/elaborate on my point because I am starting to become frustrated in this endeavor.

While millions of moms stay home and take care of their kids by themselves today, this is not typical of the human species HISTORICALLY, that is why I say it's not natural. Historically, for 99.9% of our history as a species, we have utilized the "village" concept when it comes to raising our children. This doesn't mean DAYCARE, and it doesn't mean that mothers didn't stay home with their babies. They did, but they did so within a larger social framework, with a huge network of support through family, friends, etc.

I think there's a very real and valid reason for that - it's in our DNA, in our biology, because we are SOCIAL and emotional creatures, beyond any other species on the planet. So, yes, while it is occuring today, I don't necessarily think it's natural, even if it works for someone and their family, because it goes against our social nature and upbringing, historically.

That is my opinion. I'm not saying it's wrong, I'm not saying I'm better than anyone, I'm not saying my situation is superior. I am stating an opinion, and I understand people may disagree, but I can assure you I am not making any personal attacks.


Print Post      Close Window