"Raising" a child

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

"Raising" a child

I've seen this posted over and over on the boards:
"Childcare (grandparents, daycare, babysitter, whatever) has no part in raising a child."
"You are the parent, you are the one who RAISES your child"

Not trying to start an argument here, but I just do not understand these type of statements.

A child is with a grandparent for 8+ hours a day. That grandparent has NO part in raising the child?
A child in in daycare for 40 hours a week. That daycare has NO part in raising the child?
Socialization, learning morals & values, following rules, discipline, relationships with caregivers & other children, etc.. is that not a big part of raising?

IMO child care definitely plays a big part in raising children. Why is that looked at as such a negative thing on these boards?

Posted 2/7/11 10:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I think that parents that rely on a caretaker (daycare or family or nanny, etc) don't want to feel that they are not the ones that are responsible for the values and things that their kids are learning.

I think you make a good point, but I do see a distinction. My DS is with my MIL three days a week. While I don't feel that she is raising him, I do feel that she will help to teach him things and hopefully reinforce the things that DH and I have taught him and want him to learn and how to be. I feel that those things will come from us, but of course he will be influenced by everyone that is a part of his life and the people that he spends considerable time with.

Posted 2/7/11 10:41 PM
 

laurabora
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2712 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: "Raising" a child

Well I think people generally take issue with it because it is often seen as a slam on working parents. As if having a child in daycare or being watched by someone else somehow diminishes the parents' importance.

I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.

Posted 2/7/11 10:45 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by laurabora
I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.



I completely agree with this.

Posted 2/7/11 10:47 PM
 

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by InShock

Posted by laurabora
I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.



I completely agree with this.



Maybe I don't have the same definition of "raising" as everyone else. I see what you are saying here, but I also feel that influencing = raising to a degree.

(For the record, I have 2 children in daycare and 1 child in preschool/with grandma while I work.)

Posted 2/7/11 10:53 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by julz33

Posted by InShock

Posted by laurabora
I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.



I completely agree with this.



Maybe I don't have the same definition of "raising" as everyone else. I see what you are saying here, but I also feel that influencing = raising to a degree.

(For the record, I have 2 children in daycare and 1 child in preschool/with grandma while I work.)



Yeah, I was going to say that this may just be a matter of semantics.

Posted 2/7/11 11:08 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I agree with this:

Child Raising is the process of raising and educating a child from birth until adulthood.

It has recently become a very popular topic due to the necessity of clarifying the process of upbringing a child at home by parents as the opposite to the formal education of a child at school. A teacher-student relationship is different from the parent-child relationship. Therefore a parent's methods of educating a child must be different from a teacher's. At school teachers give a child general literacy and scientific knowledge; at home parents give a child general wisdom of life as parents themselves understand it.

SOURCE



If the grandparents were involved in the daily care of my children I would feel differently but with a daycare center I feel that the teachers are there to provide care and supervision. For my older son there is an educational curriculum. They are not teaching him their beliefs or customs. They are teaching a set curriculum.

My husband and I are teaching our boys to be the people that we are...if not better. We expect them to follow our example and the rules/expectations we have in place. We introduced them to our faith and bring them to church. We lead example...their primary example.

Lucas' teacher in his Prepper room last year had a tendency to use the word "stupid" in conversations with other teachers. Lucas used the word once in my presence. It was the first and last time because that is unacceptable in our home. He was reprimanded and I explained why the word was not to be used again.

At school when he misbehaves he may receives a time-out or is taken out of the room but the teachers tell ME at the end of the day and I deal with the situation and behavior. It is very different. Any one of his teachers will say that my disappointment carries a reaction stronger than anything they can dish out.


For my younger son...with all due respect daycare watches him. They play with him and let him play and explore the room. I put him on a schedule, I worked on sleeping him, I decide everything for him...table food, bottle changes, everything. I am responsible for his overall care and the coordination of it. The teachers watch him while we are apart.



Posted 2/7/11 11:26 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by Ang-Rich

I agree with this:

Child Raising is the process of raising and educating a child from birth until adulthood.

It has recently become a very popular topic due to the necessity of clarifying the process of upbringing a child at home by parents as the opposite to the formal education of a child at school. A teacher-student relationship is different from the parent-child relationship. Therefore a parent's methods of educating a child must be different from a teacher's. At school teachers give a child general literacy and scientific knowledge; at home parents give a child general wisdom of life as parents themselves understand it.

SOURCE



If the grandparents were involved in the daily care of my children I would feel differently but with a daycare center I feel that the teachers are there to provide care and supervision. For my older son there is an educational curriculum. They are not teaching him their beliefs or customs. They are teaching a set curriculum.

My husband and I are teaching our boys to be the people that we are...if not better. We expect them to follow our example and the rules/expectations we have in place. We introduced them to our faith and bring them to church. We lead example...their primary example.

Lucas' teacher in his Prepper room last year had a tendency to use the word "stupid" in conversations with other teachers. Lucas used the word once in my presence. It was the first and last time because that is unacceptable in our home. He was reprimanded and I explained why the word was not to be used again.

At school when he misbehaves he may receives a time-out or is taken out of the room but the teachers tell ME at the end of the day and I deal with the situation and behavior. It is very different. Any one of his teachers will say that my disappointment carries a reaction stronger than anything they can dish out.


For my younger son...with all due respect daycare watches him. They play with him and let him play and explore the room. I put him on a schedule, I worked on sleeping him, I decide everything for him...table food, bottle changes, everything. I am responsible for his overall care and the coordination of it. The teachers watch him while we are apart.






ITA plus I was thinking to myself that even tho they care for my child, its still my rules they follow or I move her. Even my aunt who loves her to death knows my law is the law of the land. So in proxy I'm still the one raising her at all times.

But to say 'no part' is a bit black and white. As much as it is to say that some rather not put their kids in daycare where someone else is 'raising' them as if to imply that those FTWMs who love working are happy to be at work and are glad their children are in daycare are somehow flawed.

There was a poll recently I think about SAHM, FTWM (loving it) and FTWM (hating it/want it to change to PT, etc)

Unless I'm mistaken this group on this forum is dominantly not FTWM (loving it) .

The question of who raises our children seems to be a hot topic of debate because its a bit hurtful to say we aren't raising our children and someone else is.

Hurtful (innocent or not) can lead to defensiveness and then the sharp line of black and white statements like "Never" and "No part" "better than daycare" etc start flying around.

Every one here generally isn't out to be hurtful or insulting. Most get that and try to play nice but yeah. Sometimes it is a tad bit annoying. ha! Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-02-08 00:42:07.227000.

Posted 2/8/11 12:40 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: "Raising" a child

The line can appear blurred when we talk about daycare/grandparents, etc... "watching" the kids and the notion of "raising" a child.

Think of it this way. If your child spends 8 hours with a nanny or spends 8 hours in school, why would we concider the nanny as raising our children but not the teachers?

Parents raise their children. They decide on the values to be taught to them. Nanny/daycare are "watching" our children and hopefully folllow our directive.

I think people other than parents do help in raising a child by bringing other interactions and learning.

Just like a SAHM is not raising her children alone based on the fact that her DH works long hours. KWIM?

I would say a child is "raised" by another party if the parents are absentee and I don't mean they go to work.

Posted 2/8/11 6:57 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: "Raising" a child

I think its all about how you view the situation. I don't know.

The word "raise" can seem a bit offputting to many people i and don't blame them. If my child were in daycare all week for long hours b/c I had to work, I would never want anyone to tell me that daycare is raising my child. I think its a hurtful slam to a working mother, especially one that doesn't want to be working and would rather be home.

However...with that being said...I do think if a young child is with someone other than a parent most of the day 5 days a week, that person or place is truly instrumental in the development and growth of that child.

It's different than being 5 years or older and going to school I feel. The young years (birth-5) are all about developing skills, being taught right from wrong and setting in place the foundation that will be there for life. That is why it is so important that parents feel the choice of placement they make for a child is one they are very happy with..whether this means a parent being at home with them, or choosing care that is going to be the best for the child. Because ultimately whatever is decided (daycare, nanny, SAHM etc..) is going to be crucial in the childs development. That is how i feel. The daycare or nanny who watches that child or children full time would play a VERY big role in that childs life..not "raising" the child, but definitely helping to mold and influence the child in those early crucial years.

Posted 2/8/11 7:12 AM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I firmly believe it takes a village to raise a child. Children grow and develop due to many outside influences other than the ones in the home. School, caretakers, daycares, other family members- they all play a vital part.

I credit my son's first daycare for keeping him fed, happy and healthy in his first year. I credit this new daycare for helping me teach him many new words, how to eat on a regular chair, sleep on a cot, use utensils, etc. Too many things to name! I see us all working on the same team, toward a common goal which is helping Jake become the best Jake he can be. So corny, but I really believe it.

As a teacher, I also think I have a hand in helping to "raise" the kids in my class. I spend 6 hours a day with them! I help mold their social skills, reasoning abilities, literal thinking and critical thinking skills. It's why who your child's teacher is each year is so important.

Posted 2/8/11 7:22 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: "Raising" a child

Of course they are helping to raise your child. And I don't quite understand why people are so resident to accepting that notion. It's not, by any stretch of the imagination, a novel concept. "Villages" have been "helping" to raise children since the inception of early man. What I find more unnatural is the idea of one parent staying home by him/herself with a child until they are schoolaged, which is really a very recent notion. You would have never seen something like this 100, 1000, 10,000 years ago.

I don't at all deny that the teachers at their school are helping to raise my children, along with the other parents in their class who take them home for playmates all the time, or who report to me the funny thing Alex said to their kid the other day, or the mom in the school office who visits both my girls every day and gives me a daily update, or the teachers who HAVE become a part of the family, so much so that they invite themselves to their bday parties. They ARE our extended family and I am so incredibly thankful for this immeasurable resource, and it is exactly why childcare is the single most important decision that must be chosen with much care, thought and consideration.

Posted 2/8/11 7:36 AM
 

LauBear
LIF Infant

Member since 6/09

313 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by Teachergal

I firmly believe it takes a village to raise a child. Children grow and develop due to many outside influences other than the ones in the home. School, caretakers, daycares, other family members- they all play a vital part.

I credit my son's first daycare for keeping him fed, happy and healthy in his first year. I credit this new daycare for helping me teach him many new words, how to eat on a regular chair, sleep on a cot, use utensils, etc. Too many things to name! I see us all working on the same team, toward a common goal which is helping Jake become the best Jake he can be. So corny, but I really believe it.

As a teacher, I also think I have a hand in helping to "raise" the kids in my class. I spend 6 hours a day with them! I help mold their social skills, reasoning abilities, literal thinking and critical thinking skills. It's why who your child's teacher is each year is so important.



I agree with this 100%. I strongly believe that it does take a village to raise a child and that the daycare/preschool/teachers/grandparents etc. are all contributing to "raising" a child.

I do agree with other posters that some working moms may feel insulted by this, but both the children of working and SAHM moms will end up in school where they will be spending a large portion of their day with their teacher who, as the above poster stated, will be helping to mold their social skills, reasoning abilities, literal thinking and critical thinking skills. I think it would be naive to think that this has no effect on the child they become.

I do feel that the parents are the strongest contributors to the "raising" of a child, but definitely not the only contributors.

Message edited 2011-02-08 07:50:17.313000.

Posted 2/8/11 7:38 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I think it's really naive to say that "only YOU raise your child", and that daycare/grandma/nanny/etc is "just watching them". If that's the case then you're paying a bunch of $$$ for a whole lot of nothing. I agree with whomever said that this statement is primarily from FTWM who are unhappy with their situation and making themselves feel better.

I am a SAHM, and even I don't feel like I'm 100% responsible for the "raising" of my kids. My parents, even though they don't supply any real childcare, are an active part of the kids' lives and have had a HUGE influence on them. My DS has grown and changed in so many ways in his past 2 years of preschool, I give lots of credit to the stimulating and nurturing environment his teachers create.

It really does take a village, and to deny credit like that to all the influential caregivers in a kid's life, is kind of selfish IMO.

Posted 2/8/11 7:44 AM
 

littlebeanz
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

1667 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I agree, other people are definetly playing a major role and influence in your childs life if they are in daycare or with a sitter. Now a bad thing really but just the reality right. IM a SAHM and my parents are still involved in raising my child..

Posted 2/8/11 7:57 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

From my own experience of my childhood, it really was my parents who raised me, even though my grandmother watched me from a very young age and I was also in daycare from a young age. My grandmother influenced me. Teachers taught me. But my morals and values came from my parents. They are the ones I looked to and respected for guidance. Others may have tried, but to the extent their values clashed with my parents' values, my parents trumped. For example, my grandmother had a mean side. Not towards me or family, but towards others. Ny dad is the total opposite and made sure that those values didn't rub off on me, even though she tried. (she was or at least could be pretty hateful towards neighbors, workers in stores, etc) one day my dad came to pick me up and found me stomping on ants. He asked what I was doing. I said killing ants. Nanny said we should kill the ants. He explained to me that ants have families and feelings and what I was doing was hurtful to them, and they weren't hurting us. My parents did raise me. My grandmother took care of me, loved me, supported me and had an influence on me. Teachers taught me and impacted me in some ways. My parents made me who I am.

Posted 2/8/11 8:13 AM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by LauBear

Posted by Teachergal

I firmly believe it takes a village to raise a child. Children grow and develop due to many outside influences other than the ones in the home. School, caretakers, daycares, other family members- they all play a vital part.

I credit my son's first daycare for keeping him fed, happy and healthy in his first year. I credit this new daycare for helping me teach him many new words, how to eat on a regular chair, sleep on a cot, use utensils, etc. Too many things to name! I see us all working on the same team, toward a common goal which is helping Jake become the best Jake he can be. So corny, but I really believe it.

As a teacher, I also think I have a hand in helping to "raise" the kids in my class. I spend 6 hours a day with them! I help mold their social skills, reasoning abilities, literal thinking and critical thinking skills. It's why who your child's teacher is each year is so important.



I agree with this 100%. I strongly believe that it does take a village to raise a child and that the daycare/preschool/teachers/grandparents etc. are all contributing to "raising" a child.

I do agree with other posters that some working moms may feel insulted by this, but both the children of working and SAHM moms will end up in school where they will be spending a large portion of their day with their teacher who, as the above poster stated, will be helping to mold their social skills, reasoning abilities, literal thinking and critical thinking skills. I think it would be naive to think that this has no effect on the child they become.

I do feel that the parents are the strongest contributors to the "raising" of a child, but definitely not the only contributors.



I agree as well!

I was a FTWM and saw my kids for about 5 hours a day. They spent more time with grandparents during the week than me. Of course they were raised by all of us - it would be silly and obnoxious for me to say it was all ME.

Plus, I like to blame their bad behaviors on them as well! Chat Icon

ETA: I also agree about teachers. My daughter is constantly talking about her teacher. I use it when she's bad and say I'm going to call mrs. so and so and she usually stops whatever she's doing wrong. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-02-08 08:33:03.040000.

Posted 2/8/11 8:31 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

I agree with you Julz. It's naive to think that your child isn't picking up view, morals, ideas, etc. from the people they are interacting with day in and day out. Of course a parent is the biggest influence in a child's life however, you cannot discount the role that other people play in "raising" a child. Unless you are a F/T SAHM you better believe your child is learning many, many things from all of the other people in their life whether it be from grandparents, babysitters, or teachers in a daycare setting. It's pretty to silly to think none of those people have an influence in your child's life.

I remember when I was teaching before I had my DD parents would come up to me all the time and tell me how their kids were repeating what I said to them in school or telling their parents things like, "That's not how Mrs. B does it". When I have someone's kid 6hrs. a day, 5 days a week it's not even possible that I wouldn't be influencing their life in some way. KWIM? Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/11 8:32 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: "Raising" a child

I totally believe in the "it takes a village" concept. Even though I am a SAHM, there are tons of people my DS is in regular contact with who are all infuential in helping him grow, learn, etc.

With that said, I think we need to keep in mind the context that the "raising' issue has been said lately. There have been a lot of sad first time moms who are going back to work who feel like their job in raising their DC is being replaced by the caregivers. Which is never the case. And I think alot of BTDT moms have been trying to help these woman feel better about the changes they are about to undergo. When we work FT, PT, not at all, we as parents are the primary source of "raising" our children. The caregivers, teachers, etc IMO are supplementary to our role.

Posted 2/8/11 8:45 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by InShock

Posted by laurabora
I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.



I completely agree with this.



Semantics - but I agree w/ you Julz, to some degree the people you choose to leave your child with for 8+ hours every day are playing a huge part in raising your children -
Which is why, as a working parent, I consider VERY carefully who am comfortable leaving my kids with while I choose to go to work - Influencing IS helping to 'raise' IMO as well - but it still does not change the fact the I AM THE PARENT and it is ultimately MY responsibility to 'raise' that kid -

But that is if you're looking @ this objectively w/o passing judgement and getting defensive -

A lot of people pull the 'someone else raising my child' thing when they're taliking about why they have decided to be a SAHM - it puts the working Moms on the defense b/c it sounds like an "I'm better than you" statement (which I'd say 8x out of 10 it is NOT meant to sound that way)

Posted 2/8/11 8:51 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: "Raising" a child

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by InShock

Posted by laurabora
I do think everyone who spends time with a child influences them...but I do think the parent is ultimately the one responsible for how the child is raised.



I completely agree with this.



Semantics - but I agree w/ you Julz, to some degree the people you choose to leave your child with for 8+ hours every day are playing a huge part in raising your children -
Which is why, as a working parent, I consider VERY carefully who am comfortable leaving my kids with while I choose to go to work - Influencing IS helping to 'raise' IMO as well - but it still does not change the fact the I AM THE PARENT and it is ultimately MY responsibility to 'raise' that kid -

But that is if you're looking @ this objectively w/o passing judgement and getting defensive -

A lot of people pull the 'someone else raising my child' thing when they're taliking about why they have decided to be a SAHM - it puts the working Moms on the defense b/c it sounds like an "I'm better than you" statement (which I'd say 8x out of 10 it is NOT meant to sound that way)



ITA.

When i went back to work, if someone said that my mom was raising DD - I would have burst into tears.

But now, I am slightly saner, and I cry a LITTLE bit less so - I can see that my parents are HELPING US raise DD and for that, I am grateful.

Posted 2/8/11 8:57 AM
 

ko123
My loves!

Member since 10/07

3002 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: "Raising" a child

I agree with others that MANY people help to "raise" or influence your child's development. Daycare, nannies, family members, teachers, etc. all have a hand in teaching your child how the world works and how he/she is expected to behave in that world.

Right now DD is with her nanny 3 days a week. I feel like DH and I are "raising her" because we are with her the majority of the time and we have given the nanny certain guidance as to how we want her treated, but her nanny and anyone else who interects with her also contributes to her growing and learning...and that's a GOOD thing!

Definitely a sensitive topic for working parents, but if we really think about it-the more people who influence our children's development-the more well rounded they will hopefully be.

Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/11 9:30 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: "Raising" a child

I think the problem people have with the phrase is that it's often used as a dig at working parents, and seems to suggest these people "replace" mom in particular.

I also think many people help raise a child. From a slightly different perspective, my son gets lots of services and goes to a special ed preschool. I absolutely think these teachers and therapists are helping me raise my son, because without them, he would not be making the steady progress he is. I also know many of them love him and show him lots of affection, because he is a very cute and affectionate little guy.

I, for one, can use all the help I can get and those who think I am a bad mom because my DS is in daycare do not deserve my attention or anger.

Message edited 2011-02-08 09:39:27.890000.

Posted 2/8/11 9:37 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: "Raising" a child

I think dh, who works over 60 hours a week is raising our children.

i was a nanny for the first 2 years of josh's life.
i never ever felt i was raising the other child. i was watching our little friend.
blood sweat and tears go into josh.
the other boy-i was watching the clock and waiting for payday.

so, what I really feel is that daycare providers, not grandparents or family, daycare providers are not raising kids...simply because they really have no vested interest in your child.
not saying that negatively-they are nice and love your child, take great care of your child...but really-they aren't in it for the long haul of every child that passes through.

or maybe i am wrong and it was just the relationship i had with the boy who i watched...who i do love and spent sunday morning with at a playdate.

Posted 2/8/11 9:39 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: "Raising" a child

I agree with you.

whether we want to acknowlege it or not, there are so many factors that go in to raising a child.

I think it's an extremely good thing, and would never take from my MIL the impact she has on HELPING to raise my son.

Posted 2/8/11 9:59 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is anyone on here raising a bi-lingual child? LaPetiteSirène 1/31/07 21 Parenting
Cost of raising a child...interesting article caper24 6/15/10 4 Pregnancy
Raising your child Vegetarian mlny 3/20/10 12 Pregnancy
Raising your child Vegetarian mrsdstowe 3/20/10 4 Parenting
What kind of child am I raising? nrthshgrl 2/21/09 39 Parenting
Is anyone raising their child vegetarian/vegan? dm24angel 1/16/08 5 Parenting