No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >>

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sunnygirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by shadows

Posted by sameinitials

I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted...



Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all!



I'm guessing the media hasn't really picked this incident up because I don't think they consider it an issue of race or violating civil rights.



Al Sharpton brought this up a few times at the press conference tonight.



I think this is a very different situation. Articles I have read state he wasn't shooting at him his gun discharged, bullet ricocheted off the wall and killed him, only one shot was fired. It was a horrible beyond words accident. Sharpton really can't claim any racially motivated killing here, Not excusing it in any way but very different situation



Oh ok. I Wasn't fully aware of the facts of the stairwell incident. I heard about it initially but haven't followed it. Either way sunnygirl I agree with your comments above.

Posted 12/3/14 8:54 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Sparrow

For the people who think this officer's force was so excessive, I'm honestly curious, what was he supposed to do? That guy was huge and resisting arrest. Apparently whatever hold he was using was legal.

It was clearly an accident. If you're not having a physical battle with the cops, you're not going to have this happen.


I have to shake my head at this because I've personally seen cops physically assault someone on more than one occasion on Jamaica Avenue in Queens, in one vivid case the guy clearly had submitted and all because of a language barrier . Incidents like that stopped me from pursuing a career as a cop after the military years ago.

Posted 12/3/14 10:18 PM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

supposedly this guy had like 31 prior arrests or something of the sort.
if he didn't resist he would still be alive today
it was not a chokehold but a seatbelt hold which po's are trained for.
no one has any respect for cops anymore. i agree with the previous posters- are they supposed to be selective in whom they are arresting? should they look the other way? they are LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. they are supposed to ENFORCE THE LAW.
the guy was committing a crime.
are cops supposed to say ok no problem, have a nice day?
i just dont understand this.
i'm starting to think that this country just wants murder and mayhem.

Posted 12/3/14 10:40 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Not that ANY of these men deserve to be met with death, but STOP doing illegal things, stop putting yourself in a situation where the police need to be involved. They by NO MEANS deserve death as a repercussion for their actions, but these things would NEVER happen if they werent doing something illegal (no matter how benign) to begin with.

Message edited 2014-12-03 22:42:05.677000.

Posted 12/3/14 10:41 PM
 

ShhhTTCin11
3 under 3?!

Member since 5/11

2229 total posts

Name:
Coleen

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

It is very sad that Garner is dead, but he put himself in a horrible situation.

I don't think he deserved to die, but I also don't think it was intentional. I'm glad the cop wasn't indicted.

Posted 12/3/14 10:51 PM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I'm POSITIVE no cop goes to work and says I want to kill someone today.
Cops just want to come home safely to their families after dealing with the worst of the worst every day.
Even though po panteleo wasn't indicted, he has to deal with the guilt of a death, likey years of legal action and fees on probably no salary bc he won't be able to work again.
Unless you are a cop or a family member you have no idea what it is like to walk 8 hours in their shoes at their jobs. And therefore no right to an opinion on what you may have done.

Posted 12/3/14 11:12 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by Ayne11


His last words were "I can't breathe, I can't breathe" then he died.

It's just so sad, I can't even watch that video anymore.



I hate to be a cynic, but do you know how many suspects say that when resisting arrest and law enforcement has to use physical force to subdue them?



So every time someone says, "I can't breathe" the officer should ignore it, not check his actions to see if he is in fact, not breathing?



This could be putting the officer's life at risk, if they were to stop every time someone says that, which is often. This man was twice the size of these other cops, and resisting arrest. What exactly do you expect cops to do when someone that large amd powerful is resisting?

Posted 12/3/14 11:39 PM
 

LeeCR7
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

138 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

This is a hard one to judge because the grand jury transcripts have not been released. Hopefully the information they were given warranted no indictment.

I have a lot of sympathy for African-Americans, who see this as a pattern of injustice. It saddens me to hear people dismissing it as an annoyance to them, to have to hear about another case, etc. Even if you don't agree with their interpretation of a particular case, think about how it must feel to constantly feel marginalized and to feel that justice continually passes you by. There is no excuse for rioting, but every reason for legal protest.

Posted 12/4/14 3:19 AM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sunnygirl

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by shadows

Posted by sameinitials

I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted...



Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all!



I'm guessing the media hasn't really picked this incident up because I don't think they consider it an issue of race or violating civil rights.



Al Sharpton brought this up a few times at the press conference tonight.



I think this is a very different situation. Articles I have read state he wasn't shooting at him his gun discharged, bullet ricocheted off the wall and killed him, only one shot was fired. It was a horrible beyond words accident. Sharpton really can't claim any racially motivated killing here, Not excusing it in any way but very different situation



Those aren't the facts I heard, but I brought that incident up not as an example of a racially motivated act (though you certainly can make the argument that the project is mostly African American so the cop assumed that he was African American), but more of a situation where a cop clearly did something wrong (bc no matter how the shot killed him the gun should never have been out of the holster in the first place) to someone who was doing absolutely nothing wrong.

Posted 12/4/14 6:31 AM
 

PaddysGirl
Little princess is here!

Member since 4/07

5923 total posts

Name:
Crystal

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by MsSissy

So I can hand out free loose cigarettes but I can't sell loose cigarettes?

Ok got it.




Take it up with the FDA. Chat Icon

But that's not what the case brought before the grand jury was about.



Oh I realize thats not what was brought before the grand jury.
Just trying to make sense of why the sale of loose cigarettes started the whole situation.

et's: never realized you can get arrested for that. Always thought it would just be a ticket.



Just like a business can get in trouble for selling untaxed cigarettes what this guy was doing is illegal.

I fully agree with the decision.

Message edited 2014-12-04 06:47:09.077000.

Posted 12/4/14 6:45 AM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Horrible decision. For those wanting to read the transcripts what exactly can it say to make this "ok". Video speaks for itself IMO this was way too much force on this man that lead to his death. It's murder.

Posted 12/4/14 6:59 AM
 

Mushesgirl
Too blessed to be stressed

Member since 4/09

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by BigB

Posted by sameinitials

I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted...



That is going to be ruled an accidental shooting...rookie cop..no clue...shouldn't even had his weapon drawn!

But, I think I am in the minority here....when the cops say multiple times, "Don't move or I will shoot" or "Hands up, Police" in your best interest, you should stop and follow directives. When you don't, you risk the risk of being shot and then killed. Sorry.

Each and every day, these men and women go on the streets and protect the general public. There are some crazy ass people out there and I would be nervous as all hell.

My job calls for me to travel into some not so great areas of the bronx and brooklyn, and I will not lie, I get nervous all of the time. I can't even imagine what the Police feel like. Each and every decision they make is judged. You have a split second to make a decision. Your life or his/hers.

Not an easy job and I am sure it will be another job where the applicants decrease b/c they don't want to be put in certain situations.

Yes, I am sad this man lost his life. But he had a choice too and he didn't choose wisely.



I also work in some of the worst projects/neighborhoods in Manhattan and the Bronx. I see a lot of craziness that goes on (during the day mind you!). I can't imagine what it takes to police these areas.

It's very easy for people who don't know what it's like to sit back and armchair quarterback every move.

He resisted and gave them no choice.

Posted 12/4/14 8:00 AM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.

Message edited 2014-12-04 08:36:16.117000.

Posted 12/4/14 8:34 AM
 

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Message edited 2014-12-04 09:03:32.500000.

Posted 12/4/14 9:02 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I too worked in a high crime neighborhood for a long time and know it is really challenging and dangerous to deal with gangs and drug dealers and illegal guns, etc. But I have also watched the video and there's just no way I think what happened was justified. It should have gone to trial. It's hard to understand how the officers who killed Amadou Diallo had to go to trial (which I think was warranted) and this officer doesn't.

Posted 12/4/14 9:03 AM
 

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I believe the Grand Jury didnt see enough evidence to indite the officer. After reading the defintions of Choke hold verse Lateral vascular neck restraint I can see why they may not have indited him. They probably had to read the definitions and watch the video multiple times to come to the conclusion.
Here is what I found.
Use in law enforcement:
The lateral vascular neck restraint is still a widely taught and utilized blood restriction hold in law enforcement, and can be performed from behind the suspect (or from the front when the officer is "on top" of the suspect) by putting an arm around the neck of the suspect, with the crook of the elbow over the midline of the neck. By pinching the arm together while assisting with the free hand, the carotid arteries and jugular veins are compressed on both sides of the neck. This hold does not put any pressure on the airway, but an improperly applied hold could quickly turn into an air choke if the person being restrained resists the hold by attempting to turn around.

So i see if this move was improperly applied then it would be a choke hold. IDK, I cant say what I would have decided on the grand jury. I thought it waould have at least made it to a trial.

Unfortunatley this man lost his life for doing something illegal. The officers were doing their job by responding to a complaint from the store he was in front of. When confronted by the police officers he should have complied with their orders but instead resisted arrest. If he chose to listen to them and put his hands behind his back and be arrested he would still be here today. I am sad that he lost his life! I am sad for his family. But unfortunatley the Grand Jury did not see enough eveidence to indite him on the charges being brought up. Anyway, I understand the need to protest. Its our right to do so! But just hope people so it peacefully and no one else gets hurt.Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 9:17 AM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

You couldn't pay me a million dollars a year to be an NYPD officer. These guys have it so bad. I have three family members in force and the stories and situations they endure on a day to day basis are dangerous and terrible....... and for what??? A lousy pay check and no respect or support from the community you protect and serve. Of course, there are dirty cops out there but the vast majority are good people working to feed families. I just hope we as a country, state, city and community we don't loose sight of that.

Posted 12/4/14 9:35 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.



How do we know that it was extreme force though? If it were, in fact, the permissible hold (and not the illegal one), how can we say it's extreme? What kind of change in tactic is appropriate if the officer is doing something per protocol? I don't know... I don't think it's as easy to act on a moment's notice as civilians may think it is. It's easy to judge after the fact but I would think anyone, in the moment and having to use extremely quick judgment, would do what their training calls for.

Posted 12/4/14 9:42 AM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by bunnyluck

You couldn't pay me a million dollars a year to be an NYPD officer. These guys have it so bad. I have three family members in force and the stories and situations they endure on a day to day basis are dangerous and terrible....... and for what??? A lousy pay check and no respect or support from the community you protect and serve. Of course, there are dirty cops out there but the vast majority are good people working to feed families. I just hope we as a country, state, city and community we don't loose sight of that.




I have family on the force.

I very clearly understand that there are good cops and bad cops. But it seems like the "bad" are starting to outweigh the good. And people understandably can lose faith.

This is setting a dangerous precedent. It's not fair to the good cops out there, but this turning into an epidemic.

Posted 12/4/14 9:43 AM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Kitten1929

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.



How do we know that it was extreme force though? If it were, in fact, the permissible hold (and not the illegal one), how can we say it's extreme? What kind of change in tactic is appropriate if the officer is doing something per protocol? I don't know... I don't think it's as easy to act on a moment's notice as civilians may think it is. It's easy to judge after the fact but I would think anyone, in the moment and having to use extremely quick judgment, would do what their training calls for.



If someone died as a result, it was extreme. He was uncooperative and unarmed, but not aggressive. So there was no way for Pantaleo to release his grip slightly, no way to lighten up enough so that Garner could breathe while still keeping him subdued? Garner wasn't running, wasn't getting physical with the officers, so why did they feel the need to use such force? There weren't other tactics that they could have used?

Posted 12/4/14 9:47 AM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!

Posted 12/4/14 9:54 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Kitten1929

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.



How do we know that it was extreme force though? If it were, in fact, the permissible hold (and not the illegal one), how can we say it's extreme? What kind of change in tactic is appropriate if the officer is doing something per protocol? I don't know... I don't think it's as easy to act on a moment's notice as civilians may think it is. It's easy to judge after the fact but I would think anyone, in the moment and having to use extremely quick judgment, would do what their training calls for.



If someone died as a result, it was extreme. He was uncooperative and unarmed, but not aggressive. So there was no way for Pantaleo to release his grip slightly, no way to lighten up enough so that Garner could breathe while still keeping him subdued? Garner wasn't running, wasn't getting physical with the officers, so why did they feel the need to use such force? There weren't other tactics that they could have used?



I respectfully disagree that if someone dies it was extreme. I know how strongly you feel about this and I of course agree that all lives matter - that's not in question. If someone has pre-existing medical conditions and die as a result of the same tactic, which if used on a person with no medical conditions would not result in death, then I don't think it's fair to say it's extreme.

I don't know if there are other tactics they could have used - that's my point. It's easy to say they should have used another tactic, but neither of us know whether there was something else appropriate that could have been done.

Posted 12/4/14 9:59 AM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?

Posted 12/4/14 10:03 AM
 

cowgirlkate
Twins times TWO!

Member since 1/11

1197 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

If you are not a law enforcement officer, and you have never tried to arrest an extremely large man who is resisting, I don't think you get to give your two cents on how they should have done it.

Posted 12/4/14 10:03 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes.

I was taught to obey the law. That includes it's enforcers. I get pulled over, I automatically turn on interior light, shut off my car, put keys on the dash and put both hands on the wheel. I ask if I can go into my bag or glove for the necessary papers they are asking for.

As a teenager, I wasn't the nicest of kids. Hung out on the streets with people who weren't very law abiding. When cops would pull up on the sidewalk and tell us to go up against the wall, guess what? I went up against the wall, hands up and waited to be instructed on what to do next.

So yes, I would listen to what the police officer has asked me to do. Resisting arrest makes the other person at fault 99.9% of the time. If there was no resisting, we wouldn't be here discussing this right now.

Also, I'm curious. Are people saying that if this man was a white guy, same build, same situation, that this cop wouldn't have used the same force to subdue him? If so, why do you believe that? I have a family member who is a big guy and not a very law abiding citizen... there has been excessive forced used to subdue him in the past and now... he listens when a cop tells him to do something.

Message edited 2014-12-04 10:14:27.280000.

Posted 12/4/14 10:13 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Homeless man that got shoes from NYPD cop Aubreysmommy 12/3/12 48 Families Helping Families ™
NYPD cop in White Catle case dies. 04bride 2/8/06 13 Families Helping Families ™