No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 5 6 7 [8] | |
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MandJZ In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. I read something today that the reason for this is that police officers in the line of duty are not held to the same standard as a regular citizen. I have not had the time to actually research this but I see some valid reasoning behind it if it is true. And if it is true then that would be a big reason why the statistics are very slanted. If I have time and find out if the standard is actually a regulation in place and will update all! |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:13 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by sameinitials Posted by buttercup Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?! Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says? Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period! I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply. And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for? For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders. Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today. Actually, yes. The officer should have to explain. If a police officer approaches me and tries to search me with no explanation, I will respectfully decline, as is my right. If the police officer says "there was a burglary in this area and the suspect was wearing a coat like yours and the same shoes. Can we check your bag?" I would say yes, here, because I didn't burglarize anyone. That's exactly what the law says. We can not be stopped and searched without due process. That is our right. Even if we look like someone who may have committed a crime. That's why there are search warrants and arrest warrants. Let's agree to disagree. I appreciate, as you always are, very respectful when responding to these types of threads that have a tendency to get out of hand. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by sameinitials Posted by buttercup Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?! Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says? Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period! I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply. And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for? For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders. Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today. Actually, yes. The officer should have to explain. If a police officer approaches me and tries to search me with no explanation, I will respectfully decline, as is my right. If the police officer says "there was a burglary in this area and the suspect was wearing a coat like yours and the same shoes. Can we check your bag?" I would say yes, here, because I didn't burglarize anyone. That's exactly what the law says. We can not be stopped and searched without due process. That is our right. Even if we look like someone who may have committed a crime. That's why there are search warrants and arrest warrants. Let's agree to disagree. I appreciate, as you always are, very respectful when responding to these types of threads that have a tendency to get out of hand. Thank you And definitely, we can disagree! There's beauty in seeing every different point of view. You and I don't need to handle every situation the same way. It's what makes us all our own person.
|
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by alli3131 Posted by MandJZ In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. I read something today that the reason for this is that police officers in the line of duty are not held to the same standard as a regular citizen. I have not had the time to actually research this but I see some valid reasoning behind it if it is true. And if it is true then that would be a big reason why the statistics are very slanted. If I have time and find out if the standard is actually a regulation in place and will update all! That's interesting. If that is true, I honestly think it would be very troubling to me. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by LeeCR7 Posted by cowgirlkate If you are not a law enforcement officer, and you have never tried to arrest an extremely large man who is resisting, I don't think you get to give your two cents on how they should have done it. As with all authority figures, it is our right and our responsibility to make that judgment. If we could only have an opinion about things we are intimately familar with, most of us couldn't comment on much of anything. My sister is NYPD. Before that, she worked for another law enforcement agency in a different part of NY (being vague on purpose here). She will be the first to tell you that most of her fellow officers are the best people she has met. It is like having a war buddy, almost, after they finish training. But, as with everything, there is a dark side. There were many, many people she trained with who spouted racist garbage and misinformed nonsense. There were quite a few who joined the force so they could use force: they were looking for it, anticipating it. And police officers know they are unlikely to be punished legally. They are more worried about doing something that loses them their job. This is the minority, of course, but they exist. My point is that police officers are humans, representing both the best and worst of humanity, who are given a little more power than the rest of us, and, fairly, given a little more leeway. What they are not given is absolute power and no accountability. Most of them don't even want that. To say we can't judge because we are not police officers is simplistic and, frankly, dangerous. Who, then, can judge them? Our whole system of justice is based on the fact that we are judged by our peers. That system resulted in no indictment. Whether fairly or not, I can't make a judgement without the transcripts. With both of these cases I have been shocked at the assertion that we shouldn't question anything police officers do, ever, for any reason. America is not a police state, and we, as citizens, have the right to respectfully question them. This is the best comment I have read on the thread so far. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MandJZ Posted by alli3131 Posted by MandJZ In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. I read something today that the reason for this is that police officers in the line of duty are not held to the same standard as a regular citizen. I have not had the time to actually research this but I see some valid reasoning behind it if it is true. And if it is true then that would be a big reason why the statistics are very slanted. If I have time and find out if the standard is actually a regulation in place and will update all! That's interesting. If that is true, I honestly think it would be very troubling to me. I though can see that they would be held to a different standard because of their line of work they are put in harms way everyday. They are put with the task of keeping themselves and the rest of us safe every day. So if they have to use a higher level of force to keep the pubic safe then I think they should. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:26 PM
|
|
|
No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Parents for the love of god tell your children to be respectful towards law enforcement. Yes sir, no sir. Put your hands up, slow moments,follow directions. Don't resist arrest. If you don't want to answer a question, say respectfully officer, I don't have to answer that or I invoke my right to council. If you don't like how the officer treated you during the arrest, by all means discuss it with your lawyer and see what legal grounds are available to you. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:31 PM
|
|
|
No indictment for nypd chokehold cop When I was 17 years old- tiny little white girl, driving to work at a daycare center in Massapequa, I was pulled over. For going through a light that was green. Literally. He accused me of counting lights or something. Right off the bat the cop was nasty, rude, called me names and threatened to send me to a mental institution because I started to cry. Then he had two other cops show up as 'back up' when I asked him to please just give me a ticket if that's what he intended to do. I was then made to get out of my car and lean over on the trunk while these pieces of garbage had a coffee clutch. When I called the precinct to complain- magically, there had been NO officers in the area at that time. I was never ticketed- just humiliated and let go. I was too frazzled and upset to get names or badge numbers. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by sameinitials Posted by buttercup Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?! Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says? Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period! I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply. And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for? For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders. Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today. Actually, yes. The officer should have to explain. If a police officer approaches me and tries to search me with no explanation, I will respectfully decline, as is my right. If the police officer says "there was a burglary in this area and the suspect was wearing a coat like yours and the same shoes. Can we check your bag?" I would say yes, here, because I didn't burglarize anyone. That's exactly what the law says. We can not be stopped and searched without due process. That is our right. Even if we look like someone who may have committed a crime. That's why there are search warrants and arrest warrants. You are absolutely right, that is due process. Lets be honest though,that isn't the type of scenario that causes deaths. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 2:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MrsA1012 Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by MandJZ Posted by JRsMaMa Posted by sameinitials Posted by buttercup Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?! Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says? Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period! I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply. And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for? For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders. Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today. Actually, yes. The officer should have to explain. If a police officer approaches me and tries to search me with no explanation, I will respectfully decline, as is my right. If the police officer says "there was a burglary in this area and the suspect was wearing a coat like yours and the same shoes. Can we check your bag?" I would say yes, here, because I didn't burglarize anyone. That's exactly what the law says. We can not be stopped and searched without due process. That is our right. Even if we look like someone who may have committed a crime. That's why there are search warrants and arrest warrants. You are absolutely right, that is due process. Lets be honest though,that isn't the type of scenario that causes deaths. I don't know. I think securing indictments and taking more of these deaths to trial would allow us to better understand what type of situation does cause deaths, and why, and how they can be avoided. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MrsA1012 Parents for the love of god tell your children to be respectful towards law enforcement. Yes sir, no sir. Put your hands up, slow moments,follow directions. Don't resist arrest. If you don't want to answer a question, say respectfully officer, I don't have to answer that or I invoke my right to council. If you don't like how the officer treated you during the arrest, by all means discuss it with your lawyer and see what legal grounds are available to you. Well said. |
|
Posted 12/4/14 8:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Kitten1929 Posted by wakemeup Posted by Kitten1929 I find some of these remarks so incredibly insensitive. But no one is racist, right? I don't understand any of the comments. Here we go... what? It comes across to me like the people commenting "Greaaat" and "here we go" are insinuating that the possibility of riots are a bothersome inconvenience. Not that, you know, someone died at the hands of a police officer who used excessive force.
|
|
Posted 12/4/14 9:07 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 5 6 7 [8] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homeless man that got shoes from NYPD cop | Aubreysmommy | 12/3/12 | 48 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYPD cop in White Catle case dies. | 04bride | 2/8/06 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |






And definitely, we can disagree! There's beauty in seeing every different point of view. You and I don't need to handle every situation the same way. It's what makes us all our own person.


