No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted By Message
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Name calling? Really. That's what this has come to

Posted 12/4/14 12:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.




OK. Well, it certainly wasn't my intention to attack anyone at all. I didn't set out to do so and my first post or two was not directed at anyone in particular. I apologize if it came across as though they were directed at or attacking you.

Posted 12/4/14 12:37 PM
 

Naner325
waiting on nugget!

Member since 6/10

4432 total posts

Name:
N

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

If you don't want a cop to use excessive force, don't give them a reason to! If someone is doing something illegal and police attempt an arrest and that person resists, what are they supposed to do? Especially a man of that size! IMO, This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with someone breaking the law and resisting arrest and unfortunately the results of his reaction caused his death. If he was innocently sitting there and a police officer decided to put him in a choke hold, I would feel differently, but this man was doing something illegal and refused arrest.

Posted 12/4/14 12:37 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.










I HAVE a history of attacking people? Are you kidding me???

Holy Goodnight! That's unreal YOU would say that. There are so many people on LIF who call you out for attacking people - LIKE ALL THE TIME! And that was BEFORE you changed your screen name.

This is the best post YET!!

Posted 12/4/14 12:38 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.




OK. Well, it certainly wasn't my intention to attack anyone at all. I didn't set out to do so and my first post or two was not directed at anyone in particular. I apologize if it came across as though they were directed at or attacking you.



Thank you

I swear if your original post was the same as that last OP, who I feel really spoke to me, this would have never gotten this far.

Posted 12/4/14 12:40 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.










I HAVE a history of attacking people? Are you kidding me???

Holy Goodnight! That's unreal YOU would say that. There are so many people on LIF who call you out for attacking people - LIKE ALL THE TIME! And that was BEFORE you changed your screen name.

This is the best post YET!!



OH Kitten, it seems you deleted the post I replied to. You knew that was BS right there

Message edited 2014-12-04 12:43:49.560000.

Posted 12/4/14 12:41 PM
 

LeeCR7
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

138 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Naner325

If you don't want a cop to use excessive force, don't give them a reason to! If someone is doing something illegal and police attempt an arrest and that person resists, what are they supposed to do? Especially a man of that size! IMO, This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with someone breaking the law and resisting arrest and unfortunately the results of his reaction caused his death. If he was innocently sitting there and a police officer decided to put him in a choke hold, I would feel differently, but this man was doing something illegal and refused arrest.



Actually, he had just finished breaking up a fight when the police approached him. He had been arrested previously for selling untaxed cigarettes, but none were found on him that day. So he wasn't doing anything illegal at the time.

Police have a process for arresting. The process was not followed. There were four officers there; even as a non-cop, I could come up with quite a few ways to, as a group, non-lethally subdue one man, even a big man. From what I've seen, this absolutely should have gone to trial.

Posted 12/4/14 12:46 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by Naner325

If you don't want a cop to use excessive force, don't give them a reason to! If someone is doing something illegal and police attempt an arrest and that person resists, what are they supposed to do? Especially a man of that size! IMO, This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with someone breaking the law and resisting arrest and unfortunately the results of his reaction caused his death. If he was innocently sitting there and a police officer decided to put him in a choke hold, I would feel differently, but this man was doing something illegal and refused arrest.



Actually, he had just finished breaking up a fight when the police approached him. He had been arrested previously for selling untaxed cigarettes, but none were found on him that day. So he wasn't doing anything illegal at the time.

Police have a process for arresting. The process was not followed. There were four officers there; even as a non-cop, I could come up with quite a few ways to, as a group, non-lethally subdue one man, even a big man. From what I've seen, this absolutely should have gone to trial.



You certainly don't have to answer this but I'm curious as to whether your sister holds the same opinion.

Posted 12/4/14 12:49 PM
 

LeeCR7
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

138 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by Naner325

If you don't want a cop to use excessive force, don't give them a reason to! If someone is doing something illegal and police attempt an arrest and that person resists, what are they supposed to do? Especially a man of that size! IMO, This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with someone breaking the law and resisting arrest and unfortunately the results of his reaction caused his death. If he was innocently sitting there and a police officer decided to put him in a choke hold, I would feel differently, but this man was doing something illegal and refused arrest.



Actually, he had just finished breaking up a fight when the police approached him. He had been arrested previously for selling untaxed cigarettes, but none were found on him that day. So he wasn't doing anything illegal at the time.

Police have a process for arresting. The process was not followed. There were four officers there; even as a non-cop, I could come up with quite a few ways to, as a group, non-lethally subdue one man, even a big man. From what I've seen, this absolutely should have gone to trial.



You certainly don't have to answer this but I'm curious as to whether your sister holds the same opinion.



Sure, no problem. She is one of the reasons I feel comfortable having such strong opinions about these cases. My very own expert!

She is much more upset about this case than the Ferguson one, which has lots of gray areas. One of the basic things officers are taught is to how to safely take down a suspect. There are ways to to it by yourself, but she said there is no excuse for four officers not to be able to safely subdue one unarmed suspect.

Posted 12/4/14 12:53 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by Naner325

If you don't want a cop to use excessive force, don't give them a reason to! If someone is doing something illegal and police attempt an arrest and that person resists, what are they supposed to do? Especially a man of that size! IMO, This has nothing to do with race, it has to do with someone breaking the law and resisting arrest and unfortunately the results of his reaction caused his death. If he was innocently sitting there and a police officer decided to put him in a choke hold, I would feel differently, but this man was doing something illegal and refused arrest.



Actually, he had just finished breaking up a fight when the police approached him. He had been arrested previously for selling untaxed cigarettes, but none were found on him that day. So he wasn't doing anything illegal at the time.

Police have a process for arresting. The process was not followed. There were four officers there; even as a non-cop, I could come up with quite a few ways to, as a group, non-lethally subdue one man, even a big man. From what I've seen, this absolutely should have gone to trial.



You certainly don't have to answer this but I'm curious as to whether your sister holds the same opinion.



Sure, no problem. She is one of the reasons I feel comfortable having such strong opinions about these cases. My very own expert!

She is much more upset about this case than the Ferguson one, which has lots of gray areas. One of the basic things officers are taught is to how to safely take down a suspect. There are ways to to it by yourself, but she said there is no excuse for four officers not to be able to safely subdue one unarmed suspect.



Thanks for responding. I haven't discussed it with my own expert yet Chat Icon haven't had the opportunity.

Posted 12/4/14 12:55 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.










I HAVE a history of attacking people? Are you kidding me???

Holy Goodnight! That's unreal YOU would say that. There are so many people on LIF who call you out for attacking people - LIKE ALL THE TIME! And that was BEFORE you changed your screen name.

This is the best post YET!!



OH Kitten, it seems you deleted the post I replied to. You knew that was BS right there



You know what Phyliss - I make a conscious effort to change the way that I react to people. I realized that there was no point inciting an uproar or being aggressive. You lose the meaning in what you are trying to say that way. So yes, while I may have in the past been aggressive, I try to be more thoughtful and honest in the way that I post or ignore things that make me roll my eyes. I have tried to be more mature in the way that I post, and on this thread alone I've disagreed with people but it never came to blows. You started attacking and I stood up for my friend. I am sorry that you choose to continue attacking me.

Posted 12/4/14 12:57 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by LeeCR7

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

The part of this that just kills me is that you and a lot of people believe this police officer killed this guy because he's black. That just boggles my mind!!! Where's the proof in that statement? Is there a record of this officer killing other black men? Only? Is there record showing he only goes after black men? Has he never arrested a white person before? That's what really gets me.



For me, at least, the race is irrelevant. All that matters is if the officer used excessive force. The video does seem to support that he did, although we don't know the whole story, of course.

I don't think anybody thinks, or is saying, that this officer targeted this man because of his race. It is a lot more subtle and insidious. To me, it is about the overall perception of minorities as inherently more dangerous. Even if it does not drive your actions, that has got to play into your thought process when making these split second decisions If you read the grand jury transcripts from Ferguson, Wilson describes Brown as a "demon." Would he have described a white man like that? None of us can really know, but it speaks to his perception.

By having a justice process that holds officers more accountable for their action, that reality would probably also play into their though process, hopefully slowing the number of incidents like this.



Thank you. I am hearing a lot of pointing to the fact that he was black then anything else. What you stated definitely says something to me. I can see your point.



This is exactly what I said, and meant. But Phyllis you seem to have some idea of me and who I am that made you unable to see the point when I was the one saying it. So that's fine.

But thank you, Lee, for always being such a voice of reason.



I didn't have an idea of you or who you are.

I do now.

This poster put it into words that made sense to me. Without being judgmental to any other posters. It's easier to understand that way. When being sarcastic or finger pointing, it's hard to see past anything but that.




You made references to knowing who I was quite a few posts back, it's there clear as day. But that's fine. I've left the group we were both part of now, anyways.

I was not sarcastic, or finger pointing in the least until I was told that my experiences aren't as important as yours.

I have no problem disagreeing with people. I do have a problem being attacked.



Just because you worded your attacks in a well educated manner, doesn't mean they weren't there.










I HAVE a history of attacking people? Are you kidding me???

Holy Goodnight! That's unreal YOU would say that. There are so many people on LIF who call you out for attacking people - LIKE ALL THE TIME! And that was BEFORE you changed your screen name.

This is the best post YET!!



OH Kitten, it seems you deleted the post I replied to. You knew that was BS right there



You know what Phyliss - I make a conscious effort to change the way that I react to people. I realized that there was no point inciting an uproar or being aggressive. You lose the meaning in what you are trying to say that way. So yes, while I may have in the past been aggressive, I try to be more thoughtful and honest in the way that I post or ignore things that make me roll my eyes. I have tried to be more mature in the way that I post, and on this thread alone I've disagreed with people but it never came to blows. You started attacking and I stood up for my friend. I am sorry that you choose to continue attacking me.



So it was a conscious effort to name call? That I'm just a miserable person? Coming from someone who knows more about me then I like at this moment... Not cool.

I was not attacking your friend. I didn't decide it would be a good idea to have a heated argument with M. We were going back in forth. We both played a part in that heated argument. Which, I think, has been resolved. You, on the other hand, turned this personal with that comment and then the following comment about my LIF History.

Glass houses

Message edited 2014-12-04 13:07:41.870000.

Posted 12/4/14 1:03 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. Do I think there is a racial component to many, if not most of these cases? Yes. Maybe not outwardly, or consciously, but I think it's there.

That said. My feelings outlined above in no way mean that I am anti-police. I am not. I don't even use the word 'cop' because its origins are derogatory. I think, as I stated earlier, the vast majority of police officers are wonderful, and do a job that is scary at the best of times. But, just like we still have trials for criminals even though MOST people aren't criminals, so to should we still have trials for police officers even though MOST are good, upstanding, trustworthy, etc.

Message edited 2014-12-04 13:13:58.813000.

Posted 12/4/14 1:13 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

To get back on point, I don't see it as a race issue. Just want to make that clear. I don't like the way it was handled by the authorities and it scares me that the cop was not indicted.

Posted 12/4/14 1:13 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. Do I think there is a racial component to many, if not most of these cases? Yes. Maybe not outwardly, or consciously, but I think it's there.

That said. My feelings outlined above in no way mean that I am anti-police. I am not. I don't even use the word 'cop' because its origins are derogatory. I think, as I stated earlier, the vast majority of police officers are wonderful, and do a job that is scary at the best of times. But, just like we still have trials for criminals even though MOST people aren't criminals, so to should we still have trials for police officers even though MOST are good, upstanding, trustworthy, etc.



Chat Icon

Can you explain how "cop" stems from derogatory meaning? I never knew this and just curious. Thx

Posted 12/4/14 1:16 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Sash

Posted by MandJZ

In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. Do I think there is a racial component to many, if not most of these cases? Yes. Maybe not outwardly, or consciously, but I think it's there.

That said. My feelings outlined above in no way mean that I am anti-police. I am not. I don't even use the word 'cop' because its origins are derogatory. I think, as I stated earlier, the vast majority of police officers are wonderful, and do a job that is scary at the best of times. But, just like we still have trials for criminals even though MOST people aren't criminals, so to should we still have trials for police officers even though MOST are good, upstanding, trustworthy, etc.



Chat Icon

Can you explain how "cop" stems from derogatory meaning? I never knew this and just curious. Thx



As far as I understand it, though it has evolved into something that isn't, the term cop comes from 'copper' which was a slang used derisively against police officers a century ago (or more, even).

ETA: Just like many teachers I know often remind their students to refer to them as "Mrs. X" or whatever instead of "teach" or "Miss", because it shows proper respect, I just think that the proper term is the most respectful one.

Message edited 2014-12-04 13:21:03.840000.

Posted 12/4/14 1:20 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Sash

Posted by MandJZ

In the end what this, and so many other sad cases boil down to for me, is that a person is dead at the hands of another person. And there will be no trial. The statistics are staggering and shocking regarding the number of cases that go to trial involving police officers versus civilians. And I find that highly problematic. Do I think there is a racial component to many, if not most of these cases? Yes. Maybe not outwardly, or consciously, but I think it's there.

That said. My feelings outlined above in no way mean that I am anti-police. I am not. I don't even use the word 'cop' because its origins are derogatory. I think, as I stated earlier, the vast majority of police officers are wonderful, and do a job that is scary at the best of times. But, just like we still have trials for criminals even though MOST people aren't criminals, so to should we still have trials for police officers even though MOST are good, upstanding, trustworthy, etc.



Chat Icon

Can you explain how "cop" stems from derogatory meaning? I never knew this and just curious. Thx



As far as I understand it, though it has evolved into something that isn't, the term cop comes from 'copper' which was a slang used derisively against police officers a century ago (or more, even).

ETA: Just like many teachers I know often remind their students to refer to them as "Mrs. X" or whatever instead of "teach" or "Miss", because it shows proper respect, I just think that the proper term is the most respectful one.



Interesting, never knew that.

Posted 12/4/14 1:25 PM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?

Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period!

Posted 12/4/14 1:28 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by JRsMaMa

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?

Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period!



I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply.

Posted 12/4/14 1:33 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

In this case, after just watching the video- I believe the officer should have been indicted. If this guy started behaving violently and/or running away, then yes- he would've been in the right. It also looks very much like a choke hold to me.

Posted 12/4/14 1:57 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Kitten1929

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.



How do we know that it was extreme force though? If it were, in fact, the permissible hold (and not the illegal one), how can we say it's extreme? What kind of change in tactic is appropriate if the officer is doing something per protocol? I don't know... I don't think it's as easy to act on a moment's notice as civilians may think it is. It's easy to judge after the fact but I would think anyone, in the moment and having to use extremely quick judgment, would do what their training calls for.



If someone died as a result, it was extreme. He was uncooperative and unarmed, but not aggressive. So there was no way for Pantaleo to release his grip slightly, no way to lighten up enough so that Garner could breathe while still keeping him subdued? Garner wasn't running, wasn't getting physical with the officers, so why did they feel the need to use such force? There weren't other tactics that they could have used?



I agree with this.

Posted 12/4/14 1:59 PM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by JRsMaMa

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?

Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period!



I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply.

And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for?

For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders.

Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today.

ETA - I am not stating whether I agree with the grand jury's decision or not. I am only arguing whether or not people need to listen to cops orders.

Message edited 2014-12-04 14:06:44.643000.

Posted 12/4/14 2:05 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

I'm sorry, I have the utmost respect for the role police officers play in our communities, and the dangers of their job. I truly do. And the vast majority of them do their jobs with dignity, and do it well, and I thank them for it. But they are people, too, and just like any other large group of people - there will be those who do NOT do their job the way it is supposed to be done. There will be those who abuse their power. And they should NOT be given the benefit of the doubt simply because they are police officers. They should be held to the same standards, if not higher standards, than the rest of the population.

And further, we don't live in a dictatorship or an oligarchy. I, as a citizen, am not ruled by any one or any group of people. I do not have to simply listen to someone else because of their profession. If I have broken no laws and have done nothing wrong I do not have to "do what I'm told", because I'm an adult with rights. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.

The video in this case is pretty cut and dry. And just like with the case in Ferguson, the grand jury chose not to indict a police officer, when the vast majority of cases that do NOT involve police officers leads to indictments. Our justice system is holding police officers to a LOWER standard than the rest of the population. And that frightens me.

All lives matter. And what that means is that deaths that are ruled homicides deserve to be investigated and deserve a trial by jury.



Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 2:05 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by JRsMaMa

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by JRsMaMa

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?

Seriously? YES! Put your hands up, behind your back etc YES YOU SHOULD. How is this even a question? While these men shouldn't have died they also should have been listening to the police officers instructions. Period!



I'm sorry but I respectfully disagree with this as a blanket statement. If a law abiding citizen who is not doing anything illegal and is not under arrest is told by a police officer to empty their pockets/bag/etc., they do not have to comply.

And if that police office is been given a description fitting the profile of the person they have encountered, who is law abiding? Should the police offer have to explain his or herself? How does the officer know this is not the suspect they are looking for?

For myself, I was brought up to respect authority. So if I am stopped by an officer I will comply, unless the demands are ridiculous. And I do not think an officer asking for someone to stop, put their hands up, or behind their backs is so terrible. And in BOTH cases, NY and Ferguson, both men were doing something they should not have been doing and did not listen to officers direct orders.

Should Eric Garner have died? No. Should he have been selling the cigarettes illegally? No. Should he have listened to the officers? Yes. If he would have he would still be alive today.




Actually, yes. The officer should have to explain. If a police officer approaches me and tries to search me with no explanation, I will respectfully decline, as is my right. If the police officer says "there was a burglary in this area and the suspect was wearing a coat like yours and the same shoes. Can we check your bag?" I would say yes, here, because I didn't burglarize anyone.

That's exactly what the law says. We can not be stopped and searched without due process. That is our right. Even if we look like someone who may have committed a crime. That's why there are search warrants and arrest warrants.

Posted 12/4/14 2:08 PM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Message edited 2014-12-04 14:41:11.717000.

Posted 12/4/14 2:08 PM
 
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Homeless man that got shoes from NYPD cop Aubreysmommy 12/3/12 48 Families Helping Families ™
NYPD cop in White Catle case dies. 04bride 2/8/06 13 Families Helping Families ™