Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
Posted 12/4/2014 9:47:13 AM by Kitten1929


Posted by Bearcat


Posted by Kitten1929

Police officers ARE the law, but they are not ABOVE it.

They are still dealing with human beings - and sorry, I won't make sweeping generalizations that ALL criminals shokd he treated with the use of extreme force. No wonder people don't trust the police - there is a repeated pattern of abuse and violence in situations that do not warrant it and they are perpetuating a culture of distrust of law enforcement. By everyone else's standards, being a criminal ALONE gives the police carte Blanche to use extreme physical force without any right or regard for the human being? That simply because they're a criminal or are in contact with an officer they are immediately stripped of any and all human rights and are subject to die at the hands of an officer who felt he was justified? So I could be treated with the same force for say, failing to pay a parking ticket, as someone who murders someone?

To me, it's a human rights issue. The police are entrusted to uphold the law - not to bend it to their will, not to be vigilantes, and certainly not to take the lives of others when a simple change in tactic could have had a very different outcome for Garner and Pantaleo.


I won't apologize for thinking that human lives are worth something. Blanket generalizations about criminals and "maybe they shouldn't put themselves in that situation" just won't sway me. There are far too many variables.



How do we know that it was extreme force though? If it were, in fact, the permissible hold (and not the illegal one), how can we say it's extreme? What kind of change in tactic is appropriate if the officer is doing something per protocol? I don't know... I don't think it's as easy to act on a moment's notice as civilians may think it is. It's easy to judge after the fact but I would think anyone, in the moment and having to use extremely quick judgment, would do what their training calls for.



If someone died as a result, it was extreme. He was uncooperative and unarmed, but not aggressive. So there was no way for Pantaleo to release his grip slightly, no way to lighten up enough so that Garner could breathe while still keeping him subdued? Garner wasn't running, wasn't getting physical with the officers, so why did they feel the need to use such force? There weren't other tactics that they could have used?
Print Post      Close Window