No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Chatham-Chick Posted by Ayne11 His last words were "I can't breathe, I can't breathe" then he died. It's just so sad, I can't even watch that video anymore. I hate to be a cynic, but do you know how many suspects say that when resisting arrest and law enforcement has to use physical force to subdue them? This. This a hundred times. I feel terrible for garners family, but am happy the cop wasn't indicted. And what exactly would the public like? The police to politely ask people to comply? So then when people resist, what should the cops say? "Oh ok, have a. Nice day sir, please refrain from breaking the law further." |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:31 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Chatham-Chick Posted by MsSissy Some thing I don't understand about this case. Is why go after a guy selling loose cigarettes? I understand it's against the law. Which honestly is ridiculous to me. I know the city wants their tax money. But they got it already with the purchase of the pack of cigarettes. But really, was this the biggest threat they were seeing all day? Unless there was more to this story that I haven't seen/heard about. There are laws and regulations put in place for everything. It's not an officer's job to decide what laws are silly. It's their job to enforce them. And even though cigarettes aren't healthy for you in general, whose to say what's being placed in cigarettes sold illegally. There's also a health & safety issue there. I understand the rules and regulations are there for a reason. But IMO selling loose cigarettes isn't exactly a threat to the cops or anyone for that matter. They go after the people because the city isn't getting their tax dollars. Which is what' has been reported. That's all. If they were so concerned about the health and safety issue they wouldn't sell cigarettes in the 1st place. It's about the money. I think what could be placed in cigarettes sold illegally is a bit of stretch. That hasn't been mentioned at all. At least I haven't seen that in any story being reported. Jay walking is also against the law. I don't see cops taking anyone down for that. And thousands of people do that everyday. They could make tons of money enforcing that law. But they don't. They let it slid. I just think 4 cops taking a guy down for cigarettes is extreme. And for someone to loose their life over it, is a tragedy. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MsSissy Some thing I don't understand about this case. Is why go after a guy selling loose cigarettes? I understand it's against the law. Which honestly is ridiculous to me. I know the city wants their tax money. But they got it already with the purchase of the pack of cigarettes. But really, was this the biggest threat they were seeing all day? Unless there was more to this story that I haven't seen/heard about. I know, I agree- I don't understand either. Was there more to the story? Without the city making their money as it was said ... there's no regulation. Loose cigarettes can be laced. So its the risk. Plus its not like he's carding for age now is he? I am GLAD they prevent it. From what I've read the indictment would have had to have shown malicious intent to kill. I don't see NYC breaking out in riots on this. This was a grown adult who was obviously not cooperating. Excessive force? I am not sure. That's a big man. But I agree with PP there's more to the story and we don't have the full story. We would have had to sit on the jury the entire time to even get a chance at knowing 'more' of the story much less all of it. Just my opinion |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop So I can hand out free loose cigarettes but I can't sell loose cigarettes? Message edited 2014-12-03 17:45:35.860000. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:45 PM
|
|
|
No indictment for nypd chokehold cop This is terrible. He should have been indicted, I hope people can keep their wits about them that's all I'm saying... |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:49 PM
|
|
|
No indictment for nypd chokehold cop As much as I believe he should have been indicted, we are seeing a snippet of a video. He did technically resist arrest. Once again I want to read the Grand Jury's testimony and see the full story. I don't want to be swayed by the media. They want a riot to boost ratings. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MsSissy So I can hand out free loose cigarettes but I can't sell loose cigarettes? Ok got it. Take it up with the FDA. But that's not what the case brought before the grand jury was about. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 5:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Chatham-Chick Posted by MsSissy So I can hand out free loose cigarettes but I can't sell loose cigarettes? Ok got it. Take it up with the FDA. But that's not what the case brought before the grand jury was about. Oh I realize thats not what was brought before the grand jury. Just trying to make sense of why the sale of loose cigarettes started the whole situation. et's: never realized you can get arrested for that. Always thought it would just be a ticket. Message edited 2014-12-03 18:17:37.610000. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 6:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop I cannot believe how some people on this board attack other members. Especially without knowing all the facts. Right away the comments of "Here we go" and "Great" are racist remarks? Maybe some people are concerned that there will be rioting. That their small businesses will be looted or burned. Worse, that they have family in law enforcement who will have to subdue possible looters and can't do more then ask politely for the person who is breaking the law to please stop. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 6:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop From all that i saw on TV, I do think the officer should have been charged with negligent homicide or manslaughter. I don't belive that the officer intended to ever kill Mr. Garner, but I do think he intended to subdue him under any means necessary. I feel that he decided to use a choke hold, an improper hold by officer standards, and that intent to hold is enough for an intent when a death negligently occurs because he intended to subdue him. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 6:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by MsSissy So I can hand out free loose cigarettes but I can't sell loose cigarettes? Ok got it. It seems as if your issue is with the laws, and cops don't make the laws, politicians and lawmakers do. I 100% agree with you that this is a stupid law. But you can't blame the cops for enforcing it. Government wants to regulate everything. IMO we don't need laws for every little thing because then you get cases like this, where it escalates to something bad very quickly. But the cops are not to blame for attempting to arrest this man. If he was standing on a corner selling single cigarettes in front of a Bodega, I'm sure the bodega and customers of the bodega call the police to complain. The cops respond to complaints. This man was allegedly a repeat offender. And you can't blame the cops for a person's decision to resist arrest. I wasn't on the jury, so I won't make a decision about excessive force. And since Jay-walking is illegal, if the powers that be decided they wanted to start enforcing that law, cops would start ticketing people. Message edited 2014-12-03 18:52:05.533000. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop For the people who think this officer's force was so excessive, I'm honestly curious, what was he supposed to do? That guy was huge and resisting arrest. Apparently whatever hold he was using was legal. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Xelindrya Posted by forevermylilgirls Posted by MsSissy Some thing I don't understand about this case. Is why go after a guy selling loose cigarettes? I understand it's against the law. Which honestly is ridiculous to me. I know the city wants their tax money. But they got it already with the purchase of the pack of cigarettes. But really, was this the biggest threat they were seeing all day? Unless there was more to this story that I haven't seen/heard about. I know, I agree- I don't understand either. Was there more to the story? Without the city making their money as it was said ... there's no regulation. Loose cigarettes can be laced. So its the risk. Plus its not like he's carding for age now is he? I am GLAD they prevent it. From what I've read the indictment would have had to have shown malicious intent to kill. I don't see NYC breaking out in riots on this. This was a grown adult who was obviously not cooperating. Excessive force? I am not sure. That's a big man. But I agree with PP there's more to the story and we don't have the full story. We would have had to sit on the jury the entire time to even get a chance at knowing 'more' of the story much less all of it. Just my opinion Selling loose cigarettes turn many neighborhoods into a turf war. Like other drugs. People don't see the bigger picture. The residents of the neighborhood are tired of it and actually complained about Eric Garner. Not excusing what happened, but that's why they were ther in the first place |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop He didn't even have any cigarettes on him. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Xelindrya From what I've read the indictment would have had to have shown malicious intent to kill. That isn't the case. They could have indicted for negligent homicide. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Kitten1929 Posted by MsSissy Some thing I don't understand about this case. Is why go after a guy selling loose cigarettes? I understand it's against the law. Which honestly is ridiculous to me. I know the city wants their tax money. But they got it already with the purchase of the pack of cigarettes. But really, was this the biggest threat they were seeing all day? Unless there was more to this story that I haven't seen/heard about. From what I know there isn't much more than that. He was approached by the officers for selling the cigarettes, said he was always being bothered by the police, was speaking to them in an agigtated manner and NOTHING that a reasonable person would say would cause the officers to be in fear of their lives, then they took him down and he died. I don't think the officers ever said "they feared for their lives". They were trying to arrest someone who said something along the lines of "not today, you're not doing this to me again". Who gets to tell the police that they can't arrest them for breaking the law? |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by LSP2005 From all that i saw on TV, I do think the officer should have been charged with negligent homicide or manslaughter. I don't belive that the officer intended to ever kill Mr. Garner, but I do think he intended to subdue him under any means necessary. I feel that he decided to use a choke hold, an improper hold by officer standards, and that intent to hold is enough for an intent when a death negligently occurs because he intended to subdue him. For me, I don't think violence or violent protests are ever the answer, but I do think peaceful protests are absolutely necessary and warranted in this case. Yes, this. My husband, who is a criminal defense attorney, said that negligent homicide would definitely be warranted. And i also agree re protests. Peaceful protests/rallies are completely appropriate. Obviously, violent protests don't accomplish anything, including getting the point across. There are ways to express anger/dismay without further violence. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:43 PM
|
|
|
No indictment for nypd chokehold cop I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... |
|
Posted 12/3/14 7:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by JoesWife628 Posted by Kitten1929 Posted by wakemeup Posted by Kitten1929 I find some of these remarks so incredibly insensitive. But no one is racist, right? I don't understand any of the comments. Here we go... what? It comes across to me like the people commenting "Greaaat" and "here we go" are insinuating that the possibility of riots are a bothersome inconvenience. Not that, you know, someone died at the hands of a police officer who used excessive force. No, not a bothersome inconvenience. How about downright frightening that some animals will equate burning buildings, looting and rioting with gaining justice for Garner. With the city's population density, so much damage could be done. I do believe the officer should have been indicted in this case, but violent acts will not change the outcome. I just hope protests are peaceful and nobody gets hurt.
|
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by sameinitials I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... That is going to be ruled an accidental shooting...rookie cop..no clue...shouldn't even had his weapon drawn! But, I think I am in the minority here....when the cops say multiple times, "Don't move or I will shoot" or "Hands up, Police" in your best interest, you should stop and follow directives. When you don't, you risk the risk of being shot and then killed. Sorry. Each and every day, these men and women go on the streets and protect the general public. There are some crazy ass people out there and I would be nervous as all hell. My job calls for me to travel into some not so great areas of the bronx and brooklyn, and I will not lie, I get nervous all of the time. I can't even imagine what the Police feel like. Each and every decision they make is judged. You have a split second to make a decision. Your life or his/hers. Not an easy job and I am sure it will be another job where the applicants decrease b/c they don't want to be put in certain situations. Yes, I am sad this man lost his life. But he had a choice too and he didn't choose wisely. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by sameinitials I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all! |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by shadows Posted by sameinitials I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all! I'm guessing the media hasn't really picked this incident up because I don't think they consider it an issue of race or violating civil rights. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Chatham-Chick Posted by shadows Posted by sameinitials I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all! I'm guessing the media hasn't really picked this incident up because I don't think they consider it an issue of race or violating civil rights. Al Sharpton brought this up a few times at the press conference tonight. |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop I just wanted to comment on the choke hold po friends of mine have said it wasnt a choke hold because if it was garner would not have been able to even say I can't breathe, when you are being choked you can't speak, that's why they are saying it was an allowable type of hold. Also with a man of that side they had to subdue him from behind. You can see in the video him resisting and struggling against the cops the minute they try to arrest him |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop Posted by Ayne11 Posted by Chatham-Chick Posted by shadows Posted by sameinitials I'm waiting for the day when the cop who shot the guy in the stairwell for literally no reason at all isn't indicted... Yes, I feel like this hasn't gotten any attention in the wake of these other media spectacles. This stairwell incident seems, to me, like the worst one of all! I'm guessing the media hasn't really picked this incident up because I don't think they consider it an issue of race or violating civil rights. Al Sharpton brought this up a few times at the press conference tonight. I think this is a very different situation. Articles I have read state he wasn't shooting at him his gun discharged, bullet ricocheted off the wall and killed him, only one shot was fired. It was a horrible beyond words accident. Sharpton really can't claim any racially motivated killing here, Not excusing it in any way but very different situation |
|
Posted 12/3/14 8:49 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homeless man that got shoes from NYPD cop | Aubreysmommy | 12/3/12 | 48 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYPD cop in White Catle case dies. | 04bride | 2/8/06 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
















