No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted By Message
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes.

I was taught to obey the law. That includes it's enforcers. I get pulled over, I automatically turn on interior light, shut off my car, put keys on the dash and put both hands on the wheel. I ask if I can go into my bag or glove for the necessary papers they are asking for.

As a teenager, I wasn't the nicest of kids. Hung out on the streets with people who weren't very law abiding. When cops would pull up on the sidewalk and tell us to go up against the wall, guess what? I went up against the wall, hands up and waited to be instructed on what to do next.

So yes, I would listen to what the police officer has asked me to do. Resisting arrest makes the other person at fault 99.9% of the time. If there was no resisting, we wouldn't be here discussing this right now.

Also, I'm curious. Are people saying that if this man was a white guy, same build, same situation, that this cop wouldn't have used the same force to subdue him? If so, why do you believe that? I have a family member who is a big guy and not a very law abiding citizen... there has been excessive forced used to subdue him in the past and now... he listens when a cop tells him to do something.



I agree with this. Even more with the day and age of record everything, help none.

I also agree not every cop is good and frankly I generally distrust them. We didn't call the cops unless we were about to die and frankly if we did, we didn't expect them to show up, care about us or help us. We expect them to blame us, be lax about it and frankly cause more hell. Generally, we were right.

That said. There are good cops trying to do the right thing for all the right reasons.

But if a cop says to do something, just do it. Why is it such a big deal these days to push back, resist, talk back, record it and basically act like you know more than them? I've seen plenty of video of people who verbally put a cop in their place rightfully so but you take that on your OWN risk.

I've told the story before about the cop who put me in the back of his cruiser after responding to a fender bender (I was at fault) my car stalled. He then said "So what if I just took you somewhere?" Umm what do you do then? I giggled and said, yeah funny, hey lets see if my car starts my Dad is probably crazy wondering where I am. (not true at all, I lived alone). I got in my car and GOT OUT THERE! He did give me his card and said maybe I should call him sometime.. AS IF!

You follow their orders within the ability you can. I have been told to lay on the ground or put my hands behind my back and I did so calmly slowly and QUIETLY. I've been told to provide information I felt was unlawful and I refused. I instead invited them to arrest me.

Posted 12/4/14 10:22 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes! If I'm not doing anything wrong, then why should I not listen to the cop? I'm sure if he/she has 1/2 a brain they would realize I wasn't doing anything, rather than act smart and tough and get into trouble with the law (and ruin my future) and get into loads of $hitt with my parents.. which I was what I was most afraid off..cops got nothin on my folks.. Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 10:24 AM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes.

I was taught to obey the law. That includes it's enforcers. I get pulled over, I automatically turn on interior light, shut off my car, put keys on the dash and put both hands on the wheel. I ask if I can go into my bag or glove for the necessary papers they are asking for.

As a teenager, I wasn't the nicest of kids. Hung out on the streets with people who weren't very law abiding. When cops would pull up on the sidewalk and tell us to go up against the wall, guess what? I went up against the wall, hands up and waited to be instructed on what to do next.

So yes, I would listen to what the police officer has asked me to do. Resisting arrest makes the other person at fault 99.9% of the time. If there was no resisting, we wouldn't be here discussing this right now.



I'm not talking about a situation where you are getting pulled over or where you are in a situation that could arguably be suspicious. I'm talking about a situation where you are walking down the street, minding your own business, not doing anything wrong (even arguably). It's a very slippery slope to say that you should do whatever the cops say, no matter the circumstances.

Posted 12/4/14 10:27 AM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Chatham-Chick

Posted by Kitten1929
...

Yes, I totally understand that. But I feel that there has been a frightening increase in the use of excessive force in scenarios that may not have warranted it. That is a big issue to me. And I think that perhaps we hold police officers like they are untouchable gods, and everything they do should be acceptable without consequence or explanation. Who is to say that cops don't abuse their authority? It seems too easy that cops can say, I was in fear of my life, even if they weren't, just to use that as an excuse?




The officer wasn't trying to kill him because he feared for his life. He was trying to arrest him, along with 4 other officers. IMO, the only intent on the officer's part was to subdue the suspect and arrest him.

Why did Garner choose to resist arrest this time? How does an officer know why?

How do you think the officers should have handled it? Just said "Forget it guys...we'll arrest him next time"?




Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 10:28 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes.

I was taught to obey the law. That includes it's enforcers. I get pulled over, I automatically turn on interior light, shut off my car, put keys on the dash and put both hands on the wheel. I ask if I can go into my bag or glove for the necessary papers they are asking for.

As a teenager, I wasn't the nicest of kids. Hung out on the streets with people who weren't very law abiding. When cops would pull up on the sidewalk and tell us to go up against the wall, guess what? I went up against the wall, hands up and waited to be instructed on what to do next.

So yes, I would listen to what the police officer has asked me to do. Resisting arrest makes the other person at fault 99.9% of the time. If there was no resisting, we wouldn't be here discussing this right now.



I'm not talking about a situation where you are getting pulled over or where you are in a situation that could arguably be suspicious. I'm talking about a situation where you are walking down the street, minding your own business, not doing anything wrong (even arguably). It's a very slippery slope to say that you should do whatever the cops say, no matter the circumstances.



Which is why I added the second scenario from when I was younger hanging out with - well, it was a gang. And we would get "harassed" by the cops all the time (rightfully so) We were just hanging out on the corner. Nothing obviously being done and they would roll up, multiple cars and search for drugs. Some ran. Those same people are either dead or in jail now. I listened and did what was asked and was always dismissed.

I'm not saying that this man should have died for his resisting. What I'm saying is why did he resist? Just listen to the cop. Not hard to do.

I also believe that the cop should be charged with accidental death of some sort (don't know the term for it) because he did kill him, but in my opinion, it's wasn't intentional.

Posted 12/4/14 10:33 AM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Really? Even if you aren't doing anything wrong, you should just do what the cop says?



Yes.

I was taught to obey the law. That includes it's enforcers. I get pulled over, I automatically turn on interior light, shut off my car, put keys on the dash and put both hands on the wheel. I ask if I can go into my bag or glove for the necessary papers they are asking for.

As a teenager, I wasn't the nicest of kids. Hung out on the streets with people who weren't very law abiding. When cops would pull up on the sidewalk and tell us to go up against the wall, guess what? I went up against the wall, hands up and waited to be instructed on what to do next.

So yes, I would listen to what the police officer has asked me to do. Resisting arrest makes the other person at fault 99.9% of the time. If there was no resisting, we wouldn't be here discussing this right now.



I'm not talking about a situation where you are getting pulled over or where you are in a situation that could arguably be suspicious. I'm talking about a situation where you are walking down the street, minding your own business, not doing anything wrong (even arguably). It's a very slippery slope to say that you should do whatever the cops say, no matter the circumstances.



Do you mean like stop and frisk? As person different ethnic background, I can't begin to tell you how many "random" checks I have gone through, and my poor brother has going through.. and everytime, I just hand over my bag, my tote whatever.. I don't question it. I get it, it is an invasion of privacy, but it is what it is. I can't change my skin color, nor can I as a single person change what law enforcement has set forth to protect the citizens.

Posted 12/4/14 10:35 AM
 

StaceyWill
It's a girl!!!

Member since 6/10

21539 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by buttercup

Not excusing Eric Garner's death in any way, but if a cop is coming up to you and telling you do something, just do it! Figure out the fine details later.. just go with the flow. Unfortunately, many kids these days are taught to fear cops rather than respect them. I'm sure there are dirty cops out there.. and probably racists, and disrespectful fools who end up getting a badge, and think they are above the law themselves just like in any profession.. but without these guys can you imagine what the streets would be like?!?!



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 10:36 AM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by cowgirlkate

If you are not a law enforcement officer, and you have never tried to arrest an extremely large man who is resisting, I don't think you get to give your two cents on how they should have done it.



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 10:40 AM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929


If someone died as a result, it was extreme. He was uncooperative and unarmed, but not aggressive. So there was no way for Pantaleo to release his grip slightly, no way to lighten up enough so that Garner could breathe while still keeping him subdued? Garner wasn't running, wasn't getting physical with the officers, so why did they feel the need to use such force? There weren't other tactics that they could have used?



I don't understand how anyone could watch the video and think it was not extreme. Garner wasn't acting violently.

One of the most disturbing things to me is that Pantaleo WAVES at the camera after killing this man. That speaks volumes to me about the value that he placed on this man's life. This officer has also been accused of misconduct before. Why should I give him the benefit of the doubt?

Posted 12/4/14 10:43 AM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I am all for the all lives matter motto too

But of you resist arrest,now the officer and surrounding people lives are are affected(not in this case,I mean in general)

What if the officer can't/is afraid to use the means necessary to subdue a criminal and he gets away and my family and the officer is hurt bc of it

It's a slippery slope and I could never understand what cops go through

None of us can

And yes there are bad ones but you hear about that way more than the good ones

It's a game time decision when it comes to controlling a perp and only that officer can understand what he or she needed to do

Posted 12/4/14 10:46 AM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 10:48 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I'm sorry, I have the utmost respect for the role police officers play in our communities, and the dangers of their job. I truly do. And the vast majority of them do their jobs with dignity, and do it well, and I thank them for it. But they are people, too, and just like any other large group of people - there will be those who do NOT do their job the way it is supposed to be done. There will be those who abuse their power. And they should NOT be given the benefit of the doubt simply because they are police officers. They should be held to the same standards, if not higher standards, than the rest of the population.

And further, we don't live in a dictatorship or an oligarchy. I, as a citizen, am not ruled by any one or any group of people. I do not have to simply listen to someone else because of their profession. If I have broken no laws and have done nothing wrong I do not have to "do what I'm told", because I'm an adult with rights. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.

The video in this case is pretty cut and dry. And just like with the case in Ferguson, the grand jury chose not to indict a police officer, when the vast majority of cases that do NOT involve police officers leads to indictments. Our justice system is holding police officers to a LOWER standard than the rest of the population. And that frightens me.

All lives matter. And what that means is that deaths that are ruled homicides deserve to be investigated and deserve a trial by jury.

Posted 12/4/14 11:05 AM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

I'm sorry, I have the utmost respect for the role police officers play in our communities, and the dangers of their job. I truly do. And the vast majority of them do their jobs with dignity, and do it well, and I thank them for it. But they are people, too, and just like any other large group of people - there will be those who do NOT do their job the way it is supposed to be done. There will be those who abuse their power. And they should NOT be given the benefit of the doubt simply because they are police officers. They should be held to the same standards, if not higher standards, than the rest of the population.

And further, we don't live in a dictatorship or an oligarchy. I, as a citizen, am not ruled by any one or any group of people. I do not have to simply listen to someone else because of their profession. If I have broken no laws and have done nothing wrong I do not have to "do what I'm told", because I'm an adult with rights. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.

The video in this case is pretty cut and dry. And just like with the case in Ferguson, the grand jury chose not to indict a police officer, when the vast majority of cases that do NOT involve police officers leads to indictments. Our justice system is holding police officers to a LOWER standard than the rest of the population. And that frightens me.

All lives matter. And what that means is that deaths that are ruled homicides deserve to be investigated and deserve a trial by jury.



Exactly.

Posted 12/4/14 11:11 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.

Posted 12/4/14 11:12 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by Kitten1929

Posted by MandJZ

I'm sorry, I have the utmost respect for the role police officers play in our communities, and the dangers of their job. I truly do. And the vast majority of them do their jobs with dignity, and do it well, and I thank them for it. But they are people, too, and just like any other large group of people - there will be those who do NOT do their job the way it is supposed to be done. There will be those who abuse their power. And they should NOT be given the benefit of the doubt simply because they are police officers. They should be held to the same standards, if not higher standards, than the rest of the population.

And further, we don't live in a dictatorship or an oligarchy. I, as a citizen, am not ruled by any one or any group of people. I do not have to simply listen to someone else because of their profession. If I have broken no laws and have done nothing wrong I do not have to "do what I'm told", because I'm an adult with rights. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.

The video in this case is pretty cut and dry. And just like with the case in Ferguson, the grand jury chose not to indict a police officer, when the vast majority of cases that do NOT involve police officers leads to indictments. Our justice system is holding police officers to a LOWER standard than the rest of the population. And that frightens me.

All lives matter. And what that means is that deaths that are ruled homicides deserve to be investigated and deserve a trial by jury.



Exactly.



Abso-freaking-lutely! This word for word!!

Posted 12/4/14 11:14 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?

Posted 12/4/14 11:15 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary

Posted 12/4/14 11:19 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary



I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?

ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.

Message edited 2014-12-04 11:21:57.003000.

Posted 12/4/14 11:21 AM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



I'd like to think that regardless of race, a person resisting arrest would be handled the same way.. but then again, the people I'm familiar with would give in, if a situation like this were to arise (regardless of color).

Posted 12/4/14 11:23 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary



I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?

ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.



To add to this: I have the privilege of working with young men and women of color at a private special education school in Manhattan. These kids commute into the city from the boroughs, from terrible areas where the things they encounter and witness are unimaginable. All so that they could have a good education and hope to get out of the cycle they live in. And yet, these amazing, fantastic teenagers who are hard working, studious, ambitious kids, are harassed DAILY on the subway and on their walk by police officers. ONLY based on how they look. And I HAVE witnessed it firsthand, because I have sat in the subway car with them on class trips, and seen it. With my own eyes. Kids doing NOTHING other than wearing baggy clothes and having corn-rows. Being harassed by police officers.

I had a 15 year old boy come into my office at 9am one morning IN TEARS because he was searched on the subway that morning. He was standing, listening to music, and he was stopped and searched and had his iphone confiscated because the officer assumed it was stolen. That he couldn't have afforded it otherwise.

Tell me how that is fair?

If it isn't about race, explain that to me.

Message edited 2014-12-04 11:28:26.737000.

Posted 12/4/14 11:27 AM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by bunnyluck

You couldn't pay me a million dollars a year to be an NYPD officer. These guys have it so bad. I have three family members in force and the stories and situations they endure on a day to day basis are dangerous and terrible....... and for what??? A lousy pay check and no respect or support from the community you protect and serve. Of course, there are dirty cops out there but the vast majority are good people working to feed families. I just hope we as a country, state, city and community we don't loose sight of that.


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 11:40 AM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

I don't get where this is starting to spin???

Maybe I'm blind. I don't see this as a race issue

Idk if it was excessive or not. And I say that bc I was not there. I'm not a cop. I never tried to arrest or take anyon down of that size

But if it's true he was arrested 31 times prior you would think when the officer tries to do his job you would follow

Again idk it was excessive but it has to be taken into account that he resisted.

Posted 12/4/14 11:41 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary



I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?

ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.




I am not talking about having a student, or knowing, or learning in a lecture here. I'm talking about family, friends, neighborhoods. I do not know you well enough, but I am pretty sure you didn't grow up living in and around crime.

I did.

That is where I say "close to". And again, I say YES, an officer of the law asks you something, you respectfully answer. If he asked you what time it is and you said 12 and he throws you on the floor because you were wrong? Ok, that's unnecessary. But in this case and a lot of others like it, it wasn't as simple of a situation as that.


I am not saying that there are no racist cops. Or people for that matter. What I am saying is in this particular case, I FEEL, my opinion, my thought on the matter, is that it had nothing to do with race and everything to do with size and resisting.

I guess you also have a background in IAB? Sounds like it

Posted 12/4/14 11:48 AM
 

LeeCR7
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

138 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by cowgirlkate

If you are not a law enforcement officer, and you have never tried to arrest an extremely large man who is resisting, I don't think you get to give your two cents on how they should have done it.



As with all authority figures, it is our right and our responsibility to make that judgment. If we could only have an opinion about things we are intimately familar with, most of us couldn't comment on much of anything.

My sister is NYPD. Before that, she worked for another law enforcement agency in a different part of NY (being vague on purpose here). She will be the first to tell you that most of her fellow officers are the best people she has met. It is like having a war buddy, almost, after they finish training.

But, as with everything, there is a dark side. There were many, many people she trained with who spouted racist garbage and misinformed nonsense. There were quite a few who joined the force so they could use force: they were looking for it, anticipating it. And police officers know they are unlikely to be punished legally. They are more worried about doing something that loses them their job. This is the minority, of course, but they exist.

My point is that police officers are humans, representing both the best and worst of humanity, who are given a little more power than the rest of us, and, fairly, given a little more leeway. What they are not given is absolute power and no accountability. Most of them don't even want that. To say we can't judge because we are not police officers is simplistic and, frankly, dangerous. Who, then, can judge them? Our whole system of justice is based on the fact that we are judged by our peers. That system resulted in no indictment. Whether fairly or not, I can't make a judgement without the transcripts.

With both of these cases I have been shocked at the assertion that we shouldn't question anything police officers do, ever, for any reason. America is not a police state, and we, as citizens, have the right to respectfully question them.

Message edited 2014-12-04 11:52:42.907000.

Posted 12/4/14 11:50 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by PhyllisNJoe

Posted by MandJZ

. Would I, personally, choose to listen to a police officer if I was ever in a situation where one was telling me to do something? Yes, likely I would. But if I am not being questioned or charged with a crime I do not have to.




You don't have to. But you would. That's the point a lot of people are trying to make.

Nobody answeres my question before. Do you think if this man, same situation, same build, same everything, was white - that these officers would have reacted using the same force ? My answer is yes. Same protocol no matter what race the person is.
I feel like a lot of people are saying it's because he was black that this cop didn't care enough to stop and check on him.



Personally? No. I don't think he would have used the same force. But that wasn't really my point.

And, even if I would choose to listen...if I didn't, do I then deserve to be attacked or have force used against me?



Yes.
If you resist arrest, you will be taken down to. Non threatening position so u can be arrested.

So yes

I'm sorry you believe that the reason force was used is bc of his race. You are lucky enough to not be close with people - white people - who have been in and out of the system who have been forced to surrender for arrest before.

I have. It's not a pretty scene though absolutely necessary



I'm not talking about resisting arrest. I'm talking about what I said above. If I have not done anything, and am not being questioned or arrested, and I choose not to listen to something a police officer says, do I deserve to have force used against me?

ETA: with all due respect, you have no clue who I know and what their situations are. So you don't know if I am "close with" any one, of any race, who has been in and out of the system.



To add to this: I have the privilege of working with young men and women of color at a private special education school in Manhattan. These kids commute into the city from the boroughs, from terrible areas where the things they encounter and witness are unimaginable. All so that they could have a good education and hope to get out of the cycle they live in. And yet, these amazing, fantastic teenagers who are hard working, studious, ambitious kids, are harassed DAILY on the subway and on their walk by police officers. ONLY based on how they look. And I HAVE witnessed it firsthand, because I have sat in the subway car with them on class trips, and seen it. With my own eyes. Kids doing NOTHING other than wearing baggy clothes and having corn-rows. Being harassed by police officers.

I had a 15 year old boy come into my office at 9am one morning IN TEARS because he was searched on the subway that morning. He was standing, listening to music, and he was stopped and searched and had his iphone confiscated because the officer assumed it was stolen. That he couldn't have afforded it otherwise.

Tell me how that is fair?

If it isn't about race, explain that to me.



In this case, no. That isn't fair. That is a jerk in the mix. It happens. Everywhere. There are bad people in every walk of life. And yes, even police officers.

AGAIN, in the case of what this thread is about - I don't think that's what happened.

Posted 12/4/14 11:51 AM
 
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Homeless man that got shoes from NYPD cop Aubreysmommy 12/3/12 48 Families Helping Families ™
NYPD cop in White Catle case dies. 04bride 2/8/06 13 Families Helping Families ™