Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...
Posted 12/17/2008 11:01:32 AM by CrankyPants


Posted by MST9106


Posted by CrankyPants


Posted by maybebaby


Posted by MST9106

I think the situation you're in is like Chat Icon . I totally agree with you but you know what, you're better off just leaving it alone. If she doesn't want to contribute then make sure that you list everyones names on the card except hers...and thats it.



It's nice to know some people can empathize with me. I am not a hateful or mean person. I just wanted to do right by these teachers that bust their butts with these special needs kids everyday....I guess I didnt full "understand" the background of this religion, but now I do and I am letting it rest!



I don't think that is the answer. Would you normally list all the names of the kids or would you just sign it from her class? If the latter, I wouldn't go out of my way to exclude her because of her child, that doesn't seem in the spirit of your holiday.

I also don't think you are hateful at all, I just don't think you understand all the dimensions of this persons religion. There are certain aspects of other religions that as a Catholic I would never participate in. It may not seem like a big deal to others, but it is to me and my religion. I would extend the same understanding to her.



Why isn't that the answer? How else do you go about the situation? Exclude 99% of the people from gift giving around the holidays just bc 1 person does not believe in it? .



I'm not saying that either. I would just write "from your class" to avoid leaving anyone out or overtly including anyone who wouldn't want to be included.

ETA I also like Ophelia's solution:

Posted by Ophelia

it IS their religion.

the right thing to do is put the child's name on the card so he doesn't feel left out and call it a day.

ETA: I would call her back and ask her how she feels about having her family name included in the card.

I don't understand why this is such a big deal....


Print Post      Close Window