Circumcision

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Thelma-n-Louise
LIF Infant

Member since 10/11

116 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision. I feel terrible for all men whose parents make this choice for them. It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female. Also, the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old. Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core. Anyway, to the OP, I find circumcision to be abusive, immoral and absolutely unnecessary. It's not a hard decision to make for your child....but it can be hard to justify in the face of uninformed family and friends. Go with your gut.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I really.just.cant.stop.laughing.

Seriously?

If a newborn baby can remember getting circumcised then that would mean it would also remember being born. Holy crap! Can you imagine how traumatic that must be?

Posted 11/1/11 2:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

petvet
LIF Adult

Member since 5/08

1238 total posts

Name:
Meredith

Re: Circumcision

Posted by DRMom

I did have it done and both were botched and look horrible. Actualy our ped told us one of our sons got 1/2 a circ and we should only pay 1/2 the bill. If I had it to do over, I probably would not have done it again.



This is what happened with my brother, and then he had to have it redone when he was like 4 due to adhesions. He said that it was the worst medical and emotional thing he ever had to have done. Since there is no strong medical evidence that circumcision is needed we won't be doing it if we have a boy...It is going to cause some religious issues in my family but they will have to deal. Not an easy decision one way or another but it will work out. Good luck!

Posted 11/1/11 2:26 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision.

It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female.



Can you cite your resources? I am really curious.

And circumcision for males are NOT the same as female circcumcision. Female lose ability to enjoy $ex hence the whole reason of female circumcision. Males DO NOT.

This topic came about a while ago. You need to inform yourself on the female circumcision who endure indeed traumatic physical and psychological side effects.

Not even remotely the same.


To OP. DS is circumcised. I am on the fence whether it was right to do it or not. DH wanted him too. I guess it was not "too traumatised" after all to have it done on his OWN son.

Message edited 2011-11-01 14:50:55.590000.

Posted 11/1/11 2:47 PM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Circumcision

Intactivist Video

http://www.drmomma.org/2011/08/intact-or-circumcised-significant.html


http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/day-i-withdrew-from-nursing-school.html

Doctors Opposing Circumcision Organization

This is a harsh procedure. It deserves harsh criticism from those who oppose it. I don't find it necessary to tip toe around for fear of hurting others feelings. Again...I never compared rape to circumcision. I only compared the use of the excuse that they won't remember so why bother. People often say don't waste your money on a huge first birthday party...they won't remember. And, my response uses the same logic in this scenario as it does in debunking the use of the logic to circumcize.....Just because they won't remember doesn't mean it won't impact them. Should we withhold hugs and kisses now because they won't remember them. Of course not. It helps build their character. Anyway....the information about the horrors of circumcision is out there for parents wishing to decide for themselves instead of follow status quo or family tradition. Could I have make my point less in a less inflammatory way...sure. But again, this is a horrific procedure that deserves to be criticized harshly.

Message edited 2011-11-01 14:58:14.383000.

Posted 11/1/11 2:57 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Intactivist Video

http://www.drmomma.org/2011/08/intact-or-circumcised-significant.html


http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/day-i-withdrew-from-nursing-school.html

Doctors Opposing Circumcision Organization

This is a harsh procedure. It deserves harsh criticism from those who oppose it. I don't find it necessary to tip toe around for fear of hurting others feelings. Again...I never compared rape to circumcision. I only compared the use of the excuse that they won't remember so why bother. People often say don't waste your money on a huge first birthday party...they won't remember. And, my response uses the same logic in this scenario as it does in debunking the use of the logic to circumcize.....Just because they won't remember doesn't mean it won't impact them. Should we withhold hugs and kisses now because they won't remember them. Of course not. It helps build their character. Anyway....the information about the horrors of circumcision is out there for parents wishing to decide for themselves instead of follow status quo or family tradition. Could I have make my point less in a less inflammatory way...sure. But again, this is a horrific procedure that deserves to be criticized harshly.



You still cannot compare male circumcision to female circumcision. It's just uncomparable!

I have worked in the field with $ex educators working with mutilated women in Africa. I have seen VERY graphic videos of it. I have translated educational materials on this topic. Trust me!!! It's NOT the same!

Yes, it's a surgery for males. Yes, it can be seen as "barbaric". But so is putting earings on a baby or piercings.

I think you need to inform yourself on what you are really comparing it to.

There are 3 levels of mutilation on women.

And it's called Female MUTILATION in female more than "circumcision".

Message edited 2011-11-01 15:09:15.583000.

Posted 11/1/11 3:08 PM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Circumcision

Smdl.....I didn't post those articles/videos above in response to you asking for sources. I was actually writing my post while you were writing yours, so I didn't get a chance to see your request. Male circumcision does cut erectile tissue and it does impact their sexual pleasure (those most cut men I know are doing just fine in this area). It is comparable on some, but not all levels, since circumcision only cuts a portion of the male erectile tissue not all and it's also done under more controlled settings. I just wanted to clarify that the articles I posted were NOT intended to be sources comparing male vs. genital mutiliation. Sorry for the mix up.

Posted 11/1/11 3:22 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

I know people get easily offended (especially with something like this b/c you've done it to your baby- your baby that you love and protect dearly) but after doing my own research-

I honestly do believe circumcision is a bodily mutilation.

I feel that so many people do it "just because that's what people do" (I'm talking besides religious reasons- which is a whole other can of worms).

I admitted in my response that if DH was circumcised I most likely just would have done it too b/c I wouldn't have looked into it the way I did.

I know (and have read on here many times before) that some women find it unattractive to be uncut but honestly it's all a matter of perspective (again, what seems "normal"). If that's the way you always knew it it, things would be different.

Skipping the procedure is actually on the rise as more and more people look into why it's the norm. It's definitely something worth taking the time to research.

Before anyone gets up in arms that I said you mutilated your child- yes I do believe it is a mutilation. However, I KNOW that parents aren't doing it to be mean or bad. We are doing it as a society b/c we grew up being told/believing that this is normal and right. My parents and grandparents were a little shocked when they found out my decision but when I explained it to them they understood my decision.

Posted 11/1/11 3:40 PM
 

QuackQuack
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/06

572 total posts

Name:
Chrissy

Re: Circumcision

DS got it done. Didn't think twice about it and figured he would never remember.

Posted 11/1/11 4:06 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Circumcision

OP, if you decide to get your DS circumcised, I highly recommend hiring a Mohel to do it rather than getting it done at the hospital by an OB, regardless of whether or not you are Jewish.

We had a Bris for my DS and he was circumcised by a Mohel (DH is Jewish, I am not). DS was not strapped down, he was being held by DH's uncle, laying on his lap on top of a pillow. He cried out for literally a second and it was over. He was fine the rest of the afternoon and did not seem uncomfortable to me at all the days following. He healed beautifully and there were no complications.

IMO, mohels are MUCH more qualified to perform circumcisions than OBs are because they are specially trained in circumcision.

Posted 11/1/11 4:57 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: Circumcision

i asked my dh and he said "absolutely"
for our son.

i would have supported him either way.

Posted 11/1/11 6:28 PM
 

hopeful4baby11
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/11

447 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Circumcision

If we have a son, he will have a circumcision. I am a urology nurse and have seen the pros and cons of circumcision more times than you can count. It is a decision my husband and I made which I am very comfortable with. It really needs to be the decision of the parents and what they believe is the right thing to do.

Posted 11/1/11 6:55 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Momma2Be

OP, if you decide to get your DS circumcised, I highly recommend hiring a Mohel to do it rather than getting it done at the hospital by an OB, regardless of whether or not you are Jewish.

We had a Bris for my DS and he was circumcised by a Mohel (DH is Jewish, I am not). DS was not strapped down, he was being held by DH's uncle, laying on his lap on top of a pillow. He cried out for literally a second and it was over. He was fine the rest of the afternoon and did not seem uncomfortable to me at all the days following. He healed beautifully and there were no complications.

IMO, mohels are MUCH more qualified to perform circumcisions than OBs are because they are specially trained in circumcision.



I completely agree with this. If we have another boy, I am seeking a mohel.

Posted 11/1/11 6:58 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Circumcision

Alright grill, I typically try to stay out this stuff, but this was pointed out to me and I feel the need to briefly respond.

I was raped. I had my son circumsized. Does that make me a repeat abuser? You always hear that those abused like to abuse others. Guess that was my intention? I looked into all my options and made an informed decision. My poor son has endured 3 surgeries in that area now. But I guess he deserved it right? Maybe I deserved it by being his mother?

It is fine having your opinion, but to be so blatant is your criticism has me extremely perturbed. I am trying to be nice and not get banned. You crossed the line and I refuse to do the same.

Posted 11/1/11 7:04 PM
 

Mrs-Boop
My Babies

Member since 5/05

4956 total posts

Name:
Jaime

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Thelma-n-Louise

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision. I feel terrible for all men whose parents make this choice for them. It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female. Also, the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old. Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core. Anyway, to the OP, I find circumcision to be abusive, immoral and absolutely unnecessary. It's not a hard decision to make for your child....but it can be hard to justify in the face of uninformed family and friends. Go with your gut.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I really.just.cant.stop.laughing.

Seriously?

If a newborn baby can remember getting circumcised then that would mean it would also remember being born. Holy crap! Can you imagine how traumatic that must be?




Seriously my newborn was in my arms ten minutes after being circumsized, smiling at me. He was surely not scarred for life.

Posted 11/1/11 7:44 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Circumcision

DS is circumcised - more because I have personally known 3 adult uncircumcised males that kept developing infections for various reasons. All 3 ended up having to undergo extremely painful adult circumcisions with long recovery periods.
No way was I subjecting my son to that if I could prevent it. I know it's not the norm, but the fact that I knew of 3 males dealing with it - when I knew maybe 10 uncircumcised males in my whole life - was enough to make that decision easy for me.

Posted 11/1/11 7:54 PM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Circumcision

I was raped. I had my son circumsized. Does that make me a repeat abuser? You always hear that those abused like to abuse others. Guess that was my intention? I looked into all my options and made an informed decision. My poor son has endured 3 surgeries in that area now. But I guess he deserved it right? Maybe I deserved it by being his mother?


Part of me feels extremely sympathetic to you for interpreting my statements this way. If you read my words, there is NO WAY you can draw such a faulty conclusion. Another part of me finds your logic absurd and rather silly. Of course your rape and your son's circumcision are not related. If it were, all mothers who chose to circumcise would have abuse in their history as well. Circumcision is a cultural norm that needs to be challenged because IT IS ABUSIVE. It has nothing to do with the abuse you have suffered (for which I am so sad and sick to learn and I wish you nothing but peace and strength).
AGAIN...for the last time. I used the Baby Abuse Scenario AND the First Birthday Bash scenario to debunk the concept of "what you don't remember, won't hurt you". That's all. I happen to believe that things you don't remember CAN still hurt you. Research does do. To those of you reading anything different or drawing parallels or comparisons between circumcision and sexual abuse...please reconsider. It's not even close to what I was saying. I'm done posting on this thread. I was asked to share how I felt about male genital mutilation and I provided my opinion. End of story.

Posted 11/1/11 7:56 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision. I feel terrible for all men whose parents make this choice for them. It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female. Also, the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old. Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core. Anyway, to the OP, I find circumcision to be abusive, immoral and absolutely unnecessary. It's not a hard decision to make for your child....but it can be hard to justify in the face of uninformed family and friends. Go with your gut.

ETA: Intactivist Video: Powerful, Emotional and Hopefully Compelling To Those On the Fence



It's one thing to have an opinion . . . .it's another thing to be rude.

You could have given an opinion that was helpful & informative instead you made it disgusting.

To call parents who have made the decision to get it done. . .abusive & immoral (which is basically what you are saying) is just honestly awful.

Posted 11/1/11 9:18 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Circumcision

Grill...

You are very entitled to your feelings, but your words are so harsh.

There ARE medical benefits to circumcision by the way...lots of older men end up getting it done to prevent chronic problems they end up having because of never being circ'ed

Both my sons barely cried..actually Ryan cried for 30 seconds and then went to sleep, woke up smiling while I held him.

There are MANY MANY things a child will go though that do not stay with them and cause future problems..

I would say that my sons bloodwork caused more angst than anything. As well as immunizations, 5 stitches in his forehead after falling, etc....

And i hate that you compare circumcision to female genital mutilation. They are not even comparable...

Your words sound very very hostile and terrible judgmental to a group of women who have either circumcised or will be circumcising their sons. Chat Icon

Posted 11/1/11 9:19 PM
 

babyfaith
Onward and Upward!

Member since 2/08

3210 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

A male friend of mine had a circumcision in his teens for medical reasons and still talks about how traumatic is was. He wishes his parents had it done when he was a baby.

Posted 11/1/11 9:42 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Circumcision

My DH and I talked about it and I was against it and he was for it. I asked him to do some research and let me know what he thought. We both then did research and decided against it. It's just not for us.

I will NOT debate my decision because I don't feel it's anybodies business what my dh and I decide with MY sons penis, so having said that all I can say is do research and be objective either way. If you want to chat in fm i'm more then happy to tell you what we found, but doing it on here I will not. I just think it's to personal and I really only want to share with a mommy who is considering not to. This decision is also based on personal feelings as well, and since it is personal I would not want to come across as saying I thought somebody made a bad decision. DOes that make sense? I already have to "defend" our decision to my whole freaking family....I just don't have the energy for LIF alsoChat Icon

Posted 11/2/11 1:08 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Circumcision

I did not circumcise my sons, and won't circumcise the boy I am carrying.

I did a TON of research, and I couldn't find compelling evidence to do it, the mindset is more "well everyone else is doing it so I will too." I firmly believe this is their body, and their choice, and without an imminenet need I don't think it's my right to permanently alter the way their privates function or look.

They can always get it done later in life, and while many claim it ismore traumatic then I'd rather them have access to anesthesia that works 100% (the anesthesia they provide to newborns doesn't completely numb them) and pain medication afterward. Also there are A LOT of boys that get recircumcised and I don't see the need to put them through one surgery just to increase their chances of needed the same exact surgery due to complications. In fact, the rate of boys needed to be recircumcised is the same as boys that were never circed needing to be circumcised, so it's a matter of 1 surgery versus 2, kwim?

As far as comparing male circumcision to female circumcision, of course with the more severe types of FGM they are not comparable in any way obviously. HOWEVER, in mnay countries female circ is the same as male, they are taken in the hospitals an have only their clitoris removed (Egypt was the one I read the most about that does this.) The male foreskin is kind of the equivalent of the clitoris. Would any of us ladies be ok with doing that to our daughters? Of course not! It's all a matter of cultural conditioning, and to us it's just as odd as male circumcision is to those in the UK and the rest of Europe. They dont regularly circumncise and there is hardly a parade of adult men having issue upon issue with their penises. Sometimes cultural practices can be wrong and deserve to be challenged, how else would they ever change?

To the OP- my husband and I had HUGE fights over this when I was pregnant with my first son. I basically told DH he had to do his own research and convince me, that he couldn't say "Because I said so". That's not the way we agreed to parent our kids, and neither one of us gets veto power over the other just because we feel like it, we have to convince the other person WHY, not just say "because I said so."

Posted 11/2/11 2:31 AM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Posted by smdl

Posted by Grill

Intactivist Video

http://www.drmomma.org/2011/08/intact-or-circumcised-significant.html


http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/day-i-withdrew-from-nursing-school.html

Doctors Opposing Circumcision Organization

This is a harsh procedure. It deserves harsh criticism from those who oppose it. I don't find it necessary to tip toe around for fear of hurting others feelings. Again...I never compared rape to circumcision. I only compared the use of the excuse that they won't remember so why bother. People often say don't waste your money on a huge first birthday party...they won't remember. And, my response uses the same logic in this scenario as it does in debunking the use of the logic to circumcize.....Just because they won't remember doesn't mean it won't impact them. Should we withhold hugs and kisses now because they won't remember them. Of course not. It helps build their character. Anyway....the information about the horrors of circumcision is out there for parents wishing to decide for themselves instead of follow status quo or family tradition. Could I have make my point less in a less inflammatory way...sure. But again, this is a horrific procedure that deserves to be criticized harshly.



You still cannot compare male circumcision to female circumcision. It's just uncomparable!

I have worked in the field with $ex educators working with mutilated women in Africa. I have seen VERY graphic videos of it. I have translated educational materials on this topic. Trust me!!! It's NOT the same!

Yes, it's a surgery for males. Yes, it can be seen as "barbaric". But so is putting earings on a baby or piercings.

I think you need to inform yourself on what you are really comparing it to.

There are 3 levels of mutilation on women.

And it's called Female MUTILATION in female more than "circumcision".



I completely agree. You can't compare the two.

Posted 11/2/11 9:09 AM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

I was raped. I had my son circumsized. Does that make me a repeat abuser? You always hear that those abused like to abuse others. Guess that was my intention? I looked into all my options and made an informed decision. My poor son has endured 3 surgeries in that area now. But I guess he deserved it right? Maybe I deserved it by being his mother?


Part of me feels extremely sympathetic to you for interpreting my statements this way. If you read my words, there is NO WAY you can draw such a faulty conclusion. Another part of me finds your logic absurd and rather silly. Of course your rape and your son's circumcision are not related. If it were, all mothers who chose to circumcise would have abuse in their history as well. Circumcision is a cultural norm that needs to be challenged because IT IS ABUSIVE. It has nothing to do with the abuse you have suffered (for which I am so sad and sick to learn and I wish you nothing but peace and strength).
AGAIN...for the last time. I used the Baby Abuse Scenario AND the First Birthday Bash scenario to debunk the concept of "what you don't remember, won't hurt you". That's all. I happen to believe that things you don't remember CAN still hurt you. Research does do. To those of you reading anything different or drawing parallels or comparisons between circumcision and sexual abuse...please reconsider. It's not even close to what I was saying. I'm done posting on this thread. I was asked to share how I felt about male genital mutilation and I provided my opinion. End of story.



You have made your point known, can you stop posting your harsh words about this subject now?!?

Posted 11/2/11 9:16 AM
 

TessMike214
Gabriella Aubrey born 3/26!

Member since 5/10

2440 total posts

Name:
Tess

Re: Circumcision

I had my son circusmsized, and honestly, I felt like it was taking forever and I felt so bad when I was waiting for him...it was a teeny bit traumatizing for me, I can't speak for him obviously...after reading these comments and that seeing that videoChat Icon I'm starting to feel bad again about the procedure that I chose for my son...can't turn back time though and it does seem to be the norm in the US

Posted 11/2/11 9:27 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Urologist Needed! Circumcision needs to be re-done.. gabbygirl855 8/16/11 17 Parenting
Who do I see to get a circumcision fixed? 2boys4me 7/29/11 7 Parenting
Moms of boys....when can I give my DS a real bath after a circumcision? missrock 4/27/09 2 Parenting
Can anyone refer a urologist to correct a circumcision in Nassau? ckone 2/3/09 4 Parenting
not for the easily offended. Circumcision and bris humor Kerie-is-so-very 10/8/07 2 Pregnancy
Something I didn't know about Circumcision nrthshgrl 3/3/06 30 Pregnancy