Re: Circumcision
Posted 11/2/2011 9:09:06 AM by CookiePuss
Posted by smdl
Posted by Grill
Intactivist Video
http://www.drmomma.org/2011/08/intact-or-circumcised-significant.html
http://www.drmomma.org/2010/01/day-i-withdrew-from-nursing-school.html
Doctors Opposing Circumcision Organization
This is a harsh procedure. It deserves harsh criticism from those who oppose it. I don't find it necessary to tip toe around for fear of hurting others feelings. Again...I never compared rape to circumcision. I only compared the use of the excuse that they won't remember so why bother. People often say don't waste your money on a huge first birthday party...they won't remember. And, my response uses the same logic in this scenario as it does in debunking the use of the logic to circumcize.....Just because they won't remember doesn't mean it won't impact them. Should we withhold hugs and kisses now because they won't remember them. Of course not. It helps build their character. Anyway....the information about the horrors of circumcision is out there for parents wishing to decide for themselves instead of follow status quo or family tradition. Could I have make my point less in a less inflammatory way...sure. But again, this is a horrific procedure that deserves to be criticized harshly.
You still cannot compare male circumcision to female circumcision. It's just uncomparable!
I have worked in the field with $ex educators working with mutilated women in Africa. I have seen VERY graphic videos of it. I have translated educational materials on this topic. Trust me!!! It's NOT the same!
Yes, it's a surgery for males. Yes, it can be seen as "barbaric". But so is putting earings on a baby or piercings.
I think you need to inform yourself on what you are really comparing it to.
There are 3 levels of mutilation on women.
And it's called Female MUTILATION in female more than "circumcision".
I completely agree. You can't compare the two.
|