Circumcision

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Teach723
Have faith. Believe. Dream.

Member since 8/10

2356 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Sorry girls. I didn't realize this would become so controversial. That video just traumatized me and I couldn't imagine my poor baby being strapped down like that. It just broke my heart and the pregnancy hormones don't help. But DH feels so strongly about it that I really feel like it's not my choice. I'll find out next week if we'll even have to cross this bridge.

Posted 11/1/11 10:27 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Circumcision

Get it done! cause if you wait then change your mind he will have to be put out and have surgery and I feel its harder on them when there older. My son had to get re-circumsised when he was close to a year and it was the hardest thing to go threw.

Posted 11/1/11 10:33 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision. I feel terrible for all men whose parents make this choice for them. It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female. Also, the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old. Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core. Anyway, to the OP, I find circumcision to be abusive, immoral and absolutely unnecessary. It's not a hard decision to make for your child....but it can be hard to justify in the face of uninformed family and friends. Go with your gut.



Do you know how many women on here already have circumsized boys? You are disgusting.

Posted 11/1/11 10:49 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Teach723

Sorry girls. I didn't realize this would become so controversial. That video just traumatized me and I couldn't imagine my poor baby being strapped down like that. It just broke my heart and the pregnancy hormones don't help. But DH feels so strongly about it that I really feel like it's not my choice. I'll find out next week if we'll even have to cross this bridge.




If your husband still wants to do it - why don't you try to watch a video of a circumcision done at a bris -- I have never been to one but I have heard that it is "not that bad." Maybe that will make you feel better about it :)

Posted 11/1/11 10:51 AM
 

gabbie83
2 girls <3

Member since 6/08

3037 total posts

Name:
gabbie

Re: Circumcision

if we have a boy we wont circumcize him

Posted 11/1/11 10:59 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaƮt

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Circumcision

Posted by GioiaMia

Posted by Grill

Your Dh is right, the baby will forget it in a few minutes!!!


I'd love to know how this "fact" was discovered. Tons of studies show that mutilated newborns suffer biological effects for up to 3 days post circumcision. I feel terrible for all men whose parents make this choice for them. It's comparable to removing the clitoris of a female. Also, the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old. Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core. Anyway, to the OP, I find circumcision to be abusive, immoral and absolutely unnecessary. It's not a hard decision to make for your child....but it can be hard to justify in the face of uninformed family and friends. Go with your gut.



Do you know how many women on here already have circumsized boys? You are disgusting.



I don't even have words for this woman. I am so mad right now, how DARE you compare mothers and fathers who choose to circumcise their children to rapists??

It's fine to give an opinion - lord knows many people feel the same way you do - but to lambast parents and accuse them of being abusive and immoral is just BEYOND. Shame on you. @*#!@^!#@#*!#&@# (and that's all I will say because I don't need a confrontation with this azz to get me kicked off the boards).

Atrocious.

Posted 11/1/11 11:04 AM
 

3rdtimesacharm
LIF Infant

Member since 10/11

67 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Both of my boys were circumsized and it took maybe 10 minutes, and when they came back they were really fine.

Posted 11/1/11 11:06 AM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Circumcision

We circumcised our son, and any other boys we have will also be circumcised. I always just kind of assumed we would if we had a boy, but I left the final decision up to my husband. He definitely wanted it done, so that was that. The procedure was superfast- they brought him back to me like 20 minutes later and he was all swaddled and happy as can be. Within days, his little penis was back to normal and it's never been a thought since. I have no issues with those who choose not to circumcise, as I feel it really is such a personal decision for the parents to make. And there are pros and cons to both sides of it. For us, it was mainly health reasons that decided it for us.

Posted 11/1/11 11:26 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Circumcision

i think comparing circumcision of infant boys to circumsion of women, which is done in barbaric rituals at older ages is just f**** INSANE..

you might not agree with the practice, but to say that parents who have had it done are up there with child rapists is the most disgusting thing I think I've read on here.

Posted 11/1/11 11:50 AM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Crashing:

My DS was circumsized at 2 days old.
It was done quick and it went well.

I agree with others, if you want to do it, do it now to avoid surgery in the future.

To Grill: Shame on you for comparing parents that did it to rapists!

Absolutley Horrible!

Posted 11/1/11 11:51 AM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: Circumcision

They took DS to the nursery and DH folowwed to watch (although they blocked him) i think he wanted to make sure he was ok. They brough him back 25 minutes later and he was sleeping and content. he didn't seem in pain at all.

Posted 11/1/11 11:53 AM
 

Budjeg11
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

2644 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

I plan on doing it if we have a boy, DH who is also circumcised totally agrees.
For me, my ex fiance was not circumsized and to be honest, it really was a problem for me- so I made the decision a long time ago that I would want to have my son circumsized, forturnatly for me DH agreed fully.

For some people it is definitly a cultural thing- there are pros and cons to both.

I hope that you and your DH can come to a decision together that you are both comfortable with.Chat Icon

Posted 11/1/11 12:05 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: Circumcision

Both of my DS's were

Posted 11/1/11 12:21 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Circumcision

I am leaving it up to my DH and he wants our boy to be circumsized so if I have a boy, he will be.

Posted 11/1/11 12:23 PM
 

menmyboys
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

811 total posts

Name:
Nikole

Re: Circumcision

While I understand wanting to know what is going to happen during certain procedures, the circumcision is something I will NOT watch simply because of the nature of it. DH and I argued about DS being circ'd... but in the end DS was. He was uncomfortable for the first two or three days but that's what the vaseline/aquaphor is for.

You have to go with what you and DH agree upon.

He probably got mad at you because you caused yourself a lot of unnecessary stress.

Not one baby remembers it...

Posted 11/1/11 12:40 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

We didn't do it. DH's parents came to this country a few years before he was born and it was never done over there so DH is intact.

If I were married to someone circumcised I probably would have done it without much deliberation. However, being married to someone uncircumcised prompted me to do research on circumcision.

After I did the research I really decided that there was more to my choice to not do it than just the fact that DH is not done- I won't go into the specifics since that is easy enough for any of you to look into- but the pros and cons led me to the decision to leave DS as is- which was really my gut feeling anyhow.


Posted 11/1/11 12:40 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Circumcision

Posted by bdmom

Plus, both my nephews had to have it re-done because theirs were botched.



Like I said in my own response, I did not have DS circumcised, but if I did I would research research research someone to perform it b/c the amount of times I have read here on LIF about botched circumcisions is CRAZY!

My advice to someone doing it would be not to feel stupid getting someone other than your OB if you have a good recommendation or an idea for whatever reason (like a bad review on here) that your OB might not be the person for the job.

Posted 11/1/11 12:44 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Circumcision

I did have it done and both were botched and look horrible. Actualy our ped told us one of our sons got 1/2 a circ and we should only pay 1/2 the bill. If I had it to do over, I probably would not have done it again.

Posted 11/1/11 1:19 PM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Circumcision

Once again, the LIF ladies LOVE the drama, LOVE to misinterpret and LOVE to draw unnecessary conclusions in hopes of stirring up drama.
I did NOT say that circumcision was comparable to rape or sodomy. I said that children don't remeber being raped, but that doesnt mean it doesn't affect them. I was discounting the "Won't Remember" argument that is constantly used to do harsh things to your children (ie. prolonged CIO, circumcision, physical punishment, etc.). The fact that he may not remember is NOT a good enough reason in my book to strap him down in four point restraints and rip off the most sensitive part of his genitalia. Whether the reason is so that he will look like his Dad or look like the other guys in the locker room, or be able to clean it easier, or religious....I don't care. I think the procedure is abusive. I am absolutely entitled to my opinion. I am also entitled to advocate strongly for unborn males in hopes of saving them from their parents poor decisions. Yes, they'll get over it. Yes, they'll be fine emotionally. Yes, their when he and his dad compare penises with each other they will look the same. I don't need to justify my own actions. I've done the research and I feel that circumcision is synonomous with genital mutilation, which is illegal if performed on females. I do think this practice should be outlawed. And I do think that religious customs and family traditions need to be challenged from time to time in order for the population to continue to evolve morally, spiritually and biologically. I've seen several videos of hospital circs and I've attended many Bris ceremonies (which are much more peaceful...even though the mom hides in the back room and cries). But IMO, which the OP asked for, circumcision is wrong. I don't think it makes anyone a bad parent. We are all doing the best we can out of love. But I do think it is sad when a mother, who has seen what a circumcision procedure REALLY looks like and seen physiological markers of the after effects, will still willingly send her new baby off to be cut. It's a process that deserves to be intensely scrutinized by all new parents. It is not enough to say 'we are doing it, because that's what we do'. If you think I'm disgusting, go watch the videos and then go apologize to your son. The procedure is disgusting. And I don't care who I offend. I was asked for my opinion and I provided it. I know it's a strong one...but there's a brand new human being at stake here...with real feelings, emotions, security needs and pain thresholds. I feel sad for him...I don't feel judgmental towards you. I get it. I get why people do it. I just think that as a whole, our society needs to challenge this from a medical, cultural, religious and emotional points of view.

Posted 11/1/11 1:34 PM
 

Cacarina
Two girls!

Member since 12/09

2971 total posts

Name:
Cari

Re: Circumcision

Posted by Grill

Once again, the LIF ladies LOVE the drama, LOVE to misinterpret and LOVE to draw unnecessary conclusions in hopes of stirring up drama.
I did NOT say that circumcision was comparable to rape or sodomy. I said that children don't remeber being raped, but that doesnt mean it doesn't affect them. I was discounting the "Won't Remember" argument that is constantly used to do harsh things to your children (ie. prolonged CIO, circumcision, physical punishment, etc.). The fact that he may not remember is NOT a good enough reason in my book to strap him down in four point restraints and rip off the most sensitive part of his genitalia. Whether the reason is so that he will look like his Dad or look like the other guys in the locker room, or be able to clean it easier, or religious....I don't care. I think the procedure is abusive. I am absolutely entitled to my opinion. I am also entitled to advocate strongly for unborn males in hopes of saving them from their parents poor decisions. Yes, they'll get over it. Yes, they'll be fine emotionally. Yes, their when he and his dad compare penises with each other they will look the same. I don't need to justify my own actions. I've done the research and I feel that circumcision is synonomous with genital mutilation, which is illegal if performed on females. I do think this practice should be outlawed. And I do think that religious customs and family traditions need to be challenged from time to time in order for the population to continue to evolve morally, spiritually and biologically. I've seen several videos of hospital circs and I've attended many Bris ceremonies (which are much more peaceful...even though the mom hides in the back room and cries). But IMO, which the OP asked for, circumcision is wrong. I don't think it makes anyone a bad parent. We are all doing the best we can out of love. But I do think it is sad when a mother, who has seen what a circumcision procedure REALLY looks like and seen physiological markers of the after effects, will still willingly send her new baby off to be cut. It's a process that deserves to be intensely scrutinized by all new parents. It is not enough to say 'we are doing it, because that's what we do'. If you think I'm disgusting, go watch the videos and then go apologize to your son. The procedure is disgusting. And I don't care who I offend. I was asked for my opinion and I provided it. I know it's a strong one...but there's a brand new human being at stake here...with real feelings, emotions, security needs and pain thresholds. I feel sad for him...I don't feel judgmental towards you. I get it. I get why people do it. I just think that as a whole, our society needs to challenge this from a medical, cultural, religious and emotional points of view.



I really hate to perpetuate said drama, but I really don't think there was ANY drama in this thread until you posted what I took (and I believe many others took) as a highly offensive way to put across your opinion. I have no problem with you giving out your opinion and I would never ever flame your choice, but the things you said in your argument were over the line, in my opinion. There were probably better ways to put your point across without offending a lot of people who already have made the choice to circumcise their boys. And maybe YOU didn't mean to compare circumcision to rape of children, but that's kind of how I took it...

Posted 11/1/11 1:44 PM
 

MrsDeVito
Gio's gonna be a big brother!

Member since 7/09

4671 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: Circumcision

Grill, there is a difference between stating your opinion and sounding like a berating lunatic. If you're so passionate about your cause, try informing people in a non confrontational way. I guarantee you'll get more people to listen. The way you choose to speak (write) is abusive.

Also "female circumcision" is done on MUCH older girls, usually with dirty make shift instruments by people who are not trained. The purpose of female circumcision is often to render sex unpleasurable. You're trying to compare apples and oranges.

And after your first post I asked every man in my family and close friends. They are all circumcised, all happy it was done when they were babies and all said if it hadn't been done they would have been upset with their parents for putting them in the situation to have to do it as adults if they wanted it.

You are entitled to your opinion and choice but there is a way to say it.

Message edited 2011-11-01 13:53:47.867000.

Posted 11/1/11 1:53 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Circumcision

Posted by MrsDeVito

Grill, there is a difference between stating your opinion and sounding like a berating lunatic. If you're so passionate about your cause, try informing people in a non confrontational way. I guarantee you'll get more people to listen. The way you choose to speak (write) is abusive.

Also "female circumcision" is done on MUCH older girls, usually with dirty make shift instruments by people who are not trained. The purpose of female circumcision is often to render sex unpleasurable. You're trying to compare apples and oranges.

And after your first post I asked every man in my family and close friends. They are all circumcised, all happy it was done when they were babies and all said if it hadn't been done they would have been upset with their parents for putting them in the situation to have to do it as adults if they wanted it.

You are entitled to your opinion and choice but there is a way to say it.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Very well said!

Posted 11/1/11 1:58 PM
 

menmyboys
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

811 total posts

Name:
Nikole

Re: Circumcision

Posted by MrsDeVito

Grill, there is a difference between stating your opinion and sounding like a berating lunatic. If you're so passionate about your cause, try informing people in a non confrontational way. I guarantee you'll get more people to listen. The way you choose to speak (write) is abusive.

Also "female circumcision" is done on MUCH older girls, usually with dirty make shift instruments by people who are not trained. The purpose of female circumcision is often to render sex unpleasurable. You're trying to compare apples and oranges.

And after your first post I asked every man in my family and close friends. They are all circumcised, all happy it was done when they were babies and all said if it hadn't been done they would have been upset with their parents for putting them in the situation to have to do it as adults if they wanted it.

You are entitled to your opinion and choice but there is a way to say it.




Couldn't have said it better... Thank MrsDeVito.

Posted 11/1/11 2:00 PM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: Circumcision

Having been team green, this was one of my worries. I didn't want my little guy to have to go through it. DH is Jewish and he said he wanted a bris so that meant he was a few days older now too. I really was hurting knowing that he had to go through it but I knew it wasn't that bad. My GF had her sons bris earlier this year and I attended. I stood right up front and watched the whole thing being done. Her son was more ****** off at having his diaper taken off than anything else. He cried for less than a minute. Later in the afternoon he cried for several minutes while waiting for his bottle to be prepared correctly. And he was way more ****** off about the bottle.

Two weeks ago today I gave birth to my DS. I was more than williing to have the hospital do the circ, but dh wanted the bris. Fine. Ok, we can do this! The mohelette (a female mohel) that did the procedure took more time setting up everything and getting ready than anything else. There was no strapping down. He cried for less than a minute when she applied the scissor looking things to the skin and I really think it was because they were cold. He stopped as soon as my mom shook the pacifier in his mouth. It was over before we knew it was happening. She said she was just going to take a measurement and about 30 seconds later she was saying, ok, all done.

If you would like the info of the mohelette, please send me an FM. She was amazing. A few other mamas on here used her.

Also, I'd like to see the video so I can tell you if it was anything like what I saw the two times. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/1/11 2:13 PM
 

menmyboys
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

811 total posts

Name:
Nikole

Re: Circumcision

Let's just look at your OP Grill:


"... the lame excuse that they won't remember is getting old ..."

So, where in the wording here should we not be offended?? A "lame" excuse? Sure, that's not snarky or rude.





"...Children under three that are raped, sodomized and molested don't remember either. It doesn't mean that it doesn't impact their development and their core..."


The word "either" indicates a direct correlation to the after effects of circumcision and rape/sodomy/molestation. So for you to say that you did not compare circs to rape, sodomy or molestation, is false. You sure did. Do YOU have any information that shows that a little boy is emotionally damaged from a circumcision?? Perhaps post that instead of your inflammatory remarks.

Maybe it's necessary to write out your opinion, take a step back and re-read it from another person's perspective before posting it. Maybe you'd see how your comments can cut to the core. Empathy can go a long way... Especially for the pregnant women you are directing this toward. In the same vein of empathy, I get your drive to save the unborn baby boys out there... I do. There are MANY things in our society that need to be changed... including the perspective on circumcision. Education is necessary. But it is not your job to berate and belittle those who have chosen contrary to what you believe.

As a PP has more eloquently stated your delivery is harsh and definitely could have been stated differently so you could get people to see your POV.

Message edited 2011-11-01 14:17:04.517000.

Posted 11/1/11 2:14 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Urologist Needed! Circumcision needs to be re-done.. gabbygirl855 8/16/11 17 Parenting
Who do I see to get a circumcision fixed? 2boys4me 7/29/11 7 Parenting
Moms of boys....when can I give my DS a real bath after a circumcision? missrock 4/27/09 2 Parenting
Can anyone refer a urologist to correct a circumcision in Nassau? ckone 2/3/09 4 Parenting
not for the easily offended. Circumcision and bris humor Kerie-is-so-very 10/8/07 2 Pregnancy
Something I didn't know about Circumcision nrthshgrl 3/3/06 30 Pregnancy