Re: Circumcision
Posted 11/2/2011 2:31:06 AM by Kidsaplenty

I did not circumcise my sons, and won't circumcise the boy I am carrying.

I did a TON of research, and I couldn't find compelling evidence to do it, the mindset is more "well everyone else is doing it so I will too." I firmly believe this is their body, and their choice, and without an imminenet need I don't think it's my right to permanently alter the way their privates function or look.

They can always get it done later in life, and while many claim it ismore traumatic then I'd rather them have access to anesthesia that works 100% (the anesthesia they provide to newborns doesn't completely numb them) and pain medication afterward. Also there are A LOT of boys that get recircumcised and I don't see the need to put them through one surgery just to increase their chances of needed the same exact surgery due to complications. In fact, the rate of boys needed to be recircumcised is the same as boys that were never circed needing to be circumcised, so it's a matter of 1 surgery versus 2, kwim?

As far as comparing male circumcision to female circumcision, of course with the more severe types of FGM they are not comparable in any way obviously. HOWEVER, in mnay countries female circ is the same as male, they are taken in the hospitals an have only their clitoris removed (Egypt was the one I read the most about that does this.) The male foreskin is kind of the equivalent of the clitoris. Would any of us ladies be ok with doing that to our daughters? Of course not! It's all a matter of cultural conditioning, and to us it's just as odd as male circumcision is to those in the UK and the rest of Europe. They dont regularly circumncise and there is hardly a parade of adult men having issue upon issue with their penises. Sometimes cultural practices can be wrong and deserve to be challenged, how else would they ever change?

To the OP- my husband and I had HUGE fights over this when I was pregnant with my first son. I basically told DH he had to do his own research and convince me, that he couldn't say "Because I said so". That's not the way we agreed to parent our kids, and neither one of us gets veto power over the other just because we feel like it, we have to convince the other person WHY, not just say "because I said so."
Print Post      Close Window