Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...
Posted 10/15/2010 11:57:40 AM by oneday


Posted by Janice


Posted by Little-J-Mommy


Did I battle the guilt of "giving up"? You bet I did!! Did this thread strike a chord with me to make me feel like a sh11ty mom for giving up? You bet it didChat Icon



deb, but that is just it. you can't "give up" unless you tried.
you did bf your baby. then you stopped. you tried it out.

But either way, you could afford the alternative.

no one is saying anyone is a sh!tty mom. bf or ff.


But Janice, and I hope you can read my tone b/c I am not trying to be snarky at all, but what would constitute enought "Trying" then. I tried very hard to BF. DS never latched well, my breasts hurt so much I could not even dry them with a towel. And that was for almost 4 months. But I had support. And I was able to be on maternity leave. I can't imagine doing that if if I was in a bad situation anyway.

A woman who needs help and does not want to BF could just walk in and say she "tried." She could even see a LC but unless you are sending her home with one for weeks (I saw one a number of times and though DS would usually latch there, we still had problems) how would you know? I just don't think BF is something you can FORCE someone to do. But denying a child formula isn't going to help anyone.

I also agree with Goldi - I think there are definately women who really shouldn't be breastfeeding. They probably likely shouldn't have been pregnant either, but I don't think we can take away a persons right to have a baby - as much as that would seem a good idea sometimes.Chat Icon

ETA - I do think that education on this is so important and I don;t really have a problem with the commercial itself - though it may be somewhat of false advertising if it gets some woman to consider BF more, I don't think that is all bad.
Print Post      Close Window