Re: WIC breastfeeding commericial...
Posted 10/15/2010 11:19:16 AM by Disneygirl
Posted by Ophelia
Posted by MarisaK
I didn't breastfeed b/c I didn't want to. I wasn't comfortable with it - Plain and simple. It was my personal choice. - However, my personal bank account could afford the formula I chose to give my son instead.
If I couldn't afford that formula, I think my comfort and 'personal decision' would be trumped by the fact that my CHILD NEEDED TO EAT so I think the expectation that I suck it up and TRY is perfectly acceptable - If I COULDN"T do it for whatever reason, that's different. But taking gov't aid simply b/c I didn't 'feel like doing it' ??? - Um, no sorry, I don't agree with that.
this is what I mean. I think brinaesq brought up some good posted about the effects of forcing it upon the mother in respect to how it would effec the child. it has softened by view i suppose b/c it makes me react emotionally, not fiscally.
but I guess I feel like rather than just hand over a can of formula, an LC ccan sit down with the mom and at least try. if you try and fail, at that point fine. then that is a REASON (which we siad, without reason. with reason is reasonable)
if this was about anything other than BF people would be so up in arms. I see MANY otherwise very conservative people being very liberal here and i can only surmise it's b/c they can relate in a way to this issue.
I wonder though, if we started talking about illegal women getting wic. getting free formula for their babies...where would that conversation go (ftr, I think they should try to bf too)
when you ask for assistance it cannot always be on your terms. it's not. there are rules and laws when you are on wic. on welfare. there are certain parameters that must be met.
it's not about using the services if you are in need. there is NO SHAME in that whatsoever. i just feel the basic idea and message is being lost and instead people are being painted in the light that I think is pretty harsh and unfair.
Ah thank you this is the point I've been trying to make all along. However BF is just one tiny issue in a giant sea of problems with how the gov't offers assistance to women in need as Goldi pointed out.
|