Re: Thoughts on this?
Posted 1/31/2013 7:02:03 PM by mommy2B3
Posted by Goobster
Posted by mrspalomino148
Posted by SweetTooth
Posted by Goobster
Posted by maybebaby
EXACTLY!!!
Breastfeeding is a normal bodily function but for a young child, it isn't! Simple as that.
Exactly. Young girls do not develop BREASTS or milk ducts until they reach puberty, therefore it is NOT a normal bodily function for THEM.
Why not just make Barbie and Ken dolls with working penis and vaginas, that teach about natural body functions like intercourse? Not cool or necessary either, just as this doll is not IMO. Young girls do NOT have breasts that can feed babies so therefore this doll is very inappropriate IMO.
I'm sorry, but that is a ridiculous comparison. I know you hate breastfeeding, but this is way over the top. Out of curiosity, what would you do if your DD pretended to breastfeed a doll?
I agree, I can't believe you would make that comparison. I would never have sex in front of my kids, but my DS has seen me breastfeed my DD. I really can't get over how people feel about breastfeeding, people are making it out to be a sexual thing between mother and child, which is just obscene, it's an incredibly special bond!
Dont see what the big deal is. Sex is natural. But it's private. Breastfeeding is natural. But not for children since they cannot breastfeed until they are adults.
I know one is about "nutrition". But to take it to the next extreme and have young girls have a doll to simulate, that has crossed the line, since young girls DO NOT HAVE breasts.
Breastfeeding isn't gross or unnatural. So why is sex now? B/c kids can't and should not have sex? Right. And kids can't breastfeed until adult age. So why not keep it off the table as a child's toy? That's my point. Some things are off limits as children's toys (hence my sarcastic point above about Barbie and Ken) and a child pretending to untie a top to expose a breast (that they dont even have) crosses that line.
JMO. That's the way I see it.
See I understand your point bc I'm assuming you were bottle only for your DC? But do you not see that some families are only EBF? While my oldest had bottles, my youngest never had a bottle, not ever, so in our house the norm is BF instead of bottles since my DS was old enough to remember how his sister was fed, so he told my DD how to feed her babies, just like mommy did kwim? I feel like most things kids do in imaginary play is not age appropriate, like cooking, cleaning etc. So I don't understand what the big deal is, kids do it bc that's what normal is in their home.
|