The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>

JessT
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

323 total posts

Name:

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

I didnt read the other threads, but i have a question. Can CIO work the same way if the DC goes to sleep ok, than wakes periodically throughout the night or is this for just going down to sleep the first time?

Posted 4/20/10 2:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by JessT

I didnt read the other threads, but i have a question. Can CIO work the same way if the DC goes to sleep ok, than wakes periodically throughout the night or is this for just going down to sleep the first time?



Yes. That is what we used it for since my DS was still waking to eat at 12 months old

Posted 4/20/10 2:26 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by JessT

I didnt read the other threads, but i have a question. Can CIO work the same way if the DC goes to sleep ok, than wakes periodically throughout the night or is this for just going down to sleep the first time?



This was how we used it. My DD went to bed just fine. It was the incessant night-wakings that we needed to fix. Because I EBF I was really child-led for a long time and always nursed her when she woke. By the time she was 10 months old though, I *knew* she didn't need those middle of the night feedings, so we started CIO.

It took almost a week total, but the worst was 3 days of crying and fussing. By the end of that week it worked and she was sleeping from 6:30pm til 6am.

Posted 4/20/10 2:29 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by JessT

I didnt read the other threads, but i have a question. Can CIO work the same way if the DC goes to sleep ok, than wakes periodically throughout the night or is this for just going down to sleep the first time?



I had to do it for the middle of the night wakings. Both went to sleep just fine but would wake constantly throughout the night, when I knew for a fact that they weren't hungry anymore.

Posted 4/20/10 2:32 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

I'm glad you posted this. What it comes down to is most people will only understand CIO if the HAVE to do it. I waited 10.5 months b/f giving in. I was SO against it. My DS NEVER EVER slept - unless i was physically standing rocking him. The older he got - the worse it got. He cried for two nights and that was it. He was a changed baby and I was a changed mommy.

For the poster who said she thinks it is cruel and explained what she did - yes, that worked for you - b/v me I would have done ANYTHING to not let my child cry. NOTHING worked except for that. I tried what you suggested - didn't work for us. My DS is and was a smart cookie. The older he got the worse it got - once he realized that all he had to do was cry and I would rock him it got so bad that is all he wanted. We slept for maybe 2 hrs at a time for AT BEST a total of 6 or 7 hrs TOTAL a day sleep for DS - including naps which were almost non-existent unless i stood rocking him the ENTIRE time. I did what I had to do - in my mind - cruel would have been to let my DS live his life without getting any sleep. Sleep deprivation is a REAL problem for children and affects their physical and mental growth a lot more than crying for two nights.

Message edited 2010-04-20 14:41:25.210000.

Posted 4/20/10 2:38 PM
 

mommy2devin
2 Boys, I need calgon!

Member since 10/07

1572 total posts

Name:
Shannon

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by MRSBA

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by MRSBA

Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms.

JMO



I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up.

For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc.

I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children.



yes, but when you title the post "the truth about CIO" I think it implies to new moms that this is how CIO works...when really it's just your version and not based on actual theories....and IMO that's why some new moms get scared off...cause they think to themselves that they would never let their child cry for an hour and a half so they assume CIO is not for them....just offering up a different "truth" that's all.....not sure that any actual book you read advocated your method.....



There are actually SEVERAL books that descibe the method Diana and myself (and many others) have SUCCESSFULLY used! This method, letting them cry WITHOUT going to them, is called the extinction method. I, personally, do not think that I am cruel. And guess what, DS is a normal, happy, healthy, WELL RESTED 3 year old who ADORES his Mommy. To all mommies, do what is best for your child and YOURSELF. We owe it to our children to teach them to put themselves to sleep and stay asleep. However we need to do that. Broken sleep is VERY detrimental to a child's development, even more so than the "cruelty" of lettiing them cry for a few nights.....

Chat Icon

Posted 4/20/10 2:41 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by Porrruss

Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods.

Ferber was a load of crap for me- but I've heard it has worked wonders for others. We tried it and it didn't work. And I followed it to the letter. I CANNOT go into my kids as it makes them more upset.

I used the Healthy Sleep Habits book's form of CIO. Specifically the Extinction method which was NO going in at night, and only going in after an hour for naps. HSHHC also has a graduated method which is similar to Ferber.




i just used the healthy sleep habits as well and just FYI- the extinction method says to not allow more then one hour of crying.

I think its imperative for kids to learn to self soothe and sometimes for some kids, CIO is the only method and it works.

For any mom, I would suggest doing research and deciding what is best for you.

CIO without going in is one method, but I would hate to think someone would possibly let their child cry for 2-3 hours without going in. Thats not advocated anywhere..and thats what my son would do. he'd cry for an hour, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr. CIO never worked for him. and yet we never found the right method.

I'm lucky with the twins that CIO did work and it only took 2 days and no more then 10 min's crying ( although we have had one or two set backs with naps...and for that I follow the book referenced above, its the one I'm most comfortable with).

I think as always, the bottom line as sooo many have mentioned is so whats best for you , dont defend your choices.

I can see how Dianas title might make it seem like shes saying one thing, but her post clearly said this was what worked for her and was sharing her experience and trying to help people.

Posted 4/20/10 2:41 PM
 

MRSBA
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

923 total posts

Name:

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by dm24angel


I can see how Dianas title might make it seem like shes saying one thing, but her post clearly said this was what worked for her and was sharing her experience and trying to help people.



agreed, I actually admit I misunderstood the intent of her message - which I think is a good one - you have to do what works for you. Whether it is some form of CIO or not.

My intent was simply to state that this was not the only form - I originally read the post as saying - "here is how it is done" not "here is one way it worked".

After reading her subsequent posts I think she was trying to point out that after one night, things were much better for her. I simply wanted to point out that for those that are hesitant to CIO - not all forms of CIO mean you can't go in the room...you can wait as little as a minute and keep going in. I think CIO can mean MANY different things and I was just pointing out that to even those who think it is "cruel" they may not understand that there are graduated ways of CIO....

Posted 4/20/10 2:53 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

We did a variation of CIO that worked for us.

Basically, mommy was so tired from constantly getting up all night that at 10PM she grabbed a bottle of red and hid in the closet crying.

After a year of that, I realized that it was cruel not to encourage healthy sleeping habits in my child so I tried a new version of CIO and it worked. Within 2 days my darling daughter slept like, well, like a babyChat Icon

And I just want to say that my parenting style rules and I am better than all of you people.

Posted 4/20/10 2:57 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by JessT

I didnt read the other threads, but i have a question. Can CIO work the same way if the DC goes to sleep ok, than wakes periodically throughout the night or is this for just going down to sleep the first time?



Yes. That is what we used it for since my DS was still waking to eat at 12 months old



We did too. At 8 mos DS was going to sleep fine, but waking twice during the night and I was osing my mind from lack of sleep.

Posted 4/20/10 2:58 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Porrruss

Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods.

Ferber was a load of crap for me- but I've heard it has worked wonders for others. We tried it and it didn't work. And I followed it to the letter. I CANNOT go into my kids as it makes them more upset.

I used the Healthy Sleep Habits book's form of CIO. Specifically the Extinction method which was NO going in at night, and only going in after an hour for naps. HSHHC also has a graduated method which is similar to Ferber.







CIO without going in is one method, but I would hate to think someone would possibly let their child cry for 2-3 hours without going in. Thats not advocated anywhere..and thats what my son would do. he'd cry for an hour, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr. CIO never worked for him. and yet we never found the right method.



But Donna, isn't it possible that you going in after each hour was the reason that it never worked with Noah? Maybe at an hour and 15 minutes he would have fallen asleep?

To be honest, every 20 minutes or so the other night I would say to myself "I'm going in to get him" but then I realized that I just let him cry for 20 minutes for no reason. Then at 40 minutes I would say "Forget it - not tonight" but then thought to myself, well then I just tortured the both of us for 40 minutes. It went like that until he finally fell asleetp.

And, like I previously stated - it was not all out hysterical crying for an hour and a half. It stopped a number of times, and turned to soft whimpers a number of times. That was how I knew he was ok. He even fell asleep a few minutes during that time period.

The bottom line is that it doesn't work for everyone - but it's not cruel and just a way to torture your kids.

Message edited 2010-04-20 15:06:35.840000.

Posted 4/20/10 3:06 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

As I said I did NOT do CIO and DD is 4 and VERY well adjusted, well rested, well behaved, smart, outgoing, independent, friendly.....need I go on? and all this WITHOUT CIO so for those of you who keep bringing up my use of the word cruel and how you HAD to do CIO to get your kids to sleep through the night for their development etc etc etc I too got mine to sleep but not using CIO.

Posted 4/20/10 3:07 PM
 

Fallbaby09
number 3...coming soon!

Member since 4/09

1811 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

we just did it last week at 5.5 months and it worked after 4 nights with each night getting easier. Me and DH felt that DS was ready for it. He was waking numerous times during the night and could not put himself back to sleep so we decided to try it. The longest we let him cry was for 15 minutes and I then I would go in and put my hand on his chest for 30-60 seconds and then leave. The first 2 nights he cried from midnight to 3 am and the next two nights it was much less. We felt that DS could only benefit from it and it really did work!

Posted 4/20/10 3:08 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by Porrruss

Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods.

Ferber was a load of crap for me- but I've heard it has worked wonders for others. We tried it and it didn't work. And I followed it to the letter. I CANNOT go into my kids as it makes them more upset.

I used the Healthy Sleep Habits book's form of CIO. Specifically the Extinction method which was NO going in at night, and only going in after an hour for naps. HSHHC also has a graduated method which is similar to Ferber.




i just used the healthy sleep habits as well and just FYI- the extinction method says to not allow more then one hour of crying.




I've got the book in front of me and can't find where it says no more than 1 hour other than for naps.Chat Icon The Extinction Method is described as "let-cry, no time limit" whereas Graduated Extinction is listed as "let-cry, time limit". Perhaps that's where our interpretations are different?

It's up to the parent to determine whether or not a child is crying due to hunger (which Weissbluth encourages the need to go in) or for other reasons. By the time my DD was 10 months I knew she wasn't hungry and had just developed a habit.

Of course I agree that we all do what's best for our families, which is why I waited until my DDs were a little older before starting the Extinction Method to CIO. I have also learned to keep my feelings to myself with regards to some others' parenting styles who are polar opposites of my own.

It's funny, LIF has really taught me so much about communication and not judging other's choices, even IRL. Chat Icon

Posted 4/20/10 3:09 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by beachgirl

As I said I did NOT do CIO and DD is 4 and VERY well adjusted, well rested, well behaved, smart, outgoing, independent, friendly.....need I go on? and all this WITHOUT CIO so for those of you who keep bringing up my use of the word cruel and how you HAD to do CIO to get your kids to sleep through the night for their development etc etc etc I too got mine to sleep but not using CIO.




But you also just previously said how your 4 year old ends up on a mattress in your room every morning and how she slept in a crib attached to your bed until she was two. While that worked for your family, and you had no problems with that, I'd like parents to know that there are other options out there.

Because while CIO is not an option for you, the things that you do are not an option for me.

Posted 4/20/10 3:09 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Parents should recognize that having their babies cry unnecessarily harms
the baby permanently. It changes the nervous system so they're sensitive to
future trauma."
- Dr. Michael Commons, Dept of Psychiatry, Harvard
-
No one is saying a good parent will never allow his baby to cry. They cry a lot. Again, it is their only means of communication. However, a parent should never give up trying to solve whatever is wrong with their baby. It is a modern, western notion that babies should be placed in a large crib in their own room by themselves at night. It is also a western notion that babies should be somehow “trained” to put themselves to sleep and stay that way 8-10 hours. When a doctor asks if your baby is sleeping through the night, he doesn’t mean for 8 hours straight! Babies have different sleep patterns than adults. Trying to push a baby into some kind of deep sleep, or "independence” is not in the best interest of the baby, it is in the best interest of a sleep-deprived parent who wants to catch some shut-eye. (Child rearing has no short cuts, folks.)

Posted 4/20/10 3:10 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by Fallbaby09

we just did it last week at 5.5 months and it worked after 4 nights with each night getting easier. Me and DH felt that DS was ready for it. He was waking numerous times during the night and could not put himself back to sleep so we decided to try it. The longest we let him cry was for 15 minutes and I then I would go in and put my hand on his chest for 30-60 seconds and then leave. The first 2 nights he cried from midnight to 3 am and the next two nights it was much less. We felt that DS could only benefit from it and it really did work!



Exactly, and that is another method that worked! There are tons of methods out there, people just need to find what works best for their family. Chat Icon

Posted 4/20/10 3:10 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by beachgirl

As I said I did NOT do CIO and DD is 4 and VERY well adjusted, well rested, well behaved, smart, outgoing, independent, friendly.....need I go on? and all this WITHOUT CIO so for those of you who keep bringing up my use of the word cruel and how you HAD to do CIO to get your kids to sleep through the night for their development etc etc etc I too got mine to sleep but not using CIO.




That's fantastic for you. Thank goodness you didn't have to do something you thought was cruel to finally get your child to get good sleep. Many of us are not so lucky and would appreciate not being called cruel.Chat Icon

I did not have to do full-on CIO with my second DD. Her personality is MUCH different and we didn't need it for her to learn how to self soothe.

Posted 4/20/10 3:12 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Just to clarify I DID NOT call any of your cruel parents. I said that I think that CIO is cruel...CIO is cruel not a, b, c are cruel parents. There is a difference.

Also just because my 4 year old wakes up in the middle or the night and walks into our bedroom next door where she falls asleep promptly on her mattress does not make her sleep deprived. Its the same as if she got up to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night.

Message edited 2010-04-20 15:14:14.060000.

Posted 4/20/10 3:13 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

can we do CIO on LIF? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

btw Cranky, my kung fu is better than yours.

Posted 4/20/10 3:13 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by CrankyPants

We did a variation of CIO that worked for us.

Basically, mommy was so tired from constantly getting up all night that at 10PM she grabbed a bottle of red and hid in the closet crying.

After a year of that, I realized that it was cruel not to encourage healthy sleeping habits in my child so I tried a new version of CIO and it worked. Within 2 days my darling daughter slept like, well, like a babyChat Icon

And I just want to say that my parenting style rules and I am better than all of you people.



omg Chat Icon !!!!!!!!

Posted 4/20/10 3:14 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by beachgirl

Parents should recognize that having their babies cry unnecessarily harms
the baby permanently. It changes the nervous system so they're sensitive to
future trauma."
- Dr. Michael Commons, Dept of Psychiatry, Harvard
-
No one is saying a good parent will never allow his baby to cry. They cry a lot. Again, it is their only means of communication. However, a parent should never give up trying to solve whatever is wrong with their baby. It is a modern, western notion that babies should be placed in a large crib in their own room by themselves at night. It is also a western notion that babies should be somehow “trained” to put themselves to sleep and stay that way 8-10 hours. When a doctor asks if your baby is sleeping through the night, he doesn’t mean for 8 hours straight! Babies have different sleep patterns than adults. Trying to push a baby into some kind of deep sleep, or "independence” is not in the best interest of the baby, it is in the best interest of a sleep-deprived parent who wants to catch some shut-eye. (Child rearing has no short cuts, folks.)



I'm sure that we can find plenty of studies that go against what you do in your house.

Again - TO EACH HIS OWN.

Posted 4/20/10 3:16 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Posted by beachgirl

Parents should recognize that having their babies cry unnecessarily harms
the baby permanently. It changes the nervous system so they're sensitive to
future trauma."
- Dr. Michael Commons, Dept of Psychiatry, Harvard
-
No one is saying a good parent will never allow his baby to cry. They cry a lot. Again, it is their only means of communication. However, a parent should never give up trying to solve whatever is wrong with their baby. It is a modern, western notion that babies should be placed in a large crib in their own room by themselves at night. It is also a western notion that babies should be somehow “trained” to put themselves to sleep and stay that way 8-10 hours. When a doctor asks if your baby is sleeping through the night, he doesn’t mean for 8 hours straight! Babies have different sleep patterns than adults. Trying to push a baby into some kind of deep sleep, or "independence” is not in the best interest of the baby, it is in the best interest of a sleep-deprived parent who wants to catch some shut-eye. (Child rearing has no short cuts, folks.)



IIRC that study was based on very young babies who were left to CIO over LONG periods of time. To the point that it was considered neglect. Like a parent just leaving their NB in a bassinet while they went out.

This study is NOT based on 3 nights of crying for an hour or so.

At the same time I'm sure I can post some studies that show some extreme cases of AP that cause some sort of psychological damage.

Once again, different strokes for different folks.Chat Icon

Posted 4/20/10 3:16 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please?

Posted 4/20/10 3:17 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff

And all I was trying to do here was explain to new moms that when you let a child CIO it doesn't mean that they fall asleep hysterical for the rest of their lives.

Gotta love LIF Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/20/10 3:17 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
to start CIO or not? (i know i know, another CIO post . . .) LoveMySMT09 3/18/10 8 Parenting
CIO question sunny 3/8/06 15 Parenting
anyone not use the CIO method Boobobunny 3/3/06 25 Parenting
We fell into CIO last night.... dree 3/1/06 7 Parenting
When can you start the CIO method? mishy 3/1/06 7 Parenting
CIO moms Bxgell2 2/22/06 10 Parenting