The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 | |
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
Message edited 2010-04-20 20:24:09.747000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:21 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Thank you for explaining and inspiring me to "bite the bullet" and try CIO. My DS is 12 1/2 months old, and the moment he sees his crib, he freaks out...literally, holding onto me like there's a monster in his crib. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article I would like a link and/or citation to the actual study, not some vague attribution such as "A recent Harvard study." |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by pig22seal My question is, if I try CIO, and he throws his bottle and blankets and all out of the crib, is it ok to go in his room and give him his bottle and lay him back down? My DH said thats not ok, that its teasing him. ! IMO, no. Some people do go in and try to soothe DC, but it never worked for us, we had to do a little "tough love" and not go in b/c DS would get worse if he saw is (teasing is a good way to look at it actually!) He will learn not to throw things
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by pig22seal Thank you for explaining and inspiring me to "bite the bullet" and try CIO. My DS is 12 1/2 months old, and the moment he sees his crib, he freaks out...literally, holding onto me like there's a monster in his crib. My routine is as follows. Bedtime routine ends with a bottle of (warm) milk, with his head on two pillows and his body laying on my lap, all on the couch. Within 5-10 minutes later he is sleeping. I place him in his crib ever so softly and 1 - 2 hours later he is standing in his crib awake, SCREAMING...tears and all. I don't run in, but within 5 minutes I take him out either lay on the couch with him the same way, or if I'm already in bed, he's right beside me until the breakfast time. If I'm still on the couch, I out him back in the crib and he will probably not wake up until 4:30-5am. I then make him a bottle and bring him into bed. The other night, he cried for 1 hour, and I broke down and took him out of the crib. My question is, if I try CIO, and he throws his bottle and blankets and all out of the crib, is it ok to go in his room and give him his bottle and lay him back down? My DH said thats not ok, that its teasing him. The reason why I didn't do this sooner, is because I'm big on the theory of attachment, and I don't want to create an insecure child. THANK YOU! The bottom line with CIO is you have to do what works for you and what you are comfortable with. There is no set formula. ETA: Personally, I'd let him throw the stuff out of the crib and just leave it. Message edited 2010-04-20 20:56:15.360000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by SweetTooth Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article I would like a link and/or citation to the actual study, not some vague attribution such as "A recent Harvard study." And actually, 06 is not really that recent anymore
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article Yes, that was the article mentioned before. And it's pretty vague about details....no age is mentioned anywhere in the article. Obviously, CIO might cause damage to young infants....no one is arguing that. The implication that parents who are using CIO are neglecting their children, or taking the easy way out is just wrong. CIO is difficult! It is so much easier to go in and comfort your child! But sleep is important to a child's brain development. And some children need to CIO to sleep. It would be neglectful to not CIO with those children. It's unfortunate that certain people aren't willing to admit that there is more than one CORRECT way to parent a child. And continue to judge others for their decisions. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Another article citing Harvards study about CIO |
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article Yes, that was the article mentioned before. And it's pretty vague about details....no age is mentioned anywhere in the article. Obviously, CIO might cause damage to young infants....no one is arguing that. The implication that parents who are using CIO are neglecting their children, or taking the easy way out is just wrong. CIO is difficult! It is so much easier to go in and comfort your child! But sleep is important to a child's brain development. And some children need to CIO to sleep. It would be neglectful to not CIO with those children. It's unfortunate that certain people aren't willing to admit that there is more than one CORRECT way to parent a child. And continue to judge others for their decisions. I'm in NO WAY saying my way is the "right" way. I'm not judging or claiming others are neglectful. I personally haven't read the entire thread! I read the first page and immediately quoted someone I agreed with. When I click on the page again, I saw someone asking for an article- thats all! To each his own! CIO isn't something I can do in my house, do whatever you feel is best in yours!
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 8:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Where's the actual study though? This article referencing the study was written in 2000....that was 10 years ago.
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Where's the actual study though? This article referencing the study was written in 2000....that was 10 years ago. Trying to find it, no luck just yet! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MrsP747 I'm in NO WAY saying my way is the "right" way. I'm not judging or claiming others are neglectful. I personally haven't read the entire thread! I read the first page and immediately quoted someone I agreed with. When I click on the page again, I saw someone asking for an article- thats all! To each his own! CIO isn't something I can do in my house, do whatever you feel is best in yours! But the articles you're quoting is saying that by allowing your child to cry, you're pretty much causing them brain damage and PTSD! You're not saying it personally, but by putting it out there, you are agreeing with it. Without ever mentioning that there *might* be another way to do things! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Posted by MrsP747 I'm in NO WAY saying my way is the "right" way. I'm not judging or claiming others are neglectful. I personally haven't read the entire thread! I read the first page and immediately quoted someone I agreed with. When I click on the page again, I saw someone asking for an article- thats all! To each his own! CIO isn't something I can do in my house, do whatever you feel is best in yours! But the articles you're quoting is saying that by allowing your child to cry, you're pretty much causing them brain damage and PTSD! You're not saying it personally, but by putting it out there, you are agreeing with it. Without ever mentioning that there *might* be another way to do things! I saw you asked for articles (at least I think it was you), so I went searching on the internet- thats all!! I'm sure there's many people who are against "Attachment Parenting" which is the style I follow. I'm sure there are many articles out there stating that I may be doing harm and I would not take offense to it if someone posted many links right now! Like I said, to each his own (or however the saying goes). And no I am not judging! In the end, I'm almost postive all our children will turn into teens who sleep all day and night and how they got there prob doesn't matter! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Sorry, I have to weigh in on this one... |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Once again, that article was written about babies who were left to cry for hours and hours every day. Babies who were documented cases of NEGLECT. Babies whose basic needs weren't being met. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Thank you so much for this. I have to notebook it and show my husband..then maybe we will be able to support each other and try ti |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by MrsP747 I'm in NO WAY saying my way is the "right" way. I'm not judging or claiming others are neglectful. I personally haven't read the entire thread! I read the first page and immediately quoted someone I agreed with. When I click on the page again, I saw someone asking for an article- thats all! To each his own! CIO isn't something I can do in my house, do whatever you feel is best in yours! But the articles you're quoting is saying that by allowing your child to cry, you're pretty much causing them brain damage and PTSD! You're not saying it personally, but by putting it out there, you are agreeing with it. Without ever mentioning that there *might* be another way to do things! I saw you asked for articles (at least I think it was you), so I went searching on the internet- thats all!! I'm sure there's many people who are against "Attachment Parenting" which is the style I follow. I'm sure there are many articles out there stating that I may be doing harm and I would not take offense to it if someone posted many links right now! Like I said, to each his own (or however the saying goes). And no I am not judging! In the end, I'm almost postive all our children will turn into teens who sleep all day and night and how they got there prob doesn't matter! It was me that asked for articles....mostly as a sarcastic comment for the poster who was calling CIO "cruel" and letting us know that CIO causes brain damage. She posted the article you did, and after looking myself, that was the only study I could find reference to about the matter....which makes me believe that there really is no answer! I did find something that stated that babies who are picked up immediately when they cry all the time tend to cry more because they learn that crying will get them attention, while babies who are left to cry a little before they are picked up tend to figure out other ways to soothe themselves. Which I thought was interesting....but unrelated. For the record, I never really used CIO....my daughter never really needed it, she taught herself how to self-soothe and has always been a great sleeper. But the few times she's been inconsolable, we've let her cry for a few minutes, and she worked it out herself. And she's a pretty happy kid! I just don't like the tone of the study....implying that CIO does so much damage. When, clearly, it can't be proven! And when the research is over 10 years old!
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride I just don't like the tone of the study....implying that CIO does so much damage. When, clearly, it can't be proven! And when the research is over 10 years old! The tone of the study isn't what people are reading, it's the biased sources that pick and choose what they want to report on that make the tone. The actual study that describes the subjects, and explains the variables, for some reason is unable to be found.
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff I am clearly not against the CIO method, even though I am finding it quite difficult to come to terms with. I just finished a 10 page term paper (citing 10 difference resources) and wanted to share a passage: |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article Yes, that was the article mentioned before. And it's pretty vague about details....no age is mentioned anywhere in the article. Obviously, CIO might cause damage to young infants....no one is arguing that. The implication that parents who are using CIO are neglecting their children, or taking the easy way out is just wrong. CIO is difficult! It is so much easier to go in and comfort your child! But sleep is important to a child's brain development. And some children need to CIO to sleep. It would be neglectful to not CIO with those children. It's unfortunate that certain people aren't willing to admit that there is more than one CORRECT way to parent a child. And continue to judge others for their decisions. see but that is the thing...there IS more than one way and I cannot understand why only ONE opinion is welcomed on this topic... It is obvious that more people DO use CIO so it is not some unheard of, rare, concept. Some people choose not to, some people think it is cruel to do CIO, some people think it is "coddling" to not do it, such is life why are people being asked to prove their feeling as valid with news articles...why can't people think it is "cruel" it is not a personal attack, just an opinion and for the record, I do not think it is cruel but I think all kids are different and you have to find what works for you and go with it, no appologies |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Porrruss Posted by Palebride I just don't like the tone of the study....implying that CIO does so much damage. When, clearly, it can't be proven! And when the research is over 10 years old! The tone of the study isn't what people are reading, it's the biased sources that pick and choose what they want to report on that make the tone. The actual study that describes the subjects, and explains the variables, for some reason is unable to be found. oops! that's what I meant!
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff BTW, here is the actual "study", which is not a study but an observation relating how Kenyan and Mexican mothers parent as opposed to American mothers. Message edited 2010-04-20 21:30:39.547000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by pinkandblue Posted by Palebride Posted by MrsP747 Posted by Palebride Posted by beachgirl Really? There are studies out there that go against parents responding to their babies needs? Find me one please? Sure thing.....while I'm at it though, can you find me a study that says that CIO and teaching your child how to become an independent human being in control of his/her own actions is being neglectful? Thanks! Here's an lil passage from an article I just read: A recent Harvard study shows that children who are left to cry themselves to sleep suffer long-lasting damage to their nervous system. As a result, they are more susceptible to post traumatic stress and anxiety disorders, including panic attacks. Responding to your baby’s cues when he cries does not spoil a child and it does not mean he will never sleep soundly on his own. In fact, a child who is comforted and nurtured will become more independent and healthy sleepers later because they know they have a dependable support system waiting for them when they wake up. Link to full article Yes, that was the article mentioned before. And it's pretty vague about details....no age is mentioned anywhere in the article. Obviously, CIO might cause damage to young infants....no one is arguing that. The implication that parents who are using CIO are neglecting their children, or taking the easy way out is just wrong. CIO is difficult! It is so much easier to go in and comfort your child! But sleep is important to a child's brain development. And some children need to CIO to sleep. It would be neglectful to not CIO with those children. It's unfortunate that certain people aren't willing to admit that there is more than one CORRECT way to parent a child. And continue to judge others for their decisions. see but that is the thing...there IS more than one way and I cannot understand why only ONE opinion is welcomed on this topic... It is obvious that more people DO use CIO so it is not some unheard of, rare, concept. Some people choose not to, some people think it is cruel to do CIO, some people think it is "coddling" to not do it, such is life why are people being asked to prove their feeling as valid with news articles...why can't people think it is "cruel" it is not a personal attack, just an opinion and for the record, I do not think it is cruel but I think all kids are different and you have to find what works for you and go with it, no appologies Because Stef, people are saying that we are causing long term damage to our children, that is why. Like someone said before, I don't agree with everything everyone does - but I don't throw out there that they are harming their kids. It gets very personal when someone says that. I am sure that if a child is left to cry all day, every day - yes, that will cause damage down the road. But, a few days up to a week? Give me a break. We are not talking about being neglectful parents. We are talking about doing what is right for us and our children! Message edited 2010-04-20 21:28:28.203000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Palebride Posted by Porrruss Posted by Palebride I just don't like the tone of the study....implying that CIO does so much damage. When, clearly, it can't be proven! And when the research is over 10 years old! The tone of the study isn't what people are reading, it's the biased sources that pick and choose what they want to report on that make the tone. The actual study that describes the subjects, and explains the variables, for some reason is unable to be found. oops! that's what I meant! I wish we could FIND that actual study so we can see what the true study was about. IIRC the study was lookiing at behavior changes in newborns who had been neglected. Who here can access medical journals online? |
|
Posted 4/20/10 9:28 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| to start CIO or not? (i know i know, another CIO post . . .) | LoveMySMT09 | 3/18/10 | 8 | Parenting |
| CIO question | sunny | 3/8/06 | 15 | Parenting |
| anyone not use the CIO method | Boobobunny | 3/3/06 | 25 | Parenting |
| We fell into CIO last night.... | dree | 3/1/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| When can you start the CIO method? | mishy | 3/1/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| CIO moms | Bxgell2 | 2/22/06 | 10 | Parenting |



But for ONCE, i'm going to keep my mouth shut. CIO was the BEST THING i ever did for my son and for our family. ANd i'll leave it at that.








