Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
Posted 4/20/2010 3:06:10 PM by Diana1215


Posted by dm24angel


Posted by Porrruss

Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods.

Ferber was a load of crap for me- but I've heard it has worked wonders for others. We tried it and it didn't work. And I followed it to the letter. I CANNOT go into my kids as it makes them more upset.

I used the Healthy Sleep Habits book's form of CIO. Specifically the Extinction method which was NO going in at night, and only going in after an hour for naps. HSHHC also has a graduated method which is similar to Ferber.







CIO without going in is one method, but I would hate to think someone would possibly let their child cry for 2-3 hours without going in. Thats not advocated anywhere..and thats what my son would do. he'd cry for an hour, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr, we'd go in, he'd cry for another hr. CIO never worked for him. and yet we never found the right method.



But Donna, isn't it possible that you going in after each hour was the reason that it never worked with Noah? Maybe at an hour and 15 minutes he would have fallen asleep?

To be honest, every 20 minutes or so the other night I would say to myself "I'm going in to get him" but then I realized that I just let him cry for 20 minutes for no reason. Then at 40 minutes I would say "Forget it - not tonight" but then thought to myself, well then I just tortured the both of us for 40 minutes. It went like that until he finally fell asleetp.

And, like I previously stated - it was not all out hysterical crying for an hour and a half. It stopped a number of times, and turned to soft whimpers a number of times. That was how I knew he was ok. He even fell asleep a few minutes during that time period.

The bottom line is that it doesn't work for everyone - but it's not cruel and just a way to torture your kids.
Print Post      Close Window