The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >> | |
|
The truth about CIO - one more spinoff I'm not sure if everyone truly understands what CIO really means. I also understand that it's not for everyone - but I'm not sure that all of those people know the truth about CIO. Message edited 2010-04-20 13:46:46.520000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 12:56 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Thank you for explaining! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 12:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff I also understand that it's not for every child. BUT, it does work. It's soooo hard, and Diana helped me so much when we were going through it with DS. Now, at 3, we all get a good night's sleep. So, take Diana's encouragement and words of advice if you are THINKING about CIO. She knows what she's talking about! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Someone wrote on another thread that they thought it cruel. I do not believe this at all. You are doing something that enables your child to get a good, full nights sleep - that's not cruelty. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by SweetCaroline Someone wrote on another thread that they thought it cruel. Ahhhh, I missed that one! In that case I must be a complete and total witch! Guess what though, both of my boys still love me! I have a feeling whoever said it never had a child who was up ALL NIGHT LONG!
Message edited 2010-04-20 13:06:01.730000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by SweetCaroline Someone wrote on another thread that they thought it cruel. I do not believe this at all. You are doing something that enables your child to get a good, full nights sleep - that's not cruelty. ITA. I watched my sister rock her youngest son to sleep until he was 4 years old. 4!!!!! And you know what? When she had finally had enough, she had to let him cry anyway--but it was much harder because instead of just crying, she got "MOMMMMMMMYYYYYYYY!!!! MOMMMMMMYYYYYYY COME BAAAAAAAAACK!!!!!!!!!" She didn't have more children after that one, but she always told me to teach my kids EARLY to fall asleep on their own. I think it's very sound advice, and you're giving your child an essential gift. A few nights of crying when they are at least 6 months old is not going to traumatize them--my DD is just fine and goes to sleep very easily now.
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MRSBA Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. JMO I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up. For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc. I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Diana1215 Posted by MRSBA Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. JMO I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up. For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc. I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children. yes, but when you title the post "the truth about CIO" I think it implies to new moms that this is how CIO works...when really it's just your version and not based on actual theories....and IMO that's why some new moms get scared off...cause they think to themselves that they would never let their child cry for an hour and a half so they assume CIO is not for them....just offering up a different "truth" that's all.....not sure that any actual book you read advocated your method..... |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MRSBA Posted by Diana1215 Posted by MRSBA Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. JMO I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up. For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc. I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children. yes, but when you title the post "the truth about CIO" I think it implies to new moms that this is how CIO works...when really it's just your version and not based on actual theories....and IMO that's why some new moms get scared off...cause they think to themselves that they would never let their child cry for an hour and a half so they assume CIO is not for them....just offering up a different "truth" that's all.....not sure that any actual book you read advocated your method..... I didn't realize the wording of my subject would be taken so literally. I think it's clearly stated in the body of my text that this is what worked for me. AND it may be different for everyone. And, the TRUTH about CIO is simply that you do not put your child down to sleep crying EVERY SINGLE NIGHT FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES. That is the point of my thread. There is a huge misconception about that. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff I am the mom who said I thought it was cruel in the other post. I cannot help how I feel. I am the type of mom who when I hear another child cry instinctively I want to go and lift that baby and comfort him / her - its just the way I am and I am not going to fight it. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by SweetCaroline Someone wrote on another thread that they thought it cruel. I do not believe this at all. You are doing something that enables your child to get a good, full nights sleep - that's not cruelty. you know I love you.... that said, if that OP thinks it is cruel, that is her perogative...CIO is not a requirement I never did CIO with Miki (I just could NOT listen to her scream)., It does not work for every family and it is not the only way Just wanted to share another side of the coin |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by beachgirl I am the mom who said I thought it was cruel in the other post. I cannot help how I feel. I am the type of mom who when I hear another child cry instinctively I want to go and lift that baby and comfort him / her - its just the way I am and I am not going to fight it. I do think its cruel to let a baby cry. I just dont see the logic of letting a baby cry until they give up and fall asleep as that is what they do- give up. We co slept with our first daughter until she was about 8 months then we attached her crib to our bed and she slept there until she was around 2 and then we bought her a big bed. Since then ( she is now 4) she starts off her night in her own room but ends up on a mattress in our room most nights and that is fine by us. We will do the same with DS who is now 8 months. Am I tired? Yes!! I EBF AND I work a full time job from home so its not like this is the easy option for me but its the only option. I have family members who do CIO and it works for them but it does not for me and we agree to differ on this aspect of parenting. It does not make either one of us a better parent just different. I think that every parent chooses what to do with their own child. You cannot listen to a baby cry - and I do respect that. I cannot have my children sleeping in my room. We all do what works for us. I try to keep the judgement to a minimum because I never know what I will encounter down the road! |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MRSBA Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. JMO That's the Ferber method, but there are other methods that say let them cry and not go in. In our case I read a few different methods and took the things that worked for me. I think its good to modify so its fits your family and your child. For DS it worked best for me to go in, lay hm down, say goodnight and leave. He was 8 mos old, I waited longer each time (or as long as I could) it took DS about 35 min the 1st night, 20 the 2nd and 5 the 3rd and we were done. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff I think people have to do whatever works for them, and regardless of what I think about certain parenting methods, it doesn't make anyone better than anyone else. We all try to do whatever is best for our kids, and that is all that matters. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Kidsaplenty I think people have to do whatever works for them, and regardless of what I think about certain parenting methods, it doesn't make anyone better than anyone else. We all try to do whatever is best for our kids, and that is all that matters. ITA! I take in as much information that I can, but then I do what is right for my child. I have learned not to judge anyone's parenting style because I never know what I will have to deal with down the road.
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by MRSBA Posted by Diana1215 Posted by MRSBA Eh - I understand your point but I actually think you are doing a disservice to CIO methods. IMO from what I've read, they do not recommend what you did. The Ferber method does not advocate letting a child cry for an hour and a half without going in and comforting them. Especially not the first night. I think this is where many parents get scared away from the CIO method because Ferber himself said that many people were not reading his books and just "extracting" what they thought cry it out meant. He really advocated a prolonged approach where it could take several nights, weeks or even months to get to the STTN, because there was a gradual progression of letting a child cry. I appreciate that this worked for you and many other moms, but I think you might be scaring off New Moms. JMO I'm not trying to scare off new moms. I said that this is what worked for ME! I also said that other people had success when going in to comfort their child. If my children even so much as felt my hand on their back - they got even more worked up. For me, two nights of crying is worth it to me when I will then have a child that is able to fall asleep on his own. Not only when he is 6 months - but when he is 2 years, 3 years, etc. I read Ferber. In fact I read every single sleep book out there before trying CIO with my son. I took pieces from every single one of them and made it my own - to fit with my children. yes, but when you title the post "the truth about CIO" I think it implies to new moms that this is how CIO works...when really it's just your version and not based on actual theories....and IMO that's why some new moms get scared off...cause they think to themselves that they would never let their child cry for an hour and a half so they assume CIO is not for them....just offering up a different "truth" that's all.....not sure that any actual book you read advocated your method..... I think what Diana means is that CIO was getting bashed in another thread for being all of these things and making it sound like pure torture. And yes, Ferber is one KIND of CIO. Like Amy (porrruss) said, it isn't the only kind. I did it too, and it didn't work for me until DS was 12 months old (though we did it on and off until from when he was 5 months, on my PEDs recommendation) I also think that this really, really, really falls into one of these things that newer moms think sounds TERRIBLE because they can't see their little newborn crying, but that is why it isn't recommended til babies are older |
|
Posted 4/20/10 1:59 PM
|
|
|
QuoteTheRaven424
Member since 5/05 13659 total posts Name: |
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff The bottom line is -like others have said - different strokes for different folks. |
Posted 4/20/10 2:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff We did this with DS#1 and DS#2 Message edited 2010-04-20 14:06:39.383000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by KateDevine I think what Diana means is that CIO was getting bashed in another thread for being all of these things and making it sound like pure torture. I must've missed that because I did not see any bashing....I almost think it is the other way around on these boards - not bashing persay but it seems like more people do CIO than not. I just want everyone to know, again, that CIO is not the only way to get your child to sleep through the night from 6 weeks - 2 1/2 miki was a great sleeper, she is going through some issues now with sleeping but CIO just does not work for us, at least with miki |
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff thank you for posting this. As a non parent i think this is really important to learn about. My sister in law's only flaw i found was always going to the kids when they had cried. Now at 8 years old they still wake up and need to sleep with mommy and daddy. My mother said she put me in the crib and let me cry my little heart out until i finally gave up and went to sleep. If i ever become a parent I plan on following that rule. Message edited 2010-04-20 14:17:08.917000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by pinkandblue Posted by KateDevine I think what Diana means is that CIO was getting bashed in another thread for being all of these things and making it sound like pure torture. I must've missed that because I did not see any bashing....I almost think it is the other way around on these boards - not bashing persay but it seems like more people do CIO than not. I just want everyone to know, again, that CIO is not the only way to get your child to sleep through the night from 6 weeks - 2 1/2 miki was a great sleeper, she is going through some issues now with sleeping but CIO just does not work for us, at least with miki IMO, "cruel" is bashing
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by pinkandblue Posted by KateDevine I think what Diana means is that CIO was getting bashed in another thread for being all of these things and making it sound like pure torture. I must've missed that because I did not see any bashing....I almost think it is the other way around on these boards - not bashing persay but it seems like more people do CIO than not. I just want everyone to know, again, that CIO is not the only way to get your child to sleep through the night from 6 weeks - 2 1/2 miki was a great sleeper, she is going through some issues now with sleeping but CIO just does not work for us, at least with miki I was referring to the fact that so many people were saying how they don't like to listen to their child cry. I think it's a misconception that CIO is an ongoing thing. Yes, they cry for a few nights, but having child CIO does not mean that they will cry themselves to sleep every single night for the rest of their infant/toddler years. I didn't think that all of the new moms really understood that. Message edited 2010-04-20 14:16:55.513000. |
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff Posted by Diana1215 I was referring to the fact that so many people were saying how they don't like to listen to their child cry. I think it's a misconception that CIO is an ongoing thing. Yes, they cry for a few nights, but having child CIO does not mean that they will cry themselves to sleep every single night for the rest of their infant/toddler years. I didn't think that all of the new moms really understood that. i completly agree with this. No one WANTS to see their child cry/hurt/sick. to say cio is not for you is one thing but to say that its cruel is judging what I think is best for MY child. ds cried 25 min the first night, 10 min the second night and by the third night he whimpered for 30 seconds. By the way ds JUST rolled over from belly to back for the first time ever as i was writing this Hes been a PRO from back to belly but today we have a belly to back roller
|
|
Posted 4/20/10 2:26 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| to start CIO or not? (i know i know, another CIO post . . .) | LoveMySMT09 | 3/18/10 | 8 | Parenting |
| CIO question | sunny | 3/8/06 | 15 | Parenting |
| anyone not use the CIO method | Boobobunny | 3/3/06 | 25 | Parenting |
| We fell into CIO last night.... | dree | 3/1/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| When can you start the CIO method? | mishy | 3/1/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| CIO moms | Bxgell2 | 2/22/06 | 10 | Parenting |







Guess what though, both of my boys still love me!









Hes been a PRO from back to belly but today we have a belly to back roller