Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
Posted 4/20/2010 3:09:45 PM by Porrruss


Posted by dm24angel


Posted by Porrruss

Just want to clarify something- Ferber is a FORM of CIO. It's not the end all be all of CIO methods.

Ferber was a load of crap for me- but I've heard it has worked wonders for others. We tried it and it didn't work. And I followed it to the letter. I CANNOT go into my kids as it makes them more upset.

I used the Healthy Sleep Habits book's form of CIO. Specifically the Extinction method which was NO going in at night, and only going in after an hour for naps. HSHHC also has a graduated method which is similar to Ferber.




i just used the healthy sleep habits as well and just FYI- the extinction method says to not allow more then one hour of crying.




I've got the book in front of me and can't find where it says no more than 1 hour other than for naps.Chat Icon The Extinction Method is described as "let-cry, no time limit" whereas Graduated Extinction is listed as "let-cry, time limit". Perhaps that's where our interpretations are different?

It's up to the parent to determine whether or not a child is crying due to hunger (which Weissbluth encourages the need to go in) or for other reasons. By the time my DD was 10 months I knew she wasn't hungry and had just developed a habit.

Of course I agree that we all do what's best for our families, which is why I waited until my DDs were a little older before starting the Extinction Method to CIO. I have also learned to keep my feelings to myself with regards to some others' parenting styles who are polar opposites of my own.

It's funny, LIF has really taught me so much about communication and not judging other's choices, even IRL. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window