Re: Tax Cap
Posted 2/19/2011 7:03:30 AM by bookworm

there's so much myth and misinformation on this thread, i don't even know where to start, but here goes:

* teachers pay into their benefits just like everybody else. in my district it's the upper administration that has 100% employer contribution for health.

* most teachers pay into the retirement system. as another poster said, tier 4 contributes for the first 10 years. that was amended, and new teachers (tier 5) pay their whole career. the folks breaking the retirement system are baby boomers who don't contribute and are all retiring at the same time, and sorry folks, you can't welch on an agreement that was made 30 years ago and that people planned their lives around. i'd also like to point out that the retirement system was heavily invested in the stock market, so in many ways, greedy BANKERS broke it.

* someone said they don't complain about what Verizon workers make because they don't pay their salaries. excuse me, but who does? the salary fairy? customers pay those salaries--paying for a service, not all that different from school taxes, which are still lower than tuition at a private school.

* i get really tired when people pull out this mythical ineffective gym teacher making 6 figures and then act like that's everyone and blame that for the broken system. you could fire that guy and still have the same problem. most teachers work really hard. most teachers don't make 6 figures. the ineffective ones that need to be removed are few and far between.

* this notion that people with more money shouldn't expect a better education for their kids is absurd. this is a capitalist nation; that's how it works. the state provides a basic, free and public education. people in wealthier neighborhoods exercise their democratic rights when they agree to pay higher taxes to provide their children with added opportunities. this is the reward for working hard in life (educating yourself, sinking energy into career ambition) and thereby making more money than other people. the idea that every high school graduate who has a baby is entitled to these perks is ridiculous.

* as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live.

* as far as special ed, what i have observed is that there are kids with legit special needs and then there are kids who have gaps in their education due to factors rooted in the home and slide into special ed as a means to make up for those gaps. as a community, i 100% agree that we have to band together and give a little extra for those who are battling disadvantages that are beyond their control. it's the second group, to me, that is exploding faster than really makes sense and milks budgets dry. ESL classes, where the numbers are usually under 15 with a teacher and maybe a para, are also very expensive. maybe it's different in other districts, but this is what i observe in my school on a daily basis.

* teachers, in large part, are highly educated, intelligent people. if gov't and voters bear down on them as if they're the root of the problem, you're going to drive away the talent. good teachers are not stuck in teaching; bad ones are. if you strip the job of its perks, people will leave the field. you get what you pay for. do you really want to be stuck with what's leftover?

* final point: the tax cap strips districts of financial resources but does nothing to address the problems that make the budgets so difficult to juggle, including all the unfunded mandates that are passed down by the state itself. what remains vulnerable is exactly what you don't want cut--teachers. then class sizes go up, and i'm sorry, but your kid's not going to get a lot of hands-on attention in a room with 29 other kids. if you want the RIGHT stuff cut, there's no easy solution--you have to get into the political mud and exercise your voice as a voter and taxpayer.

ETA:


Posted by MrsECullen7319

Effective teachers should not worry about losing tenure...if they are effective, their jobs should be safe.

I chose to quit teaching b/c it absolutely wasn't for me...I give HARD WORKING teachers all the credit in the world...you couldn't pay me enough to deal with some of these crazy parents who feel their child is entitled to everything they want.



those crazy parents are exactly the problem with eliminating tenure. sometimes it amazes me how quickly the PTA can stir up a witch hunt because a teacher refuses to inflate grades or give the frenzied, entitled mob whatever unreasonable concession it's demanding. if a teacher could bank on job security based on performance i'd agree with you, but this just isn't how schools work.
Print Post      Close Window