Re: "Raising" a child
Posted 2/8/2011 1:50:18 PM by maybebaby
Posted by Bxgell2
Posted by maybebaby
Posted by Bxgell2
Posted by computergirl
Posted by maybesoon
100 years ago Moms stayed home with their babies, right? Mom's having babies, and going right back to work is a relatively new concept so I don't agree w/ what Bxgell is saying
I think what she was saying is that 100 yrs ago, most moms did stay at home, so there was likely more of that "it takes a village" mentality, where women helped each other out with their kids. Also there were probably more multigenerational families living together, so grandma and maybe other relatives were probably more of a presence helping with the kids, kwim?
I think it was the concept of SAHM as a relative minority (depending on where you live) and thus having less of the "village" benefits .... that didn't exist 100 years ago.
Bingo - this is exactly what I meant - perhaps unnatural is not the right word, more like, not the norm. It is a recent concept for one individual to stay at home with a child for most of the day. Even 100 years ago, yes, while the mother was probably at home, she also had significant help from older siblings, grandparents, aunts, etc.
I'm not saying one way is wrong or right - I'm just saying that the "village raising a child" concept, which includes parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and even daycare providers, is not a novel concept.
Thanks for clarifying.
And yes, unnatural was not the right word at all. Like another poster stated, there is nothing MORE natural than a mom staying home with their baby. Not "better" but very natural.
It is not unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her baby, but I DO think it is unnatural for a mother to stay at home with her child, without any assistance from family, friends, daycare, what-not. Parenting in isolation, in my opinion, is not natural... I've done it myself when I was on maternity leave with my oldest, and it was beyond traumatizing.
This discussion is not about SAHM v. Working Moms. It's about whether others "raise" our children, whether we are SAHM or working, and I say yes, others DO, and I take it one step further by saying they SHOULD. But, again, that is MY opinion and I recognize that others may disagree.
No, the discussion wasn't about SAHM vs working mom. And it shouldn't be. B/c it doesn't matter. I just got defensive when i read your first comment. Which i think you can see can come across very different as to how you later explain it.
But i have to say....I pretty much parent in isolation, or at least i did for 2 years until johnny went to PT school...and i didn't find it unnatural. At all. DH worked, my family lived in NY while i was in VA.
DH came home every day at 4:30 which was awesome. but from 6:30a-4:30pm it was me and Johnny. And at times it was a bit isolating, but overall a wonderful experience i wouldn't have traded for the world. I didn't honestly need anyone else. BUT if he had been in someone elses care PT during that time, it would have been ok with me! I think it's good for kids to be exposed to others of course, i just didn't have that option..
|