Question about Circumcision...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Melbernai
I am a lucky Momma!

Member since 7/05

15652 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Question about Circumcision...

I keep seeing posts every week or so where people are talking about their son needing to be re-circumcised because it wasn't done properly the first time.

And to be honest it is scarying the HECK out of this pregnant woman! Chat Icon

How many of these cases are out there just on this site alone, which is a small sampling of the population?

I think we always had it in our mind that if we had a son we'd go ahead with the circumcision since Dh is...but honestly, this is freaking me out!

Posted 1/6/12 11:44 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Question about Circumcision...

I am not sure how common it is. We chose not to do it to our son. Reading those posts break my heart.

Posted 1/7/12 12:07 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Question about Circumcision...

I feel horrible for those women whose son's have to be re-circumcised. I would look to hire someone like a Mohel who does this for a living. Then you will know you had it done properly. We used Cantor Phil Sherman who performs circumcisions with out the religious ceremony for non Jewish families. http://www.emohel.com/ He did an excellent job. I believe that there is a doctor Diamond who is also a mohel that some other moms here have used.

ETA: Cantor Sherman performed a bris on DS as we are Jewish. If I recall correctly it was 750 for the bris. I am not sure if he would charge the same price for a circumcision or if prices have increased since we used him 4 years ago. I think he did an excellent job.

Message edited 2012-01-07 15:18:36.003000.

Posted 1/7/12 12:11 AM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Question about Circumcision...

My son had to be redone. Next time, although we are catholic, we are using our friend 's Mohel.

Posted 1/7/12 4:26 AM
 

MrsW2010
Mommy of two!

Member since 5/10

2202 total posts

Name:
Jill

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by ABCiverson

I am not sure how common it is. We chose not to do it to our son. Reading those posts break my heart.



ditto

and...my dh is circ and my son is not and we are 100% fine with that

Message edited 2012-01-07 07:59:55.503000.

Posted 1/7/12 7:11 AM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Not to be snarky...but how often do you think your husband and son will be comparing their penises? And, if they were different from each other, wouldn't a simple conversation clear up the matter and actually teach that perhaps what was done in the past isn't always the right thing? IMHO parents need to carefully analyze the purpose, risks, benefits and methods of the procedure before making the choice to cut their infants' erectile tissue off. In addition to my own opposition to circumcision...I have several friends whose sons didn't go so well. Here's a website called Doctors Opposing Circumcision if you are interested. Good luck to you and DH as you face this critical decision.

Posted 1/7/12 7:27 AM
 

VTTG0609
My loves <3

Member since 8/09

3294 total posts

Name:
V

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Unfortunately I think it is more common than not. Ds 1 was circ by a neonatologist and it was beyond perfect!
Ds2 had his done by the regular ob and it's a shotty job IMO. I am now stuck dealing extra skin, extra cleaning and a lot of work. I would like to get him recirced so it doesn't become a problem for him. Dh keeps telling me he will grow into it.
When I asked my ped about it he said experience definitely has ALOT to do with it.

Just wanted to add that none of these stories would get me to not circ my sons.

Message edited 2012-01-07 07:32:13.650000.

Posted 1/7/12 7:30 AM
 

dandj
Love of my life....

Member since 5/05

3687 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: Question about Circumcision...

DH and I both wanted to circumsize DS. My ob/gyn did it in the hospital but a year and half later we had to have him recircumsized because she left too much on.

It was pretty traumatic for me but DS (now 2 1/2) has no memory of it and had a very easy recovery.

I have heard it happening very often once I started researching it.

Posted 1/7/12 9:16 AM
 

Babymakin
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

920 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Question about Circumcision...

I have not read any of the posts, but I would be curious to know if the botched circumcision were Jewish done by a mohel.

I don't know if mohel's will do non Jewish children, but If you can, they are experts.

Posted 1/7/12 9:19 AM
 

Babymakin
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

920 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by LSP2005

I feel horrible for those women whose son's have to be re-circumcised. I would look to hire someone like a Mohel who does this for a living. Then you will know you had it done properly. We used Cantor Phil Sherman who performs circumcisions with out the religious ceremony for non Jewish families. http://www.emohel.com/ He did an excellent job. I believe that there is a doctor Diamond who is also a mohel that some other moms here have used.



Should have read this.

Exactly this post!

Posted 1/7/12 9:20 AM
 

Babymakin
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

920 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by LSP2005

I feel horrible for those women whose son's have to be re-circumcised. I would look to hire someone like a Mohel who does this for a living. Then you will know you had it done properly. We used Cantor Phil Sherman who performs circumcisions with out the religious ceremony for non Jewish families. http://www.emohel.com/ He did an excellent job. I believe that there is a doctor Diamond who is also a mohel that some other moms here have used.



Should have read this.

Exactly this post!

Posted 1/7/12 9:21 AM
 

CloudNine
My Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 2/09

2831 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Question about Circumcision...

from what i hear its better to get the on site ped to do it as oppose to the OB? i think thats what ive read in a few posts on here

Posted 1/7/12 9:22 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

first of all, my son is circ and my husband is not, his father is circ and my husband tells me he never realised that his fathers willy was different from his.

You may be hearing some stories about circ's that haven't gone well, but there are more stories that you DON'T hear because the circs went fine.

its your decision, don't let anyone else try to change your mind

Posted 1/7/12 9:23 AM
 

KangaMom
...

Member since 1/06

4593 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by ABCiverson

I am not sure how common it is. We chose not to do it to our son. Reading those posts break my heart.



Same here

Posted 1/7/12 9:49 AM
 

Kathy042806
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

1417 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by CloudNine

from what i hear its better to get the on site ped to do it as oppose to the OB? i think thats what ive read in a few posts on here



Some peds aren't surgeons, so they can't do it, at least that's what I was told. My OB did my ds when he was a couple of days old, and I've never had a problem. Looks great and I have no regrets.

Posted 1/7/12 10:00 AM
 

CloudNine
My Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 2/09

2831 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by Kathy042806

Posted by CloudNine

from what i hear its better to get the on site ped to do it as oppose to the OB? i think thats what ive read in a few posts on here



Some peds aren't surgeons, so they can't do it, at least that's what I was told. My OB did my ds when he was a couple of days old, and I've never had a problem. Looks great and I have no regrets.



im not 100% sure of the info, just something i thought i read. i had a random OB in the hospital do my son's and its messed up but im not saying its just cuz she was an OB, seems to be happening with a variety of diff surgeons. just stinks all around

Posted 1/7/12 10:19 AM
 

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: Question about Circumcision...

I have heard about a handful on this site but never knew anyone in my regular life who had a problem.

My OB did DS's in the hospital and it was perfect.

I think it seems like a lot here because this is a place where people may go looking for info on it but when you consider how many people are on this site but never mention it b/c they've not had a problem, it's really not that high a percentage. (IMO)

Posted 1/7/12 10:44 AM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by yankinmanc

You may be hearing some stories about circ's that haven't gone well, but there are more stories that you DON'T hear because the circs went fine.




This.

DS#1 is absolutely perfect and fine, done by my OB when he was born. Will do again for DS#2.

Posted 1/7/12 10:45 AM
 

ny55angel
car seat tech & geek :-)

Member since 2/06

4346 total posts

Name:
P

Re: Question about Circumcision...

DS was a preemie, and I seriously think that he was just too small when my OB did it. I regret having her do it, and it weighed heavy on me when we realized it would have to be redone. fast forward to now, 2.5 months after his re circ by Dr palmer and it looks great and healed very quickly. If DH and I have another child, and it is a boy, preemie or not, i am NOT having my ob do it. I will hire a mohel.

Posted 1/7/12 12:03 PM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by oneday

I have heard about a handful on this site but never knew anyone in my regular life who had a problem.

My OB did DS's in the hospital and it was perfect.

I think it seems like a lot here because this is a place where people may go looking for info on it but when you consider how many people are on this site but never mention it b/c they've not had a problem, it's really not that high a percentage. (IMO)



I agree with this.

I used a mohelette that Otherme recommended. She was amazing and DS is perfect.

Posted 1/7/12 12:14 PM
 

jacksmom09
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

687 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by MrsW2010

Posted by ABCiverson

I am not sure how common it is. We chose not to do it to our son. Reading those posts break my heart.



ditto

and...my dh is circ and my son is not and we are 100% fine with that




Us too.. we decided not to circ our son

Good luck with your decision! I did a lot of research and talked to medical professionals before making our ultimate decision, maybe it would be helpful to speak to your gyno, or a pediatrician?

Chat Icon

Posted 1/7/12 12:16 PM
 

Melbernai
I am a lucky Momma!

Member since 7/05

15652 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about Circumcision...

It is such a difficult decision! I think we always just assumed that our son would get circumcised but now that we are approaching the birth and still don't know if we are having a boy or not, we really have to discuss it. 6.5 years ago when we were having my DD we hadn't heard these scary stories. The stories definately make me want to think about it more carefully.

One thing that Dh and I discussed was hiring a mohel to do it. He did think that it would be a better decision then going with the OB which seems to be the norm. I mean, OBs are experts in women's bodies and our care during pregnancy, but I don't feel like they are experts in little boy parts!

I do have a very good friend with two sons who delivered with the same doctor I am using, so I am going to speak with her about it and see what she did. She will be able to give me an idea on how her son's procedures went, if she had them done!

Posted 1/7/12 12:54 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by LSP2005

I feel horrible for those women whose son's have to be re-circumcised. I would look to hire someone like a Mohel who does this for a living. Then you will know you had it done properly. We used Cantor Phil Sherman who performs circumcisions with out the religious ceremony for non Jewish families. http://www.emohel.com/ He did an excellent job. I believe that there is a doctor Diamond who is also a mohel that some other moms here have used.



I was going to say the same exact thing and recommend the same mohel. Cantor Sherman did an EXCELLENT job on DS and had come highly recommended from 2 other friends who had used him previously. I am not Jewish, DH is, but would have gone with a mohel even if he wasn't. Mohels specialize in circumcisions whereas OB's do not.

Posted 1/7/12 1:18 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by Melbernai
One thing that Dh and I discussed was hiring a mohel to do it. He did think that it would be a better decision then going with the OB which seems to be the norm. I mean, OBs are experts in women's bodies and our care during pregnancy, but I don't feel like they are experts in little boy parts!



If you are Jewish, and you are concerned to begin with, I STRONGLY suggest you follow through with this plan! Based on the research I made, the actual physical process of a proper bris is much different than the process of circumcision performed in a hospital by an OBGYN. I won't go into details but I can't tell you how incredibly at peace it made me feel knowing that the person performing such an all important procedure is someone who ONLY specializes in that procedure alone! It's a standard way that every mohel adheres to without deviation: always the same amount snipped, same angle, etc.etc...

Posted 1/7/12 2:38 PM
 

Melbernai
I am a lucky Momma!

Member since 7/05

15652 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by Melbernai
One thing that Dh and I discussed was hiring a mohel to do it. He did think that it would be a better decision then going with the OB which seems to be the norm. I mean, OBs are experts in women's bodies and our care during pregnancy, but I don't feel like they are experts in little boy parts!



If you are Jewish, and you are concerned to begin with, I STRONGLY suggest you follow through with this plan! Based on the research I made, the actual physical process of a proper bris is much different than the process of circumcision performed in a hospital by an OBGYN. I won't go into details but I can't tell you how incredibly at peace it made me feel knowing that the person performing such an all important procedure is someone who ONLY specializes in that procedure alone! It's a standard way that every mohel adheres to without deviation: always the same amount snipped, same angle, etc.etc...



We are not jewish. We were married in a catholic church and are bringing the kids up catholic. But DH had a jewish grandmother so even though we don't follow jewish traditions, he is familiar with them through his family. They did keep some jewish traditions when he was a child and was around his grandmother a lot.

I am going to have a serious talk with him about this tonight. We are on the fence about circumcision, but having a Mohel do it would give me a lot more peace of mind. Can anyone give me an idea about their pricing?

Posted 1/7/12 2:43 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
spinoff to circumcision question April09baby 12/8/08 17 Pregnancy
circumcision question.... mamallama 11/23/08 5 Parenting
Circumcision healing question.. Bluepixie 6/16/08 2 Parenting
Circumcision Question Michmouse 4/4/08 8 Parenting
Circumcision question shellybean 2/12/08 10 Parenting
Circumcision Question??? sweetie 9/9/07 6 Parenting