Question about Circumcision...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Four years ago Cantor Sherman charged 750 to perform the bris for DS. I am not sure if it is the same price for him to do only a circumcision or if his prices have changed in 4 years. I did not apply to have it go through our insurance as I felt it was a religious ceremony. I am not sure if your health insurance will cover it or part of it, but you could ask. He came highly recommended to me from quite a few different parents that my family knows IRL.

Posted 1/7/12 3:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by Melbernai

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by Melbernai
One thing that Dh and I discussed was hiring a mohel to do it. He did think that it would be a better decision then going with the OB which seems to be the norm. I mean, OBs are experts in women's bodies and our care during pregnancy, but I don't feel like they are experts in little boy parts!



If you are Jewish, and you are concerned to begin with, I STRONGLY suggest you follow through with this plan! Based on the research I made, the actual physical process of a proper bris is much different than the process of circumcision performed in a hospital by an OBGYN. I won't go into details but I can't tell you how incredibly at peace it made me feel knowing that the person performing such an all important procedure is someone who ONLY specializes in that procedure alone! It's a standard way that every mohel adheres to without deviation: always the same amount snipped, same angle, etc.etc...



We are not jewish. We were married in a catholic church and are bringing the kids up catholic. But DH had a jewish grandmother so even though we don't follow jewish traditions, he is familiar with them through his family. They did keep some jewish traditions when he was a child and was around his grandmother a lot.

I am going to have a serious talk with him about this tonight. We are on the fence about circumcision, but having a Mohel do it would give me a lot more peace of mind. Can anyone give me an idea about their pricing?



Hmm, not sure if a Mohel would agree to circumcise a none Jewish child. And honestly, if we weren't Jewish, we wouldn't have circumcise our son to begin with.

As far as pricing, traditionally a Mohel does NOT charge for his services: circumcising a Jewish male is a mitzvah (a good deed that celebrates G-d) and you can
not put a price on that! ;) However, everyone needs to eat so normally a nice donation is made to a temple that the Mohel is associated with. I believe my parents donated $500 for our son's bris 6 years ago.

Posted 1/7/12 4:00 PM
 

sarahbelle
Little drummer boy

Member since 5/05

2377 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by Melbernai


One thing that Dh and I discussed was hiring a mohel to do it. He did think that it would be a better decision then going with the OB which seems to be the norm. I mean, OBs are experts in women's bodies and our care during pregnancy, but I don't feel like they are experts in little boy parts!




Dr. Diamond performed our son's bris. He is a mohel and a urologist, which made me feel very confident that he would do a great job and he did. We have had no issues and our peds office has given his work a lot of compliments.

It was $700 or $750, I don't recall. I have no idea what it would be if you went to his office.

Posted 1/7/12 4:54 PM
 

Gdesq
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1314 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Our DS was circumcized by my OB who is a mohel. We have had no problems thankfully!

Posted 1/7/12 6:57 PM
 

carlowlou
loving my babies!

Member since 4/08

4594 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Question about Circumcision...

We did not have DS circumcised due in part to some of these issues I have heard about and also because DH is not. We just saw no need for it and we are not Jewish so no religious need either.

Message edited 2012-01-07 21:32:14.240000.

Posted 1/7/12 8:25 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

I am jewish so of course I did a bris. The mohel also did a great job

Posted 1/7/12 8:43 PM
 

maybemommy10
Big Brothers to Be !

Member since 2/10

3868 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

We had our sons snipped by Dr. Pilitteri (my OB at the time) and both are perfectChat Icon All the NICU nurses commented on how great a job it wasChat Icon Even our night nurse mentioned how good they look!

Never met anyone in real life that ever had an issue,

Posted 1/7/12 8:57 PM
 

jmf423
:)

Member since 5/05

6372 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

My OB did both of my sons curcumcisions and they were both fine and never had any issues.

Posted 1/7/12 8:59 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

My opinion is don't not do it bc of botched jobs bc with research you will prob find someone great to do it right. IMO there are a ton of other better reasons to not do it but obviously that's a personal decision and anyway ur not asking about that here.

Posted 1/7/12 9:16 PM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

My OB, Dr Pillitteri did it and did a great job.... phew. Is there anything that man can't do?

Posted 1/7/12 9:19 PM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by maybemommy10

We had our sons snipped by Dr. Pilitteri (my OB at the time) and both are perfectChat Icon All the NICU nurses commented on how great a job it wasChat Icon Even our night nurse mentioned how good they look!

Never met anyone in real life that ever had an issue,



Ha, I just posted the same t hing about Dr P!

Posted 1/7/12 9:19 PM
 

missus-hbradio
Twin mommy

Member since 5/05

15857 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about Circumcision...

My ob did a crappy job on my DS. Long story short we think he was in a rush and mad at the nurse at the time of the circ. We asked the ped several times if we should get it fixed and he said it will be fine in the long run so we opted not to put DS through it again. I never understood why it was the ob's job anyway - what do they know about penises???

Posted 1/7/12 10:22 PM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by carlowlou

We did not have DS circumcised due in part to some of these issues I have heard about and also because DH is not. We just saw no need for it and we are not Jewish so no religious need either.



Same here. I understand why people have their sons circumcised...it just breaks my heart to think that they have it done, and then have to do it again when they get older!

Posted 1/7/12 10:28 PM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Question about Circumcision...

most of the stories have to do with the skin reattaching itself which doesn't really have much to do with how well the child was circumcised but rather how it was cared for afterwards.... you have to continuously pull the skin down so it doesn't reattach.

Posted 1/7/12 10:58 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by lbride

most of the stories have to do with the skin reattaching itself which doesn't really have much to do with how well the child was circumcised but rather how it was cared for afterwards.... you have to continuously pull the skin down so it doesn't reattach.



I nave NEVER heard of this from anyone and was never told to do it with my son

I am pretty sure the stories of skin reattaching have to do with the amount of skin left vs. the amount of skin that was taken off. The reason why it is not an issue when circumcision is performed by a mohel is because there are very strict rules in Judaism about how much skin is taken off. It's not left to the discretion of a doctor: there is a law that everyone follows.

Posted 1/7/12 11:17 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Question about Circumcision...

Posted by DeniseMarie

Posted by maybemommy10

We had our sons snipped by Dr. Pilitteri (my OB at the time) and both are perfectChat Icon All the NICU nurses commented on how great a job it wasChat Icon Even our night nurse mentioned how good they look!

Never met anyone in real life that ever had an issue,



Ha, I just posted the same t hing about Dr P!



Phew! This makes ME feel so much better if I have a boy! I've been struggling with the decision as well. Good. .to know!

Posted 1/7/12 11:37 PM
 

bluekat16
My boys :-)

Member since 3/09

6659 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Question about Circumcision...

DS # 1 is not circumsized. We wanted to but they thought he had hypospadeas and wouldn't do it in the hospital When we saw the pediatric urologist he said our Ds #1 case was very mild and they could've done it. We could've chosen to have him circumsized at 8 months but pediatric urologist said if it was his son he wouldn't doing purely for aesthetics.

DS #2 is circumsized and I dread reading the re-circ posts...UGH. He's only 3 months old and I keep praying it was done right.

Posted 1/8/12 3:03 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
spinoff to circumcision question April09baby 12/8/08 17 Pregnancy
circumcision question.... mamallama 11/23/08 5 Parenting
Circumcision healing question.. Bluepixie 6/16/08 2 Parenting
Circumcision Question Michmouse 4/4/08 8 Parenting
Circumcision question shellybean 2/12/08 10 Parenting
Circumcision Question??? sweetie 9/9/07 6 Parenting