Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

lyss4525
LIF Infant

Member since 12/09

284 total posts

Name:
Alyssa

Nanny vs Daycare?

What are your opinions?

Posted 5/7/10 5:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

skinny
3 boys and a princess!

Member since 11/08

8178 total posts

Name:
Momma

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

I wanted to go w/ a nanny. A bunch of people brought up a good point----if she is sick, u r stuck. Going to a day care, someone is always there. I had to go visit a bunch of day cares----I saw some upsetting things that made me cry, but I finally found one that seems to be a good fit for us.

Posted 5/7/10 6:10 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

DD #1 is in daycare and I've never had an issue. I love them. DS will start going there when he is 12 weeks old.

Posted 5/7/10 6:31 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

There are pros and cons to both.

Developmentally, if you find a great daycare, I think it's a great option. DD was in daycare for 2 years and she learned sooooo much being there. Night and day difference with the stay home kids that I know. I even feel bad that I can't or don't know how to teach her like she was being taught when she was there, now that I'm home.

Nanny's can be more nurturing.

Posted 5/7/10 6:54 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by skinny

I wanted to go w/ a nanny. A bunch of people brought up a good point----if she is sick, u r stuck. Going to a day care, someone is always there. I had to go visit a bunch of day cares----I saw some upsetting things that made me cry, but I finally found one that seems to be a good fit for us.




I just wanted to bring up a counterpoint. If you choose daycare and your DC is sick, you're also out of luck because they can't go to daycare. There is no issue of that with a nanny. I have had a nanny for 3 years for my DD, and she (nanny) has been sick maybe 3x. I have maaaany friends whose DC get sick MUCH more than that in a given year due to daycare sicknesses.

Again, just a counterpoint to that first point you mentioned. It really comes down to what works for each family. Chat Icon

Posted 5/7/10 7:56 PM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Definitely daycare but it has to be an excellent one. With a nanny you are completely reliant on that one person being a honest and good person. With daycare, you have the checks and balances of many people keeping an eye out on each other. Of course, daycares are also regulated by the state as well.

Posted 5/7/10 8:32 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing.

With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning.

I am sure a nanny would love her as well as Chat Icon , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way.

Posted 5/7/10 10:32 PM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Unfortunately, a daycare center isn't an option for us. We live in a city and walk to the train station to get to work, so driving to a center and back home to then commute would add 2+ hours to our day.

So, I'm going with a nanny.. but believe me, I've thought long and hard about the +/- of each:

Nanny
+ Don't have to take the baby out in the morning (especially important in the winter)
+ Nanny will be here when DC is sick
+ Less daycare germs
+ One on one care at the infant stage
+ Personal relationship with DH and I, can really focus on our requests
+ Dont have to go crazy the night before prepping bag with supplies for day care

- More expensive than daycare
- Paying for every hour/minute (big train delay, nanny still gets paid by the hour)
- Some of those daycare germs might be good for DC (though I'm not entirely convinced of that theory)
- No socializing with other children
- No educational structure/stimulation

Posted 5/8/10 7:39 AM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

PPs bring up some excellent points. I also think a lot depends on the child's age. I'd be uncomfortable leaving a very young baby in a large daycare center; I'd feel much better if they were home with a single caretaker (JMO). But for an older baby (say, 1 year +) the socialization and stimulation of day care would be great for them.

Posted 5/8/10 8:42 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

We went back and forth on this when DD was born.

I was home for the first 6 months before going back to work and then went back PT.

In the end we decided on daycare.

The socialization aspect. I didn't want my DD to not have interaction with other children throughout the day, I look at it as she goes to a 2 day a week all day playgroup where she learns as well. With a nanny, she would be stuck home with the same person day after day, with no interaction with other children.

Like Leslie said too, my DD is thriving in such a way I never knew possible in daycare, and she's STILL in the infant room!

Not to put down nannies, or start anything, but as I'm home with DD 2 days a week, I take her to the park on nice days and I'm usually the only mom there, among the neighborhood nannies, and to be honest, the first time I was at the park, I was a little taken aback at how UNattentive the nannies/babysitters were to the kids. Most of them were sitting on the benches either talking on the phone or talking with eachother and not paying attention to the kids at all. Again, this is what I have observed and see all the time in my neighborhood. After seeing that it made me feel that much better about the decision to put DD in daycare.


ETA: My DD has only gotten sick in daycare maybe twice in the time she's been going. I know MANY kids who stay home with either their SAHMs, nannies, etc, that are sick all the time.

Message edited 2010-05-08 10:11:29.237000.

Posted 5/8/10 10:10 AM
 

Salason
&hearts;

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by melbalalala

Unfortunately, a daycare center isn't an option for us. We live in a city and walk to the train station to get to work, so driving to a center and back home to then commute would add 2+ hours to our day.

So, I'm going with a nanny.. but believe me, I've thought long and hard about the +/- of each:

Nanny
+ Don't have to take the baby out in the morning (especially important in the winter)
+ Nanny will be here when DC is sick
+ Less daycare germs
+ One on one care at the infant stage
+ Personal relationship with DH and I, can really focus on our requests
+ Dont have to go crazy the night before prepping bag with supplies for day care

- More expensive than daycare
- Paying for every hour/minute (big train delay, nanny still gets paid by the hour)
- Some of those daycare germs might be good for DC (though I'm not entirely convinced of that theory)
- No socializing with other children
- No educational structure/stimulation



I have a nanny (started for same reason that we were in the city) and this is the perfect list. We have since moved to LI and are sticking with a nanny because we like the benefits. That said, DS has what I would call some socialization issues in that he doesnt like dealing with adults other than me, DH, my mom and the nanny. I know some of it is just his personality but I cant help but wonder if that would have been naturally corrected through daycare.

FYI though, most FT nannies are salaried so you shouldnt have to pay for every extra minute from things like train delays. Remember there will also likely be days you get home a little early and let her go and days she'll have train delays too so it all evens out.

Posted 5/8/10 10:20 AM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by melbalalala

Unfortunately, a daycare center isn't an option for us. We live in a city and walk to the train station to get to work, so driving to a center and back home to then commute would add 2+ hours to our day.

So, I'm going with a nanny.. but believe me, I've thought long and hard about the +/- of each:

Nanny
+ Don't have to take the baby out in the morning (especially important in the winter)
+ Nanny will be here when DC is sick
+ Less daycare germs
+ One on one care at the infant stage
+ Personal relationship with DH and I, can really focus on our requests
+ Dont have to go crazy the night before prepping bag with supplies for day care

- More expensive than daycare
- Paying for every hour/minute (big train delay, nanny still gets paid by the hour)
- Some of those daycare germs might be good for DC (though I'm not entirely convinced of that theory)
- No socializing with other children
- No educational structure/stimulation



I was a nanny for a few years and I have to say, I got paid a salary so I didn't count mins/hours etc. one day they would get home late but another day early and let me get out early. so it all worked out in the end. neither side ever counted mins.

As for socialization- once the kids turned 8 or 9months old, I began mommy and me programs and would take them 2-3 times per week. we also had at least 2 or 3 play dates a week with other kids. sometimes it was with SAHM and sometimes it was with other nanny's/babysitters. then once the children were 2 years old, I took them to the YMCA for 2 or 3 morning classes. I would drop them off, it was just a few hours, but they got to meet other kids, and learn a lot. I also did a ton with the kids- took them to the park, bike riding, museums, the beach in the summer, the aquarium, the zoo, etc. I read to them a lot, and really tried to teach them as much as possible.

I have a few friends who worked in daycares and I remember them jumping around, for many different reasons. One negative about daycares is that they have a high turn over rate.

I'm not trying to say daycare is the wrong choice by any means, I only know the one side since that's the part I was involved in. I didn't get sick that often, but when I did, I tried to get on antibiotics as quick as possible. I always told the family I was sick as soon as possible, and unless I was really very ill, I usually left it up to them if they wanted me to still come. (as a mom your still around your kids when your sick, so its not that terrible) But out of the choices I think it cost a lot more for a nanny, then daycare. And if cost is a factor, daycare might be the better option

Posted 5/9/10 12:11 AM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by Salason

FYI though, most FT nannies are salaried so you shouldnt have to pay for every extra minute from things like train delays. Remember there will also likely be days you get home a little early and let her go and days she'll have train delays too so it all evens out.



I'm going back to work p/t though (2 days/week) so I'm probably going to have an hourly nanny

Posted 5/10/10 8:50 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by skinny

I wanted to go w/ a nanny. A bunch of people brought up a good point----if she is sick, u r stuck. Going to a day care, someone is always there. I had to go visit a bunch of day cares----I saw some upsetting things that made me cry, but I finally found one that seems to be a good fit for us.




I agree with this. I realized that the daycare centers would always be open-except snow days, etc-where as an individual could quit at any time, get sick, have family emergencies etc
I looked at the Tutor Time near me and I was very impressed with their infant room and the caregivers.
I feel very comfortable with her going there.
Plus I feel like in daycare she will be able to interact with other children- which I feel is so important for her social development.

Posted 5/10/10 8:53 AM
 

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by Goldi0218

Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing.

With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning.

I am sure a nanny would love her as well as Chat Icon , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way.



ITA. They do things with him all day long, things a Nanny would never have the time for. he is a very social kid, can speak and understand two languages. We have the added benefit of a spanish speaking daycare provider. so when she speaks with him, we asked that she speak to him in spanish. (DH's family speaks spanish, so this is great!) he can count in both English and Spanish, knows his colors in both languages and is in the early stages of potty training. The are very structured with nap times and meal times, which makes it very easy. These are all things I attribute to daycare.

Some of the cons I have identified are:

Cost $$$

Staff turnover

My son has Asthma, so he gets sick often

with our second child, he/she will also go to daycare...but only after 6 months like the first kid.

Posted 5/10/10 9:37 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by HeatherRose


As for socialization- once the kids turned 8 or 9months old, I began mommy and me programs and would take them 2-3 times per week. we also had at least 2 or 3 play dates a week with other kids. sometimes it was with SAHM and sometimes it was with other nanny's/babysitters. then once the children were 2 years old, I took them to the YMCA for 2 or 3 morning classes. I would drop them off, it was just a few hours, but they got to meet other kids, and learn a lot. I also did a ton with the kids- took them to the park, bike riding, museums, the beach in the summer, the aquarium, the zoo, etc. I read to them a lot, and really tried to teach them as much as possible.




this is something else to consider. For me, I do not trust anyone else to drive my DD around. But that's MY comfort level, and was also one of the factors in considering daycare vs nanny for us. It was actually a HUGE factor. You have to decide how comfortable you are with having someone else drive your kids around.

Posted 5/10/10 10:30 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

DD is in day care right now. I had her with a private babysitter when I first went back to work and it was just an awful experience. DS will start at the day care with his sister once he's 3 months old.

My experience with the day care is similar to what Goldi posted - I stopped counting DD's words ages ago because she speaks exceptionally well for a child her age, can count above 10, knows all her colors and shapes, all because of her activities in day care. She's really thrived in this environment.

She did get sick A LOT her first winter there and I'm very nervous about that when it comes to DS, since he'll be 4 months younger than DD was when she started, but her immune system is definitely stronger and she didn't get sick as often this winter.

Posted 5/10/10 10:33 AM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

There are definitely pros and cons to both.

For me, personally, I have to go back to work after 4 months. I'm not comfortable with a newborn in daycare, so I had a babysitter for DS #1.

I saw as soon as DS hit about 1 yr old that he was really bored at home with the babysitter and would have really thrived at a good daycare center but we were just comfortable in our routine, and truthfully, having a babysitter is easier bc she comes to our house so we don't have to worry about getting DS ready in the morning or running home to pick him up.

Now that we have DD on the way, we are thinking of keeping the babysitter to watch DD till she is 1 and then putting them both in daycare.

My babysitter in a year and a half has only called in sick on me 2x and once she got her 17 yr old daughter to cover for her.

Posted 5/10/10 10:40 AM
 

jennarose023
Jack's gonna be a big brother!

Member since 11/08

7769 total posts

Name:
<font color=green><b>Jenna</b></font color=green>

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

we are going to hire a nanny for 1 day a week since i am able to work at home all other days...so for us daycare isn't an option right now Chat Icon

Posted 5/10/10 10:40 AM
 

Salason
&hearts;

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by MrsFlatbread

Posted by Goldi0218
I am sure a nanny would love her as well as Chat Icon , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way.



ITA. They do things with him all day long, things a Nanny would never have the time for. he is a very social kid, can speak and understand two languages. We have the added benefit of a spanish speaking daycare provider. so when she speaks with him, we asked that she speak to him in spanish. (DH's family speaks spanish, so this is great!) he can count in both English and Spanish, knows his colors in both languages and is in the early stages of potty training. The are very structured with nap times and meal times, which makes it very easy. These are all things I attribute to daycare.



Have to disagree on these sentiments... If you find the right person, they will teach them everything they would learn in daycare but with an added bonus that it's custom tailored to your child. She most certainly has time to do things with him all day long because he is her ONLY responsibility. There is no lack of stimulation for my DS because this child is always out and about and when he's not they're working on things at home. I wouldnt pay more than double the cost of a daycare center for one on one care if he was sitting at home doing nothing and being put at a disadvantage...

Since I prefer a structured routine (naps and mealtimes) for DS, he gets just that (although it is hugely beneficial when he is sick etc that the routine can be adjusted for him.) Since he was 6 mos old, he's always out and about: at library & book store story times, playdates with kids in the neighborhood, at the park, at gym class, music class, etc. When they're not outside or at a class/playdate, my nanny works on craft projects, flashcards, and learning games with him that have given him a vocabulary & comprehension far exceeding that expected of his age (and that's coming from his ped and nursery school director not just a proud parent Chat Icon)

This isnt to say I dont think daycare has certain benefits. I'll be the first to say I think daycare is better for socialization. While we've exposed DS to lots of other kids through all of the stuff listed above, he's extremely attached to the main adults in his life (me, DH, nanny and grandma) and has a hard time warming up to other adults. We frequently wonder if daycare would have helped with that and it continues to be a huge challenge for us. But as far as stimulation, learning and structure, with the right nanny, I dont see daycare as being superior in that respect.

Posted 5/10/10 10:58 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

I was an au pair (a little different than a nanny), and I think if you find the right person and a 1:1 environment is important to you then it can be wonderful for your kids.

I wanted a more structured environment. I also wanted a lot of eyes watching (I don't trust anyone 100% with my kids, and I like that in a day care there is always someone else around). I wanted lots of in house activities (large playground and gymnasium, dance, music, soccer, etc). I like the coverage (i.e. there is always backup).

The only thing I do not like about daycare is the turnover rate-It was never a problem in the infant rooms, but my daughter's 2's room has had some turn over and I know this is the norm in a center environment.


Posted 5/10/10 11:10 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

I would rather have a nanny I want my baby to have one on one attention only. I don't want anything being taken away from him for other peoples children in the infant/ baby stage. Once they get to be around 2.5-3 I would put my kids in daycare for social aspect. my inlaws watched my DS for me when I was working and he is as smart as a whip now, he has cousins to play with and we take him to play groups, he was much better off w/ the one on one attention. and I never had to worry about him being sick and taking time off from work. HTH

have you visited any daycares? It may help your decision. we did, and I just couldn't leave DS there, I was Chat Icon at the thought of it .

Message edited 2010-05-10 12:35:05.993000.

Posted 5/10/10 12:34 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by maybesoon


have you visited any daycares? It may help your decision. we did, and I just couldn't leave DS there, I was Chat Icon at the thought of it .



OP-pay close attention to this. Daycare will may you and your children cry.

Posted 5/10/10 12:55 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by maybesoon


have you visited any daycares? It may help your decision. we did, and I just couldn't leave DS there, I was Chat Icon at the thought of it .



OP-pay close attention to this. Daycare will may you and your children cry.



funny. everyone is different, I knew ( and DH was adamant) we could never leave my DS in a daycare center after visiting. If you are happy using a daycare center, good for you Chat Icon

Posted 5/10/10 1:18 PM
 

babyonthebrain
Brotherly Love!

Member since 1/08

6209 total posts

Name:
Rafaela

Re: Nanny vs Daycare?

If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think...Chat Icon

Posted 5/10/10 1:25 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Does anyone use or plan to use a nanny/sitter rather than daycare? NervousNell 1/20/10 11 Pregnancy
WWYD: Which would you prefer - PT daycare or PT nanny? Bridex100 5/20/09 11 Parenting
Considering switching from daycare to nanny/sitter - with lots of questions! clwp 5/7/09 6 Parenting
Please help! PT daycare/nanny? pixie 7/1/08 6 Parenting
If money weren't an issue would you have a nanny or daycare? leighla 9/17/07 45 Parenting
Daycare vs. Nanny- what should I do?? Shelly 10/19/06 10 Parenting