Re: Nanny vs Daycare?
Posted 5/9/2010 12:11:23 AM by HeatherRose


Posted by melbalalala

Unfortunately, a daycare center isn't an option for us. We live in a city and walk to the train station to get to work, so driving to a center and back home to then commute would add 2+ hours to our day.

So, I'm going with a nanny.. but believe me, I've thought long and hard about the +/- of each:

Nanny
+ Don't have to take the baby out in the morning (especially important in the winter)
+ Nanny will be here when DC is sick
+ Less daycare germs
+ One on one care at the infant stage
+ Personal relationship with DH and I, can really focus on our requests
+ Dont have to go crazy the night before prepping bag with supplies for day care

- More expensive than daycare
- Paying for every hour/minute (big train delay, nanny still gets paid by the hour)
- Some of those daycare germs might be good for DC (though I'm not entirely convinced of that theory)
- No socializing with other children
- No educational structure/stimulation



I was a nanny for a few years and I have to say, I got paid a salary so I didn't count mins/hours etc. one day they would get home late but another day early and let me get out early. so it all worked out in the end. neither side ever counted mins.

As for socialization- once the kids turned 8 or 9months old, I began mommy and me programs and would take them 2-3 times per week. we also had at least 2 or 3 play dates a week with other kids. sometimes it was with SAHM and sometimes it was with other nanny's/babysitters. then once the children were 2 years old, I took them to the YMCA for 2 or 3 morning classes. I would drop them off, it was just a few hours, but they got to meet other kids, and learn a lot. I also did a ton with the kids- took them to the park, bike riding, museums, the beach in the summer, the aquarium, the zoo, etc. I read to them a lot, and really tried to teach them as much as possible.

I have a few friends who worked in daycares and I remember them jumping around, for many different reasons. One negative about daycares is that they have a high turn over rate.

I'm not trying to say daycare is the wrong choice by any means, I only know the one side since that's the part I was involved in. I didn't get sick that often, but when I did, I tried to get on antibiotics as quick as possible. I always told the family I was sick as soon as possible, and unless I was really very ill, I usually left it up to them if they wanted me to still come. (as a mom your still around your kids when your sick, so its not that terrible) But out of the choices I think it cost a lot more for a nanny, then daycare. And if cost is a factor, daycare might be the better option
Print Post      Close Window