Re: Nanny vs Daycare?
Posted 5/10/2010 10:58:31 AM by Salason


Posted by MrsFlatbread


Posted by Goldi0218
I am sure a nanny would love her as well as Chat Icon , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way.



ITA. They do things with him all day long, things a Nanny would never have the time for. he is a very social kid, can speak and understand two languages. We have the added benefit of a spanish speaking daycare provider. so when she speaks with him, we asked that she speak to him in spanish. (DH's family speaks spanish, so this is great!) he can count in both English and Spanish, knows his colors in both languages and is in the early stages of potty training. The are very structured with nap times and meal times, which makes it very easy. These are all things I attribute to daycare.



Have to disagree on these sentiments... If you find the right person, they will teach them everything they would learn in daycare but with an added bonus that it's custom tailored to your child. She most certainly has time to do things with him all day long because he is her ONLY responsibility. There is no lack of stimulation for my DS because this child is always out and about and when he's not they're working on things at home. I wouldnt pay more than double the cost of a daycare center for one on one care if he was sitting at home doing nothing and being put at a disadvantage...

Since I prefer a structured routine (naps and mealtimes) for DS, he gets just that (although it is hugely beneficial when he is sick etc that the routine can be adjusted for him.) Since he was 6 mos old, he's always out and about: at library & book store story times, playdates with kids in the neighborhood, at the park, at gym class, music class, etc. When they're not outside or at a class/playdate, my nanny works on craft projects, flashcards, and learning games with him that have given him a vocabulary & comprehension far exceeding that expected of his age (and that's coming from his ped and nursery school director not just a proud parent Chat Icon)

This isnt to say I dont think daycare has certain benefits. I'll be the first to say I think daycare is better for socialization. While we've exposed DS to lots of other kids through all of the stuff listed above, he's extremely attached to the main adults in his life (me, DH, nanny and grandma) and has a hard time warming up to other adults. We frequently wonder if daycare would have helped with that and it continues to be a huge challenge for us. But as far as stimulation, learning and structure, with the right nanny, I dont see daycare as being superior in that respect.

Print Post      Close Window