Nanny vs Daycare?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think... I've read your opinion on daycare.... It's not your opinion that people "jump" on you for, it's your delivery of it.... |
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think... I probably should have FM her my response as well
|
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Thank you, everyone, for all of your responses! You have given me and my hubby a lot to think about. I will be going back to work when DS is 5 months, so it is a tough decision. I look forward to some of your FM's |
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by MrsRbk Posted by babyonthebrain If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think... I've read your opinion on daycare.... It's not your opinion that people "jump" on you for, it's your delivery of it.... I don't think I've extensively discussed my opinion on daycare here, I even did a search and couldn't find anything. I don't know how tactful I can be delivering a view on something I do not agree with, there's just some things that can't be sugarcoated. I am a blunt, straight forward person and that's something a lot of people don't deal well with. You can please some people sometimes but not all people all the time.
|
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by Goldi0218 Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing. With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning. I am sure a nanny would love her as well as , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way. I am a preschool teacher but even if I wasn't I think I could stimulate my child the same way any daycare/preschool could. I can't speak for everyone of course but I think many parents can be empowered to teach their child just as much as any daycare could. You don't need a lesson plan to do that. You just have to read on what's appropriate for teaching preschoolers. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by MrsRbk Posted by babyonthebrain If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think... I've read your opinion on daycare.... It's not your opinion that people "jump" on you for, it's your delivery of it.... I don't think I've extensively discussed my opinion on daycare here, I even did a search and couldn't find anything. I don't know how tactful I can be delivering a view on something I do not agree with, there's just some things that can't be sugarcoated. I am a blunt, straight forward person and that's something a lot of people don't deal well with. You can please some people sometimes but not all people all the time. The only other thing I don't like about day care is that someone with your views could possibly be a teacher in my child's classroom. If you feel the way you do then you shouldn't be in the classroom. Message edited 2010-05-10 13:59:40.180000. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by melbalalala Unfortunately, a daycare center isn't an option for us. We live in a city and walk to the train station to get to work, so driving to a center and back home to then commute would add 2+ hours to our day. So, I'm going with a nanny.. but believe me, I've thought long and hard about the +/- of each: Nanny + Don't have to take the baby out in the morning (especially important in the winter) + Nanny will be here when DC is sick + Less daycare germs + One on one care at the infant stage + Personal relationship with DH and I, can really focus on our requests + Dont have to go crazy the night before prepping bag with supplies for day care - More expensive than daycare - Paying for every hour/minute (big train delay, nanny still gets paid by the hour) - Some of those daycare germs might be good for DC (though I'm not entirely convinced of that theory) - No socializing with other children - No educational structure/stimulation You have a lot of great points but I must say that a nanny can provide a child with education and structure. There's so many things they can do together that are educational such as reading books, painting, coloring, cutting papers, taking walks around the neighborhood, talking about what's around. They can can songs and do fingerplays, all that at the comfort of your home or nanny's home. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 1:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by CrankyPants Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by MrsRbk Posted by babyonthebrain If I give you my opinion here people will come and jump down my throat. Too many people who can't respect the opinion of others if it differs from theirs so I will FM you what I think... I've read your opinion on daycare.... It's not your opinion that people "jump" on you for, it's your delivery of it.... I don't think I've extensively discussed my opinion on daycare here, I even did a search and couldn't find anything. I don't know how tactful I can be delivering a view on something I do not agree with, there's just some things that can't be sugarcoated. I am a blunt, straight forward person and that's something a lot of people don't deal well with. You can please some people sometimes but not all people all the time. The only other thing I don't like about day care is that someone with your views could possibly be a teacher in my child's classroom. If you feel the way you do then you shouldn't be in the classroom. Feel which way? I'm not sure I'm following. Whether I prefer daycare or private care, it has nothing to do with my job performance. Just as the same whether I am a republican, democrat or independent. A person's views on things in life should influence their job performance in any way. (does it for some people, sure I guess so, but it doesn't for me) That's why we are professionals. I went to school for many many moons in order to be a highly qualified teacher, so my opinions have no bearing on my teaching. I think that's what fair teachign is. You present facts to your students not opinions
|
|
Posted 5/10/10 2:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain You have a lot of great points but I must say that a nanny can provide a child with education and structure. There's so many things they can do together that are educational such as reading books, painting, coloring, cutting papers, taking walks around the neighborhood, talking about what's around. They can can songs and do fingerplays, all that at the comfort of your home or nanny's home. You're right... they CAN... however, I know many do not. Being a PT SAHM, I've seen how 'some' nannies/babysitters go about their day with the kids they watch and it makes me GLAD my DD is in a structured environment during the day. I need a GUARANTEE the my DD is being watched/nurtured and taught during the day. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 3:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by Goldi0218 Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing. With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning. I am sure a nanny would love her as well as , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way. I am a preschool teacher but even if I wasn't I think I could stimulate my child the same way any daycare/preschool could. I can't speak for everyone of course but I think many parents can be empowered to teach their child just as much as any daycare could. You don't need a lesson plan to do that. You just have to read on what's appropriate for teaching preschoolers. It seems as if you have jumped to the defensive on MANY opinions here. I speak of my own experiences, my own standards of teaching and learning and frankly, I would not even begin to challenge ANY parent as to what they are capable of. We are obviously capable. I had been speaking of day care versus nanny (NOT PARENTS) and the experiences Abby has had thus far. Frankly, unless I am hiring a certified pre-school teacher as a nanny for my children, I can guarantee this nanny will NOT provide the same experiences that Abby has had thus far. I am pleased and do NOT want this to change. Will I be able to afford 2 kids in day care just after buying a house? Possibly, though not likely. I am allowed to "grieve" the changes in my children's learning experiences. I'm not going to sit here and list them because it would make no difference to anyone but me and my OPINION on my own child is the only one that truly matters. I myself am an educator with EXTREMELY high standards having taught children ages 5-21 over the course of 14+ years in various subjects. I carry two certificates and am qualified myself to teach on a pre-school level, but you know what? Until and unless we hit lotto, I am teaching other people's children all day and do not wish to "teach" when I get home. I just want to come home, love her, hug her and sing with her. I want to feed her, play with her and do her hair. I don't need the most current info on what is right for my toddler, but a nanny might. Message edited 2010-05-10 17:52:39.863000. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 5:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by Salason Good points. I should not have made assumptions about a nanny. I will say though, with a daycare, I feel like there is safety in numbers. Even though you can get a nanny cam, if he/she did something to your child, you would find out hours after the fact. IMO, after the fact is way too late. |
|
Posted 5/10/10 8:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? I was ALL about a nanny /anti-daycare while I was pregnant. Then I watched my friends sister go thru 5 nannies in 1 year. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 7:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? my kids go to in home care and it works for us... |
|
Posted 5/11/10 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by Goldi0218 Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by Goldi0218 Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing. With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning. I am sure a nanny would love her as well as , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way. I am a preschool teacher but even if I wasn't I think I could stimulate my child the same way any daycare/preschool could. I can't speak for everyone of course but I think many parents can be empowered to teach their child just as much as any daycare could. You don't need a lesson plan to do that. You just have to read on what's appropriate for teaching preschoolers. It seems as if you have jumped to the defensive on MANY opinions here. I speak of my own experiences, my own standards of teaching and learning and frankly, I would not even begin to challenge ANY parent as to what they are capable of. We are obviously capable. I had been speaking of day care versus nanny (NOT PARENTS) and the experiences Abby has had thus far. Frankly, unless I am hiring a certified pre-school teacher as a nanny for my children, I can guarantee this nanny will NOT provide the same experiences that Abby has had thus far. I am pleased and do NOT want this to change. Will I be able to afford 2 kids in day care just after buying a house? Possibly, though not likely. I am allowed to "grieve" the changes in my children's learning experiences. I'm not going to sit here and list them because it would make no difference to anyone but me and my OPINION on my own child is the only one that truly matters. I myself am an educator with EXTREMELY high standards having taught children ages 5-21 over the course of 14+ years in various subjects. I carry two certificates and am qualified myself to teach on a pre-school level, but you know what? Until and unless we hit lotto, I am teaching other people's children all day and do not wish to "teach" when I get home. I just want to come home, love her, hug her and sing with her. I want to feed her, play with her and do her hair. I don't need the most current info on what is right for my toddler, but a nanny might. I think you have completely misunderstood most of what I was trying to say and missed a few good points so I will try again, I will put it in a different way to see if it will make more sense. I have not jumped into defensive in any of the replys I answered. I simply I looked through the thread and I replied where I felt I had something to say. There were many great threads I wanted to comment on. Just because I commended on a few doesn't mean that I was being defensive. I'm chatty and I have lots to say! I don't think I have challenged parents as to what they are capable of. I think I have actually said parents can be empowered to teach their children just as much if not more than teachers. (whether they want to or not) Some ladies had mentioned they didn't think a nanny could teach their children as much as a daycare would. I whole heartedly disagree with that. I think every person in a child's life can teach them, whether it be a nanny, a parent or a daycare worker. As you previously mentioned (I'll quote) "unless I am hiring a certified pre-school teacher as a nanny for my children, I can guarantee this nanny will NOT provide the same experiences that Abby has had thus far. " I think they are 2 different things there fore 2 completely different childcare experiences by nature but my question is How would you guarantee that? Why couldn't a competent nanny do the same kinds of things that are happening in preschool (i.e singing, circle time, crafts, etc...) minus the other children of course. How come you feel that can't be accomplished by a nanny? Can some nanny's do nothing all day and sit on the internet as a previous poster said. YES! absolutely. I think the key to having a nanny situation work for you is that you have to completely trust that individual. That's a pretty big thing and in this day and age probably hard to come by. I must say thus far I have been very lucky. Are some daycares not that great out there? I'm sure there are some. Some may not be providing child a child with a program that is developmentally appropriate. Some may not even be following a curriculum of any kind. Do you knwo what I mean? There are a lot of "if's" when it comes to daycares too. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? I think both nanny & daycare are good. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 9:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain Can some nanny's do nothing all day and sit on the internet as a previous poster said. YES! absolutely. I think the key to having a nanny situation work for you is that you have to completely trust that individual. That's a pretty big thing and in this day and age probably hard to come by. I must say thus far I have been very lucky. Are some daycares not that great out there? I'm sure there are some. Some may not be providing child a child with a program that is developmentally appropriate. Some may not even be following a curriculum of any kind. Do you knwo what I mean? There are a lot of "if's" when it comes to daycares too. I don't agree with a lot of what you say-but I agree with this. The foundation of any good child care arrangement is trust. You have to trust that whoever watches your child will care for them in the way that you want. I want lots of activities, lots of cuddling, lots of attention, lots of eyes watching, lots of people around, lots of structure, lots of down time. I trust that the daycare we send our children to is providing this. The minute I lose faith in that is the minute we switch gears. I think that there are lazy or inattentive nannies, babysitters, daycare centers, and even parents watching their own children. It's a matter of knowing what you want for your child and what is best for your child/family. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 9:06 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? I have used both a nanny and daycare. I had a nanny for 3 years and for the past year, my children have been in daycare. There are pros and cons to both sides. For me, the nanny fit when they were younger and daycare now that they are older. I was lucky to have a great nanny that was fabulous with my children. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by CrankyPants I don't agree with a lot of what you say-but I agree with this. The foundation of any good child care arrangement is trust. You have to trust that whoever watches your child will care for them in the way that you want. I want lots of activities, lots of cuddling, lots of attention, lots of eyes watching, lots of people around, lots of structure, lots of down time. I trust that the daycare we send our children to is providing this. The minute I lose faith in that is the minute we switch gears. I think that there are lazy or inattentive nannies, babysitters, daycare centers, and even parents watching their own children. It's a matter of knowing what you want for your child and what is best for your child/family. I think you put it very nicely. Trust is key to any child care arrangement no matter what it may be. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 9:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? I think that both options have something to offer. I will say that I *personally* am not a huge fan of day care centers more because I am not comfortable with the lack of education and experience the teachers are required to have to work there. I worked in a few day care centers prior to becoming a teacher and most require nothing more than a general associates degree and a 30hr. childcare certificate. I just never felt comfortable with the idea of leaving my child in the hands of someone who isn't a true educator. And speaking as a certified elementary school teacher I can promise that most day care "teachers" are not full, certified teachers with Masters degrees simply because day care centers don't pay even close to what a real teachers salary is. They pay very minimally and it's the reason why the turnover rate is pretty high in day care centers. All that being said, people need daycare and there are merits to both a center and a nanny. Message edited 2010-05-11 09:52:46.350000. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 9:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by Goldi0218 Posted by babyonthebrain Posted by Goldi0218 Abby is in day care right now in a center and she is thriving in a way I never dreamed possible. Her vocabulary is huge - I stopped counting how many words she can say and use correctly because I lost count. She has an interest in reading. Her gross motor and fine motor skills are excellent. She can count past 10. Her social skills are amazing. With baby number two coming and us being in contract to buy a house, it is likely that we will have to switch her from where she is to either another center or to bring someone into the home to save money. I am distraught over pulling her out because of how much she is loved and how much she is learning. I am sure a nanny would love her as well as , but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way. I am a preschool teacher but even if I wasn't I think I could stimulate my child the same way any daycare/preschool could. I can't speak for everyone of course but I think many parents can be empowered to teach their child just as much as any daycare could. You don't need a lesson plan to do that. You just have to read on what's appropriate for teaching preschoolers. It seems as if you have jumped to the defensive on MANY opinions here. I speak of my own experiences, my own standards of teaching and learning and frankly, I would not even begin to challenge ANY parent as to what they are capable of. We are obviously capable. I had been speaking of day care versus nanny (NOT PARENTS) and the experiences Abby has had thus far. Frankly, unless I am hiring a certified pre-school teacher as a nanny for my children, I can guarantee this nanny will NOT provide the same experiences that Abby has had thus far. I am pleased and do NOT want this to change. Will I be able to afford 2 kids in day care just after buying a house? Possibly, though not likely. I am allowed to "grieve" the changes in my children's learning experiences. I'm not going to sit here and list them because it would make no difference to anyone but me and my OPINION on my own child is the only one that truly matters. I myself am an educator with EXTREMELY high standards having taught children ages 5-21 over the course of 14+ years in various subjects. I carry two certificates and am qualified myself to teach on a pre-school level, but you know what? Until and unless we hit lotto, I am teaching other people's children all day and do not wish to "teach" when I get home. I just want to come home, love her, hug her and sing with her. I want to feed her, play with her and do her hair. I don't need the most current info on what is right for my toddler, but a nanny might. I think you have completely misunderstood most of what I was trying to say and missed a few good points so I will try again, I will put it in a different way to see if it will make more sense. I have not jumped into defensive in any of the replys I answered. I simply I looked through the thread and I replied where I felt I had something to say. There were many great threads I wanted to comment on. Just because I commended on a few doesn't mean that I was being defensive. I'm chatty and I have lots to say! I don't think I have challenged parents as to what they are capable of. I think I have actually said parents can be empowered to teach their children just as much if not more than teachers. (whether they want to or not) Some ladies had mentioned they didn't think a nanny could teach their children as much as a daycare would. I whole heartedly disagree with that. I think every person in a child's life can teach them, whether it be a nanny, a parent or a daycare worker. As you previously mentioned (I'll quote) "unless I am hiring a certified pre-school teacher as a nanny for my children, I can guarantee this nanny will NOT provide the same experiences that Abby has had thus far. " I think they are 2 different things there fore 2 completely different childcare experiences by nature but my question is How would you guarantee that? Why couldn't a competent nanny do the same kinds of things that are happening in preschool (i.e singing, circle time, crafts, etc...) minus the other children of course. How come you feel that can't be accomplished by a nanny? Can some nanny's do nothing all day and sit on the internet as a previous poster said. YES! absolutely. I think the key to having a nanny situation work for you is that you have to completely trust that individual. That's a pretty big thing and in this day and age probably hard to come by. I must say thus far I have been very lucky. Are some daycares not that great out there? I'm sure there are some. Some may not be providing child a child with a program that is developmentally appropriate. Some may not even be following a curriculum of any kind. Do you knwo what I mean? There are a lot of "if's" when it comes to daycares too. I did not misunderstand ANYTHING you said. I spoke of my own standards and choices. I don't need to be schooled and addressed in a condescending manner. Thank you. |
|
Posted 5/11/10 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny vs Daycare? For me it wasn't a matter of pros and cons of each - I am not comfortable with the idea of choosing a stranger to take care of my child, alone, in my house all day - |
|
Posted 5/11/10 12:20 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Does anyone use or plan to use a nanny/sitter rather than daycare? | NervousNell | 1/20/10 | 11 | Pregnancy |
| WWYD: Which would you prefer - PT daycare or PT nanny? | Bridex100 | 5/20/09 | 11 | Parenting |
| Considering switching from daycare to nanny/sitter - with lots of questions! | clwp | 5/7/09 | 6 | Parenting |
| Please help! PT daycare/nanny? | pixie | 7/1/08 | 6 | Parenting |
| If money weren't an issue would you have a nanny or daycare? | leighla | 9/17/07 | 45 | Parenting |
| Daycare vs. Nanny- what should I do?? | Shelly | 10/19/06 | 10 | Parenting |





, but unless I leave a nanny lesson plans, I am pretty sure my kids won't get stimulated in the same way. 





