how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted By Message
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 8

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

In my view, it is impolite to expect any guest (including the bridal party) to pay for your shower or pre-wedding festivities. Being a bridesmaid should be an honor, not a burden. Also presumptuous to expect people to cover their plates.

However, when people are generous with themselves and cheap with friends, it's unrealistic to expect people not to notice and to judge. I couldn't imagine not giving friends at least what they gave me unless I had truly fallen on hard times. I'd rather sacrifice anything for myself (new clothes, meals out, etc.) than to give a friend or relative something that I consider to be cheap (like a $20 frame not on their registry) or less than they gave me. JMO.

That's how I feel. I am inspired by those who have shared honestly on this thread even though they faced some unnecessary nastiness.

Posted 5/25/12 5:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

It amazes me what people assume about the financial position and liquid assets of other people.

Give what you can afford. We typically give $300 unless it's a super close friend. We've never brought kids to a wedding so I can't help you there, but I will tell you that the only kids at our wedding were DH's four cousins, and the family of six gave us $1200. Not sure if that helps but I figured I'd share. Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/12 6:20 PM
 

KristenRSF
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/10

487 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by headoverheels

It amazes me what people assume about the financial position and liquid assets of other people.

Give what you can afford. We typically give $300 unless it's a super close friend. We've never brought kids to a wedding so I can't help you there, but I will tell you that the only kids at our wedding were DH's four cousins, and the family of six gave us $1200. Not sure if that helps but I figured I'd share. Chat Icon




Cheapo.

Posted 5/25/12 6:30 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by KristenRSF

Posted by headoverheels

It amazes me what people assume about the financial position and liquid assets of other people.

Give what you can afford. We typically give $300 unless it's a super close friend. We've never brought kids to a wedding so I can't help you there, but I will tell you that the only kids at our wedding were DH's four cousins, and the family of six gave us $1200. Not sure if that helps but I figured I'd share. Chat Icon




Cheapo.



Yeah but I'd rather spend my money on Louboutins so that makes it okay Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/12 6:44 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by KristenRSF

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by KristenRSF

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by KristenRSF

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by cncforever

I'm more surprised no one pointed out how long it's taken you to send out thank yous ;)



LOL It's been a busy year!

You should see how long it took us to unpack. Dh doesn't get home until 9 many night and I'm always working and volunteering. We haven't had time to do anything. I feel really bad about it, but I'm trying to squeeze in under the gun for 1 year.



You have plenty of time to plan Disney trips and post about Disney like all day every day on the travel board though. lol Chat Icon



So you're observant enough to notice that but not observant enough to notice that's her job. IMO makes your clever joke about a gazillion times less clever.




Oh, I was not aware that Jennifer had a paying job with LIF! MY BAD!

Chat Icon

Chat Icon

Nobody really cares about your opinion though, LynnD.





Chat Icon Um okay. Weird response. I guess that's since you feel silly? Also btw they're called vendors- it's what pays for the site. Okay, KRISTENRSVPABCDEFG? I'll fm you next time I have a thought. Derrrr.



You sound miserable and it makes me sad Chat Icon



Again, makes no sense. Please just step away from the keyboard as you're sounding more and more silly. Bye.

Posted 5/25/12 7:43 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Wow this thread makes me so sad and so thankful I don't know some of you. Where I come from a wedding isn't about the gifts you'll get but about joining lives with your counterpart. Some of you sound like such selfish children! Well so and so gave me a 25.00 gift and I gave them 150.00! So what?!?!?! Be thankful your friend came and enjoyed the day with you.

To the OP I would say 100-150 for the wedding, if you can afford it.

Posted 5/25/12 7:47 PM
 

ItsTime2011
Meh...

Member since 1/11

2148 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

This is making me sad. I have a wedding to go next month. Its a sit down plated dinner that we had to choose the meal beforehand and the its on a beach on the cape of Massachusetts. I don't have a job and DH works part time. It's hard and I am hoping to be able to give $100.
I remember at our wedding I made the card box but COMPLETELY forgot about it. I had someone remind me about it and I actually started crying when opening the gifts because of the generosity of people. The thought, though, that people only give what they expect to get back makes me sad. I always give based on what I WANT to give and what I can afford. The fact that there are "standards" on these things takes the joy and celebratory nature out of it.

Posted 5/25/12 8:11 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

As many times I say it's not the money but the (perceived lack of ) thought behind it, people won't listen. Everyone needs a bandwagon to get on.

Posted 5/25/12 8:17 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by KristenRSF

Posted by headoverheels

It amazes me what people assume about the financial position and liquid assets of other people.

Give what you can afford. We typically give $300 unless it's a super close friend. We've never brought kids to a wedding so I can't help you there, but I will tell you that the only kids at our wedding were DH's four cousins, and the family of six gave us $1200. Not sure if that helps but I figured I'd share. Chat Icon




Cheapo.



Yeah but I'd rather spend my money on Louboutins so that makes it okay Chat Icon



Don't lie. It's WINE. You'd rather spend it on wine Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/12 8:18 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

DH and I were invited to a very small wedding (we are 2 of 14 people invited) via text message at our friends' house. We will be giving the same as we would for someone who is getting married at Oheka.

To the OP, I'd give whatever you feel comfortable with.

Posted 5/25/12 8:31 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by JenniferEver

As many times I say it's not the money but the (perceived lack of ) thought behind it, people won't listen. Everyone needs a bandwagon to get on.


How much thought can one put into a CASH gift? End of day you write a check sign it and watch the money slip from your account. Yet someone who got you a tea kettle is an A hole for getting you a gift they THOUGHT you might like. And you laughed at it. I just don't understand the mentality of it. I come from TX where you get Tea Kettles, bread machines, dishes (and I DON'T MEAN CHINA) so on and so forth.

Posted 5/25/12 8:38 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Please stop

Posted 5/25/12 8:48 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by HeathKernandez

Please stop



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/12 9:09 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.

Posted 5/25/12 9:15 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by dpli

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.



Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes.

Posted 5/25/12 9:22 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by dpli

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.



Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes.



I get what you say, but what I feel is this:

If I choose to buy an expensive handbag and just came back from a fancy vacaction, and I give you a gift of 150 for your wedding, I feel heads roll. You (universal) assumes I should give MORE to your wedding based on how I spend my money on myself. And I feel I shouldn't. What I give is what I give, and it's a gift. It's better than nothing and why should I shell out mucho dinero? Why isn't 100-150 good enough? Because I'm not covering my plate? That is where it turns into fundraiser territory, KWIM? I'm not supposed to help you pay for your wedding. I'm there as a GUEST to celebrate and give a gift of my choice, without it having to be "well, she buys expensive bags for herself but gave me less of a gift than what her Michael Kors bag cost."

Posted 5/25/12 9:31 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by dpli

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.



Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes.



Chat IconChat Icon

it would be great if this thread morphed into an "eating in the grocery store before paying" discussion

Posted 5/25/12 9:33 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by cncforever
I'm not supposed to help you pay for your wedding.




ding ding ding!!!

people have their priorities so messed up.

Posted 5/25/12 9:33 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by dpli

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.



Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes.



I really couldn't disagree more.
My dad died 3 days before my wedding.
3 DAYS.
We had to MOVE our wedding from the scheduled date of 11/23 to 11/24.
By some MIRACLE the venue (fancy schmancy, one wedding at a time, over $210 a head) was available and they switched us without any ruckus.

As all of that was going on, unbeknownst to us, a group of his best best childhood friends made arrangements to hop over here from Dublin for our day. It started as a group of 3 guys discussing it over a few pints in their local pub. Well imagine both of our surprise as we got to the church and saw 13 of his BEST FRIENDS for his whole life there. For us.
There was one group card they all signed, and whatever cash they had on hand was thrown in, it was some crazy arbitrary number, well under $200 Chat Icon

Let me tell you something. Those guys MADE OUR WEDDING. The best memories I have of that day are the motley crew of Dublin dudes who showed up, suited up, and did their thing for me and my new husband. I could cry right now thinking about it.

One of my favorite aunts from Ireland also travelled here to our wedding in 2007. It was the last time I saw her - she died in Nov. 2011.

SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Chat Icon


Posted 5/25/12 9:43 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by colette

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by dpli

Posted by lynnd126

I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line.



Best line of this thread.



Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes.



I really couldn't disagree more.
My dad died 3 days before my wedding.
3 DAYS.
We had to MOVE our wedding from the scheduled date of 11/23 to 11/24.
By some MIRACLE the venue (fancy schmancy, one wedding at a time, over $210 a head) was available and they switched us without any ruckus.

As all of that was going on, unbeknownst to us, a group of his best best childhood friends made arrangements to hop over here from Dublin for our day. It started as a group of 3 guys discussing it over a few pints in their local pub. Well imagine both of our surprise as we got to the church and saw 13 of his BEST FRIENDS for his whole life there. For us.
There was one group card they all signed, and whatever cash they had on hand was thrown in, it was some crazy arbitrary number, well under $200 Chat Icon

Let me tell you something. Those guys MADE OUR WEDDING. The best memories I have of that day are the motley crew of Dublin dudes who showed up, suited up, and did their thing for me and my new husband. I could cry right now thinking about it.

One of my favorite aunts from Ireland also travelled here to our wedding in 2007. It was the last time I saw her - she died in Nov. 2011.

SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Chat Icon





Awesome story with a good point..and so sorry that your dad passed away right before your wedding. I can't even imagine. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/12 9:47 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by colette


Let me tell you something. Those guys MADE OUR WEDDING. The best memories I have of that day are the motley crew of Dublin dudes who showed up, suited up, and did their thing for me and my new husband. I could cry right now thinking about it.

One of my favorite aunts from Ireland also travelled here to our wedding in 2007. It was the last time I saw her - she died in Nov. 2011.

SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Chat Icon






Thank you for this. DH's uncle just passed away. He was the only person from his dad's side in this country (his dad passed away). We were so happy to have him at our wedding. He actually did not give us a physical gift, but what we do have is the memory of him being there.

What a wonderful reminder (and story) Colette.

Posted 5/25/12 9:54 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by colette


I really couldn't disagree more.
My dad died 3 days before my wedding.
3 DAYS.
We had to MOVE our wedding from the scheduled date of 11/23 to 11/24.
By some MIRACLE the venue (fancy schmancy, one wedding at a time, over $210 a head) was available and they switched us without any ruckus.

As all of that was going on, unbeknownst to us, a group of his best best childhood friends made arrangements to hop over here from Dublin for our day. It started as a group of 3 guys discussing it over a few pints in their local pub. Well imagine both of our surprise as we got to the church and saw 13 of his BEST FRIENDS for his whole life there. For us.
There was one group card they all signed, and whatever cash they had on hand was thrown in, it was some crazy arbitrary number, well under $200 Chat Icon

Let me tell you something. Those guys MADE OUR WEDDING. The best memories I have of that day are the motley crew of Dublin dudes who showed up, suited up, and did their thing for me and my new husband. I could cry right now thinking about it.

One of my favorite aunts from Ireland also travelled here to our wedding in 2007. It was the last time I saw her - she died in Nov. 2011.

SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Chat Icon





THANK YOU.

ONe of my oldest, dearest friends traveled from England to New York on 2 months notice for my wedding. Mind you, he is equivalent to "working class" over the pond so I know coming to ny on such short notice cost a pretty penny.

I couldn't care LESS that he "only gave me a card" The gift was seeing him again...

Even despite the fact that he traveled far to be here for me... If someone is special to me, heck- ANYONE I want to share my day with... the gift is them THERE.

If people cared about "breaking even" with their wedding then DON'T HAVE AN EXPENSIVE WEDDING. simple as that.

I made my own favors... bought my dress off the rack... we didn't go on a honeymoon... got *cheapy* flowers, had a friend DJ...

still had a wonderful party...

Message edited 2012-05-25 22:06:34.143000.

Posted 5/25/12 10:05 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by colette

SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Chat Icon




I wish I had more friends like you Colette. I'm being 100% genuine. The fact is that if I got an invitation to a wedding right now because I would feel ashamed that I can't afford the 'appropriate' amount. I just know that some of the people would be rolling their eyes and gnashing their teeth and trying to figure out my financial solvency by reviewing their perception of my spending habits. I just feel like folks would rather sell 'my spot' to someone with more $$ than share their special day with someone who can't afford to pony up $200. I guess I'll go back to my spot on the welfare line now..

Posted 5/25/12 10:28 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Message edited 2012-05-25 22:33:51.290000.

Posted 5/25/12 10:33 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted by seaside

In my view, it is impolite to expect any guest (including the bridal party) to pay for your shower or pre-wedding festivities. Being a bridesmaid should be an honor, not a burden. Also presumptuous to expect people to cover their plates.

However, when people are generous with themselves and cheap with friends, it's unrealistic to expect people not to notice and to judge. I couldn't imagine not giving friends at least what they gave me unless I had truly fallen on hard times. I'd rather sacrifice anything for myself (new clothes, meals out, etc.) than to give a friend or relative something that I consider to be cheap (like a $20 frame not on their registry) or less than they gave me. JMO.

That's how I feel. I am inspired by those who have shared honestly on this thread even though they faced some unnecessary
nastiness.



Beautifully said. I do think it is natural to be upset if you went out of your way to give a generous gift and the person did not reciprocate. Obviously, if the person was struggling financially, that is a different story.

Posted 5/25/12 10:43 PM
 
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 8
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to wedding songs... Who think they had a unique wedding song that you don't normally hear... HeathKernandez 8/23/11 141 Families Helping Families ™
GOOD LUCK PRINCESSMARIS!!! TOMORROW IS HER WEDDING DAY! btrflygrl 7/21/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Do you ever not wear your wedding band/engagement ring? Lichi 7/14/05 50 Families Helping Families ™
i finally had the guts to pick up my wedding video... ggt08 7/12/05 43 Families Helping Families ™
WOW!! Couple Celebrates 80th Wedding Anniversary!! DebG 6/2/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
how many times do you listen to your wedding song? janet 5/24/05 24 Families Helping Families ™