how much would you give for wedding? Updated
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Well I can tell you what a family of 4 from Hudson NY gave us for our wedding.......a plastic collage frame! Message edited 2012-05-24 21:12:35.660000. |
|
Posted 5/24/12 9:06 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by tarabelle99 The whole "cover your plate" mentality and thought that couples who are marrying should profit from a wedding is beyond greedy. Who's profiting? We paid for our own wedding. There was pressure from family to do a traditional thing at a catering hall. We went with a VERY reasonable place (one of the only places we could afford) and our wedding still cost us like $7k after gifts. I didn't hold grudges or anything. For the most part people gave something reasonable unless there was a circumstance (traveling, unemployed, etc.) But it's always curious to me that in honor of getting married, the couple is expected to wine and dine 100-200 of their closest friends and family members but keep their spoiled little mouths shut about presents. Just devil's advocate. This thread always turns to So flame on
|
|
Posted 5/25/12 6:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by bookworm But it's always curious to me that in honor of getting married, the couple is expected to wine and dine 100-200 of their closest friends and family members but keep their spoiled little mouths shut about presents. In my opinion, you give a wedding because you want to celebrate with your friends and family. You have a choice. You don't have to wine and dine hundreds of people. Plenty of people elope or have very small parties. You should not expect to receive presents to cover your costs, gifts are at the discretion of the guest and are not owed to you. Several people came to my wedding and gave nothing, not even a card. I just shrugged my shoulders and moved on. I was not hurt or insulted.
|
|
Posted 5/25/12 7:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by Chai77 Posted by bookworm But it's always curious to me that in honor of getting married, the couple is expected to wine and dine 100-200 of their closest friends and family members but keep their spoiled little mouths shut about presents. In my opinion, you give a wedding because you want to celebrate with your friends and family. You have a choice. You don't have to wine and dine hundreds of people. Plenty of people elope or have very small parties. You should not expect to receive presents to cover your costs, gifts are at the discretion of the guest and are not owed to you. Several people came to my wedding and gave nothing, not even a card. I just shrugged my shoulders and moved on. I was not hurt or insulted. Sure, but there are lots of families who put pressure on the couple to host this party. I'm not the only person who has felt that way. But then there's the finger-wagging about expecting a gift. Lots of families would be really hurt if a couple just ran off to Vegas alone. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 8:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by mzsocialworker1 I am from the Hudson Valley and childhood friends and extended family from up that way who came to my wedding only gave on average $50.00-$100.00 as a couple. Things are VERY different up there compared to down here. They don't have the "pay per head" mentality, and wedding venues are A LOT cheaper. Our wedding venue for over 100 people cost WELL UNDER $10K and it is one of the nicer ones. Agree with everything you said... the LI wedding mentality( Gift= covering yoru palte) just doesnt happen up here. Most wedding upstate I have been to only have crackers and cheese at the cocktail hour! Plus there might be a cash bar so I dont think $500 or more is necessary at all! |
|
Posted 5/25/12 8:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by Arieschick29 Posted by mzsocialworker1 I am from the Hudson Valley and childhood friends and extended family from up that way who came to my wedding only gave on average $50.00-$100.00 as a couple. Things are VERY different up there compared to down here. They don't have the "pay per head" mentality, and wedding venues are A LOT cheaper. Our wedding venue for over 100 people cost WELL UNDER $10K and it is one of the nicer ones. Agree with everything you said... the LI wedding mentality( Gift= covering yoru palte) just doesnt happen up here. Most wedding upstate I have been to only have crackers and cheese at the cocktail hour! Plus there might be a cash bar so I dont think $500 or more is necessary at all! It is very different. A lot of people just can't afford it. Many people don't have the types of jobs most people on Long Island do, to even support the LI lifestyle many of us lead. Not saying people are hill-billy's or anything (MIL when she met me actually asked if we had running water and electricity growing up and I lived only a couple hours north of the city ) but things are VERY different. You have stereotypical "Upstaters" there just like you have the stereotypical "Long Islanders" down here ;). The area is changing in some parts too, especially as people from down here move up there. You will find you get a lot more for your $$$$$. Most people I know from "home" do get married in places like VFWs and firehouses though. With that said, still give what you feel is right, that you can afford, no matter where the location of the wedding is or what someone on LIF feels you should give ;). Message edited 2012-05-25 09:50:42.917000. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? I only think it is wrong when guests come to a formal catered event and gift nothing. I had quite a few people come to my wedding and not even acknowledge us with a card. I think that is rude and tacky. If I didn't have money for a nice monetary or even materialistic gift, I would at least make sure I wrote a nice sentimental card and maybe even included a bottle of wine or a couple of cheap scratch-off lotto tickets. Just something small to acknowledge the bride and groom and say thanks for inviting us in your special day- congratulations. Some people only gave us $25 for 4 people... but I was only upset and angry with the people who gave us $0 (and not even a card). Yes, I wanted these people to be physically present and they came, so yes that is nice- but if they don't bring a card or small token it seems as if they are not emotionally there and then to me, that is like they came for a free meal or a free night of entertainment and that is equal to brides and grooms who expect their guests to cover their meals. It goes both ways in the selfishness direction. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by tarabelle99 Posted by JenniferEver First cousins? I really don't know, since it's upstate. Here I would say $400. but out of state is so different. Some people from out of state (and some clieless people) gave us gfts of like $25-50 for a couple. I am still holding a grugde since my wedding was like $170pp. I gave $250 for an OOS wedding for me and DH and i felt SOOOO cheap writing that check and when i got there I didn't feel cheap any more. Then they turned around and gave us half that. I'm writing out my thank yous so I am especially bitter. An OOS familyof 5 who came to our wedding gave $300. I felt it was a little low by "cover your plate standards" but I felt it was ok. They can't be expected to shell out thousands because they have kids who *I* invited. I'd go with $300 in your case, but never less than $200 So clueless people and people from out of state give too little? You chose a venue, menu etc that cost 170pp. You invited these people to share in your event, to celebrate your special day. The oblige by coming to your event and participating in your day. Usually they'll even give gift. Some of these people incurred costs to get there (as they are from OOS) and enjoy your day. Do you take that into account? Do you take into account that not everyone can afford as much as you? The whole "cover your plate" mentality and thought that couples who are marrying should profit from a wedding is beyond greedy. And to admit that you're bitter and holding a grudge? Really? It really comes across as selfish and ungrateful when these types of posts are made. Here's a thought, rather than spending extravagantly expecting to recoup costs from people "covering their plates" how about just spending what you can afford and then being appreciative of the fact that people show up at all to enjoy your day? I know if I were invited to a wedding and found out later that my gift wasn't "good enough" and that the couple expected me to not only incur the costs of travel but also to profit from me? Hell, even if there weren't travel concerns, I'd be pizzed to hear that my gift wasn't "good enough". And you know what? It'd be the LAST time I ever gave a gift or attended any of their events. Here's an idea for future brides: Instead of asking for gifts, and expecting that you'll get this "cover your plate plus some" 'gift' just send invoices to people so they know how much to give you. That's right, just sell tickets and charge admission, because that is essentially what you're doing when you complain about ANY gift that is given to you. But what do I know, Im from the South where you get breadmakers.
|
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? I would have loved a breadmaker!!!!! |
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by Laura1976 we have my cousins wedding next week. My 3 kids are coming with us (all under 5 years old), upstate NY (not sure if that matters). Not very close to cousins, met his fiance' once. I would look up the venue and see what type of place it is. If it's very expensive I would try to give more. I would say $200-$300 range. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? My wedding was about $170pp- obviously much more if you count everything besides food. I didn't expect to recoup, although the majority of our gifts were $400 Message edited 2012-05-25 21:29:16.917000. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by lynnd126 I get slayed for this on here but I do often give what I received. I'm the same way. I would NEVER give less than I received (unless let's say we're in a drasticlaly different financial situation than the person giving it. Like if say one of our wealthier aunts and uncles had a wedding or something, I don't think we'd be able to give the same back), which is why I was shocked when people turned around and 2 months later gave us way less. If it were me and money were tight, I'd hold on to the money they gave me and give it right back to them. That's the norm in my family. I was talking to my cousin about gifts at one point and I was saying we had some no-gifters and I told her about the measuring cups gift and I said "well, she's just finished grad school,maybe that's all they can afford" and my cousin said to me "I don't care if you don't eat for a week, you bring a gift" That's just the mentality in my family. I'd definitely give up something (such as a cake decorating class *ahem*) to give someone a decent wedding gift. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Give what you can afford and if the people getting married have a problem with that then I would tell them to F OFF. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by alli3131 Give what you can afford and if the people getting married have a problem with that then I would tell them to F OFF. I had people come to my wedding that could afford to give me plenty and did nto receive a gift at all and you know what...at no point did I even question it. I had the wedding for me and for me to be able to share that day with my friends and family and I truely did not care if anyone came with a gift...I am very thankful for those that did but just as thankful for those that gave nothing and jsut shared my day. I'm sorry but I have a hard time swallowing that. You honestly had people come to your wedding totally empty handed and "did not even question it"? I don't think I'm "greedy" bc I would find that rude. I did have one person come with nothing and no I didn't care one bit. The circumstance although was not that I didn't even question it. The person has bad emotional problems and is a drug addict. I was thrilled to see him dressed up and enjoying the night. I never expected a gift. That's so different though imo. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by bookworm Posted by Chai77 Posted by bookworm But it's always curious to me that in honor of getting married, the couple is expected to wine and dine 100-200 of their closest friends and family members but keep their spoiled little mouths shut about presents. In my opinion, you give a wedding because you want to celebrate with your friends and family. You have a choice. You don't have to wine and dine hundreds of people. Plenty of people elope or have very small parties. You should not expect to receive presents to cover your costs, gifts are at the discretion of the guest and are not owed to you. Several people came to my wedding and gave nothing, not even a card. I just shrugged my shoulders and moved on. I was not hurt or insulted. Sure, but there are lots of families who put pressure on the couple to host this party. I'm not the only person who has felt that way. But then there's the finger-wagging about expecting a gift. Lots of families would be really hurt if a couple just ran off to Vegas alone. Then, quite simply put, those putting pressure on the couple should contribute to the costs of the wedding over and above what the couple can afford or wants to spend, outright pay for it, or be told to buzz off. Same with "my mother is making me invite x,y and z". No, that's not how it works, unless your mother is footing the bill. How many times here and elsewhere are brides told "it's YOUR day". You don't have to run off to Vegas alone to do something within your means. If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by tarabelle99 If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. There is etiquette regarding wedding gift-giving. There's also etiquette regarding how to dress, how to act, and whom to bring. My invitation would have been like 2pt font to fit all that in. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by lynnd126 Posted by alli3131 Give what you can afford and if the people getting married have a problem with that then I would tell them to F OFF. I had people come to my wedding that could afford to give me plenty and did nto receive a gift at all and you know what...at no point did I even question it. I had the wedding for me and for me to be able to share that day with my friends and family and I truely did not care if anyone came with a gift...I am very thankful for those that did but just as thankful for those that gave nothing and jsut shared my day. I'm sorry but I have a hard time swallowing that. You honestly had people come to your wedding totally empty handed and "did not even question it"? I don't think I'm "greedy" bc I would find that rude. I did have one person come with nothing and no I didn't care one bit. The circumstance although was not that I didn't even question it. The person has bad emotional problems and is a drug addict. I was thrilled to see him dressed up and enjoying the night. I never expected a gift. That's so different though imo. Nope I didn't question it at all. I had my wedding for me. Those people cam danced with me and celebrated with me. Said congrats quite a few times. Thats all I needed. My wedding was for my and my DH. I did not need a single gift or card....as lon gas people came and celebrated with me that's all I cared about. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Where upstate is the wedding? I ask because some people consider Westchester to be upstate and Westchester weddings are definitely not "cheap." |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by alli3131 Posted by lynnd126 Posted by alli3131 Give what you can afford and if the people getting married have a problem with that then I would tell them to F OFF. I had people come to my wedding that could afford to give me plenty and did nto receive a gift at all and you know what...at no point did I even question it. I had the wedding for me and for me to be able to share that day with my friends and family and I truely did not care if anyone came with a gift...I am very thankful for those that did but just as thankful for those that gave nothing and jsut shared my day. I'm sorry but I have a hard time swallowing that. You honestly had people come to your wedding totally empty handed and "did not even question it"? I don't think I'm "greedy" bc I would find that rude. I did have one person come with nothing and no I didn't care one bit. The circumstance although was not that I didn't even question it. The person has bad emotional problems and is a drug addict. I was thrilled to see him dressed up and enjoying the night. I never expected a gift. That's so different though imo. Nope I didn't question it at all. I had my wedding for me. Those people cam danced with me and celebrated with me. Said congrats quite a few times. Thats all I needed. My wedding was for my and my DH. I did not need a single gift or card....as lon gas people came and celebrated with me that's all I cared about. It just doesn't make sense to me. It's like turning a blind eye to their rationale regarding why they brought no gift whatsoever. It's not the money that would hurt me- it would be the guest being like eh eff them, they have enough, or their wedding is in a cheap place, or this is their third wedding, etc. Don't you wonder what these people were thinking? Sounds like you had a few of them. I mean, it's not like they're from another planet and don't know. Message edited 2012-05-25 12:16:19.190000. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by JenniferEver Posted by tarabelle99 If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. There is etiquette regarding wedding gift-giving. There's also etiquette regarding how to dress, how to act, and whom to bring. My invitation would have been like 2pt font to fit all that in. One person actually showed up to my wedding in a bikini made of dead fish but I'm just glad they spent the day with me. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by JenniferEver Posted by tarabelle99 If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. There is etiquette regarding wedding gift-giving. There's also etiquette regarding how to dress, how to act, and whom to bring. My invitation would have been like 2pt font to fit all that in. Yes, there is. And per etiquette "rules" the "cover your plate" mentality is flat out not one of them. At least Emily Post and other experts state that Am I supposed to buy a gift that costs as much as what the hosts spend on each person at the wedding? No. This modern myth causes considerable anxiety for guests, but it is simply untrue. The amount you spend is strictly a matter of your budget, how close you are to the bride and groom, and what you think is an appropriate gift. http://www.emilypost.com/weddings/a-guide-for-guests/845-choosing-gifts 3. Should the amount I give depend on the price per dinner plate or how posh the venue is? Quite simply, no. "Never think about it in those terms," says Martha Woodham, author of "The Bride Did What?! Etiquette for the Wedding Impaired." Instead, think about it this way: You're not expected to pay for your meal at a friend's dinner party, so why should you be expected to pay for a night of dinner and dancing at a wedding? A gift is separate from the party itself and should not be considered "the admission price to the wedding," says Woodham. http://www.smartmoney.com/spend/family-money/the-wedding-gift-etiquette-guide-23264/ |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by tarabelle99 Posted by JenniferEver Posted by tarabelle99 If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. There is etiquette regarding wedding gift-giving. There's also etiquette regarding how to dress, how to act, and whom to bring. My invitation would have been like 2pt font to fit all that in. Yes, there is. And per etiquette "rules" the "cover your plate" mentality is flat out not one of them. At least Emily Post and other experts state that Am I supposed to buy a gift that costs as much as what the hosts spend on each person at the wedding? No. This modern myth causes considerable anxiety for guests, but it is simply untrue. The amount you spend is strictly a matter of your budget, how close you are to the bride and groom, and what you think is an appropriate gift. http://www.emilypost.com/weddings/a-guide-for-guests/845-choosing-gifts 3. Should the amount I give depend on the price per dinner plate or how posh the venue is? Quite simply, no. "Never think about it in those terms," says Martha Woodham, author of "The Bride Did What?! Etiquette for the Wedding Impaired." Instead, think about it this way: You're not expected to pay for your meal at a friend's dinner party, so why should you be expected to pay for a night of dinner and dancing at a wedding? A gift is separate from the party itself and should not be considered "the admission price to the wedding," says Woodham. http://www.smartmoney.com/spend/family-money/the-wedding-gift-etiquette-guide-23264/ This may be true but it is also localized and give what you get IS the norm around me. Etiquette isn't always something so finite from a book, you know? Maybe what goes on around here isn't "proper" etiquette. Maybe you could argue that's the difference- idk. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by lynnd126 It just doesn't make sense to me. It's like turning a blind eye to their rationale regarding why they brought no gift whatsoever. It's not the money that would hurt me- it would be the guest being like eh eff them, they have enough, our their wedding is in a cheap place, or this is their third wedding, etc. Don't you wonder what these people were thinking? Sounds like you had a few of them. I mean, it's not like they're from another planet and don't know. This is exactly what I mean. Thank God, I'm not in the poor house because people didn't give me enough cash at the wedding lol. I really want to photoshop pictures of me sitting on top of a pile of money, and of me opening cards at the wedding to pay the hall because apparently that's what people think. But this is why I found it insulting. Like, what was the thought behind this? Another winner gift was a relative who brought us a tea kettle. We had 3 registries. None of them involved a tea kettle of any kind. We laughed so much about that one. I mean if you only want to spend $20, fine, i guess, but at least get us a $20 item we want. And it was a RELATIVE. I'm sorry, a relative warrants more than a $20 gift. We did get our money's worth in laughter out of it. I don't know why but we just find it so funny and it's become our joke. if we get invited to an event and we don't particularly like the people or whatever it is, we joke that we'll get them a teakettle. Whilch is kind of telling about why i find the out of place gifts insulting. it's like "we don't really care about these people...just get them a tea kettle!" |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Posted by lynnd126 Posted by JenniferEver Posted by tarabelle99 If you expect a gift of a certain denomination, make it clear in your invitation by charging for people to come. Be up front about i at least! Point is, you have a wedding to get married. You invite people to celebrate with you. Any gift you receive is a bonus and should be appreciated. Period. There is etiquette regarding wedding gift-giving. There's also etiquette regarding how to dress, how to act, and whom to bring. My invitation would have been like 2pt font to fit all that in. One person actually showed up to my wedding in a bikini made of dead fish but I'm just glad they spent the day with me. I have tears in my eyes! Maybe I should cut the cousins getting high on the patio and the 40 year old man passed out under the table some slack then? |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? You don't have to cover your plate, but there is appropriate and inappropriate when it comes to gifts. Message edited 2012-05-25 12:24:57.410000. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 12:21 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spinoff to wedding songs... Who think they had a unique wedding song that you don't normally hear... | HeathKernandez | 8/23/11 | 141 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| GOOD LUCK PRINCESSMARIS!!! TOMORROW IS HER WEDDING DAY! | btrflygrl | 7/21/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Do you ever not wear your wedding band/engagement ring? | Lichi | 7/14/05 | 50 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| i finally had the guts to pick up my wedding video... | ggt08 | 7/12/05 | 43 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| WOW!! Couple Celebrates 80th Wedding Anniversary!! | DebG | 6/2/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| how many times do you listen to your wedding song? | janet | 5/24/05 | 24 | Families Helping Families ™ |





So flame on


) but things are VERY different. You have stereotypical "Upstaters" there just like you have the stereotypical "Long Islanders" down here ;). 




