how much would you give for wedding? Updated
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 | |
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by rojerono I wish I had more friends like you Colette. I'm being 100% genuine. The fact is that if I got an invitation to a wedding right now because I would feel ashamed that I can't afford the 'appropriate' amount. I just know that some of the people would be rolling their eyes and gnashing their teeth and trying to figure out my financial solvency by reviewing their perception of my spending habits. I just feel like folks would rather sell 'my spot' to someone with more $$ than share their special day with someone who can't afford to pony up $200. I guess I'll go back to my spot on the welfare line now.. It's so wrong that an invitation to ANY party can cause such feelings in anyone. It should be about the celebration and NOT the gift at all. We were invited to a wedding when DH and I were just dating. At the time we were seriously broke. It was also before I had ever heard of LIW and LIF wasn't even around yet, so I had no idea about the whole "cover your plate" mentality. DH and I gave what we could afford and it was well below what people would expect at such a nice location. To be honest I actually opted to pay my car note late just to give what we could so we could give SOMETHING. I guess they were offended by our gift because after the wedding we didn't even get a TY card and they stopped calling to hang out. We did the best we could at the time and clearly it wasn't good enough that they just tossed us aside. I'm sure they had the mentality when they opened our card like several of the snotty selfish brats on this thread. Oh well, their loss because DH and I are pretty damn awesome in the friend department.
Message edited 2012-05-25 22:49:59.113000. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:47 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by seaside In my view, it is impolite to expect any guest (including the bridal party) to pay for your shower or pre-wedding festivities. Being a bridesmaid should be an honor, not a burden. Also presumptuous to expect people to cover their plates. However, when people are generous with themselves and cheap with friends, it's unrealistic to expect people not to notice and to judge. I couldn't imagine not giving friends at least what they gave me unless I had truly fallen on hard times. I'd rather sacrifice anything for myself (new clothes, meals out, etc.) than to give a friend or relative something that I consider to be cheap (like a $20 frame not on their registry) or less than they gave me. JMO. That's how I feel. I am inspired by those who have shared honestly on this thread even though they faced some unnecessary nastiness. ita..you said it much better than i could |
|
Posted 5/25/12 10:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by rojerono Posted by colette SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. I wish I had more friends like you Colette. I'm being 100% genuine. The fact is that if I got an invitation to a wedding right now because I would feel ashamed that I can't afford the 'appropriate' amount. I just know that some of the people would be rolling their eyes and gnashing their teeth and trying to figure out my financial solvency by reviewing their perception of my spending habits. I just feel like folks would rather sell 'my spot' to someone with more $$ than share their special day with someone who can't afford to pony up $200. I guess I'll go back to my spot on the welfare line now..[/QUOTE This thread is disgusting. I would be so upset if someone didn't come to my wedding because they thought they couldn't afford a "proper" gift. |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by colette SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. Exactly |
|
Posted 5/25/12 11:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Give what you can afford - don't worry about how much or little it seems to be. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 2:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by teachermom Posted by rojerono Posted by colette SO I hope and pray that anyone reading this thread who has an upcoming wedding and has ANY kind of financial situation going on does not forego the wedding out of embarrassment or fear of not meeting some standard that a bunch of spoiled brats want to pretend is the norm. I wish I had more friends like you Colette. I'm being 100% genuine. The fact is that if I got an invitation to a wedding right now because I would feel ashamed that I can't afford the 'appropriate' amount. I just know that some of the people would be rolling their eyes and gnashing their teeth and trying to figure out my financial solvency by reviewing their perception of my spending habits. I just feel like folks would rather sell 'my spot' to someone with more $$ than share their special day with someone who can't afford to pony up $200. I guess I'll go back to my spot on the welfare line now..[/QUOTE This thread is disgusting. I would be so upset if someone didn't come to my wedding because they thought they couldn't afford a "proper" gift. We found out my mom's uncle didn't come to our wedding because he couldn't afford a gift. It made me so sad. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 7:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated The "spoiled brat" comments are unnecessary. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 7:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated I always give 200-250. I would not feel obligated to include the children. Travel costs are expensive, if you can afford to give more and you feel it's necessary... |
|
Posted 5/26/12 8:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by maybeamommy Posted by headoverheels Posted by KristenRSF Posted by headoverheels It amazes me what people assume about the financial position and liquid assets of other people. Give what you can afford. We typically give $300 unless it's a super close friend. We've never brought kids to a wedding so I can't help you there, but I will tell you that the only kids at our wedding were DH's four cousins, and the family of six gave us $1200. Not sure if that helps but I figured I'd share. Cheapo. Yeah but I'd rather spend my money on Louboutins so that makes it okay Don't lie. It's WINE. You'd rather spend it on wine DON'T JUDGE ME. ![]() This whole thing is ridiculous. And sad. I've been married 4.5 years and I could not tell you who gave me $25 and who gave me $250. I can remember who danced the most, and who drank the most, and who gave me the biggest hugs, and who cried the most. Yeah this debate is old, but it's the first time I have EVER seen someone say that they are holding a GRUDGE because someone else didn't give a good enough gift. And you can cover up and backtrack all you want, but the truth of the matter is that if you didn't actually feel that way it never would have crossed your mind to write it in the first place. THAT is more than sad, it's shameful. Also, just to point out something else, saying that the "cover your plate" mentality is a Long Island thing does not make it okay, or acceptable, it makes all Long Islanders look like a bunch of spoiled brats. Message edited 2012-05-26 08:52:30.973000. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 8:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated I find this thread ridiculously sad. No wonder half of all marriages end in divorce. People are so obsessed with the wedding and how much money they're going to "make" on it. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 9:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by Teachergal The "spoiled brat" comments are unnecessary. This has been my experience- I know for me and my group of family or friends it is natural to give back what you received unless you have fallen on hard times. And yes, one couple did right before our wedding (the DH lost his job) and they gave a small gift. I didn't bat an eye. Everyone else was a 2 income family or BF/GF couple. There were no kids in the picture when I got married amongst any of my friends. It would have seemed odd to me that a couple didn't reciprocate a gift after we had given generously to them. Since we were one of the last to get married, we had spent a lot of money on all of our friends because we WANTED to. I guess if they hadn't reciprocated it would have made me feel like they DIDN'T want to give the same back. And it would have hurt. They all did give back the same though because that's just how my group of friends/family are. I get this. I'm not in anyway saying that expectation or anticipation is ABNORMAL. I think almost every person has some idea in their head about what they might expect as a gift - usually based on what THEY themselves would give. And when expectations fall short it's not unusual to get a little .. curious or whatever. But here's the thing (for me).. just because it's NORMAL doesn't mean it's RIGHT. I'm going to admit that when Rob and I were opening our cards there was a family that I happened to know was VERY wealthy. I not only knew his specific monthly income, I also knew the majority of his expenses. And I wasn't guessing or speculating, this was something that I knew. He brought 4 people and gave me $300. I remember thinking that we were close and I actually expected him to give me more. I mean - I made a fraction of his income and gave a similar amount for 2 people at a recent wedding. I ADMIT that I was stymied by that gift... but I will also admit that the reaction was BRATTY. It was self centered and childish to focus on the amount of a check rather than the fact that this guy had gone out of his way to make it to my wedding. It was sillly to assume that the amount of money offered was in any way tied to the amount of affection or esteem in which he held me. I mean the biggest gift I got was from someone that I know doesn't like me as much as people who gave me some smaller gifts. It might be typical to have expectations and I don't think that makes a person BAD.. but it's also typical for a child to open a birthday card and start to shake it or search for money or a gift when they don't immediately see it. KWIM? |
|
Posted 5/26/12 9:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by rojerono But here's the thing (for me).. just because it's NORMAL doesn't mean it's RIGHT. You're correct, it doesn't make you right, it makes you HUMAN. Something the posters here on LIF seem to forget. This stupid site is so flipping PC it makes me laugh. I'm not going to argue whether it's ridiculous or not to hold grudges over gifts or whether it's right that anyone speculates someone's financial position. I'm willing to bet we've ALL done it at one time or another so to sit here and lambast a poster over this is really freakin hypocritical and such an epic waste of time. Does ANYONE think she's gonna change her mind? Is she gonna change yours? I didn't think so. So move the F on. This is so old not to mention completely USELESS to the OP and her question. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 10:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Yeah, I'm a "spoiled brat" because I think it's rude for someone to show up to a wedding party with no gift. I mean, that's so ridiculous that it barely warrants my response. Also, I love the examples- my friend rode on an elephants back to my wedding from Africa on eight minutes notice... That's OBVIOUSLY not what this conversion is about. I'm talking about TYPICAL couples showing up with NOTHING. It is RUDE. Ugh I'm not even opening this thread again. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 2:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated All I can say is that I would have been so upset if someone I loved didn't go to my wedding because they thought their gift wasn't up to par |
|
Posted 5/26/12 2:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Message edited 2012-05-26 23:28:40.377000. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 5:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line. Best line of this thread. Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes. I was being a smart azz. Colette, I have said it before - I know I don't know you, but I think I love you. A wedding is to celebrate with family and friends. I don't remember who gave me what. I remember that we were lucky to have many out of town guests we didn't think would make it. I'm glad that a few family members were able to make it, since they passed not long after the wedding. I hate these threads. I had my wedding for me and my DH. If you are expecting to get back what you paid for the reception hall, than maybe your wedding is costing you too much. I will also say that now, 7 years later, after a whole shitstorm of events that have gone on in our life, this whole conversation is trivial and if your friends are the type that do this tit for tat with gifts, then maybe they aren't such good friends. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 5:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line. Best line of this thread. Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes. I was being a smart azz. Colette, I have said it before - I know I don't know you, but I think I love you. A wedding is to celebrate with family and friends. I don't remember who gave me what. I remember that we were lucky to have many out of town guests we didn't think would make it. I'm glad that a few family members were able to make it, since they passed not long after the wedding. I hate these threads. I had my wedding for me and my DH. If you are expecting to get back what you paid for the reception hall, than maybe your wedding is costing you too much. I will also say that now, 7 years later, after a whole shitstorm of events that have gone on in our life, this whole conversation is trivial and if your friends are the type that do this tit for tat with gifts, then maybe they aren't such good friends. Don't worry, I knew that. I loled because again someone missed my point. You guys should all show up to the next party you're invited to and give a hand written note that explains your position on gifts. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 5:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line. Best line of this thread. Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes. I was being a smart azz. Colette, I have said it before - I know I don't know you, but I think I love you. A wedding is to celebrate with family and friends. I don't remember who gave me what. I remember that we were lucky to have many out of town guests we didn't think would make it. I'm glad that a few family members were able to make it, since they passed not long after the wedding. I hate these threads. I had my wedding for me and my DH. If you are expecting to get back what you paid for the reception hall, than maybe your wedding is costing you too much. I will also say that now, 7 years later, after a whole shitstorm of events that have gone on in our life, this whole conversation is trivial and if your friends are the type that do this tit for tat with gifts, then maybe they aren't such good friends. Don't worry, I knew that. I loled because again someone missed my point. You guys should all show up to the next party you're invited to and give a hand written note that explains your position on gifts. And a copy of your bank statement!
|
|
Posted 5/26/12 7:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated I always am amazed at these posts....and the amount of money people say they give. Aside from my MOH and another close friend who in hindsight should have been a BM but i got caught up in the LIW frenzy and needed a girl to guy balance, not one of my BMs (my closest dearest friends) gave more than $100. My relatives, aunts, uncles and cousins included, gave the same amount as my coworkers (150-200 per couple). While there were obviously some exceptions, the average gift per couple was $150. DH's sister (brought our nephew and our niece was a Jr. BM) gave us nothing. I received a $25 GC to Target from one guest. I received a check for $45 from another guest. I personally have never given a wedding gift over $200. So again, these gift amounts baffle me and I secretly wish that I was friends with you all |
|
Posted 5/26/12 8:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by lynnd126 Don't worry, I knew that. I loled because again someone missed my point. I don't think anyone missed your point. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 8:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated I think we need a thread about thank you cards now. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line. Best line of this thread. Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes. I was being a smart azz. Colette, I have said it before - I know I don't know you, but I think I love you. A wedding is to celebrate with family and friends. I don't remember who gave me what. I remember that we were lucky to have many out of town guests we didn't think would make it. I'm glad that a few family members were able to make it, since they passed not long after the wedding. I hate these threads. I had my wedding for me and my DH. If you are expecting to get back what you paid for the reception hall, than maybe your wedding is costing you too much. I will also say that now, 7 years later, after a whole shitstorm of events that have gone on in our life, this whole conversation is trivial and if your friends are the type that do this tit for tat with gifts, then maybe they aren't such good friends. Don't worry, I knew that. I loled because again someone missed my point. You guys should all show up to the next party you're invited to and give a hand written note that explains your position on gifts. Thought you weren't opening this thread again |
|
Posted 5/26/12 9:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by HeathKernandez Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 Posted by dpli Posted by lynnd126 I didn't make my wedding guest list off the welfare line. Best line of this thread. Lol, just to explain what I meant- I was saying that I think it's rude for someone to show up with nada. I just think it's the pinnacle of impolite. I knew a million people would say something like "you don't know what someone's financial situation is" but that's really waaaay the exception and not the rule bc basically every one of my guests has at least an average monetary situation- average enough that you shouldn't show up to a wedding reception be it in a back yard or buckingham palace with zero gift. I feel like on lif there's always that exception argument being played as the rule like the dizzy diabetic in the grocery store that NEEDS to nibble on grapes. I was being a smart azz. Colette, I have said it before - I know I don't know you, but I think I love you. A wedding is to celebrate with family and friends. I don't remember who gave me what. I remember that we were lucky to have many out of town guests we didn't think would make it. I'm glad that a few family members were able to make it, since they passed not long after the wedding. I hate these threads. I had my wedding for me and my DH. If you are expecting to get back what you paid for the reception hall, than maybe your wedding is costing you too much. I will also say that now, 7 years later, after a whole shitstorm of events that have gone on in our life, this whole conversation is trivial and if your friends are the type that do this tit for tat with gifts, then maybe they aren't such good friends. Don't worry, I knew that. I loled because again someone missed my point. You guys should all show up to the next party you're invited to and give a hand written note that explains your position on gifts. Thought you weren't opening this thread again So incredibly lame of you to point out. I thought by now this would be on page 10 but it's lingering got the best of me. This is the last time I am using any of my electronic devices. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 10:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated Posted by KristenRSF The night of my wedding, my husband was passed out drunk and I counted the money while eating Domino's pizza in my bridal underwear, bra and veil. I seriously read the cards, and put the money in an envelope. I didn't make a spreadsheet of who gave me what, and I know there were a few gifts that were not as much as others but in a million years I would never give less or the same to those people just because of that.You give what you can afford. And just because some people go on a vacation, or take a 20 dollar cake decorating class does not mean you have a right to judge what they gave you. $170 a plate? That's pretty over the top if you ask me. If you paid for the wedding yourself, then you made that choice. If you didn't, be happy you were able to keep the money you made. Yeah maybe... but you still counted it though Didn't even wait to take off your veil, or for your husband to sober up before you dug right in lol... which tells me you too were at least somewhat eager and curious about gifts that night Just because you didn't make a spreadsheet doesn't make you better than other posters who said otherwise. I couldn't care less either way on either side of this argument... everyone will have their own opinion, but seriously live and let live already... How many people are going to come out of the woodwork to jump on the bashing bandwagon?! If she feels like caring about gifts, then she's entitled to her opinion... Some people are calling her bratty and selfish, but they don't sound any better themselves! Seriously, some people are acting like they went out the very next day and just donated all their wedding gifts with the way they are carrying on! There is some real holier than thou NASTINESS on this thread!
Message edited 2012-05-26 23:37:43.937000. |
|
Posted 5/26/12 11:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: how much would you give for wedding? Updated To the OP- I think 200-250 is good. The kids probably aren't costing much. |
|
Posted 5/27/12 7:16 AM
|
|
| Pages: << 4 5 6 [7] 8 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spinoff to wedding songs... Who think they had a unique wedding song that you don't normally hear... | HeathKernandez | 8/23/11 | 141 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| GOOD LUCK PRINCESSMARIS!!! TOMORROW IS HER WEDDING DAY! | btrflygrl | 7/21/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Do you ever not wear your wedding band/engagement ring? | Lichi | 7/14/05 | 50 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| i finally had the guts to pick up my wedding video... | ggt08 | 7/12/05 | 43 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| WOW!! Couple Celebrates 80th Wedding Anniversary!! | DebG | 6/2/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| how many times do you listen to your wedding song? | janet | 5/24/05 | 24 | Families Helping Families ™ |


















