how much would you give for wedding? Updated

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

i would prob give 300,400 if i was close to them

Posted 5/24/12 12:18 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by JenniferEver

First cousins?

I really don't know, since it's upstate. Here I would say $400.

but out of state is so different. Some people from out of state (and some clieless people) gave us gfts of like $25-50 for a couple. I am still holding a grugde since my wedding was like $170pp.

I gave $250 for an OOS wedding for me and DH and i felt SOOOO cheap writing that check and when i got there I didn't feel cheap any more. Then they turned around and gave us half that.

I'm writing out my thank yous so I am especially bitter.

An OOS familyof 5 who came to our wedding gave $300. I felt it was a little low by "cover your plate standards" but I felt it was ok. They can't be expected to shell out thousands because they have kids who *I* invited. I'd go with $300 in your case, but never less than $200



I could be wrong, but haven't you written in the past about financial struggles? With that said, I would put yourself in other people's shoes and not be so critical about their GIFT.

And if you really were having a difficult time with money, why did you choose a venue where you felt like you should be reimbursed for the $$$ you spent?

I'm not trying to be mean, but that's a really $hitty attitude to have to people who came to celebrate your day.

Posted 5/24/12 8:01 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by LiveItUp

I don't know if all areas upstate are the same, but when I got married DH's relatives from upstate came dressed pretty casually and were shocked at how 'fancy' (their words) our wedding was. I don't think they spend nearly as much for weddings as people do in LI



Outside of Long Island, this is totally the norm. I know many people who are not from NY, but the South and Mid-west and they have a hard time wrapping their head around the amount of $$$ spent and the "look at me look at me" show some couples have here on Long Island.

In fact, I know someone from S. Carolina now on LI, and she had the wedding down there and she couldn't find a box anywhere for cards down there. A friend from NY had to bring it down for her.

They mostly do gifts like housewares and such.

I know some couples here now on LI who are STILL paying off their wedding from several years ago, and they can barely pay their other bills they need to live.

Posted 5/24/12 8:06 AM
 

blu6385

Member since 5/08

8351 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

some of these repsonses Chat Icon

i always went by a general rule that you should give no less than $75 per person and i wouldnt even count kids, most places dont charge for kids.

It wasnt till this site and LIW that i realized i am consisder cheap.

All well i still stand by $75 per peson is the min. i would give for a wedding.

Message edited 2012-05-24 09:21:44.613000.

Posted 5/24/12 8:36 AM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

i would give about $300
i agree that you give what you can afford...you are are also 5 people

Posted 5/24/12 9:14 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by mzsocialworker1



I could be wrong, but haven't you written in the past about financial struggles? With that said, I would put yourself in other people's shoes and not be so critical about their GIFT.

And if you really were having a difficult time with money, why did you choose a venue where you felt like you should be reimbursed for the $$$ you spent?

I'm not trying to be mean, but that's a really $hitty attitude to have to people who came to celebrate your day.



I didn't expect to be reimbursed. We paid for our own wedding, but some of the gifts seemed like either the person was clueless or, or it was kind of insulting.

The friend who gave us a $50 gift for 2 people 2 weeks later was the first person to sign up for a $70 cake decorating class with me.

The friend who gave $25 was bragging about how he was taking his fiance on a $1500 weekend to AC for her birthday.

If people really can't afford it, it's one thing. There were several people I told please don't bring a gift. Please just come to share the day. But I feel like I woudn't even give $25 for a birthday party, who would give that at a wedding? I'm not the only person whose eyebrows have been raised by their wedding gifts, I'm just honest about it.

Posted 5/24/12 9:20 AM
 

tink23
Step by step....

Member since 6/11

1061 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by JenniferEver

I didn't expect to be reimbursed. We paid for our own wedding, but some of the gifts seemed like either the person was clueless or, or it was kind of insulting.

The friend who gave us a $50 gift for 2 people 2 weeks later was the first person to sign up for a $70 cake decorating class with me.

The friend who gave $25 was bragging about how he was taking his fiance on a $1500 weekend to AC for her birthday.

If people really can't afford it, it's one thing. There were several people I told please don't bring a gift. Please just come to share the day. But I feel like I woudn't even give $25 for a birthday party, who would give that at a wedding? I'm not the only person whose eyebrows have been raised by their wedding gifts, I'm just honest about it.



I get what you are saying. It's one thing to be clueless or to be broke, that's understandable and I wouldn't be mad if that was the case.

At my wedding I had cousins come from Texas who gave $100 for their family of 5. To be honest, when I opened up the envelope I was shocked. But when I thought about all the expenses it took to get there and the fact that they are not rich, I felt thankful to get anything and happy that they made it out to celebrate.

Then on the other side of the coin, I had 2 sets of couples that gave $50 per couple. Other people's finances are none of my business but both of these couple live in NYC, go out to clubs, and take trips quite frequently. Again, it is none of my business how people spend their money, but
I feel that for them to give $25 a person, for a wedding,
seems kind of crappy.

Posted 5/24/12 9:37 AM
 

tink23
Step by step....

Member since 6/11

1061 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

I would give $250-$300

Posted 5/24/12 9:39 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

I should have put a Chat Icon or Chat Icon face.

I 100% knew people were not going to "cover their plates" for my wedding. I CHOSE to have it an expensive place.That was MY choice, not theirs.

HOWEVER, I did find some of the gifts I got insulting. $25 for a wedding? Is there anyone here who thinks that's appropriate? If you can't afford it, that's one thing. There's also a difference between a modest gift given from the heart, and someone who just decided to throw something together. Like the people who came to our wedding and gave us half what we gave them. I just don't think that's normal.

As for the $300 gift from 5 people I was saying it was ok, as in I felt it was an appropriate gift, and could be used as a guideline for the future.

Look, this post comes up once every 3 months, and this time I'm the one being called a selfish spoiled brat. I always tlel new brides they'll be very surprised. Surprised by the people who blow the wedding off, and by the ones who go completely out of their way to be there, surprised by the thoughtless gifts or no-gifters, and by the incredible generousity of others. ow supportive some people can be and how nasty other people are.

I'm not the only person who looked at the gifts and instead of saying "oh look another gift" said "WOW that was really generous" or "Really!?" while looking at it. Someone who has a job and comes to my wedding and gives $25? I find it insulting. It made me angry. I would rather they have spent the $25 on a thoughtful gift or something. $25 just says "i don't give a crap" to me. And as for people OOS, yes they would give lower because that's their tradition and culture. They don't give $300 at weddings. And when i saw clueless I'll put it this way, my friends who are married already gave appropriate gifts. $100 can be an appropriate gift. My younger friends and those not married gave much lower gifts that you would not normally give for a wedding. That's why I'm saying they're more clueless than maybe deliberately being insulting, but some gifts did feel like sleights. There's a lot of politics to gift giving in families sometimes. My MIL wanted to know what everyone gave us so she could know to match it for upcoming weddings,, ir if they gave less than she did for their kids wedding. Anywya, you have people on here saying "I'd never give less than $75pp for a wedding", "you should never give less than $200", and that's an ok statement to make, and I can'y say people gave me gifts well below that threshold and it felt crappy? These posts asking what to give for a wedding establish that there is such a thing as an apporpriate and inapropriate gift for a wedding based on the closeness to the bride and groom, location, and other factors. If we've already established that there is a realm of appropriate and inappropriate, why can't I say I'm currently annoyed because some of the gifts i got were inappropriate? And that those people maybe didn't bother to ask anyone or think about what kind of gift would suit a close friend or family member's wedding. I'd never vent about IRL, but I clearly chose the wrong forum. I def. should have known better.

People who know me know I'm a very generous person, I'm extremely grateful for all I have in life. DH and I have been through a LOT. We had a 7.5 year engagement (not by choice).I threw an expensive wedding for a lot of reasons, all of them my own. It was never a fund raiser. If we had gotten $0 in gifts we'd be fine. We probably wouldn't have gotten the new TV we used one of our gifts for Chat Icon, but we'd be fine. You know how they say "it's the thought that counts"? Well some of these gifts made it feel like there was no thought involved, or that our wedding was not important to them. It was a formal wedding, not a backyard barbecue. I'm also still annoyed about the friend whose DH passed out on the patio and then crawled under his table and passed out again. FTR, they gave a very appropriate gift.Chat Icon


ETA: I'm sorry to have hijacked the OPs thread. I was just feeling super annoyed after having seen that the GC had $25 on it and had to get it out. $12.50 per person? That's like going to a movie! Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-05-24 09:47:08.487000.

Posted 5/24/12 9:40 AM
 

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by JenniferEver

First cousins?

I really don't know, since it's upstate. Here I would say $400.

but out of state is so different. Some people from out of state (and some clieless people) gave us gfts of like $25-50 for a couple. I am still holding a grugde since my wedding was like $170pp.

I gave $250 for an OOS wedding for me and DH and i felt SOOOO cheap writing that check and when i got there I didn't feel cheap any more. Then they turned around and gave us half that.

I'm writing out my thank yous so I am especially bitter.

An OOS familyof 5 who came to our wedding gave $300. I felt it was a little low by "cover your plate standards" but I felt it was ok. They can't be expected to shell out thousands because they have kids who *I* invited. I'd go with $300 in your case, but never less than $200



I could be wrong, but haven't you written in the past about financial struggles? With that said, I would put yourself in other people's shoes and not be so critical about their GIFT.

And if you really were having a difficult time with money, why did you choose a venue where you felt like you should be reimbursed for the $$$ you spent?

I'm not trying to be mean, but that's a really $hitty attitude to have to people who came to celebrate your day.



If memory serves YOU used to post a lot about financial difficulties so I think you're just trying to be snotty by implying they couldn't afford their wedding.

Posted 5/24/12 9:58 AM
 

ODonnell
.

Member since 9/05

5983 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by tink23

I would give $250-$300



This is what I was going to suggest also. We didn't get charged for kids under 5 at our wedding.

Posted 5/24/12 10:00 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

LOL I really don't know how anyone remember what anyone used to post back in the day. I barely remember what *I* posted *last week*.

Posted 5/24/12 10:01 AM
 

Mrs007
Im obsessed w my lil man!

Member since 3/09

2528 total posts

Name:
K

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Give whatever you can afford to comfortably give.

Posted 5/24/12 10:09 AM
 

MySunshine
In love with my Baby Boy

Member since 3/11

2783 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by tarabelle99

Posted by JenniferEver

First cousins?

I really don't know, since it's upstate. Here I would say $400.

but out of state is so different. Some people from out of state (and some clieless people) gave us gfts of like $25-50 for a couple. I am still holding a grugde since my wedding was like $170pp.

I gave $250 for an OOS wedding for me and DH and i felt SOOOO cheap writing that check and when i got there I didn't feel cheap any more. Then they turned around and gave us half that.

I'm writing out my thank yous so I am especially bitter.

An OOS familyof 5 who came to our wedding gave $300. I felt it was a little low by "cover your plate standards" but I felt it was ok. They can't be expected to shell out thousands because they have kids who *I* invited. I'd go with $300 in your case, but never less than $200




So clueless people and people from out of state give too little?

You chose a venue, menu etc that cost 170pp.

You invited these people to share in your event, to celebrate your special day.

The oblige by coming to your event and participating in your day. Usually they'll even give gift. Some of these people incurred costs to get there (as they are from OOS) and enjoy your day. Do you take that into account? Do you take into account that not everyone can afford as much as you?

The whole "cover your plate" mentality and thought that couples who are marrying should profit from a wedding is beyond greedy.

And to admit that you're bitter and holding a grudge? Really?

It really comes across as selfish and ungrateful when these types of posts are made.

Here's a thought, rather than spending extravagantly expecting to recoup costs from people "covering their plates" how about just spending what you can afford and then being appreciative of the fact that people show up at all to enjoy your day?

I know if I were invited to a wedding and found out later that my gift wasn't "good enough" and that the couple expected me to not only incur the costs of travel but also to profit from me? Hell, even if there weren't travel concerns, I'd be pizzed to hear that my gift wasn't "good enough". And you know what? It'd be the LAST time I ever gave a gift or attended any of their events.

Here's an idea for future brides:

Instead of asking for gifts, and expecting that you'll get this "cover your plate plus some" 'gift' just send invoices to people so they know how much to give you. That's right, just sell tickets and charge admission, because that is essentially what you're doing when you complain about ANY gift that is given to you.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/12 10:42 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

I see what you mean jennifer.

I'm just disgusted by a lot of the wedding tit for tat. When my Sil got married, my dh took a drastic pay cut at that time. I lost my job then and had baby on way. We both were in wedding which was hard on us financially but we did it. Then we have them 150 for the wedding gift. Truly was all we could spare after renting tux, my dress and shoes and hair and make up. Plus after wedding shower and Bach party, etc

They were Annoyed we gave too little. When our wedding came around, which we had just a dinner with close family, no shower, no bach party, no bridesmaids
or groomsmen, they gave us 150. Which was fine but then I recall them saying, "here is your money back. we are givif you what you gave us. congrats". they were not broke like us at the time, they were making it tit for tat.


What a horrible feeling.

Posted 5/24/12 10:55 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

That's so nasty!

I'm not being that way at all. I'm more on your side where I feel like people didn't put the thought/effort into the gift. People were making it seem like I was opening envelopes in the bridal suite to pay off the hall, or planning how I was going to spend my big bucks. I ultimately don't care how much we got as wedding gifts, and that's the truth, like whether the total amount met some number. It was about how we felt treated by the individual people.

We had one cousin who had a black tie wedding, which is an expense, out of town and we had to stay 2 nights at a Hyatt for the activities, so it was a LOT of money for us. I was still in college. Now they live in NYC (in an expensive neighborhood in manhattan) and did not have to travel for our wedding and they are verh financially established (unlike how we were at their wedding) and they gave us less than we gave them. I just thought that kind of thing was odd.It just doesn't feel nice.


ETA: On the comical side, I was at a family wedidng and the BM was the grooms much older brother. 3 of his 4 kids brought dates (even the 13 year old) who weren't invited,so they ended up being like 7 people. I think the gift they gave was like $148.37. Comical not just because it's a low amount for 7 frickin' people, but because it was such a weird number. It makes me think they all scrounged for pocket change on the way over since they forgot to get a gift.

Message edited 2012-05-24 11:07:16.867000.

Posted 5/24/12 11:00 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by ladybug8

I found this--although it only lets you select that you are bringing one guest.

calculator



This thing is RIDICULOUS. Chat Icon

I had to laugh because I put:

Making 25K-35K
Attending with spouse
Friend of the family
Lost count of times married
Attended at least 3 pre-wedding festivities
West Virginia as location
Informal (House of small gathering)
Peak wedding season
Friday night


And it said my give should be -$50. Chat Icon I should be OWED money by the bride & groom. hahahaha!

Posted 5/24/12 11:09 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Posted by ladybug8

I found this--although it only lets you select that you are bringing one guest.

calculator



This thing is RIDICULOUS. Chat Icon

I had to laugh because I put:

Making 25K-35K
Attending with spouse
Friend of the family
Lost count of times married
Attended at least 3 pre-wedding festivities
West Virginia as location
Informal (House of small gathering)
Peak wedding season
Friday night


And it said my give should be -$50. Chat Icon I should be OWED money by the bride & groom. hahahaha!




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


Ive found it to be pretty accurate usually.. I guess you should go shake up the bride at the reception!

Posted 5/24/12 11:11 AM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

This topic can be touchy but just give whatever you are comfortable with, there are no rules.

Posted 5/24/12 11:12 AM
 

ItsaJoya19
my cup runneth over

Member since 1/10

2949 total posts

Name:
E

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by JenniferEver

That's so nasty!

I'm not being that way at all. I'm more on your side where I feel like people didn't put the thought/effort into the gift. People were making it seem like I was opening envelopes in the bridal suite to pay off the hall, or planning how I was going to spend my big bucks. I ultimately don't care how much we got as wedding gifts, and that's the truth, like whether the total amount met some number. It was about how we felt treated by the individual people.

We had one cousin who had a black tie wedding, which is an expense, out of town and we had to stay 2 nights at a Hyatt for the activities, so it was a LOT of money for us. I was still in college. Now they live in NYC (in an expensive neighborhood in manhattan) and did not have to travel for our wedding and they are verh financially established (unlike how we were at their wedding) and they gave us less than we gave them. I just thought that kind of thing was odd.It just doesn't feel nice.



Err i really don't like getting involved on these threads but I just need to know....

How is showing up to your wedding with a gift not treating you well? Did they help you celebrate your wedding at all? Did they sit at their table and not participate? I am with you on the clueless part - my grandpa gave us $100 and DH's grandparents gave us $1000. I was a little shocked opening the cards - bc the amounts were so different - but you know what, I danced with my grandpa at my wedding. He was THERE and watched me walk down the aisle. I wish my grandma's were there. My one grandpa passed away this year - my cousins won't have the honor of having him at their weddings. Our grandparents could have given us nothing but a card and I'd have been happy that they were there. Like I said, I wish my grandmas were there.

I think it's sad when money dictates how you feel you've been treated. If they are good friends, which I guess they'd have to be to get an invite to something as special as a wedding, isn't having them there with you to celebrate with enough? Isn't the card and check just the cherry on top?

JMHO of course.

Posted 5/24/12 11:18 AM
 

KristenRSF
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/10

487 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by mzsocialworker1



I could be wrong, but haven't you written in the past about financial struggles? With that said, I would put yourself in other people's shoes and not be so critical about their GIFT.

And if you really were having a difficult time with money, why did you choose a venue where you felt like you should be reimbursed for the $$$ you spent?

I'm not trying to be mean, but that's a really $hitty attitude to have to people who came to celebrate your day.



I didn't expect to be reimbursed. We paid for our own wedding, but some of the gifts seemed like either the person was clueless or, or it was kind of insulting.

The friend who gave us a $50 gift for 2 people 2 weeks later was the first person to sign up for a $70 cake decorating class with me.

The friend who gave $25 was bragging about how he was taking his fiance on a $1500 weekend to AC for her birthday.

If people really can't afford it, it's one thing. There were several people I told please don't bring a gift. Please just come to share the day. But I feel like I woudn't even give $25 for a birthday party, who would give that at a wedding? I'm not the only person whose eyebrows have been raised by their wedding gifts, I'm just honest about it.



It's none of your business how people spend their money Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/12 12:41 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Posted by DumpsterBaby

Posted by mzsocialworker1

Posted by JenniferEver

First cousins?

I really don't know, since it's upstate. Here I would say $400.

but out of state is so different. Some people from out of state (and some clieless people) gave us gfts of like $25-50 for a couple. I am still holding a grugde since my wedding was like $170pp.

I gave $250 for an OOS wedding for me and DH and i felt SOOOO cheap writing that check and when i got there I didn't feel cheap any more. Then they turned around and gave us half that.

I'm writing out my thank yous so I am especially bitter.

An OOS familyof 5 who came to our wedding gave $300. I felt it was a little low by "cover your plate standards" but I felt it was ok. They can't be expected to shell out thousands because they have kids who *I* invited. I'd go with $300 in your case, but never less than $200



I could be wrong, but haven't you written in the past about financial struggles? With that said, I would put yourself in other people's shoes and not be so critical about their GIFT.

And if you really were having a difficult time with money, why did you choose a venue where you felt like you should be reimbursed for the $$$ you spent?

I'm not trying to be mean, but that's a really $hitty attitude to have to people who came to celebrate your day.



If memory serves YOU used to post a lot about financial difficulties so I think you're just trying to be snotty by implying they couldn't afford their wedding.



Not at all. Just pointing out how the post comes across. Not sure YOUR point except to Chat Icon . BTW, she explained what she meant and it didn't initially come across as being nice.

Message edited 2012-05-24 18:07:29.653000.

Posted 5/24/12 6:02 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

*shrugs* I've explained what I meant, and I don't think I'm the only one by far who has seen some gifts and went Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon . I didn't say I wished I hadn't invited them or I didn't appreciate them being there.

Posted 5/24/12 6:47 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

For family I always at least $300

Posted 5/24/12 7:00 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: how much would you give for wedding?

Long Island is the only area I know of where people shell out more than their car payment for wedding gifts.

Every single person that came to my sister's wedding from out of state gave $25-$50 per person. Who cares?! She sure as hell didn't. And her wedding was pretty pricey. A wedding is not a fundraiser. It's a celebration of marriage. If you want the money in your pocket, elope.

Posted 5/24/12 7:14 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to wedding songs... Who think they had a unique wedding song that you don't normally hear... HeathKernandez 8/23/11 141 Families Helping Families ™
GOOD LUCK PRINCESSMARIS!!! TOMORROW IS HER WEDDING DAY! btrflygrl 7/21/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Do you ever not wear your wedding band/engagement ring? Lichi 7/14/05 50 Families Helping Families ™
i finally had the guts to pick up my wedding video... ggt08 7/12/05 43 Families Helping Families ™
WOW!! Couple Celebrates 80th Wedding Anniversary!! DebG 6/2/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
how many times do you listen to your wedding song? janet 5/24/05 24 Families Helping Families ™