Re: how much would you give for wedding?
Posted 5/24/2012 9:40:49 AM by JenniferEver

I should have put a Chat Icon or Chat Icon face.

I 100% knew people were not going to "cover their plates" for my wedding. I CHOSE to have it an expensive place.That was MY choice, not theirs.

HOWEVER, I did find some of the gifts I got insulting. $25 for a wedding? Is there anyone here who thinks that's appropriate? If you can't afford it, that's one thing. There's also a difference between a modest gift given from the heart, and someone who just decided to throw something together. Like the people who came to our wedding and gave us half what we gave them. I just don't think that's normal.

As for the $300 gift from 5 people I was saying it was ok, as in I felt it was an appropriate gift, and could be used as a guideline for the future.

Look, this post comes up once every 3 months, and this time I'm the one being called a selfish spoiled brat. I always tlel new brides they'll be very surprised. Surprised by the people who blow the wedding off, and by the ones who go completely out of their way to be there, surprised by the thoughtless gifts or no-gifters, and by the incredible generousity of others. ow supportive some people can be and how nasty other people are.

I'm not the only person who looked at the gifts and instead of saying "oh look another gift" said "WOW that was really generous" or "Really!?" while looking at it. Someone who has a job and comes to my wedding and gives $25? I find it insulting. It made me angry. I would rather they have spent the $25 on a thoughtful gift or something. $25 just says "i don't give a crap" to me. And as for people OOS, yes they would give lower because that's their tradition and culture. They don't give $300 at weddings. And when i saw clueless I'll put it this way, my friends who are married already gave appropriate gifts. $100 can be an appropriate gift. My younger friends and those not married gave much lower gifts that you would not normally give for a wedding. That's why I'm saying they're more clueless than maybe deliberately being insulting, but some gifts did feel like sleights. There's a lot of politics to gift giving in families sometimes. My MIL wanted to know what everyone gave us so she could know to match it for upcoming weddings,, ir if they gave less than she did for their kids wedding. Anywya, you have people on here saying "I'd never give less than $75pp for a wedding", "you should never give less than $200", and that's an ok statement to make, and I can'y say people gave me gifts well below that threshold and it felt crappy? These posts asking what to give for a wedding establish that there is such a thing as an apporpriate and inapropriate gift for a wedding based on the closeness to the bride and groom, location, and other factors. If we've already established that there is a realm of appropriate and inappropriate, why can't I say I'm currently annoyed because some of the gifts i got were inappropriate? And that those people maybe didn't bother to ask anyone or think about what kind of gift would suit a close friend or family member's wedding. I'd never vent about IRL, but I clearly chose the wrong forum. I def. should have known better.

People who know me know I'm a very generous person, I'm extremely grateful for all I have in life. DH and I have been through a LOT. We had a 7.5 year engagement (not by choice).I threw an expensive wedding for a lot of reasons, all of them my own. It was never a fund raiser. If we had gotten $0 in gifts we'd be fine. We probably wouldn't have gotten the new TV we used one of our gifts for Chat Icon, but we'd be fine. You know how they say "it's the thought that counts"? Well some of these gifts made it feel like there was no thought involved, or that our wedding was not important to them. It was a formal wedding, not a backyard barbecue. I'm also still annoyed about the friend whose DH passed out on the patio and then crawled under his table and passed out again. FTR, they gave a very appropriate gift.Chat Icon


ETA: I'm sorry to have hijacked the OPs thread. I was just feeling super annoyed after having seen that the GC had $25 on it and had to get it out. $12.50 per person? That's like going to a movie! Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window