grr about voting

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: grr about voting

Posted by stayandjohn

While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended.

She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away Chat Icon




I'm sorry but I do not understand how you can think that Santa isn't a religious figure or while maybe not specifically a religious figure, certainly associated specifically with a religious holiday of one particular religion. Santa Claus certainly doesn't represent any other religion.

Posted 11/4/08 1:53 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

snowflake08
Love my boys!!!

Member since 8/07

5148 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: grr about voting

Posted by mrswask

Posted by stayandjohn

While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended.

She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away Chat Icon




I'm sorry but I do not understand how you can think that Santa isn't a religious figure or while maybe not specifically a religious figure, certainly associated specifically with a religious holiday of one particular religion. Santa Claus certainly doesn't represent any other religion.

absolutely! that is why he is associated with xmas and not chanukah or kwanzaa

Posted 11/4/08 1:56 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by mrswask

Posted by stayandjohn

While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended.

She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away Chat Icon




I'm sorry but I do not understand how you can think that Santa isn't a religious figure or while maybe not specifically a religious figure, certainly associated specifically with a religious holiday of one particular religion. Santa Claus certainly doesn't represent any other religion.


ITA.

I think a lot of people just assume everyone celebrates Christmas. I'm due on Christmas and I constantly get comments about how I'll have a special Christmas present this year, etc. I don't bother correcting strangers and telling them I'm Jewish. The how sad comment would've really annoyed me though.

Posted 11/4/08 2:02 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: grr about voting

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!

Posted 11/4/08 2:02 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.

Posted 11/4/08 2:08 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: grr about voting

I agree that Santa is most defintiely an intricate part of Christian religions- to say *he* is not is silly.

That said, I think the woman in question wasn't attempting to impose her religious beliefs on the OP. Rather, she was just making conversation and put her foot in her mouth. I'm assuming the "how sad" comment was because of the "lack of gifts", not that it is sad to be Jewish as evidenced by her later comment about still receiving gifts for Chanukah.

Posted 11/4/08 2:13 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: grr about voting

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!



She wasn't supposed to know, but after being told by the poster that they were Jewish, she shouldn't have said "how sad" (meaning how sad they don't believe in Santa).

It's the how sad statement that as a jew myself, gets under my skin. Why should a kid be made to feel that it's sad they celebrate a different holiday and do not believe in Santa?

Posted 11/4/08 2:14 PM
 

secretbabymaker
I love my kids

Member since 12/06

2503 total posts

Name:

Re: grr about voting

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



Santa is a fable, yes he is associated with people who believe in the christian religions, but technically he is not part of the true religion of christmas, He is not in the bible and is not mentioned at church ceremonies during christmas time..Chat Icon

Posted 11/4/08 2:14 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by secretbabymaker

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



Santa is a fable, yes he is associated with people who believe in the christian religions, but technically he is not part of the true religion of christmas, He is not in the bible and is not mentioned at church ceremonies during christmas time..Chat Icon


I understand Santa is not a religious figure, but he's associated with a particular religious holiday just like the Easter Bunny. I wouldn't expect them to come up at church, but IMO, that doesn't mean they're not tied into a particular religion/religious holiday.

Posted 11/4/08 2:21 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by Porrruss

I agree that Santa is most defintiely an intricate part of Christian religions- to say *he* is not is silly.

That said, I think the woman in question wasn't attempting to impose her religious beliefs on the OP. Rather, she was just making conversation and put her foot in her mouth. I'm assuming the "how sad" comment was because of the "lack of gifts", not that it is sad to be Jewish as evidenced by her later comment about still receiving gifts for Chanukah.



Obviously, we'll never know her intent, but I took that comment to mean it was sad that he won't have the Santa/Christmas celebration experience.

Posted 11/4/08 2:23 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: grr about voting

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by Porrruss

I agree that Santa is most defintiely an intricate part of Christian religions- to say *he* is not is silly.

That said, I think the woman in question wasn't attempting to impose her religious beliefs on the OP. Rather, she was just making conversation and put her foot in her mouth. I'm assuming the "how sad" comment was because of the "lack of gifts", not that it is sad to be Jewish as evidenced by her later comment about still receiving gifts for Chanukah.



Obviously, we'll never know her intent, but I took that comment to mean it was sad that he won't have the Santa/Christmas celebration experience.



That's how I understood it as well. But I guess only that lady knows for sure!

Posted 11/4/08 2:24 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: grr about voting

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'

Posted 11/4/08 2:25 PM
 

snowflake08
Love my boys!!!

Member since 8/07

5148 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: grr about voting

As a person of the Jewish faith myself, and having dealt with this before; I have found that people that are not Jewish dont really "get" why this is annoying / frustrating.

while he (santa) may not be in the bible; he is ASSOCIATED with Christmas; he is on Christmas cards; not Chanukah cards.

Posted 11/4/08 2:31 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: grr about voting

Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure?

Posted 11/4/08 2:36 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'


I understand that Santa is totally separate from the religious aspects of Christmas. However, when a person brings up Santa, there's no doubt that he or she is referring to Christmas. Santa is only associated with Christmas and the Christian religion. I certainly don't think Santa is a religious figure, but whether you agree with it or not, he's associated with a particular religious holiday.

Posted 11/4/08 2:39 PM
 

secretbabymaker
I love my kids

Member since 12/06

2503 total posts

Name:

Re: grr about voting

Posted by SweetTooth

Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure?



I do believe santa is somewhat of a spinoff but the two are seperate, the only thing in common was there generosity and giving to people.

Posted 11/4/08 2:41 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: grr about voting

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'


I understand that Santa is totally separate from the religious aspects of Christmas. However, when a person brings up Santa, there's no doubt that he or she is referring to Christmas. Santa is only associated with Christmas and the Christian religion. I certainly don't think Santa is a religious figure, but whether you agree with it or not, he's associated with a particular religious holiday.



The thing is to me, when people mention Santa they are bringing up a secular holiday, not a religious one, same with the Easter Bunny; but again it doesn't bother me much.

What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other.

Posted 11/4/08 2:46 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: grr about voting

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'



I agree that there is a distinction, but for many the religious traditions and the secular traditions surrounding the holiday are intertwined. I know many people who are not religious and never were religious who celebrate a secular Christmas with presents and Santa, but most people who celebrate Christmas in a secular way have some ties to a Christian religion. For example, I have a lot of Jewish friends, but none celebrate Christmas unless they have other family members who do (e.g., DH or one parent).

So, while I agree that Santa himself is a purely secular figure, he IS tied to a holiday rooted in the Christian faiths. While the distinction between the secular holiday and the holy day is very important to many of us, we cannot deny that Santa isn't really a part of the lives of people who are not in some way affiliated with a Christian religion. Are there exceptions? Of course.

If the comment were made to me, I wouldn't see bringing up Santa as having religious undertones... but I celebrate Christmas. I can see how someone who does not celebrate Christmas would associate Santa with a the Christian faiths on some level.

Posted 11/4/08 2:49 PM
 

stayandjohn
Our life is complete

Member since 5/05

5909 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: grr about voting

Posted by mrswask

Posted by stayandjohn

While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended.

She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away Chat Icon




I'm sorry but I do not understand how you can think that Santa isn't a religious figure or while maybe not specifically a religious figure, certainly associated specifically with a religious holiday of one particular religion. Santa Claus certainly doesn't represent any other religion.



Because I know that Santa isnt the reason behind the holiday. He is a secular figure. And your right, santa doesnt represent any other religion, but in this day and age the true meaning of Christmas has been so watered down and PC that the religious aspect is all but gone.

Posted 11/4/08 2:50 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: grr about voting

Posted by SweetTooth

Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure?



Saint Nicholas (who was never actually cannonized) is the patron saint of sailors and children. He was know for leaving coins in shoes that were left out for him. The Santa Claus thing, I believe, came from a children's story by a dutch author. I'd have to look it up to be sure, but this is what I'm pulling out of my fuzzy memory.

Posted 11/4/08 2:51 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: grr about voting

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'


I understand that Santa is totally separate from the religious aspects of Christmas. However, when a person brings up Santa, there's no doubt that he or she is referring to Christmas. Santa is only associated with Christmas and the Christian religion. I certainly don't think Santa is a religious figure, but whether you agree with it or not, he's associated with a particular religious holiday.



The thing is to me, when people mention Santa they are bringing up a secular holiday, not a religious one, same with the Easter Bunny; but again it doesn't bother me much.

What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other.




Just as you stated earlier that you wouldn't expect someone rasied outside of Catholicism or Christianity to "get it." I feel the same way about people not raised in the Jewish faith to get why a comment like that would be annoying, upsetting, etc... espeically if you have a child that might question it.

As far as your BIL being from Israel, that really has nothing to do with it. While Israel is perceived to be a "Jewish State" having been there and have family that were born, raised and still live there, I can tell you the majority of the country is NOT religious and somewhat more secular around the Jewish religion than many American Jews are. While I'm not very religious myself, I do find I'm more religious than most jewish people I know from Israel.

Posted 11/4/08 2:52 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: grr about voting

It was silly of her to say this, but it doesn't sound as if she meant any harm in it. You corrected her, so you let her know not everyone celebrates Christmas, and maybe she'll think twice before saying stuff like this again.

Not long ago, an older woman was telling me my son was super cute and said "It's nice to see a blond, blue-eyed child". I was left wondering, what the heck did she mean by that?Chat Icon Chat Icon And why would a child with different coloring not be as cute? But there wasn't much I could think of saying at the time, I really don't think she meant ill by the comment, but it came off badly all the same.

Posted 11/4/08 2:55 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: grr about voting

Posted by MrsRbk

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by shiv

Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'


I understand that Santa is totally separate from the religious aspects of Christmas. However, when a person brings up Santa, there's no doubt that he or she is referring to Christmas. Santa is only associated with Christmas and the Christian religion. I certainly don't think Santa is a religious figure, but whether you agree with it or not, he's associated with a particular religious holiday.



The thing is to me, when people mention Santa they are bringing up a secular holiday, not a religious one, same with the Easter Bunny; but again it doesn't bother me much.

What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other.




Just as you stated earlier that you wouldn't expect someone rasied outside of Catholicism or Christianity to "get it." I feel the same way about people not raised in the Jewish faith to get why a comment like that would be annoying, upsetting, etc... espeically if you have a child that might question it.

As far as your BIL being from Israel, that really has nothing to do with it. While Israel is perceived to be a "Jewish State" having been there and have family that were born, raised and still live there, I can tell you the majority of the country is NOT religious and somewhat more secular around the Jewish religion than many American Jews are. While I'm not very religious myself, I do find I'm more religious than most jewish people I know from Israel.



I totally understand you being annoyed with the comment, and of course I couldn't understand the depth of why it would upset you, I was in no way saying that you shouldn't be annoyed. I was respondong to the Santa being equated to a religious holiday thing.

I'm sure there are non religious people in Isreal, just as there are in America, however, my BIL is not one of them. He practices his faith, observes and fasts on Holy Days. One of things I really enjoy about him is that he puts together Sedar every year for my family so we can experience and share in his faith. I just find his perspective interesting, which was what I said in my previous post.

Posted 11/4/08 2:59 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: grr about voting

I think the lady's first remark was innocent but the second one was ignorant. Some people really need to edit their thoughts before they speak.

As for the rest of it, Santa Claus is not religious. Yes, Santa along with Frosty and a myraid of other cartoon characters are prevelant around Christmas but they aren't religious. I never prayed to a snowman, reindeer or misfit toy. Chat Icon

Posted 11/4/08 3:03 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: grr about voting

Posted by NinaLemon

What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other.


It gets annoying when people automatically assume you celebrate a particular religion and then make comments when they find out you don't. I'm not saying everyone gets annoyed by it, but as someone who belongs to a religious minority, I certainly understand why people get offended.

Posted 11/4/08 3:09 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
grr... I just had the worst pedicure (long vent) randella 9/25/08 6 Fashion & Beauty!
FYI for those voting tomorrow for 17th District State Assembly (Merrick, Bellmore, E. Meadow, Garden City, etc.) Mommy2Boys 11/3/08 11 Home
Is this only in NC? Early voting? it started yesterday Janice 10/17/08 4 Families Helping Families ™
Comprehensive "Who are you Voting for?" Poll (with more choices) Kara 9/4/08 71 Families Helping Families ™
On the eve of the Pennsylvania Primary - Obama, Hilary and McCain will try to reach an important voting population.... QuoteTheRaven424 4/21/08 17 Families Helping Families ™
After all the voting, I still changed my mind! ddunne2 12/11/05 11 Parenting