grr about voting
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by stayandjohn While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended. She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away ita. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:17 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: grr about voting Honestly I think it is an inappropriate statement regardless of where it was. JMHO. I hate that people think the whole world is Christian, and feel like you need "pity" (ie the How Sad comment) if you are not. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:23 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: grr about voting Posted by SweetTooth Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure? yes. |
Posted 11/4/08 3:24 PM
|
|
|
QuoteTheRaven424
Member since 5/05 13659 total posts Name: |
Re: grr about voting Posted by mrswask Posted by stayandjohn While not Jewish, the how sad part would annoy me, but honestly, Santa isnt a religious figure, so she really didnt bring religion into it. If she would have said "Santa will bring you presents on the birthday of our lord and savior" then yea I would definately understand being offended. She just sounds ignorant, so take it at face value, smile roll your eyes and walk away I'm sorry but I do not understand how you can think that Santa isn't a religious figure or while maybe not specifically a religious figure, certainly associated specifically with a religious holiday of one particular religion. Santa Claus certainly doesn't represent any other religion. and actually he does represent religion - he was derived from St. Nicholas |
Posted 11/4/08 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting i hear what you are saying, but remember we live in a christian society where most people just assume everyone around them is christian too. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by NinaLemon What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other. It gets annoying when people automatically assume you celebrate a particular religion and then make comments when they find out you don't. I'm not saying everyone gets annoyed by it, but as someone who belongs to a religious minority, I certainly understand why people get offended. That's a really good point, I hadn't thought of the aspect of Judism being a religious minority here and not there. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: grr about voting Posted by NinaLemon Posted by SweetTooth Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure? Saint Nicholas (who was never actually cannonized) is the patron saint of sailors and children. He was know for leaving coins in shoes that were left out for him. The Santa Claus thing, I believe, came from a children's story by a dutch author. I'd have to look it up to be sure, but this is what I'm pulling out of my fuzzy memory. the History Channel did a special on this. Saint Nicholas was from a well off family in Turkey. he was known for giving generous gifts to the poor. the Santa Claus idea is loosely based on his story. there are also elements of Paganism. there is no denying it has its roots in Christianity, but there is such a huge commercial aspect to Santa now that the religion aspect is almost forgotten (another topic for another time). |
Posted 11/4/08 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: grr about voting Posted by NinaLemon Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by NinaLemon What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other. It gets annoying when people automatically assume you celebrate a particular religion and then make comments when they find out you don't. I'm not saying everyone gets annoyed by it, but as someone who belongs to a religious minority, I certainly understand why people get offended. That's a really good point, I hadn't thought of the aspect of Judism being a religious minority here and not there. I was going to say this, about religious minorities. I can see how it can sometimes be difficult. especially for children. although as an adult, I am very partial to the Hebrew Hammer
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting It's true about assumptions and religious minorities. The "how sad" part is also really offensive--more so IMO because it was said to a child who has to learn to accept the fact that he does not get gifts from Santa like the other kids. It's like telling a little vegetarian kid that he or she is deprived and waitinng for the inevitable fallout. you didn't need any of it. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by NinaLemon Posted by MrsRbk Posted by NinaLemon Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by NinaLemon Posted by MrsS2005 Posted by shiv Posted by Porrruss I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about. ITA, how was she supposed to know? Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character! How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas. He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays: there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents. and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi. This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it' I understand that Santa is totally separate from the religious aspects of Christmas. However, when a person brings up Santa, there's no doubt that he or she is referring to Christmas. Santa is only associated with Christmas and the Christian religion. I certainly don't think Santa is a religious figure, but whether you agree with it or not, he's associated with a particular religious holiday. The thing is to me, when people mention Santa they are bringing up a secular holiday, not a religious one, same with the Easter Bunny; but again it doesn't bother me much. What I find very interesting is how we get very upset over these things; my BIL is Jewish, from Israel, and these comments do not phase him, he actaully laughs at Americans for being so closed-minded and for not being able to see from anyone's perspective but his/her own. It really makes me wonder what is it about our culture that lends us to being so intolerant of each other. Just as you stated earlier that you wouldn't expect someone rasied outside of Catholicism or Christianity to "get it." I feel the same way about people not raised in the Jewish faith to get why a comment like that would be annoying, upsetting, etc... espeically if you have a child that might question it. As far as your BIL being from Israel, that really has nothing to do with it. While Israel is perceived to be a "Jewish State" having been there and have family that were born, raised and still live there, I can tell you the majority of the country is NOT religious and somewhat more secular around the Jewish religion than many American Jews are. While I'm not very religious myself, I do find I'm more religious than most jewish people I know from Israel. I totally understand you being annoyed with the comment, and of course I couldn't understand the depth of why it would upset you, I was in no way saying that you shouldn't be annoyed. I was respondong to the Santa being equated to a religious holiday thing. I'm sure there are non religious people in Isreal, just as there are in America, however, my BIL is not one of them. He practices his faith, observes and fasts on Holy Days. One of things I really enjoy about him is that he puts together Sedar every year for my family so we can experience and share in his faith. I just find his perspective interesting, which was what I said in my previous post. As a Jew.. I do all of the above as well. Observing the faith has nothing to do with it. Even non-religious jews celebrate the faith. I guess though in Israel, most people wouldn't come across this type of tissue to begin with. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by Ophelia Posted by NinaLemon Posted by SweetTooth Isn't Santa based on Saint Nicholas, who was a real person, and is a religious figure? Saint Nicholas (who was never actually cannonized) is the patron saint of sailors and children. He was know for leaving coins in shoes that were left out for him. The Santa Claus thing, I believe, came from a children's story by a dutch author. I'd have to look it up to be sure, but this is what I'm pulling out of my fuzzy memory. the History Channel did a special on this. Saint Nicholas was from a well off family in Turkey. he was known for giving generous gifts to the poor. the Santa Claus idea is loosely based on his story. there are also elements of Paganism. there is no denying it has its roots in Christianity, but there is such a huge commercial aspect to Santa now that the religion aspect is almost forgotten (another topic for another time). I had to look it up because it was bugging me that I couldn't remember for sure - Catholic School was a long time ago. St. Nicholas' feast day is 12/6, his feast day is when children would go around begging for alms or gifts, the santa claus part: After the American Revolution, New Yorkers remembered with pride the colony's nearly-forgotten Dutch roots. John Pintard, influential patriot and antiquarian, who founded the New York Historical Society in 1804, promoted St. Nicholas as patron saint of both society and city. In January 1809, Washington Irving joined the society and on St. Nicholas Day that year he published the satirical fiction, Knickerbocker's History of New York, with numerous references to a jolly St. Nicholas character. This was not a saintly bishop, rather an elfin Dutch burgher with a clay pipe. These delightful flights of imagination are the origin of the New Amsterdam St. Nicholas legends: that the first Dutch emigrant ship had a figurehead of St. Nicholas; that St. Nicholas Day was observed in the colony; that the first church was dedicated to him; and that St. Nicholas comes down chimneys to bring gifts. Irving's work was regarded as the "first notable work of imagination in the New World." |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by Ophelia the Santa Claus idea is loosely based on his story. there are also elements of Paganism. there is no denying it has its roots in Christianity, but there is such a huge commercial aspect to Santa now that the religion aspect is almost forgotten (another topic for another time). Both very good points. But I do find that when I bring up the Pagan connection and the Constantine influence to my Christian friends they look at me with utter shock and horror. As for the commercialism, well that is where this really gets to me. So it may be that we are in a predominantly Christian culture where we live, but so many are non-practicing, but yet have no problem clammoring for Christmas and then looking down their noses at people who do not celebrate. (Sorry this is a very hot topic with me.) |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Posted by Porrruss I agree that Santa is most defintiely an intricate part of Christian religions- to say *he* is not is silly. That said, I think the woman in question wasn't attempting to impose her religious beliefs on the OP. Rather, she was just making conversation and put her foot in her mouth. I'm assuming the "how sad" comment was because of the "lack of gifts", not that it is sad to be Jewish as evidenced by her later comment about still receiving gifts for Chanukah. I completely agree with this. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 3:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting Thank you all for your perspectives.I had to run out and did not realize this would get so many replys/views. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 9:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: grr about voting I think you were the first person to bring up religion by telling her you were Jewish. Santa really isnt a religious figure. Most christians actually believe santa takes away from the true meaning of Christmas. time someone says " Santa will be good to you" I would just smile and walk away. |
|
Posted 11/4/08 10:32 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| grr... I just had the worst pedicure (long vent) | randella | 9/25/08 | 6 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| FYI for those voting tomorrow for 17th District State Assembly (Merrick, Bellmore, E. Meadow, Garden City, etc.) | Mommy2Boys | 11/3/08 | 11 | Home |
| Is this only in NC? Early voting? it started yesterday | Janice | 10/17/08 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Comprehensive "Who are you Voting for?" Poll (with more choices) | Kara | 9/4/08 | 71 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| On the eve of the Pennsylvania Primary - Obama, Hilary and McCain will try to reach an important voting population.... | QuoteTheRaven424 | 4/21/08 | 17 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| After all the voting, I still changed my mind! | ddunne2 | 12/11/05 | 11 | Parenting |











