Re: grr about voting
Posted 11/4/2008 2:49:14 PM by Kara


Posted by NinaLemon


Posted by MrsS2005


Posted by shiv


Posted by Porrruss

I think you are reading into this WAAAAAY too much. It just sounds like this woman is truly ignorant to anything outside the Christian religions. Sad/embarrassing for her- but nothing to get upset about.



ITA, how was she supposed to know?

Also, Santa has nothing to do with the Christian religion- he's a character!


How does Santa have nothing to do with the Christian religion? He's associated with Christmas, a Christian holiday. He isn't associated with any other religion. Santa may not be a religious figure, but he's certainly tied into Christmas.



He has nothing to do with the Christian Religion because there are really two Christmas Holidays:
there is the secular which is centered around Santa and presents.
and the sacred which is about the birth of Christ, the presents are secondary and reference the gifts of the Magi.

This may not seem like much of a distinction to some people, but to me they are VERY different and I would not expect people to raised outside of Catholicism or Christianity to 'get it'



I agree that there is a distinction, but for many the religious traditions and the secular traditions surrounding the holiday are intertwined. I know many people who are not religious and never were religious who celebrate a secular Christmas with presents and Santa, but most people who celebrate Christmas in a secular way have some ties to a Christian religion. For example, I have a lot of Jewish friends, but none celebrate Christmas unless they have other family members who do (e.g., DH or one parent).

So, while I agree that Santa himself is a purely secular figure, he IS tied to a holiday rooted in the Christian faiths. While the distinction between the secular holiday and the holy day is very important to many of us, we cannot deny that Santa isn't really a part of the lives of people who are not in some way affiliated with a Christian religion. Are there exceptions? Of course.

If the comment were made to me, I wouldn't see bringing up Santa as having religious undertones... but I celebrate Christmas. I can see how someone who does not celebrate Christmas would associate Santa with a the Christian faiths on some level.
Print Post      Close Window