Do you know about DHA recommendations for infant formula?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes - chose a specific brand 12 13.19%
Yes - but didn't know about different levels in formula 16 17.58%
No 31 34.07%
Don't really care 32 35.16%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Goobster

What I would like to know is when did it become standard to add DHA to infant formulas? What year?



2002

Posted 1/18/10 1:45 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by eddiesmommy

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.



YOu are unfortunatly incorrect. Mead Johnson did not make this recommendation. If you read my OP you will see that the recommendation was made by: The American dietitic Assoc. May 2008 article - They are the experts in nutrition and make all nutrition recommendations. European Union, National Institute of Health, and World Health Organization.

Although you may consider DHA synthetic, the health care community does not. That would be like considering vitamins synthetic. Formula is synthetic....so I don't get your point on that one. Everything about formula is technically synthetic...so what should moms do if they can't breastfeed??

Furthermore, Did you take DHA with your prenate? I am sure a large proportion of moms do. 200-300mg of DHA is a standard of care for most OB/GYN practices and most don't even know why they are taking it, they just do. The reason is that during thrid trimested DHA stores are preferentially transfered via placenta to baby - going directly to brain development. Brain development continues until age 2..so why is it crucial that we take it during pregnancy but drop the ball during infancy?

You are entitled to your own opinion, I respect what you are saying, but would aprreciate if you would respect mine. I have an RD and bach/masters in nutrition. I am not just some crazy mom making up stuff.

The best thing to remember is that nutrition is a young field. It is always changing and learning more about what helps people stay/keep healthy. I am positive that formula will continue to change often as science gets closer to making a formula more and more like breast milk.

And as an FYI - Do you know that it took the FDA over 25 years to make a stand on fortifing formula with iron?! A formula without iron today would be crazy!

Posted 1/18/10 2:04 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Posted by eddiesmommy

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.



YOu are unfortunatly incorrect. Mead Johnson did not make this recommendation. If you read my OP you will see that the recommendation was made by: The American dietitic Assoc. May 2008 article - They are the experts in nutrition and make all nutrition recommendations. European Union, National Institute of Health, and World Health Organization.

Although you may consider DHA synthetic, the health care community does not. That would be like considering vitamins synthetic. Formula is synthetic....so I don't get your point on that one. Everything about formula is technically synthetic...so what should moms do if they can't breastfeed??

Furthermore, Did you take DHA with your prenate? I am sure a large proportion of moms do. 200-300mg of DHA is a standard of care for most OB/GYN practices and most don't even know why they are taking it, they just do. The reason is that during thrid trimested DHA stores are preferentially transfered via placenta to baby - going directly to brain development. Brain development continues until age 2..so why is it crucial that we take it during pregnancy but drop the ball during infancy?

You are entitled to your own opinion, I respect what you are saying, but would aprreciate if you would respect mine. I have an RD and bach/masters in nutrition. I am not just some crazy mom making up stuff.

The best thing to remember is that nutrition is a young field. It is always changing and learning more about what helps people stay/keep healthy. I am positive that formula will continue to change often as science gets closer to making a formula more and more like breast milk.

And as an FYI - Do you know that it took the FDA over 25 years to make a stand on fortifing formula with iron?! A formula without iron today would be crazy!



The thing is it does seem you are making up stuff. I just did a search of your name and "similac" and found numerous posts bashing that brand, one saying that Isomil is loaded with table sugar, that it is the second ingredient (well not according to the label I am reading right now!) and another stating that most similac brands contain table sugar (implying that enfamil does not) but I just searched online and it appears that many enfamil formulas DO have table sugar.

Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 2:12 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by computergirl

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?



I was just going to post the same exact thing. Something about these posts does not sit right with me.

My BIL is a chemist and he has designed baby formula for close to 30 years. He has worked as a VP at many of the big companies. He has told me that because of FDA regulations that many of the formulas are fairly similar in makeup and actually favors Similac over Enfamil for babies who can easily digest it. He feels that it is more similar to breastmilk. However, DD had a sensitivity to it and we switched to Enfamil Gentleease which he felt was just as good.

DHA is a fairly new addition to formula, I was raised on formula with NO DHA in it and think I turned out pretty OK.

Message edited 2010-01-18 14:18:38.967000.

Posted 1/18/10 2:18 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

That is because I never recommend any similac products for the DHA reason, and their sugar content. Enfamil products do contain corn syrup solids, which is also a sugar, but a better choice that sucrose.

I only recommend Enfamil and Good Start..never Similac.

I also beleive that enfamil products are closer to breastmilk in composition than any other formula. - that is my opinion.

I would NOT make any of this information up. Everything I post is 100% legit and truthful.

THis is going to be my offical last post on the subject. I was only asking to gather some information and apparently the post got off track.

I do not get any benefits for supporting Enfamil and Good Start...




Message edited 2010-01-18 14:22:33.890000.

Posted 1/18/10 2:18 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I also beleive that enfamil products are closer to breastmilk in composition than any other formula. - that is my opinion.




I know you said you are done posting on this topic but I think it is only appropriate that you explain your clinical reasoning behind this. We all have opinions but I would never post my opinion and claim to be an expert on the subject without having concrete facts to back it up.

Posted 1/18/10 2:26 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by computergirl

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?



this is exactly why i take everything that people post with a grain of salt. anyone can come on here and say they are a pediatric dietician/OBGYN/etc and people right away start listening to them. i'm not saying that the OP is lying, not at all. but none of us truly KNOW if what people are posting is accurate.

i thought about it--i heard about this DHA thing from the OP. nowhere else. yes, it may be true that the DHA level is lower, but if my ped feels like the formula is beneficial, that is good enough for me. they've never mentioned any concern about the DHA levels, so i'm not worrying about it at all.

people on here have posted some wacky stuff over time. and it's amazing to me how people just listen to it and run with it. i like to be informed, but not from a message board.

Posted 1/18/10 2:30 PM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by computergirl

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?



this is exactly why i take everything that people post with a grain of salt. anyone can come on here and say they are a pediatric dietician/OBGYN/etc and people right away start listening to them. i'm not saying that the OP is lying, not at all. but none of us truly KNOW if what people are posting is accurate.

i thought about it--i heard about this DHA thing from the OP. nowhere else. yes, it may be true that the DHA level is lower, but if my ped feels like the formula is beneficial, that is good enough for me. they've never mentioned any concern about the DHA levels, so i'm not worrying about it at all.

people on here have posted some wacky stuff over time. and it's amazing to me how people just listen to it and run with it. i like to be informed, but not from a message board.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ITA!

BTW... DH and I were FF and I KNOW there is no way that back then the formula was regulated or anything. I'm fine and so is DH.

Posted 1/18/10 2:33 PM
 

josie919
Here we go!

Member since 2/08

1108 total posts

Name:
Josie

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

According to what source is the DHA recommendation .2%? Is this recommendation nationwide or state specific? Before I go all crazy on someone, i'd like to have some info on hand Chat Icon Thanks for posting. My DD has been off formula for almost 6 months now, but still important for future babies.

Message edited 2010-01-18 14:43:30.810000.

Posted 1/18/10 2:39 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Why I feel Enfamil is the closest to BM:

Breastmilk is a ratio of whey to caesin - whey predominent around 60 to 40 for the first 6mths. (mature breastmilk is 80/20 - similar to cow's milk)

Enfamil is 60/40 - whey/caesin
Similac is 48/52 - whey/caesin
Good Start is 100% whey

Whey is the more easily digestible part of milk protein where as caesin is the hard curd (hense curds and whey)

All of the above formulas contain prebiotics which are found in breastmilk. However the prebiotics found in formula are galacto-oligosacharrides not oligosaccharrides b/c they are man made. Good Start also contains a probiotic routine formula but probiotics are not found in breastmilk (some are found around mom's nipple in small amts) but are beneficial for babies with allergy.

DHA reommendation is ,2% and above - again Enfamil and Good Start contain this dosage

All 3 use lactose as their form of carbohydrate which is similar to breastmilk.

For these reasons I recommend Enfamil, then Good Start (only b/c Good Start is 100% whey, but I do like their product)

Posted 1/18/10 2:39 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by computergirl

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?




I honeslty thought it was just me who thought that!
I go by MY mommy instincts and discuss everything with my pediatrician as to what is good for MY child!
Every child is different! DS was on Similac, spit up a lot, therefore ended up on Enfamil! My DD was in NICU for over a month. She was on breastmilk (that I ran from East Northport to NSUH Manhasset everyday) and was supplementing with Similac! She had NO problems and is doing GREAT with Similac!
My point is, please stop scaring the mommies out there and let us choose whats best for US! Our Children!

Posted 1/18/10 2:43 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by josie919

According to what source is the DHA recommendation .2%? That really irritates me as well because the hospital where we live in KS only offered Similac, unless medically there was a reason for a change. Is this recommendation nationwaide or state specific? Before I go all crazy on someone, i'd like to have some info on hand Chat Icon Thanks for posting. My DD has been off formula for almost 6 months now, but still important for future babies.



American Dietitic Association - May 2008 Journal
National Institue of Health
World Health Organization
European Union

It is a recommendation, similar to other nutition recommendations..not made a regulation.

Posted 1/18/10 2:43 PM
 

josie919
Here we go!

Member since 2/08

1108 total posts

Name:
Josie

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Posted by josie919

According to what source is the DHA recommendation .2%? That really irritates me as well because the hospital where we live in KS only offered Similac, unless medically there was a reason for a change. Is this recommendation nationwaide or state specific? Before I go all crazy on someone, i'd like to have some info on hand Chat Icon Thanks for posting. My DD has been off formula for almost 6 months now, but still important for future babies.



American Dietitic Association - May 2008 Journal
National Institue of Health
World Health Organization
European Union

It is a recommendation, similar to other nutition recommendations..not made a regulation.




Thank you.

Posted 1/18/10 2:44 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Posted by eddiesmommy

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.



YOu are unfortunatly incorrect. Mead Johnson did not make this recommendation. If you read my OP you will see that the recommendation was made by: The American dietitic Assoc. May 2008 article - They are the experts in nutrition and make all nutrition recommendations. European Union, National Institute of Health, and World Health Organization.

Although you may consider DHA synthetic, the health care community does not. That would be like considering vitamins synthetic. Formula is synthetic....so I don't get your point on that one. Everything about formula is technically synthetic...so what should moms do if they can't breastfeed??

Furthermore, Did you take DHA with your prenate? I am sure a large proportion of moms do. 200-300mg of DHA is a standard of care for most OB/GYN practices and most don't even know why they are taking it, they just do. The reason is that during thrid trimested DHA stores are preferentially transfered via placenta to baby - going directly to brain development. Brain development continues until age 2..so why is it crucial that we take it during pregnancy but drop the ball during infancy?

You are entitled to your own opinion, I respect what you are saying, but would aprreciate if you would respect mine. I have an RD and bach/masters in nutrition. I am not just some crazy mom making up stuff.

The best thing to remember is that nutrition is a young field. It is always changing and learning more about what helps people stay/keep healthy. I am positive that formula will continue to change often as science gets closer to making a formula more and more like breast milk.

And as an FYI - Do you know that it took the FDA over 25 years to make a stand on fortifing formula with iron?! A formula without iron today would be crazy!



I responded to you calling the "proper level" of DHA .3%, that recommendation was made by Mead Johnson, if the WHO rec is .2%, than Similac is only off by .05% and STILL not required to label it, bc it is NOT regulated by the FDA, nor has the AAP made any recommendations as to DHA.

Posted 1/18/10 2:53 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

thank you for posting this. This makes me so angry, bc DD thankfully never had any gas issues etc..and we just kept her on similac bc thats what the hospital had and what our ped gave us samples of...now I'm Chat Icon as to why our ped woudln't say anything...

Posted 1/18/10 2:57 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Nope...I said the recommendation is .2% and that Good Start and Enfamil contain .3% Never did I say the recommendation was .3%.

Similac is off by .5%....if the recommendation was .15 then I would not bat my eye but the recommendation is clearly .2%. You know whats not off by .5%...Similac's Kirkland brand- which has .3% (just like enfamil and goodstart)

If Mead Johnson is making a recommendation of .3% then that is there issue...I go with the ADA and other experts at .2%.

Posted 1/18/10 2:57 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.

Posted 1/18/10 2:59 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Posted by eddiesmommy

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.



YOu are unfortunatly incorrect. Mead Johnson did not make this recommendation. If you read my OP you will see that the recommendation was made by: The American dietitic Assoc. May 2008 article - They are the experts in nutrition and make all nutrition recommendations. European Union, National Institute of Health, and World Health Organization.

Although you may consider DHA synthetic, the health care community does not. That would be like considering vitamins synthetic. Formula is synthetic....so I don't get your point on that one. Everything about formula is technically synthetic...so what should moms do if they can't breastfeed??

Furthermore, Did you take DHA with your prenate? I am sure a large proportion of moms do. 200-300mg of DHA is a standard of care for most OB/GYN practices and most don't even know why they are taking it, they just do. The reason is that during thrid trimested DHA stores are preferentially transfered via placenta to baby - going directly to brain development. Brain development continues until age 2..so why is it crucial that we take it during pregnancy but drop the ball during infancy?

You are entitled to your own opinion, I respect what you are saying, but would aprreciate if you would respect mine. I have an RD and bach/masters in nutrition. I am not just some crazy mom making up stuff.

The best thing to remember is that nutrition is a young field. It is always changing and learning more about what helps people stay/keep healthy. I am positive that formula will continue to change often as science gets closer to making a formula more and more like breast milk.

And as an FYI - Do you know that it took the FDA over 25 years to make a stand on fortifing formula with iron?! A formula without iron today would be crazy!



In addition, I DID NOT breastfeed and gave DS enfamil lipil. Im very well aware that formula is synthetic as are nutritional supplements UNLESS they contain just the pure ingredient. I did not say there was anything wrong with DHA being synthetic, I simply said, that it IS synthetic in response to you stating that it was not. I didnt make a statement one way or another regarding its use in formula.

Id really wish youd address the points I made, AS I made them.

Posted 1/18/10 3:09 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Nope...I said the recommendation is .2% and that Good Start and Enfamil contain .3% Never did I say the recommendation was .3%.

Similac is off by .5%....if the recommendation was .15 then I would not bat my eye but the recommendation is clearly .2%. You know whats not off by .5%...Similac's Kirkland brand- which has .3% (just like enfamil and goodstart)

If Mead Johnson is making a recommendation of .3% then that is there issue...I go with the ADA and other experts at .2%.



and I quote

"enfamil & Good Start both contain the proper levels of .3%"

Posted 1/18/10 3:11 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride

I don't know....I kind of feel like this information is being put out there to scare mothers. And I am not a fan of scare tactics.

I used Similac with Lily and I'll use it with any other children I have.



ita - ds is on similac and he is thriving.

is todays generation not as smart as our future generation bc of lack of dha in forumla back in the day???

Posted 1/18/10 3:12 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.



that is an irresponsible general sweeping statement of pediatricians......I will ALWAYS trust the person with the MEDICAL degree over someone with a masters.

Posted 1/18/10 3:12 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.



Chat Icon Chat Icon i dont know what pediatrician u work with or u send ur kids to... Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:20 PM
 

alexlynn7
Big brother to be!

Member since 9/06

6314 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by WNA01


is todays generation not as smart as our future generation bc of lack of dha in forumla back in the day???



exactly...

maybe if my husband had been fed with formula containing DHA, he wouldn't have missed the one question on the SAT that separated him from a perfect score.

Chat Icon

Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:20 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I think this is a good lesson for everyone...be careful of what you read on the internet, and don't use LIF as your only resource. Ask your doctor, read with an open mind, and do your own research!

Posted 1/18/10 3:22 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.

Posted 1/18/10 3:23 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Mom's who tried BFing and now use formula brownie 7/28/09 6 Parenting
HELP! New mom needs help with formula Squirl1003 6/11/09 4 Parenting
Mom's who BF and also supplement with formula.... MelToddJulia 8/25/08 25 Parenting
EDITED Q-Way tmi q for mom's of 7-9 mo olds - formula fed diaper q itsbabytime 5/2/08 6 Parenting
Mom's using Canned Formula - watch CBS2 news at 5 adeline27 12/5/07 8 Parenting
mom's with children on soy formula alex7-2 2/9/07 6 Parenting