Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?
Posted 1/18/2010 2:12:32 PM by NinaLemon


Posted by hdrd0411


Posted by eddiesmommy

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.



YOu are unfortunatly incorrect. Mead Johnson did not make this recommendation. If you read my OP you will see that the recommendation was made by: The American dietitic Assoc. May 2008 article - They are the experts in nutrition and make all nutrition recommendations. European Union, National Institute of Health, and World Health Organization.

Although you may consider DHA synthetic, the health care community does not. That would be like considering vitamins synthetic. Formula is synthetic....so I don't get your point on that one. Everything about formula is technically synthetic...so what should moms do if they can't breastfeed??

Furthermore, Did you take DHA with your prenate? I am sure a large proportion of moms do. 200-300mg of DHA is a standard of care for most OB/GYN practices and most don't even know why they are taking it, they just do. The reason is that during thrid trimested DHA stores are preferentially transfered via placenta to baby - going directly to brain development. Brain development continues until age 2..so why is it crucial that we take it during pregnancy but drop the ball during infancy?

You are entitled to your own opinion, I respect what you are saying, but would aprreciate if you would respect mine. I have an RD and bach/masters in nutrition. I am not just some crazy mom making up stuff.

The best thing to remember is that nutrition is a young field. It is always changing and learning more about what helps people stay/keep healthy. I am positive that formula will continue to change often as science gets closer to making a formula more and more like breast milk.

And as an FYI - Do you know that it took the FDA over 25 years to make a stand on fortifing formula with iron?! A formula without iron today would be crazy!



The thing is it does seem you are making up stuff. I just did a search of your name and "similac" and found numerous posts bashing that brand, one saying that Isomil is loaded with table sugar, that it is the second ingredient (well not according to the label I am reading right now!) and another stating that most similac brands contain table sugar (implying that enfamil does not) but I just searched online and it appears that many enfamil formulas DO have table sugar.

Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window