Do you know about DHA recommendations for infant formula?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes - chose a specific brand 12 13.19%
Yes - but didn't know about different levels in formula 16 17.58%
No 31 34.07%
Don't really care 32 35.16%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Sassyz75

eh- I don't freak out about all this stuff.. it was more important to me that the Enfamil formula cans had BPA in the lining and the similac did not.



i knew the info and am not bothered by it at all



Whoa - I did not know that!!!!!
I just switched to enfamil cans and am now upset about that! There always will be something to drive us insane, won't there?

Posted 1/18/10 11:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I had no idea and I do feel that it's important for moms to know as much as possible about what they are feeding their baby.

I am happy that DS does eat Good Start, although I too delivered at NSUH and they gave us Similac too. DS wasn't on it for long (maybe about a week or 2) until we switched due to gas issues.

Posted 1/18/10 11:45 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by spa118

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Sassyz75

eh- I don't freak out about all this stuff.. it was more important to me that the Enfamil formula cans had BPA in the lining and the similac did not.



i knew the info and am not bothered by it at all



Whoa - I did not know that!!!!!
I just switched to enfamil cans and am now upset about that! There always will be something to drive us insane, won't there?



actually, it was all the brands. Similac, Enfamil, Nestle....

Link

Message edited 2010-01-18 11:51:40.120000.

Posted 1/18/10 11:51 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I was just going to post a similar study

http://www.ewg.org/node/25636

Its in ALL formula brand, there has been NO leaching found by the enviornmental working group from the cans into powdered formula, there was leaching detected in all liquid brands, including similac whose top and bottom of containers contain BPA.

ewg.org/babysafe

from the EWG report

You can also check out http://safemama.com/?s=bpa+formula

Image Attachment(s):

Message edited 2010-01-18 11:58:08.360000.

Posted 1/18/10 11:52 AM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Just was looking around about this with the BPA:

BPA FAQs re: Good Start and Gerber Products

This info about BPA from all the manufacturers seemed to all be from 2008. Not sure if there have been some changes made since then.

Posted 1/18/10 12:02 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by eddiesmommy

I was just going to post a similar study

http://www.ewg.org/node/25636

Its in ALL formula brand, there has been NO leaching found by the enviornmental working group from the cans into powdered formula, there was leaching detected in all liquid brands, including similac whose top and bottom of containers contain BPA.

ewg.org/babysafe

from the EWG report

You can also check out http://safemama.com/?s=bpa+formula




Yeah I read the same info (from the same page). Still from a year and a half ago. It may be possible that the companies have made changes since then. I would call the manufacturer and just ask.

Posted 1/18/10 12:03 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Just an FYI about BPA

There is more BPA in moms breastmilk than formula...b/c of what mom's eat in there diet. Similac does contain BPA in their nursette's, but its just on the top metal part of the ring. Honestly...just another thing to drive us crazy! The amt that one has to ingest is billions, way more than what can effect us.

The DHA in formula is not "synthetic". It is made derived from algea. To my knowledge there have been no published evedience that it is harmful, and it has been in european formulas for over 20 years. It has been in the US for about 10 and studies have shown no long term issues or concerns. But I can understand why some may not like the idea. I guess we have to pick and choose what is important to us. I just feel that the common denominator in the formula world is the similac brand. Why are they the only ones to not put proper dosage in their products - but put the proper amt in their store brand??

I appreciate all the responses and can definatly use this information in my Mother/Baby classes! Thanks so much!

Posted 1/18/10 12:13 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by LittleBlueBug

Just was looking around about this with the BPA:

BPA FAQs re: Good Start and Gerber Products

This info about BPA from all the manufacturers seemed to all be from 2008. Not sure if there have been some changes made since then.



as far as I know the BPA is worst in canned RTF formulas- Similac is a soft plastic.

Also- Similac powder is now also in a soft plastic container, not metal lined top & bottom parts like enfamil is (and theirs used to be).

Posted 1/18/10 12:18 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

as for the BPA

here is the FDAs 2010 supdated study

http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/PublicHealthFocus/ucm197739.htm

They have found that NO BPA leaches into powdered formula regardless of the brand. RTF formula seems to be the worst offender but even then they state, they do not feel the potentially harmful effects of the BPA outweighs the benefits of the formula, so they are NOT recommended any changes to the formula habits of parents right now. But that if you are concerned, to avoid the Liquid, but ALL powdered is safe and showed no traces of BPA.

Posted 1/18/10 12:21 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I actually knew that about similac...so if DD has to be on formula we will def be using Enfamil again (used it with my DS)

Message edited 2010-01-18 12:24:15.337000.

Posted 1/18/10 12:24 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Just an FYI about BPA

There is more BPA in moms breastmilk than formula...b/c of what mom's eat in there diet. Similac does contain BPA in their nursette's, but its just on the top metal part of the ring. Honestly...just another thing to drive us crazy! The amt that one has to ingest is billions, way more than what can effect us.

The DHA in formula is not "synthetic". It is made derived from algea. To my knowledge there have been no published evedience that it is harmful, and it has been in european formulas for over 20 years. It has been in the US for about 10 and studies have shown no long term issues or concerns. But I can understand why some may not like the idea. I guess we have to pick and choose what is important to us. I just feel that the common denominator in the formula world is the similac brand. Why are they the only ones to not put proper dosage in their products - but put the proper amt in their store brand??

I appreciate all the responses and can definatly use this information in my Mother/Baby classes! Thanks so much!



They arent required to label it as such, so it is always up to the consumer and mother to do their research first. Again, their level or still in the normal range of DHA provided by breastmilk, depending on the mothers diet. I dont think its a major controversy.

Posted 1/18/10 12:26 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

When DS was on formula I don't think they even added the DHA so I am not concerned. She did very well on Similac Advance and if my hospital and ped think it is right for her, then that is what I will give her.

Posted 1/18/10 12:27 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I don't know....I kind of feel like this information is being put out there to scare mothers. And I am not a fan of scare tactics.

I used Similac with Lily and I'll use it with any other children I have.

Posted 1/18/10 12:36 PM
 

mommy2B3
2 boys 2 girls!!!!

Member since 7/08

3324 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

To be quite honest, No I didn't know about these types of things. The reason I used Similac was because my DS spit up way to much on Enfamil.

I also don't really believe in such things anyways, as I see my son around other babies his age, and all of them are different ((either breastfed, or on different formula)) and I don't see a difference between any type of milestones. My son actually started milestones ahead of most other kids his age, so I don't believe this cr*p about DHA doing anything for brain development.

Posted 1/18/10 12:37 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Just an FYI about BPA

There is more BPA in moms breastmilk than formula...b/c of what mom's eat in there diet. Similac does contain BPA in their nursette's, but its just on the top metal part of the ring. Honestly...just another thing to drive us crazy! The amt that one has to ingest is billions, way more than what can effect us.

The DHA in formula is not "synthetic". It is made derived from algea. To my knowledge there have been no published evedience that it is harmful, and it has been in european formulas for over 20 years. It has been in the US for about 10 and studies have shown no long term issues or concerns. But I can understand why some may not like the idea. I guess we have to pick and choose what is important to us. I just feel that the common denominator in the formula world is the similac brand. Why are they the only ones to not put proper dosage in their products - but put the proper amt in their store brand??

I appreciate all the responses and can definatly use this information in my Mother/Baby clas

Ases! Thanks so much!



According to the FDA it is "synthetic" just bacause it is derived from algae does not make it "natural", the creators who hold the patent to make DHA in a lab, Merck, then chemically alter the make up of the algae to create the DHA.

Quote from a study posted on Kelly Mom

"The DHA is extracted from fermented microalgae and the ARA is extracted from soil fungus. The breast does not use either of these items to manufacture its fatty acids, and these sources are new to the food chain. Each of the processed oils has its own fatty acid composition, adding a number of fatty acids to formula that already are contained in the plant oils mixed into the base formula. Human fatty acids are structurally different from manufactured ones from plant sources. Human fatty acids interact with each other in a special matrix. Just because they perform as they do in human milk does not mean they will perform at all in an artificial construct. J Lipid Research 2002; published on line ahead of print November 4, 2002).

Please see this article with sources and studies sited



http://stanford.wellsphere.com/pregnancy-fertility-article/have-they-created-a-formula-close-to-breastmilk/839913

the definition of synthetic is:
1 a : the composition or combination of parts or elements so as to form a whole b : the production of a substance by the union of chemical elements, groups, or simpler compounds or by the degradation of a complex compound c : the combining of often diverse conceptions into a coherent whole; also : the complex so formed

The algae IS combined with another element called hexane to derive the DHA from the algae or soil fungi. They dont just put the pure algae or an unaltered derivative of it, right into the formula, it is chemically compounded with hexane.

Furhtermore as of October of 2009, the FDA does not make any recommendations on DHA in formulas and have made no determination of its safety.

Message edited 2010-01-18 12:54:30.333000.

Posted 1/18/10 12:39 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by hdrd0411

Just an FYI about BPA

There is more BPA in moms breastmilk than formula...b/c of what mom's eat in there diet. Similac does contain BPA in their nursette's, but its just on the top metal part of the ring. Honestly...just another thing to drive us crazy! The amt that one has to ingest is billions, way more than what can effect us.

The DHA in formula is not "synthetic". It is made derived from algea. To my knowledge there have been no published evedience that it is harmful, and it has been in european formulas for over 20 years. It has been in the US for about 10 and studies have shown no long term issues or concerns. But I can understand why some may not like the idea. I guess we have to pick and choose what is important to us. I just feel that the common denominator in the formula world is the similac brand. Why are they the only ones to not put proper dosage in their products - but put the proper amt in their store brand??

I appreciate all the responses and can definatly use this information in my Mother/Baby clas

Ases! Thanks so much!



According to the FDA it is "synthetic" just bacause it is derived from algae does not make it "natural", the creators who hold the patent to make DHA in a lab, Merck, then chemically alter the make up of the algae to create the DHA.

Please see this article with sources and studies sited



http://stanford.wellsphere.com/pregnancy-fertility-article/have-they-created-a-formula-close-to-breastmilk/839913

the definition of synthetic is:
1 a : the composition or combination of parts or elements so as to form a whole b : the production of a substance by the union of chemical elements, groups, or simpler compounds or by the degradation of a complex compound c : the combining of often diverse conceptions into a coherent whole; also : the complex so formed

The algae IS combined with another element called hexane to derive the DHA from the algae or soil fungi. They dont just put the pure algae or an unaltered derivative of it, right into the formula, it is chemically compounded with hexane.

Furhtermore as of October of 2009, the FDA does not make any recommendations on DHA in formulas and have made no determination of its safety.



Additionally, right from the FDA site

"What is the evidence that addition of DHA and ARA to infant formulas is beneficial?

"The scientific evidence is mixed. Some studies in infants suggest that including these fatty acids in infant formulas may have positive effects on visual function and neural development over the short term. Other studies in infants do not confirm these benefits. There are no currently available published reports from clinical studies that address whether any long-term beneficial effects exist."

So there is no need to make mothers on this board who use Similac to panic or feel that they are not doing what is best for their child as there are NO proven benefits yet to DHA in formula.

Posted 1/18/10 12:49 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

it should also be made known that the recommendation that formula should contain .3% DHA to be made beneficial, was recommended by Mead Johnson, the makers of enfamil, the FDA has not made ANY conclusions as the benefits/levels/safety or DHA in formula.

In the future, hrdr, please provide mothers WITH all information before telling them that DHA in formula IS NOT synthetic and that if they are giving their child Similac that they are not providing them with the recommended amount of DHA.

Message edited 2010-01-18 13:05:31.210000.

Posted 1/18/10 1:03 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by mrspalomino148

To be quite honest, No I didn't know about these types of things. The reason I used Similac was because my DS spit up way to much on Enfamil.

I also don't really believe in such things anyways, as I see my son around other babies his age, and all of them are different ((either breastfed, or on different formula)) and I don't see a difference between any type of milestones. My son actually started milestones ahead of most other kids his age, so I don't believe this cr*p about DHA doing anything for brain development.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I agree 100%. I used Similac for DD (I was BF'ing and supplementing) because thats what the hospital gave us. DS I EBF and with #3, should I need to supplement, I will probably use Similac again.

Posted 1/18/10 1:13 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?

Posted 1/18/10 1:17 PM
 

alexlynn7
Big brother to be!

Member since 9/06

6314 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

yes, i think it's weird that similac isn't doing what the other brands are doing.

but that's as far as it goes for me.

the most important predictor of innate intelligence is who your parents are... GENETICS.

intellectual achievement is also strongly predicted by the learning opportunities you're exposed to as a baby and child.

i can't imagine that having more or less DHA in your formula is going to make too much of a difference in who you become in life.

i think that, to a large extent, the whole DHA thing is ad advertising gimmick put forth by the formula companies... jmo.

Posted 1/18/10 1:19 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride

I don't know....I kind of feel like this information is being put out there to scare mothers. And I am not a fan of scare tactics.

I used Similac with Lily and I'll use it with any other children I have.



I only used Similac at the beginning with DS, but ITA with this.

I don't think it is fair to put such scare tactics out there, like many have said, it is "always something" and as mothers we need to trust our guts and our pediatricians.

Furthermore, I was formula fed, and the formula most defintely did not have DHA in it and I am A OKChat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 1:20 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by computergirl

To the OP-- you post a lot of anti-Similac propaganda. (I don't post regularly, I just remember this because there was a whole post about Similac Sensitive being lactose-free compared to Gentlease... and how bad that was... it struck a chord with me because I used Similac Sensitive with my kids) Are you getting kickbacks from Enfamil or something?



Oooooh, good point...

Posted 1/18/10 1:32 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride

I don't know....I kind of feel like this information is being put out there to scare mothers. And I am not a fan of scare tactics.

I used Similac with Lily and I'll use it with any other children I have.



I agree. I breastfed my DD and supplemented with Similac. My pediatrician, who I feel is up on research, etc, said that there was virtually no difference. And my DD hit all her milestones early and is already smarter than DH and I. Chat Icon So I don't think she suffered.

Posted 1/18/10 1:38 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

this may have been the most ill-informed, irresponsible OP EVER - especially since its comes from a "pediatric dietician" and concerns our childrens health.

Posted 1/18/10 1:42 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride

I don't know....I kind of feel like this information is being put out there to scare mothers. And I am not a fan of scare tactics.

I used Similac with Lily and I'll use it with any other children I have.



exactly!

Posted 1/18/10 1:45 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Mom's who tried BFing and now use formula brownie 7/28/09 6 Parenting
HELP! New mom needs help with formula Squirl1003 6/11/09 4 Parenting
Mom's who BF and also supplement with formula.... MelToddJulia 8/25/08 25 Parenting
EDITED Q-Way tmi q for mom's of 7-9 mo olds - formula fed diaper q itsbabytime 5/2/08 6 Parenting
Mom's using Canned Formula - watch CBS2 news at 5 adeline27 12/5/07 8 Parenting
mom's with children on soy formula alex7-2 2/9/07 6 Parenting