Do you know about DHA recommendations for infant formula?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes - chose a specific brand 12 13.19%
Yes - but didn't know about different levels in formula 16 17.58%
No 31 34.07%
Don't really care 32 35.16%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I don't know if this is out of line, but I think all moms should know this information about formula.

I am a ped. dietitian and spend most of my day educating moms on formula issues. I also participate in a breastfeeding/formula feeding info session and I was just floored today by what took place.

I guess I am looking more for information that would be helpful for my formula feeding moms to give them in class.

So...apparently most moms do not know that there is a recommendation for DHA levels in infant formula? Most moms take DHA supplements while pregnant/nursing b/c of its crucial role in brain development. Once a baby goes to formula the DHA recommendation is .2% of DHA from fatty acids, to continue to aid in brain development. Enfamil & Good Start both contain the proper levels of .3% Similac products are the only ones on the market that do not meet this recommendation and provide only half the amt. that you get from the other formulas, but you pay the same amt for the formula? (SImilac contains only .15%)

I am just curious if mom's know about this. Do you think this is an important issue to provide moms?? Just looking for some help..

Posted 1/17/10 11:09 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

annienyc
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

1347 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

We have a newborn dd and I am truly SHOCKED by this news about Similac vs Enfamil. I delivered at North Shore LIJ and while at the hospital we were given Similac formula and our ped has supported the use of Similac and insists there is no difference between Similac, Enfamil & Good Start. I truly LOVE our ped and have never had a disagreement with them about the care of our children but this is very upsetting to us...

We will stop using the Similac immediately - I am shocked by this news and will definitely call Similac to express our dissatisfaction with their DHA levels.

Posted 1/17/10 11:25 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

i didn't know this until i read some of your posts & yes, i do feel it's important.

Posted 1/17/10 11:28 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

i didnt know this, but i breastfeed with no supplemetning, so i know nothing about formula. if i wa using formul, yes, i would care

Posted 1/17/10 11:33 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I did not know this. I trusted Similac and the fact that the ped and hospital rec it to us.

I am upset I used it without discussing it with my ped, I did not know> Thank you for sharing,

Why would Similac do this? Why would hospitals start babies on it?

Posted 1/17/10 11:35 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

What I would like to know is when did it become standard to add DHA to infant formulas? What year?

Posted 1/17/10 11:36 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I guess I am glad to see that most Mom's don't know about the DHA levels in formula. I guess we need more education done!

I am not sure why Similac does this, but I have spoken to the company and their representative and their response is that they formula contains nucleotides which make up for it. (which clinical studies have shown that DHA is dose dependant, and without the proper dose, there is no benefit). I honestly think the reason they do not have these levels is because #1. Mom's don't know that they have sub- optimal levles 2. We still buy the product b/c we don't have this information. Not to mention that they manufacture the Kirkland brand and put the proper DHA levels in.

I think it all comes down to money. Why should Similac pay the additional money to put the additional DHA in if people still buy their product. All the DHA in formula and prenate's come from the same company called Life's DHA, so I guess Enfamil and Good Start pay more for double the amt.

The recommendation has been around for about 5 years (from the WHO, NIH, EU) but I believe in 2008 it was recommended by the ADA - American Dietetic Assoc. who recommended that any baby not getting human milk should be supplemented on a formula containing at least .2% of DHA and above for adequate brain development (I believe this was in their May 2008 journal).



Posted 1/17/10 11:58 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Oh..why do hospitals provide it...b/c the choice is made from a management standpoint, not clinical. We used to only provide Similac (lets just say they have deep pockets), now we let Dr./Mom's choose. But the choice was made from upper level, not us peon's!

Posted 1/18/10 12:00 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

The chemical structure of extracted DHA/ARA isn’t the same as human DHA/ARA. And even baby formulas with DHA and ARA aren’t a perfect match for breast milk because breast milk contains hundreds of components that can’t be replicated. Also, infants can make these fatty acids from other fatty acids in their diet, including those in unfortified infant formula. Although the FDA approved the addition of DHA and ARA to infant formulas, they caution that the scientific evidence is mixed. Some studies in infants suggest that including these fatty acids in infant formulas may have positive effects on visual function and neural development over the short term. Other studies in infants do not confirm these benefits. There are no currently published reports from clinical studies that address whether any long-term beneficial effects exist.
Also not to include on similac's website it says that DHA/ARA is in MOST & the Similac Advanced is on the list (most commonly used). It's not in the gentle ones because it can cause stomach problems for some children.

Message edited 2010-01-18 00:17:58.633000.

Posted 1/18/10 12:06 AM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Breastmilk being the best goes without saying, however...if you do not take in adequate amts of DHA when nursing you will not provide adequate amts of DHA in your breastmilk. DHA is dose dependant and a multitude of clinical evidence supports this. If you were to look at DHA levels across the world you would see that areas like Japan have the highest DHA levels in BM b/c their diet is mostly fish, where as area's like the Sudan have the lowest b/c they eat mainly a vegetarian based diet.

No one knows at what level DHA can be "made" from other fatty acids. Some babies may be good converters and some bad. About 90% of studies that show improvement in cognitive & develpmental improvement are all with DHA levles of .3% and up. The ones with no improvements are at less than .2%.

Another way to look at it...why would every formula company put .3% of DHA into their formula except 1?? The same 1 that puts .3% into their generic version?? Doesn't this seem odd??

I personally believe in the science behind DHA and why wouldn't you want to give it the benefit of the doubt? It doesn't cost you any more? Not to mention you only have 2 years to impact a childs brain development with DHA. After age 2 the window is closed and you can never go back. But hey..thats just my opinion.

Posted 1/18/10 12:21 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Well I knew.. its says so on the can.

But I still asked my ped.. he couldnt recommend technically one over the other but told me all the benefits of Enfamil up front. I used the generic brand of Enfamil for AJ until she went to milk.

Im surprised more mom's didn't know. I always felt like i was the slacker mom in education and my child.

Some say its a personal choice so I went with that thought. *shrug*

I chose DHA and Enfamil

Posted 1/18/10 12:41 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Breastmilk being the best goes without saying, however...if you do not take in adequate amts of DHA when nursing you will not provide adequate amts of DHA in your breastmilk. DHA is dose dependant and a multitude of clinical evidence supports this. If you were to look at DHA levels across the world you would see that areas like Japan have the highest DHA levels in BM b/c their diet is mostly fish, where as area's like the Sudan have the lowest b/c they eat mainly a vegetarian based diet.

No one knows at what level DHA can be "made" from other fatty acids. Some babies may be good converters and some bad. About 90% of studies that show improvement in cognitive & develpmental improvement are all with DHA levles of .3% and up. The ones with no improvements are at less than .2%.

Another way to look at it...why would every formula company put .3% of DHA into their formula except 1?? The same 1 that puts .3% into their generic version?? Doesn't this seem odd??

I personally believe in the science behind DHA and why wouldn't you want to give it the benefit of the doubt? It doesn't cost you any more? Not to mention you only have 2 years to impact a childs brain development with DHA. After age 2 the window is closed and you can never go back. But hey..thats just my opinion.

Yes but at the same time it's falls back into the category of it's not the same in formula as it is in a woman's body. It's made in a lab!! It's SYNTHETIC!!! I mean we are a world turning organic by the second why would you want anything SYNTHETIC in your babies formula. Also there have been no studies showing the long term effects of Synthetic DHA in formula. Not to include it was put in formula simply as a marketing tool that formula is closer to mothers milk now more so than ever. the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) expressed concern to Martek about the safety of the new additive, indicating that the agency desired to convene a formal meeting to address the issue. Martek denied this request and, shortly thereafter, the FDA reversed its previous stance and approved the additive's use despite the lack of any independent scientific safety review. The FDA never launched an investigation either on this. Not to include Synthetic DHA is giving more and more infants Gastrointestinal problems.

Posted 1/18/10 12:47 AM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Wow that's shocking. The hospital started him on Simalac too but I switched him to Enfamil. Why would they start them on Simalac?

Posted 1/18/10 9:22 AM
 

mooshyboo
So Blessed!

Member since 11/07

6297 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I knew the DHA level ~ I did choose Enfamil. (and thankful that it worked well with my son)

I did not know Similac did not meet those DHA standards ~ that is not right! Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 9:25 AM
 

Ladybug3
Two is better than one!!!

Member since 12/07

4474 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I used similac for my DS and now I'm Chat Icon as to why my ped never mentioned this to me.

Posted 1/18/10 9:28 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I did not know this, but my daughter has been on Similac Alimentium since she was 2 months old. I had no choice as she did not do well on other formulas. For me personally, her comfort was and is what's most important to me.

Posted 1/18/10 9:29 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by MrsRbk

I did not know this, but my daughter has been on Similac Alimentium since she was 2 months old. I had no choice as she did not do well on other formulas. For me personally, her comfort was and is what's most important to me.



ditto. i feel like this information is trying to scare us. babies have been on formula with out DHA for ages and im sure most of us are fine.

I have to go with what is going to agree with DH's belly so he can eat. I also supplement with vitamin drops in his formula 1x a day.

Posted 1/18/10 10:07 AM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by sal79

i didnt know this, but i breastfeed with no supplemetning, so i know nothing about formula. if i wa using formul, yes, i would care


same

Posted 1/18/10 10:52 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I did know this and BF my twins until 3(for my son with food allergies-he went on Nutramigen AA) and 6 months for the other. Then put him on Good Start Natural Cultures. But thanks for posting. I love when you postChat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 10:58 AM
 

luckyinlove
I love my baby girls!

Member since 12/06

2441 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Thank you for this. I too BF my DD and at 10 months just started supplementing a little, but use Good Start. I don't eat a diet high in fish and worry that my BM did not have enough DHA in it. I have to start taking a supplement, i suppose.

Posted 1/18/10 11:06 AM
 

BeachMom
Love my 4 kiddos!

Member since 11/08

8346 total posts

Name:
Kristie

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

My ped did tell us about the DHS level. Problem is my DD can only have the SIMILAC SENSITIVE RS, and the ENFAMIL and other similar brands bound her up sooo much she was in constant pain.

Honestly, i don't see what the big deal is. I have a 9 year old daughter who never had DHA in her formula and is very smart. The DHA is supossed to be for healthy brain and eye development. What shows that a child with or without it is better off. Just my opinion.

Posted 1/18/10 11:11 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by teddysmama1021

Posted by hdrd0411

Breastmilk being the best goes without saying, however...if you do not take in adequate amts of DHA when nursing you will not provide adequate amts of DHA in your breastmilk. DHA is dose dependant and a multitude of clinical evidence supports this. If you were to look at DHA levels across the world you would see that areas like Japan have the highest DHA levels in BM b/c their diet is mostly fish, where as area's like the Sudan have the lowest b/c they eat mainly a vegetarian based diet.

No one knows at what level DHA can be "made" from other fatty acids. Some babies may be good converters and some bad. About 90% of studies that show improvement in cognitive & develpmental improvement are all with DHA levles of .3% and up. The ones with no improvements are at less than .2%.

Another way to look at it...why would every formula company put .3% of DHA into their formula except 1?? The same 1 that puts .3% into their generic version?? Doesn't this seem odd??

I personally believe in the science behind DHA and why wouldn't you want to give it the benefit of the doubt? It doesn't cost you any more? Not to mention you only have 2 years to impact a childs brain development with DHA. After age 2 the window is closed and you can never go back. But hey..thats just my opinion.

Yes but at the same time it's falls back into the category of it's not the same in formula as it is in a woman's body. It's made in a lab!! It's SYNTHETIC!!! I mean we are a world turning organic by the second why would you want anything SYNTHETIC in your babies formula. Also there have been no studies showing the long term effects of Synthetic DHA in formula. Not to include it was put in formula simply as a marketing tool that formula is closer to mothers milk now more so than ever. the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) expressed concern to Martek about the safety of the new additive, indicating that the agency desired to convene a formal meeting to address the issue. Martek denied this request and, shortly thereafter, the FDA reversed its previous stance and approved the additive's use despite the lack of any independent scientific safety review. The FDA never launched an investigation either on this. Not to include Synthetic DHA is giving more and more infants Gastrointestinal problems.



I think Tiffany makes valid points, I wonder why they arent being addressed?

Posted 1/18/10 11:13 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

For those that are shocked by this, it should be noted that the average level of DHA in North American womens breastmilk is .17%. (a study by Healthy Canada), where as in countries where fish is consumed as a high concentration of the diet, like Japan, the levels can be as high as .99%, so it is really all relative.

http://dhaomega3.org/index.php?category=health-conditions&title=Sept24-07

Posted 1/18/10 11:33 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

eh- I don't freak out about all this stuff.. it was more important to me that the Enfamil formula cans had BPA in the lining and the similac did not.

Posted 1/18/10 11:38 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Sassyz75

eh- I don't freak out about all this stuff.. it was more important to me that the Enfamil formula cans had BPA in the lining and the similac did not.



i knew the info and am not bothered by it at all

Posted 1/18/10 11:41 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Mom's who tried BFing and now use formula brownie 7/28/09 6 Parenting
HELP! New mom needs help with formula Squirl1003 6/11/09 4 Parenting
Mom's who BF and also supplement with formula.... MelToddJulia 8/25/08 25 Parenting
EDITED Q-Way tmi q for mom's of 7-9 mo olds - formula fed diaper q itsbabytime 5/2/08 6 Parenting
Mom's using Canned Formula - watch CBS2 news at 5 adeline27 12/5/07 8 Parenting
mom's with children on soy formula alex7-2 2/9/07 6 Parenting