Would you sue?

Forum Opinion Poll
(This poll is closed.)
Yes in a heartbeat 9 23.08%
No- let it go 26 66.67%
other-explain 4 10.26%
 
View poll

Thanks- got my answers!

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Thanks- got my answers!

Thanks everyone for your input! I appreciate it.

Message edited 2010-09-22 17:09:24.807000.

Posted 9/22/10 3:39 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

first of all, I would edit your post to remove any information that could play into a lawsuit.

YES, I would consult an attorney. I have a similar condition which was treated from the beginning of my pregnancy and has a normal, full term baby.

If you warned the doctor of this beforehand and they ignored it, thats negligence.

Also, they should have noticed the small placenta. They monitor these things or at least they should.

From the basics, sounds like there is a case there but of course, im sure there are MANY more details.

Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 3:42 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Why didnt you ask for the test knowing it runs in the family. Im not trying to be snarkybeithy just asking. If you knew and were concerned maybe you should have pushed for it.

And for the original question. No i would not.

Posted 9/22/10 3:43 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

First, my heart goes out to you and all that you, your DD, and family have been through.

I honestly can't say what I would do unless I was put in that position.

I will tell you that I think your heart is definitely in the right place in that you want to make sure that this kind of mistake never happens to anyone else.
How you choose to do that, well, that is up to you. I would totally understand your position no matter which way you decide to go.


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 3:46 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by JennZ

Why didnt you ask for the test knowing it runs in the family. Im not trying to be snarkybeithy just asking. If you knew and were concerned maybe you should have pushed for it.

And for the original question. No i would not.



I didnt ask for a test b/c I didnt know there was anything wrong with me until after i had my DD and went to a perinatolgist. I was under the impresssion I was fine and it was just a fluke like my OB told me. It wasnt until a specialist a few months ago ran a simple blood test and answered all of these questions. My sister did not know she had this condition either until I told her. 10 years ago when she had a preemie the test didnt exist.

Posted 9/22/10 3:47 PM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

First off, I am so sorry for what you had to go through and am so glad to hear that your DC is doing well Chat Icon

As for the original question, I probably would not sue. You said that you mentioned to your OB that your sister had gone into pre-term labor, and based on that info alone, I wouldn't have expected my OB to run any additional bloodwork/tests on me. If, on the other hand, you had known and told your OB that the blood disorder ran in your family and THEN he didn't run any additional test, that would be a different story.

Posted 9/22/10 3:50 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

yes...I would.

You gave the info. This is their job.
To deliver a healthy baby.

I am sure you were billed for the surgeries.

Posted 9/22/10 3:54 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

I understand that you are angry and that your mind can't help but go to all the what if's but I don't think i would sue. I don't think it is negligence bc there was really no reason for your OB to believe that you had a clotting disorder - the fact that your sister went into labor at 26 weeks doesn't scream clotting disorder, she probably thought it was just one of those things, a coincidence. Did you know about her clotting disorder? Did you specifically mention that to your Dr? And I would think that a clotting disorder might have affected you in other ways throughout your life, not just during pregnancy (like did you ever have problems with injuries, bleedng, bruises, your menstrual period) As for the size of the placenta - I imagine that they would not have noticed that until you were further along in your pregnancy and the baby showed intrauterine growth restriction but i'm not an MD so i'm just guessing.

Maybe take all of your energy and put it towards educating more people about this clotting disorder so that maybe you can prevent someone else from enduring all that your family has been through.

Posted 9/22/10 3:54 PM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by JennZ

Why didnt you ask for the test knowing it runs in the family. Im not trying to be snarkybeithy just asking. If you knew and were concerned maybe you should have pushed for it.

And for the original question. No i would not.



I'm sorry you had to go through this. Chat Icon Chat Icon But I am glad that your DD made it!

I agree with this - if there was something like this in my family history I was worried about in the least, I would have pushed for the tests.

I would not sue.

Posted 9/22/10 3:57 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

I wouldn't sue because it seems like your DD doesn't have an injury that will reduce her quality of life in the long run. If I'm wrong and she does, then I would absolutely sue.

If you could report this to a medical board or something like that then I would do that instead. Write letters to the doctor, the doctor's affiliated hospital and anyone else attached to him explaining everything that happened. I think he should be put on notice that he dropped the ball and he's lucky that it didn't turn out for the worse..

I'm sorry you even have to think about this. Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 3:59 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

No, I would not. Just saying your sister went into preterm labor would not be reason for them to run any blood clotting panels on you. If, on the other hand, you had known before hand your sister had a genetic blood clotting disorder and had told your OB, and they didn't test you as well, then I think you might have a case.

I am very sorry you had to go through this.

Posted 9/22/10 4:00 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

am i not one to sue generally. but if you are looking to make sure this does not happen to another baby--even 1 other--that's a good reason and i dont see how karma can get you with that being your intention.

apart from that, as much as you say it is not about money, you do not know if your baby will have any medical complications down the road, and if money from a lawsuit would benefit her down the road, it may be in her best interest for you to sue, or sue on her behalf. the dr will not hurt for money--the dr has insurance. the lawsuit affects the dr's reputation, but that is the lesson the dr needs to learn.

in any event, it cannot hurt to consult a medical malpractice atty. see what he/she has to say.

Posted 9/22/10 4:01 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by Tine73

Posted by JennZ

Why didnt you ask for the test knowing it runs in the family. Im not trying to be snarkybeithy just asking. If you knew and were concerned maybe you should have pushed for it.

And for the original question. No i would not.



I'm sorry you had to go through this. Chat Icon Chat Icon But I am glad that your DD made it!

I agree with this - if there was something like this in my family history I was worried about in the least, I would have pushed for the tests.

I would not sue.



Again, i had NO knowledge that there was any disorder but pre term birth in my family. I did not know of this blood clotting disorder until 3 months ago. Either did my sister. Thus, how can I push for something I didnt know I had- or that my sister had? Isnt that her job?

What I mean is when my Dr saw my placenta results and the size of it was half of what it should have been and she told me "everything looked fine" - dont other people deserve a Dr with a bit more time and knowledge than I got?

Posted 9/22/10 4:02 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

First, I am sorry for what you went through.

Based on what you said, as an attorney myself, I would not sue. Honestly, there was no reason for the OB to believe that you needed genetic testing, even based upon your sister's early birth unless you gave the doctor other facts that you maybe did not mention in your post that would put the reasonable doctor on notice that such testing was needed. If your doctor had any reason to know that you had a blood disorder then it is a different story. Otherwise, it is a mere coincidence until you see a specialist. If this was your second DC, it would be different.

Posted 9/22/10 4:05 PM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

I personally wouldn't sue, it would cause me more grief than good. I WOULD, however, spread the word on your experience with the Dr/Practice.

Posted 9/22/10 4:05 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by munchkinfacemama

First, I am sorry for what you went through.

Based on what you said, as an attorney myself, I would not sue. Honestly, there was no reason for the OB to believe that you needed genetic testing, even based upon your sister's early birth unless you gave the doctor other facts that you maybe did not mention in your post that would put the reasonable doctor on notice that such testing was needed. If your doctor had any reason to know that you had a blood disorder then it is a different story. Otherwise, it is a mere coincidence until you see a specialist. If this was your second DC, it would be different.



ITA with this. My co-worker found out she had a blood clotting disorder after she had her 2 children.

Posted 9/22/10 4:08 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by Shorty

I personally wouldn't sue, it would cause me more grief than good. I WOULD, however, spread the word on your experience with the Dr/Practice.



this is exactly my struggle. The pain is just so deep that i dont know if I could go through it and drag it all to the surface again. I thought about a letter to the Dr. and maybe spread the word some how as well. I think all would be shocked to know who it was since I got her from here.

Posted 9/22/10 4:08 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

I would probably consult an attorney to see what they thought.

My cousin's wife is almost full term. About midway through her pregnancy the doctors noticed on a sonogram that there was a rare problem with her umbilical cord or placenta - I'm not entirely sure what it is. It's so rare her doctor has never seen it, and he had to consult with some specialist in the city. Anyhow, they've been monitoring her closely to see if they need to induce her early since it could create a health issue for the baby.

If they can spot a rare problem from a sonogram, I'd imagine a placenta that's half the size of a normal one would be easy to spot as well. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-09-22 16:14:15.707000.

Posted 9/22/10 4:12 PM
 

mrskmurphy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/09

688 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

I would definitely do it - what I think is the key point is that they didn't notice the small (almost non-existent!!!????) placenta!!! That ABSOLUTELY should have been seen during basic pregnancy monitoring and should have been a red flag, causing the dr. to order the blood test you're talking about.

The fact that the small placenta went unnoticed, untreated, etc...is where I think you may have a case for negligence.

If everything were perfectly normal and the dr. just didn't order the bloodtest, I would say no, but considering the placenta issue...that would REALLY really upset me enough to sue. hands down.

Posted 9/22/10 4:30 PM
 

LoveMySMT09
<3mySMT.AJT

Member since 1/09

2623 total posts

Name:
VT

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Im so sorry you went through all that!!


I have clotting disorders too. Factor V, Protein S, etc.

The only reason I know is because I was considered "high-risk" because of my congenital heart defects. My twin sister was then tested when she was pregnant because of my disorders (but we're identical twins so it was obvious she'd have them too . . .)


With that said, these specific genetic tests are usually ONLY done by a periantologist, not a regular OB-GYN. They only test for them if they know there is a reason to do it.


I probably wouldn't sue. IMHO there was no reason for your OB to test for thrombophilia. They didn't know what caused your sis' pre-t labor.


Im so sorry! Chat Icon


ETS
Im more on the fence now that I think about the placenta issue.

Im an ultrasound tech so im thinking about the technical side of it. If the placent was thrombosed EARLY in the pregnancy it would be EASY to see. As the baby gets bigger it's much tougher to diagnose a clot because you can't see it as well. Also, there are many things that can cause placental issues. A two vessel umbillical cord, a poor umbillical cord implanation site, as well as clots and others. If they didnt actually see a clot then there would be no reason to test for clotting issues.

Message edited 2010-09-22 16:37:58.240000.

Posted 9/22/10 4:32 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by Shorty

I personally wouldn't sue, it would cause me more grief than good. I WOULD, however, spread the word on your experience with the Dr/Practice.



this is exactly my struggle. The pain is just so deep that i dont know if I could go through it and drag it all to the surface again. I thought about a letter to the Dr. and maybe spread the word some how as well. I think all would be shocked to know who it was since I got her from here.



if you spread it, you risk a defamation lawsuit- so I think if you really want it publicized, you need to sue.

In your situation, I would sue- like a pp said, there is no way to know if your dc will need that money for the future. I dont think as a lay person it was your responsibility to know what tests you need, thats why we go to doctors/professionals because they are supposed to know Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 4:32 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Im so sorry you went through all that!!


I have clotting disorders too. Factor V, Protein S, etc.

The only reason I know is because I was considered "high-risk" because of my congenital heart defects. My twin sister was then tested when she was pregnant because of my disorders (but we're identical twins so it was obvious she'd have them too . . .)


With that said, these specific genetic tests are usually ONLY done by a periantologist, not a regular OB-GYN. They only test for them if they know there is a reason to do it.


I probably wouldn't sue. IMHO there was no reason for your OB to test for thrombophilia. They didn't know what caused your sis' pre-t labor.


Im so sorry! Chat Icon


ETS
Im more on the fence now that I think about the placenta issue.

Im an ultrasound tech so im thinking about the technical side of it. If the placent was thrombosed EARLY in the pregnancy it would be EASY to see. As the baby gets bigger it's much tougher to diagnose a clot because you can't see it as well.



yeah and you should also know that after i had my DD and I went back for my PP check up and she looked at the placenta results and size of placenta where it specifically stated it was 50% operational and it was half the size it should have been and STILL told me the placenta was fine!??? She didnt even know how to read the &*^(& test!!!!

Thats what got me thinking that this Dr needs to be stopped.

Posted 9/22/10 4:37 PM
 

LoveMySMT09
<3mySMT.AJT

Member since 1/09

2623 total posts

Name:
VT

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Im so sorry you went through all that!!


I have clotting disorders too. Factor V, Protein S, etc.

The only reason I know is because I was considered "high-risk" because of my congenital heart defects. My twin sister was then tested when she was pregnant because of my disorders (but we're identical twins so it was obvious she'd have them too . . .)


With that said, these specific genetic tests are usually ONLY done by a periantologist, not a regular OB-GYN. They only test for them if they know there is a reason to do it.


I probably wouldn't sue. IMHO there was no reason for your OB to test for thrombophilia. They didn't know what caused your sis' pre-t labor.


Im so sorry! Chat Icon


ETS
Im more on the fence now that I think about the placenta issue.

Im an ultrasound tech so im thinking about the technical side of it. If the placent was thrombosed EARLY in the pregnancy it would be EASY to see. As the baby gets bigger it's much tougher to diagnose a clot because you can't see it as well.



yeah and you should also know that after i had my DD and I went back for my PP check up and she looked at the placenta results and size of placenta where it specifically stated it was 50% operational and it was half the size it should have been and STILL told me the placenta was fine!??? She didnt even know how to read the &*^(& test!!!!

Thats what got me thinking that this Dr needs to be stopped.



Did they see and document thrombus/clots? At what point did they see/doc them?

Posted 9/22/10 4:39 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Im so sorry you went through all that!!


I have clotting disorders too. Factor V, Protein S, etc.

The only reason I know is because I was considered "high-risk" because of my congenital heart defects. My twin sister was then tested when she was pregnant because of my disorders (but we're identical twins so it was obvious she'd have them too . . .)


With that said, these specific genetic tests are usually ONLY done by a periantologist, not a regular OB-GYN. They only test for them if they know there is a reason to do it.


I probably wouldn't sue. IMHO there was no reason for your OB to test for thrombophilia. They didn't know what caused your sis' pre-t labor.


Im so sorry! Chat Icon


ETS
Im more on the fence now that I think about the placenta issue.

Im an ultrasound tech so im thinking about the technical side of it. If the placent was thrombosed EARLY in the pregnancy it would be EASY to see. As the baby gets bigger it's much tougher to diagnose a clot because you can't see it as well.



yeah and you should also know that after i had my DD and I went back for my PP check up and she looked at the placenta results and size of placenta where it specifically stated it was 50% operational and it was half the size it should have been and STILL told me the placenta was fine!??? She didnt even know how to read the &*^(& test!!!!

Thats what got me thinking that this Dr needs to be stopped.



Did they see and document thrombus/clots? At what point did they see/doc them?



No the placenta report came back that it was 50% non operational and much smaller than the normal 27 weeks a placenta should be. I then went on my own to a specialist who tested me for the blood clot disorder. The specialist is the one who told me what caused it. My OB still has no clue- she was too busy telling me my placenta was fine!

Posted 9/22/10 4:42 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Im sorry, first of all.

But no, I would not sue. I dont feel like it was malpractice. There are a million things that could go wrong in any pregnancy and Drs cant test for all of them for all people. They have no way of knowing what the future holds for a seemingly healthy patient.

I think if it were me, and I knew my sister had a blood clotting disorder that I knew caused her to go into preterm labor, I wouldve specifically asked to be tested for it.

Posted 9/22/10 4:44 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Updated with Name!!! Sue (littlejoy06) had her baby!! Melissa77 7/29/10 26 Pregnancy
Would you sue the daycare if your DC fell and needed stitches? Bridex100 4/26/10 53 Parenting
Have we gone sue happy? Do you agree with this lawsuit? jerseypanda 8/11/09 20 Families Helping Families ™
so sue me for giving my DD a lolipop!!! dawnygirl25 11/18/08 58 Parenting
What Would Paris Do? Sue MTV Over Sketchy Sketch? MrsQ 4/4/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
What would you do? Sue for mistreatment? LIMOMx2 2/13/07 4 Families Helping Families ™