Would you sue?

Forum Opinion Poll
(This poll is closed.)
Yes in a heartbeat 9 23.08%
No- let it go 26 66.67%
other-explain 4 10.26%
 
View poll

Thanks- got my answers!

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

LoveMySMT09
<3mySMT.AJT

Member since 1/09

2623 total posts

Name:
VT

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by sweetsurprise09

Im so sorry you went through all that!!


I have clotting disorders too. Factor V, Protein S, etc.

The only reason I know is because I was considered "high-risk" because of my congenital heart defects. My twin sister was then tested when she was pregnant because of my disorders (but we're identical twins so it was obvious she'd have them too . . .)


With that said, these specific genetic tests are usually ONLY done by a periantologist, not a regular OB-GYN. They only test for them if they know there is a reason to do it.


I probably wouldn't sue. IMHO there was no reason for your OB to test for thrombophilia. They didn't know what caused your sis' pre-t labor.


Im so sorry! Chat Icon


ETS
Im more on the fence now that I think about the placenta issue.

Im an ultrasound tech so im thinking about the technical side of it. If the placent was thrombosed EARLY in the pregnancy it would be EASY to see. As the baby gets bigger it's much tougher to diagnose a clot because you can't see it as well.



yeah and you should also know that after i had my DD and I went back for my PP check up and she looked at the placenta results and size of placenta where it specifically stated it was 50% operational and it was half the size it should have been and STILL told me the placenta was fine!??? She didnt even know how to read the &*^(& test!!!!

Thats what got me thinking that this Dr needs to be stopped.



Did they see and document thrombus/clots? At what point did they see/doc them?



No the placenta report came back that it was 50% non operational and much smaller than the normal 27 weeks a placenta should be. I then went on my own to a specialist who tested me for the blood clot disorder. The specialist is the one who told me what caused it. My OB still has no clue- she was too busy telling me my placenta was fine!



hoenstly then -- if there was no documentation that the placental failure was caused by thrombosis, I dont think there's much of a case. If there is no evidence it was indeed thrombus (documented) then there was no reason to order the tests to check for thrombophilia. And honestly, from a professional standpoint, if they didnt SEE clots, and document clots, they shouldnt have told you that's what cause this. THey dont KNOW that for sure. KWIM? It could be a coincidence. Is it very possible that it was thrombus? Sure. But there is no proof

Chat Icon

Im sorry. And im not an attorney or anything, just my honest opinion.

Posted 9/22/10 4:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by eddiesmommy

Im sorry, first of all.

But no, I would not sue. I dont feel like it was malpractice. There are a million things that could go wrong in any pregnancy and Drs cant test for all of them for all people. They have no way of knowing what the future holds for a seemingly healthy patient.

I think if it were me, and I knew my sister had a blood clotting disorder that I knew caused her to go into preterm labor, I wouldve specifically asked to be tested for it.




AGAIN my sister and my self DID NOT KNOW WE HAD A DISORDER until 3 months ago- well after we had our children. Do you really think I would have known this and not gotten a test for it? Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 4:48 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by eddiesmommy

Im sorry, first of all.

But no, I would not sue. I dont feel like it was malpractice. There are a million things that could go wrong in any pregnancy and Drs cant test for all of them for all people. They have no way of knowing what the future holds for a seemingly healthy patient.

I think if it were me, and I knew my sister had a blood clotting disorder that I knew caused her to go into preterm labor, I wouldve specifically asked to be tested for it.




AGAIN my sister and my self DID NOT KNOW WE HAD A DISORDER until 3 months ago- well after we had our children. Do you really think I would have known this and not gotten a test for it? Chat Icon




You said inyour op that you told the dr your sister had an unexplained preterm birth. So if it were me i would have said are there any issues/ test i should consider since my sister went into labor early.

Posted 9/22/10 4:59 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by eddiesmommy

Im sorry, first of all.

But no, I would not sue. I dont feel like it was malpractice. There are a million things that could go wrong in any pregnancy and Drs cant test for all of them for all people. They have no way of knowing what the future holds for a seemingly healthy patient.

I think if it were me, and I knew my sister had a blood clotting disorder that I knew caused her to go into preterm labor, I wouldve specifically asked to be tested for it.




AGAIN my sister and my self DID NOT KNOW WE HAD A DISORDER until 3 months ago- well after we had our children. Do you really think I would have known this and not gotten a test for it? Chat Icon



OK, so I understand that both of u didn't know about the disorder, and both went into preterm labor, possibly bc of this clotting disorder. I'm not sure that you and your sister used the same Dr., it doesn't seem like it, but if you were to sue, wouldn't your sister have the same grounds to sue, that they basically missed a blood clotting disorder..I don't think there is a case honestly..I'm not sure what would cause a dr to test for blood clotting disorders, but it doesn't seem like anything that you exhibited during your pregnancy would have made them test...I'm sooo sorry you wen through such hell, but honestly I don't think there is grounds here for the dr to be suedChat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 5:00 PM
 

mamaesq
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

91 total posts

Name:

Re: Would you sue?_long need help

Posted by JennZ

Posted by mamaesq

Posted by eddiesmommy

Im sorry, first of all.

But no, I would not sue. I dont feel like it was malpractice. There are a million things that could go wrong in any pregnancy and Drs cant test for all of them for all people. They have no way of knowing what the future holds for a seemingly healthy patient.

I think if it were me, and I knew my sister had a blood clotting disorder that I knew caused her to go into preterm labor, I wouldve specifically asked to be tested for it.






AGAIN my sister and my self DID NOT KNOW WE HAD A DISORDER until 3 months ago- well after we had our children. Do you really think I would have known this and not gotten a test for it? Chat Icon




You said inyour op that you told the dr your sister had an unexplained preterm birth. So if it were me i would have said are there any issues/ test i should consider since my sister went into labor early.



And yes, I did that- and obviously this Dr didnt feel a test was neccesary to check for blood clots and I dont have a medical degree to run down a list of blood tests to tell her to run- do you?

Do you think that telling me I should have asked for certain tests is helpful and making me feel like some how this is my fault and you some how walk on water? Wow...just wow.

Posted 9/22/10 5:03 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Thanks- got my answers!

Listen. I think you need to relax. Im just stating that if *I* knew this info and it was ME yes i would have asked. I dont think i walk on water. You asked for opinions you got one. Take it or leave it.

Posted 9/22/10 5:13 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Thanks- got my answers!

Well the post was edited before I can read it, but I get the gist of it.

I honestly would not sue. I know many people that went into pre-term labor, for no real reason (or unexplained) at all. There are so many things that can go wrong in a pregnancy, and a doctor cannot possibly predict everything or test for each and everything. I dont think insurance would cover it either, unless there were very clear symptoms that something was wrong, and even then I could see it being a problem.

I do understand your concern with the abnormally small placenta, but if they baby looked fine, thats probably why no additional testing was done.

Posted 9/22/10 6:07 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Thanks- got my answers!

I'm not 100% sure what happened since your original post is deleted. I'm not sure if there are any current issues or if you lost a pregnancy due to the blood-clotting issues.
I will, however, give you my story first-hand.
I got pregnant after 5 long years of IF treatment. Normal, happy wonderful pregnancy. First person in my family to get pregnant. At 16 weeks, I had unexplained bleeding (a lot of it), went to OB, rushed to a sono, unexplained - poss a blood clot. Told to take it easy for a couple weeks and come back. No more bleeding, no more problems. At 21 weeks I felt something weird...turns out my cervix "opened" and my amniotic sac was protruding...did 1 week of transverse bedrest (upside down in a hospital bed, bedpan, catheter, no showers) only to lose our son after all.
Now this brings me to my next pregnancy....full on perinatal care...every 10 days I was at a Dr., sonograms every 2 weeks, full bedrest at 20 weeks. My sister gets PG a month after me, tell her OB about my story - because we apparently have a genetic issue in my family with connective tissue - and you know what he tells her?
EVERY person is different....he did NO additional testing for her, no additional treatments, NOTHING!! And I ended up having my son at 34 weeks - as soon as they allowed me one outing. and she had to be induced at 42 weeks. And she has much more of an issue with the genetic disorder....
So, longwinded though this may be...no I would not sue. You didn't know what the issue was at the time that caused your sister to lose the pregnancy so what would they test for? As far as the placental issue, my best friend had an extremely small placenta throughout her entire pregnancy, they made note of it at her 12 week sono, and she had a completely normal pregnancy and childbirth. So a small placenta is no guarantee that there is an issue either.

Posted 9/23/10 12:54 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Updated with Name!!! Sue (littlejoy06) had her baby!! Melissa77 7/29/10 26 Pregnancy
Would you sue the daycare if your DC fell and needed stitches? Bridex100 4/26/10 53 Parenting
Have we gone sue happy? Do you agree with this lawsuit? jerseypanda 8/11/09 20 Families Helping Families ™
so sue me for giving my DD a lolipop!!! dawnygirl25 11/18/08 58 Parenting
What Would Paris Do? Sue MTV Over Sketchy Sketch? MrsQ 4/4/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
What would you do? Sue for mistreatment? LIMOMx2 2/13/07 4 Families Helping Families ™