Would you lie about this question to give blood, if you knew you were disease free?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, there's such a great need for blood and it's an outdated question 16 12.70%
Yes, but only if I were giving directly to a friend or family member (not at a drive) 6 4.76%
I'm completely on the fence about it. 5 3.97%
No, rules are rules even if I disagree with them 88 69.84%
I would never donate blood regardless 8 6.35%
Obligatory other 3 2.38%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I understand the testing issues, but this also applies to heterosexual people. I still want to know the statistics regarding whether or not a gay man (or a man who has had sex with another man) is more likely to be HIV positive than a heterosexual person. I'm asking honestly - I just don't know.




Absolutely. Anal sex is deemed absolutely more risky, due to the fragile and vascular nature of the colon. In addition, in the homosexual population, it is much more commonplace to have multiple partners. So anal sex is the most risky, then vaginal sex, then oral sex. It's all about blood supply, lack of oxygen and blood to blood contact.

So anal sex is a very prominent way to contract HIV.



I understand that, but as a population, are gay men more likely to have HIV than heterosexual people or lesbians? I understand the behavior is higher risk for contracting it, but does it in fact translate today to a population of people who have higher instances of HIV such that the entire population of people is that much riskier? I wouldn't be surprised if it did, but I haven't see any statistics to back it up. (And, in 2007, statistics WERE given to the ARC (I think) attempting to prove that it was not unsafe to allow gay men to donate blood. Of course, the ARC didn't accept it as enough proof... so I don't know exactly what the statistics show.)

Also, what I edited to add to my post... Why can a woman who has has sex with a man who has had sex with a man donate a year later -- but the man can never donate again, even if he never has sex with another man again?




Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.

Posted 2/12/10 3:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by SusiBee

During my mother's illness, she received a number of blood transfusions. I was able to bank some of my blood for her, but not enough.

It is a really scary thought that someone who donated blood may have lied about their health just so that they could continue to donate, thereby jeopardizing the fragile health of someone else.

It is a great thing to donate blood - it helps so many people in need.



I've received blood myself and several family members have gotten transfusions and received blood during surgery. I COMPLETELY agree -- and nothing I'm saying indicates that I think people should lie to donate blood.

I am just questioning whether this particular question has a valid basis anymore. It very well might as others have explained... but there are many groups out there offering evidence that it isn't necessary (or safer) to ban any man who has ever had sexual contact with a man from donating blood.

Posted 2/12/10 3:20 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by SusiBee

During my mother's illness, she received a number of blood transfusions. I was able to bank some of my blood for her, but not enough.

It is a really scary thought that someone who donated blood may have lied about their health just so that they could continue to donate, thereby jeopardizing the fragile health of someone else.

It is a great thing to donate blood - it helps so many people in need.



And that's all that matter in the end!

We give blood to help. Not to endanger anyone else! And once we want to help nobody likes to be "rejected".

But if we are not eligible so be it! We try to help but how is lying going to help anyone. There are reasons for those questions. To screen eligible people.

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:22:06.767000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:21 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster


Yes, gay men or anyone who has sex with multiple partners, or riskier type sexual behaviors remain the most at risk.



Yes, you are right. I finally took 5 minutes to search for the statistics. (Didn't mean to argue with you - was just asking honest questions).

I found a CDC citation that backs up what you are saying. This also helps explain:



http://www.cdc.gov/NCHHSTP/newsroom/docs/FastFacts-MSM-FINAL508COMP.pdf

Gay and bisexual men — referred to in CDC surveillance systems as men who have sex with men (MSM)1 — of all
races continue to be the risk group most severely affected by HIV. Additionally, this is the only risk group in the U.S. in
which the annual number of new HIV infections is increasing. There is an urgent need to expand access to proven HIV
prevention interventions for gay and bisexual men, as well as to develop new approaches to fight HIV in this population.

Posted 2/12/10 3:24 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

And Goobster, thanks for answering all of my questions. Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 3:25 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster


Yes, gay men or anyone who has sex with multiple partners, or riskier type sexual behaviors remain the most at risk.



Yes, you are right. I finally took 5 minutes to search for the statistics. (Didn't mean to argue with you - was just asking honest questions).

I found a CDC citation that backs up what you are saying. This also helps explain:



http://www.cdc.gov/NCHHSTP/newsroom/docs/FastFacts-MSM-FINAL508COMP.pdf

Gay and bisexual men — referred to in CDC surveillance systems as men who have sex with men (MSM)1 — of all
races continue to be the risk group most severely affected by HIV. Additionally, this is the only risk group in the U.S. in
which the annual number of new HIV infections is increasing. There is an urgent need to expand access to proven HIV
prevention interventions for gay and bisexual men, as well as to develop new approaches to fight HIV in this population.




Dont forget, they dont have to worry about pregnancy. So other than disease prevention, they have no other use for condoms, kwim? With women, there is more than one reason to use a condom (prevent disease and a baby). Most times with heterosexual sex, people use condoms to prevent pregnancy, over STD prevention. B/c people often think the person they are with "cannot" have a disease.

Also, historically, males are very sexual in nature, whereas women often want more romance (generalizations here but you get the idea). This sexually charged behavior of a male also adds to males acting without hesitancy to think ahead and use protection.

Message edited 2010-02-12 18:33:34.563000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:26 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?

Posted 2/12/10 3:33 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

And Goobster, thanks for answering all of my questions. Chat Icon



Hey no problem. Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 3:35 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?



I havent donate for several yrs, but I remember them asking very invasive questions.

And one was have you had anal sex? how many times in your life and when was the last time?

They were similiar to the questions asked when taking an HIV test at those clinics.

Posted 2/12/10 3:36 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?



I haven't been able to donate blood in the last couple of years, but I previously was never asked this question.

Posted 2/12/10 3:36 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?



I haven't been able to donate blood in the last couple of years, but I previously was never asked this question.



interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.

Message edited 2010-02-12 15:40:34.960000.

Posted 2/12/10 3:40 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Sash

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?



I haven't been able to donate blood in the last couple of years, but I previously was never asked this question.



interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.Chat Icon Chat Icon



OMG, that must have been terrifying! Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 3:40 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Sash
interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.



Can I ask you, did you ever find out what the antibodies truly were?

Posted 2/12/10 3:41 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?




That was a few years ago, but I was asked about HIV/Aids, sexual activity history, etc...

Posted 2/12/10 3:46 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash
interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.



Can I ask you, did you ever find out what the antibodies truly were?



No, because after closely reading the letter and having my DH then Fiance read it. It was saying something along the lines that some anti bodies can look like the HIV anti bodies but it doesnt mean it HIV. It also stated I can donate again in 6 months, so I pretty much assumed I didnt have the virus.

Even though I am married and have one partner. I always agree to get STD tested everytime im asked by my physicians. The anitbody issue hasnt come up again.

Posted 2/12/10 3:47 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Kara

Posted by Sash

Posted by Kara

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash

Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.



That's why I asked, do they ask this of all donors?



I haven't been able to donate blood in the last couple of years, but I previously was never asked this question.



interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.Chat Icon Chat Icon



OMG, that must have been terrifying! Chat Icon




Yes it was. Cause when I read the letter all i could see was HIV and I cried before even reading the whole thing clearly.

I have family members who live with the virus and some who died of it. And in those several moments I felt like my life was over. It actually gave me a new level of respect for people who live with HIV and dont see it as a death sentence and live their life promoting awareness.

Posted 2/12/10 3:50 PM
 

AnonyMouse
LIF Zygote

Member since 12/09

6 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Thx everyone for responding. Thank you especially to the people who explained the statistics and why the rule exists. That makes me feel better about it.

I think I will take a PP's suggestion and see if I can do some type of volunteer work for one of the organizations that run blood drives, even if I can't donate.

Posted 2/12/10 6:18 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

As someone who just received 8 transfusions, I really really pray that my donors were honest about their past. As grateful as I am for the donors, I am scared to death that down the road I will find out I have contracted something.

Posted 2/12/10 11:27 PM
 

LastLightGlow
Mystic.

Member since 4/07

2665 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I would say that these exaggerated inclusive rules really only target a very small population that is at higher risk, but i think when it comes to blood transfusions, safer is better.

I often have to obtain consent from patients to receive blood transfusions and I have to answer questions about risks of infection transmission from those who are hesitant. Most of these patients remember the early 80s when there were a good amount of hepatitis and HIV transmission through transfusion.

I want to be able to continue to tell them how strict the regulations and screening is at the blood bank to prevent the spread of infection. If you or a family member needed a transfusion I think you will feel the same way.

Posted 2/13/10 5:01 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by TuttsyLow
I want to be able to continue to tell them how strict the regulations and screening is at the blood bank to prevent the spread of infection. If you or a family member needed a transfusion I think you will feel the same way.



The reality is though that new diseases can always surface, such as HIV did and Hep C did. That is why at risk groups must always be honest. Anyone donating must always be honest b/c there are greater reasons than they realize. A new disease could come out tomorrow that was in the blood supply that they did not test for b/c they did not know it existed. So if you were at a greater risk for HIV< you may be at a greater risk for a disease they have yet to discover.

Think Ryan White. Or Arthur Ashe.

So please everyone be honest when giving blood, even if you test negative, your past does matter. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-02-13 08:49:34.067000.

Posted 2/13/10 8:44 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Now I am not a doctor but I assume that since blood is so very needed they would not try to reject someone unless there was real issue as to why.

Some of the questions sound outdated to me as well but I would assume that there are good health reasons for them otherwise why would they want to turn down blood that we know is in demand, KWIM?

So with that said I would not lie. I think it is very generous that you want to give blood but these regulations are put in place by health professionals who know what they are doing Chat Icon

Posted 2/13/10 9:11 AM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I think part of the reason with these questions is to rule out people they will have to reject.

So for example, it might cost them $15 to draw your blood and another $20 to test it (just making up numbers). If there is a higher % of people who engaged in certain behaviors will test negative and this blood will have to be disposed of, they might choose not to take the risk.

There are higher prevalence of HIV in certain populations (iv drug users, etc.) I believe gay men do have a higher % than straight men or straight women. I am not saying this is a gay man's disease and of course anyone can get it. I just mean this might be the reasoning as mentioned in my first paragraph.

The Blood Bank of NY is actually a business. The red cross is a non-profit. They have to fund the cost of all these drives, etc. and if they end up with too much unusable blood, it is a waste of money for them.

Posted 2/13/10 9:26 AM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Goobster

Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I had a patient yesterday who contracted Hep C from blood transfusions he had years ago. They called it Non-A Non-B Hepatitis at that time before they really knew what Hep C is all about. The people that are at highest risk for Hep C is those who are drug abusers, men who have sex with men, etc. I originally had the same thought as the OP that it seems outdated that gay men or women who had sex with a gay/bi man can't donate, but I know that its in a way helping to prevent diseases we don't know about yet from infecting people.

Posted 2/13/10 9:26 AM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

Posted by Sash

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Sash
interesting I was asked. The basically were asking about my sexual history, where I travelled and medical history. It was around 2005-2006. I was donating at my church. The took my blood but rejected it due to antibodies that look like HIV antibodiesChat Icon

I remember that letter scared the ba-jesus out of me. I had to read it 20 times, I was never so scared in my life.



Can I ask you, did you ever find out what the antibodies truly were?



No, because after closely reading the letter and having my DH then Fiance read it. It was saying something along the lines that some anti bodies can look like the HIV anti bodies but it doesnt mean it HIV. It also stated I can donate again in 6 months, so I pretty much assumed I didnt have the virus.

Even though I am married and have one partner. I always agree to get STD tested everytime im asked by my physicians. The anitbody issue hasnt come up again.



Sash, my mom got the same letter years ago. They sent it certified mail and when she picked it up at the post office and read it she said the same thing, all you see when you first look at it is HIV in bold letters. I wasn't there, but she said that she nearly passed out.
When she called them, they said that she does NOT have HIV, but that there were certain antibodies that are undetermined, and in order to be safe they cannot let her donate anymore. They claim that the antibodies can even be from a common cold.
She was so upset that she wrote a letter to the blood bank (I think it was blood bank of NY?) and let them know that they should reword that letter or just leave HIV out of it if its not testing positive because it could scare someone half to death.
She immediately had all tests (HIV, Hep ABC) done at her MD office and all was negative.

My ex-fiancee's mother also got a letter from a blood bank in PA telling her that she tested positive for Hep C. We were like what?? This woman could be a nun if she werent married. She had all tests done, including Hep C twice, and all came back negative.

My mom has autoimmune issues and my ex-FH's mother has lupus, so I wonder if that caused some test to turn positive? Chat Icon

Posted 2/13/10 9:35 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial

I'd never lie about this. However I have been anemic since gastric bypass surgery and have not been able to donate blood since. That was 7 and a half years ago.

Posted 2/13/10 11:42 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Controversial Question/Topic - Banking your newborns cord blood gabbie83 1/6/09 5 Pregnancy
Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Moehick 7/9/05 28 StoryBoard
Just an update - more blood and DHs SA MrsJ 7/9/05 6 TTC
Progesterone blood test dm24angel 6/8/05 4 TTC
Blood drive HarleyGirlFLA 6/4/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Cord Blood Registry emc 6/4/05 5 Pregnancy