Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial
Posted 2/13/2010 9:26:43 AM by imagin916


Posted by Goobster


Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I had a patient yesterday who contracted Hep C from blood transfusions he had years ago. They called it Non-A Non-B Hepatitis at that time before they really knew what Hep C is all about. The people that are at highest risk for Hep C is those who are drug abusers, men who have sex with men, etc. I originally had the same thought as the OP that it seems outdated that gay men or women who had sex with a gay/bi man can't donate, but I know that its in a way helping to prevent diseases we don't know about yet from infecting people.
Print Post      Close Window