Re: Poll about giving blood - possibly controversial
Posted 2/12/2010 3:20:09 PM by Sash


Posted by Kara


Posted by Goobster


Posted by Kara


Posted by Goobster


Posted by pinkandblue

I know that the blood is tested for HIV, no matter HOW you answer the questions so I cannot see the harm in donating Chat Icon



Well the reality is there truly is a window period that HIV may not show in the blood.

Plus, the other reality is, other diseases can surface in the future, that are linked with another disease. So my point is they cannot test for diseases they are not aware of. So this is a second reason to not give blood if you may be in the category, there truly is a window period of about 2 weeks.

For ex...years ago, they tested for Hep A and Hep B. They did not know Hep C existed so they did not test. If anyone was at risk for Hep B, they may not have had it but could have had Hep C. That's how many people contracted Hep C, through transfusions. So if you have ONE disease are at risk for, you never know if another one will surface down the road that you could have and could have exposed someone to.

Am I making sense?



I understand the testing issues, but this also applies to heterosexual people. I still want to know the statistics regarding whether or not a gay man (or a man who has had sex with another man) is more likely to be HIV positive than a heterosexual person. I'm asking honestly - I just don't know.




Absolutely. Anal sex is deemed absolutely more risky, due to the fragile and vascular nature of the colon. In addition, in the homosexual population, it is much more commonplace to have multiple partners. So anal sex is the most risky, then vaginal sex, then oral sex. It's all about blood supply, lack of oxygen and blood to blood contact.

So anal sex is a very prominent way to contract HIV.



I understand that, but as a population, are gay men more likely to have HIV than heterosexual people or lesbians? I understand the behavior is higher risk for contracting it, but does it in fact translate today to a population of people who have higher instances of HIV such that the entire population of people is that much riskier? I wouldn't be surprised if it did, but I haven't see any statistics to back it up. (And, in 2007, statistics WERE given to the ARC (I think) attempting to prove that it was not unsafe to allow gay men to donate blood. Of course, the ARC didn't accept it as enough proof... so I don't know exactly what the statistics show.)

Also, what I edited to add to my post... Why can a woman who has has sex with a man who has had sex with a man donate a year later -- but the man can never donate again, even if he never has sex with another man again?




Also homosexual men arent the only ones who have anal sex. Heterosexual (sp?) people have anal sex all the time.

But I also believe they ask if you have had anal sex before and how many times regardless of sex.
Print Post      Close Window