Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

My dd co-sleeps with us and by no means was it by choice...well at first. We brought in her furniture one month after she was born and by then she was already "used" to our bed. I also then began reading and hearing stories about SIDS and other problems in the night and I became scared. Now that she is next to us it seems nice. I would never have started this way but its how it ended up. I am still tossed between putting her in her crib or not. She is 3 months old and I definitely do not want a 4 yr old sleepig with us and I am afraid if we continue with this it will be our end result. She looks so peaceful at night...I feel bad pulling her out right now.

Posted 3/2/07 11:07 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

I have friends who co-sleep and Lua was in our bed for the first few weeks. But ultimately we decided that we weren't comfortable with it. DH would wake up in a panic 2-3 times a night thinking he had rolled over on the baby. Then he was in his bassinet until he was 3 months and now he's in his crib, in his own room. For us it's fantastic!!! We don't have to tip toe around in our own room and we have our privacy back.
But you are always going to hear two sides of the story on this one. It's a personal decision and everyone needs to do what they believe is best for their own family.

ETS- I do think that if you don't want a toddler in your bed, it's better to break the habit sooner rather than later. I have friends whose 2 year old is still in the bed and she just had a baby. Now what?! I think keeping kids in the bed after a certain point is a little selfish of the parents. I say that because the child would be fine on their own (after some time of course) it's just that the parents like the feeling of their child being close. Now of course, this is just my opinion and in no way is meant to offend anyone.

Message edited 2007-03-02 11:19:25.660000.

Posted 3/2/07 11:15 AM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

What if you try putting the cradle in his room. maybe it's the transition from the cradle to the crib.

Also, would you consider a sleep positioner? Maybe DS like the closeness of the cradle and the crib is too big and open for him. With the positioner, he will feel the cloesness around his body.

This way, you are not changing too many things at a time. Now you are changing the cradle and the room. Maybe it will be easier if you do one thing at a time.

But, Steven has always slept in his crib because I didn't have room for a cradle in my room, so I never had to do this.

Good Luck. Chat Icon

I meant to quote but didn't. This is in response to BellaDonna Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-03-02 11:22:15.207000.

Posted 3/2/07 11:19 AM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

We have an arm's reach cosleeper and DD sleeps at night in it but she also sleeps in her pack and play as well as in a moses basket that I put in her crib (hoping it will ease the transition when it is time for her to sleep in her crib at night)

Posted 3/2/07 11:20 AM
 

FireIslandLove

Member since 5/05

12119 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by MelTodd604

Julia has been sleeping in our bed since she was 2 months old, I BF her so its was just easier to have her right in the bed with me. I wanted and tried to put her in her crib, but she wanted nothing to do with it and I wasn't into CIO.....




Were you ever afraid of falling asleep while BFing and suffocating her? That was my biggest fear. I wouldn't even BF in the glider. I got up and went into the living room on the couch with the TV on to keep me awake! I always think if we have *1* next time, I would want to put that baby in the room in a bassinet where I could easily BF in bed, but I come back to that same fear that I'd fall alseep on top of him/her.

Both girls have slept in their own crib since their 3rd day home from the hospital. In the mornings if only one gets up and eats, I will bring her back to bed with me to snuggle and sometimes we doze for a few minutes and I make sure to put her in the sleep positioner. DH said you better not let them get used to it - but I don't see the harm in them coming into our bed in the morning for a little while.

Posted 3/2/07 11:25 AM
 

Belladonna219
HOT MAMA

Member since 2/07

2642 total posts

Name:
Belladonna219

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Putting his cradle in his room is the next step we are trying tonight! Hope it works! DS wiggles down the sleep positioners.

Posted 3/2/07 11:32 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

We have both of our children in our bed. We love co-sleeping. We all get a great nights sleep. It is so much easier for BF. I always said I would never do it before I had children, but never say neverChat Icon

Posted 3/2/07 11:41 AM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Interesting.... I do not co-sleep. And I have no problems with those that do. I am very lucky that both my kids sleep well in their own rooms and in their own bed and/or crib.. But for those who do, do you really get sleep? I had my DS in my bed one night when he was sick, and there was no room, I was terrrified I or my DH would roll over on him, plus he kicked in his sleep all night. I didn't get one ounce of sleep! Even up until they were 3 months old, they were in a bassinet in my room and thier sounds would keep me awake all night.

Message edited 2007-03-02 11:52:07.350000.

Posted 3/2/07 11:51 AM
 

Belladonna219
HOT MAMA

Member since 2/07

2642 total posts

Name:
Belladonna219

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by chmlengr

Interesting.... I do not co-sleep. And I have no problems with those that do. I am very lucky that both my kids sleep well in their own rooms and in their own bed and/or crib.. But for those who do, do you really get sleep? I had my DS in my bed one night when he was sick, and there was no room, I was terrrified I or my DH would roll over on him, plus he kicked in his sleep all night. I didn't get one ounce of sleep! Even up until they were 3 months old, they were in a bassinet in my room and thier sounds would keep me awake all night.



DS and I sleep better when he is in his cradle in my room..trying to transition him into his own room at this point. I would never be able to sleep either with him in my bed with me, I would be too nervous as well.

Posted 3/2/07 11:55 AM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

I didn't read the article, but I have AJ in a co-sleeper, so he has his own space but he's right by my bed. It's perfect for nursing and since I'm back to work (although only part-time) I feel like it gives me more of a chance to bond with him. I read a lot about this issue and tend to follow Dr. Sears' advice -- he's a big supporter of co-sleeping. I think the problems presented by most bad co-sleeping situations come from people who didn't choose to co-sleep, but ended-up that way b/c their children were having problems sleeping -- so the sleep problem was already there and not a result of co-sleeping.

In my own experience -- AJ takes naps on his own and goes to bed on his own (I put him to bed between 8 and 9 and go to be around 10:00) -- he doesn't cry and he doesn't fight sleep -- he's secure, so I feel like it's a healthy sleep situation for us.

Posted 3/2/07 1:53 PM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

First off I want to say I don't co-sleep and never have. I am fortunate that both my kids are fairly good sleepers. But, I do believe that you have to "train" children to sleep.

My oldest went into her crib, in her own room at six weeks. She was formula fed (after an unsuccessful stint of breast feeding) and at that point was sleeping from 11 to 5 or 6. Although I was initially uncomfortable putting her in her own room my mother convinced me that if I didn't I was risking teaching a baby that slept the night not to. In retrospect, it was the best advice she gave me. I should add that my pediatrician, who is a neighbor and a friend, likewise encouraged me to move her into her own room.

My youngest, who was not as good of a sleeper (didn't sleep through the night until 4-5 months) was in her own room and crib by 8 or 9 weeks.

I understand that this is a personal decision, but I can honestly say that I have many friends who have allowed their children to co-sleep, past the age of 2 and they are universally unhappy. I think it is so much harder on a child to transition after 6 months.

I sometimes think parents unintentionally transmit the message that sleeping alone is undesirable or a punishment. But, I believe that this is something children must learn how to do.

Interestingly enough with my oldest, I had a very hard time instituting a nap schedule. She always wound up sleeping in her swing and I was able to rationalized this to myself because she slept the night in her crib,. When, at the age of 6 months, I told my pediatrician she didn't like napping in her crib and would cry; she laughed at me and told me she needs to nap; the crib is the best place; and it was my job to teach her. After some hemming and hawing I let her cry it out for naps, and I found she slept more and was happier. Needless to say with my second, I became the "sleep nazi".

I guess everybody has to do what makes them comfortable, but I just think the older a child gets the harder it is.

I also beleive that my kids get 100% of me on days that I work and on days that I don't, but I need some alone time with my husband at night. I have a friend who jokingly says she "puts her kids away at night." This is a mom of 4, and although I might not use the same phrase, I get what she is saying and do find it pretty funny.

Posted 3/2/07 9:35 PM
 

JTK
my 4 boys!

Member since 6/06

7396 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by 2girlsforme

First off I want to say I don't co-sleep and never have. I am fortunate that both my kids are fairly good sleepers. But, I do believe that you have to "train" children to sleep.

My oldest went into her crib, in her own room at six weeks. She was formula fed (after an unsuccessful stint of breast feeding) and at that point was sleeping from 11 to 5 or 6. Although I was initially uncomfortable putting her in her own room my mother convinced me that if I didn't I was risking teaching a baby that slept the night not to. In retrospect, it was the best advice she gave me. I should add that my pediatrician, who is a neighbor and a friend, likewise encouraged me to move her into her own room.

My youngest, who was not as good of a sleeper (didn't sleep through the night until 4-5 months) was in her own room and crib by 8 or 9 weeks.

I understand that this is a personal decision, but I can honestly say that I have many friends who have allowed their children to co-sleep, past the age of 2 and they are universally unhappy. I think it is so much harder on a child to transition after 6 months.

I sometimes think parents unintentionally transmit the message that sleeping alone is undesirable or a punishment. But, I believe that this is something children must learn how to do.

Interestingly enough with my oldest, I had a very hard time instituting a nap schedule. She always wound up sleeping in her swing and I was able to rationalized this to myself because she slept the night in her crib,. When, at the age of 6 months, I told my pediatrician she didn't like napping in her crib and would cry; she laughed at me and told me she needs to nap; the crib is the best place; and it was my job to teach her. After some hemming and hawing I let her cry it out for naps, and I found she slept more and was happier. Needless to say with my second, I became the "sleep nazi".

I guess everybody has to do what makes them comfortable, but I just think the older a child gets the harder it is.

I also beleive that my kids get 100% of me on days that I work and on days that I don't, but I need some alone time with my husband at night. I have a friend who jokingly says she "puts her kids away at night." This is a mom of 4, and although I might not use the same phrase, I get what she is saying and do find it pretty funny.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/2/07 9:40 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

we did the cosleeping thing on and off. but never under the age of 18m or so.

I posted this before, but we STOPPED cold turkey when my hubby woke up and hadnt realized he had his pillow over my son's face and my son gasped for air when that happened.

that was enough to scare us out of EVER letting them sleep with us again.

Just last summer, it was big-preggo me, 2 toddlers, a body pillow and a husband all in one bed Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I DEF feel VERY strongly about NOT cosleeping with infants. It's not worth the chance. and when we saw that same chance exists with toddlers, that was it for us.

and I agree with "putting the kids away"Chat Icon It's nice to have our quiet time at night.

Posted 3/2/07 11:32 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfect™

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

I say to each his own...whatever works for you in your house is none of my business.

Personally I didn't want to do this only because I watched my nieces co-sleep with my brother and SIL and after they got to big for the bed my SIL went to their room to sleep with them....that didn't stop till the oldest was 11 and the youngest 8.....no way I wanted to do thatChat Icon

Posted 3/3/07 7:41 AM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by Moehick

I say to each his own...whatever works for you in your house is none of my business.



I agree.....for the first 2 months DS hated the bassi/ crib and the pack/play so he slept in his FP glider next to our bed....one night I saw that he was trying to turn over while in his glider and that is when I put him in his crib and he has been sleeping fine ever since..

Posted 3/3/07 8:12 AM
 

beachgirl13
Mommy to 3 boys!

Member since 5/05

4114 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

I don't judge others who do, I just personally don't want to do it. So far, so good.

Posted 3/3/07 10:01 AM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by JTK

Posted by 2girlsforme

First off I want to say I don't co-sleep and never have. I am fortunate that both my kids are fairly good sleepers. But, I do believe that you have to "train" children to sleep.

My oldest went into her crib, in her own room at six weeks. She was formula fed (after an unsuccessful stint of breast feeding) and at that point was sleeping from 11 to 5 or 6. Although I was initially uncomfortable putting her in her own room my mother convinced me that if I didn't I was risking teaching a baby that slept the night not to. In retrospect, it was the best advice she gave me. I should add that my pediatrician, who is a neighbor and a friend, likewise encouraged me to move her into her own room.

My youngest, who was not as good of a sleeper (didn't sleep through the night until 4-5 months) was in her own room and crib by 8 or 9 weeks.

I understand that this is a personal decision, but I can honestly say that I have many friends who have allowed their children to co-sleep, past the age of 2 and they are universally unhappy. I think it is so much harder on a child to transition after 6 months.

I sometimes think parents unintentionally transmit the message that sleeping alone is undesirable or a punishment. But, I believe that this is something children must learn how to do.

Interestingly enough with my oldest, I had a very hard time instituting a nap schedule. She always wound up sleeping in her swing and I was able to rationalized this to myself because she slept the night in her crib,. When, at the age of 6 months, I told my pediatrician she didn't like napping in her crib and would cry; she laughed at me and told me she needs to nap; the crib is the best place; and it was my job to teach her. After some hemming and hawing I let her cry it out for naps, and I found she slept more and was happier. Needless to say with my second, I became the "sleep nazi".

I guess everybody has to do what makes them comfortable, but I just think the older a child gets the harder it is.

I also beleive that my kids get 100% of me on days that I work and on days that I don't, but I need some alone time with my husband at night. I have a friend who jokingly says she "puts her kids away at night." This is a mom of 4, and although I might not use the same phrase, I get what she is saying and do find it pretty funny.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.

Posted 3/3/07 11:16 AM
 

Belladonna219
HOT MAMA

Member since 2/07

2642 total posts

Name:
Belladonna219

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

I think it is extremely hard to transition from co-sleeping to sleeping in the crib. Initially I didnt mind cosleeping but I dont want my son to be 3 yrs old and still sleeping with me. Last night I tried putting DS in cradle in his own room only to have him wake every so often hysterical crying. It is amazing how he knows we are not there. After a few times of going into his room to soothe him he finally fell into a good sleep. My husband was telling his co-workers of our problem and his co-workers's 7yr old son sleeps w/ his wife in one room and he sleeps alone in another room. If the Mom leaves the room the 7yr old calls out looking for her! I dont want to be in that situation so I hope tonights goes better! Wish me luck.

Posted 3/3/07 5:59 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?



This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.



OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.

Posted 3/3/07 6:13 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.



OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.



Jen, I couldn't of said it better myself! (Coming from a co-sleeping mom!) Thanks!
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/07 6:33 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by FireIslandLove

Posted by MelTodd604

Julia has been sleeping in our bed since she was 2 months old, I BF her so its was just easier to have her right in the bed with me. I wanted and tried to put her in her crib, but she wanted nothing to do with it and I wasn't into CIO.....




Were you ever afraid of falling asleep while BFing and suffocating her? That was my biggest fear. I wouldn't even BF in the glider. I got up and went into the living room on the couch with the TV on to keep me awake! I always think if we have *1* next time, I would want to put that baby in the room in a bassinet where I could easily BF in bed, but I come back to that same fear that I'd fall alseep on top of him/her.

Both girls have slept in their own crib since their 3rd day home from the hospital. In the mornings if only one gets up and eats, I will bring her back to bed with me to snuggle and sometimes we doze for a few minutes and I make sure to put her in the sleep positioner. DH said you better not let them get used to it - but I don't see the harm in them coming into our bed in the morning for a little while.






When I BF Julia I always made sure I was wide awake, I would put the TV on or prop myself up and lay her on the boppy, I would sometimes lay on my side and have her BF that way, but I was always awake!

I dont think there is anything wrong with having your baby in your bed even if its bringing them into your bed in the early morning to snuggle, you just have to be very cautious! Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/07 6:46 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.



OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.

exactly what you said is exactly how I feel. I also dont think it is a debatable topic either. Either you do it or you dont. Whatever reason you choose is fine but I hate to see people talk about future behavior problems. Many kids have far worse behavior problems that I am sure have nothing to do with co-sleeping. Just another research topic that has no basis.

Posted 3/3/07 7:12 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.



OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.

Have to say I completely agree. Thanks for taking the time to write that out. Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/07 7:44 PM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.




OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.

Have to say I completely agree. Thanks for taking the time to write that out. Chat Icon

Let me start by saying that I don't completely agree with the behavioral issues theory. I think you are right in that these issues don't stem just from co-sleeping. You state the whole idea of co-sleeping is so that you can be immediately attentive to your child's needs. So, if your child is in a room directly across the hall from you, as mine was, you couldn't immediately take care of their needs when they cried? You state that you thought it was cruel to leave your child in a room, in a big crib by herself. Isn't it more cruel to keep making children change their sleep patterns and sleeping habits? Isn't it more cruel to listen to them cry and scream for what seems like hours because they can't understand why, at this particular point in time, they can't be with mom and dad any longer? Isn't it more cruel to do this over and over again. It seems to me all this can be avoided. Yes, it's true that no one will have a teenager sleeping with them, but, just stop and think a minute how hard it was for them to adjust and what they went through.

You were lucky. Your child adapted very easily. Unfortunately, that is not true for the majority. It's akin to running a race and, just when you see the finish line, someone moves it. When you're at work and you've been working on a project for an extended length of time and you're almost done, it becomes frustrating when someone decides to change it and you have to start all over. Don't you just want to scream? We're adults and we sometimes have a hard time adjusting to change even with all the practice we've had in our lives. Just think how it is for the little ones who have had no practice whatsoever and are just trying to keep up. As I said earlier, I just don't see the logic in it.

Posted 3/3/07 8:08 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Whose bed is it anyway?

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.




OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.



Have to say I completely agree. Thanks for taking the time to write that out. Chat Icon

Let me start by saying that I don't completely agree with the behavioral issues theory. I think you are right in that these issues don't stem just from co-sleeping. You state the whole idea of co-sleeping is so that you can be immediately attentive to your child's needs. So, if your child is in a room directly across the hall from you, as mine was, you couldn't immediately take care of their needs when they cried? You state that you thought it was cruel to leave your child in a room, in a big crib by herself. Isn't it more cruel to keep making children change their sleep patterns and sleeping habits? Isn't it more cruel to listen to them cry and scream for what seems like hours because they can't understand why, at this particular point in time, they can't be with mom and dad any longer? Isn't it more cruel to do this over and over again. It seems to me all this can be avoided. Yes, it's true that no one will have a teenager sleeping with them, but, just stop and think a minute how hard it was for them to adjust and what they went through.

You were lucky. Your child adapted very easily. Unfortunately, that is not true for the majority. It's akin to running a race and, just when you see the finish line, someone moves it. When you're at work and you've been working on a project for an extended length of time and you're almost done, it becomes frustrating when someone decides to change it and you have to start all over. Don't you just want to scream? We're adults and we sometimes have a hard time adjusting to change even with all the practice we've had in our lives. Just think how it is for the little ones who have had no practice whatsoever and are just trying to keep up. As I said earlier, I just don't see the logic in it.


So in essence...your problem with co-sleeping is in regard to change? I absolutely want my child to learn change from the beginning. Thats just life. Change from one room to the next should be dd's only problem in life. I am not quite understanding your opinion towards the above poster.

Posted 3/3/07 8:27 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another Poll... Do you make your bed in the morning? randella 12/21/06 70 Families Helping Families ™
Right, going to bed now and am going to stop these long titles because its late and I am very tired. yankinmanc 8/26/06 0 Parenting
1st Trimester and Exhasted!! I am sitting at my desk dreaming about bed Janice 4/28/06 8 Pregnancy
What time do you go to bed and what time do you wake up in the morning? calendargrl 3/14/06 71 Families Helping Families ™
Moms... what do you do after the kids go to bed?? JennChris 2/18/06 24 Parenting
if u were advising the opposite sex on how to make a woman/man feel good in bed..what advice would u give.. Michi 12/29/05 4 Families Helping Families ™