Whose bed is it anyway?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] | |
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Getting back to the article -- I think the "boundary issues" they are talking about stem from over-stressed families who are co-sleeping as a coping mechanism, rather than dealing with the underlying issues. I think this type of co-sleeping is completely different from the co-sleeping some of us do, which is inspired by a parenting philosophy. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by pmpkn087 Posted by MelTodd604 IMO-disciplinary issues comes from how the children are raised, and treated by there parents! Not by if there are co-sleeping or not..... Well, they are not really saying that children who co-sleep will have diciplinary issues. They are saying that co-sleeping is a sign of weakness in parents in setting boundaries and being able to say "NO" to their children. That is the most absurd thing I have ever heard (and yes I realize you did not say it). You are supposed to set boundaries with a newborn? infant? Give me a break!! They are so vulnerable and helpless and need a ton of touch and compassion and comfort and IMO at 17 months I still feel the same about my daughter and I probably will at 2 and 3. Maybe when she's 4. 5, or 6 I may not feel as strongly about her vulnerablility and certain needs but IMO now is the time we need to give our children all the sense of safety and security we can and if that means sleeping in the same room or bed with mom and day then so be it. It's not forever. They are only little and needy one. Independence comes with age. I have no problem setting boundaries with my daughter and I am learning each day new ways to teach her and set boundaries with her and honestly if she wasn't such a light sleeper I am sure we might still be co-sleeping but I made the decision I felt was best for her and tried her own room at 6 months and it worked for us. Would the person who wrote this article say that people who don't make their kids CIO to sleep and rock them to sleep instead have boundary issues? I just always feel all these "rules" or "don'ts" are about making babies and children grow up too fast. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by pmpkn087 The article that I posted and the opinions I was anxious to hear was more in regards to OLDER children co-sleeping. I can agree with a lot of you when you say that a baby needs to feel secure and be close by, etc., however I also believe that it is important for a baby to learn how to self-soothe and feel secure when you are not 2 inches away. My feeling is that by 4 or 5 months, a baby should feel safe and secure in their own crib and know that mommy and daddy will be there when they need them. Just because one does not co-sleep does not mean that they are not there for their children. As far as the behavioral issues, I think some of you may have misunderstood. They are not saying that it is the CO-SLEEPING that leads to behavioral issues. They are saying that parents who co-sleep, are more likely to not be able to set boundaries and have a tough time saying NO. THAT, in turn, can lead to behavioral issues. Mind you, as I said above, the articles is looking at children above the age of 2 or 3 (I can't remember). Don't foret, they tell the story of a mom who is still co-sleeping with her 11 year old girls. And not happy about it. That is co-sleeping to the extreme and a totally different topic than if you co-sleep with your newborn. And almost every parent featured in the article on tried to put the child in their own room well after the age of 1. As I said, to each's own, I am not one to judge what you do behind closed doors. I don't really agree with the theory that young infants and toddlers know how to self soothe, and I'm not sure it can be taught at 4-5 months, like you mentioned. I agree that its not just co-sleeping that can cause issues, its the parent's inability to say no and hold their ground. This part of the article stood out to me. Like a lot of parents right now, Ms. Costello is a reluctant co-sleeper, too tired to disrupt a practice that may irritate one or both adults, but, in the end, seems to promise the “most amount of sleep for the most people in the house,” as Miriam K. Schneider, the mother of 11-year-old twin daughters, said. This mother, and others in the article, just don't want to works at parenting. At the end of the article it says But sleep is good, sleep is best. Indeed, the best nights, she continued, are the nights when “we don’t actively try to fix the problem, when we just give in and everybody gets a good night’s sleep.” I don't think these parents even try to fix their problem. They just take the path of least resistance. I also think there is a big difference between parents who are reluctant co-sleepers and those that consciously choose to do so. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by greeneyes361708 [ I don't think these parents even try to fix their problem. They just take the path of least resistance. I also think there is a big difference between parents who are reluctant co-sleepers and those that consciously choose to do so. I totally agree. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by greeneyes361708 I also think there is a big difference between parents who are reluctant co-sleepers and those that consciously choose to do so. I completely agree. I think people often assume that cosleepers are just lazy parents who don't want to deal where more often than not it's by choice. We chose to sleep with DD in the beginning but when it wasn't working for anyone we make the effort to try to fix the problem and we did. I can see where the types of cosleepers the article refers to have discipline problems with their children because they probably end up taking the path of least resistance in most sitatuations. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by monkeybride You are supposed to set boundaries with a newborn? infant? Give me a break!! I don't think that's what they mean. The way I took it is that a parent who reluctantly co-sleeps, is showing signs of weakness in setting boundaries for their children (in general) which will surface later on and perhaps become problematic when disciplining becomes necessary. I can completely understand that because essentially a parent who co-sleeps because they are "giving in" (as opposed to making the conscious decision because it is their preference - like you do) is, in fact letting the child win and get their way. To me that is clearly a sign of things to come. I can't believe I'm going to say this but greeneyes hit the nail on the head when she pointed out the fact that the true issue here is that the article is referring moreso to parents that are reluctantly co-sleeping.BIG difference IMO between the reluctant co-sleeper and the conscious co-sleeper. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Personally I think anyone who sleeps in actual bed with their baby is risking their childs life. How can you say for sure you won't suffocate or roll over on them while your sleeping? To each is own but IMO a risk I would not be willing to take no matter what. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by lullabella Personally I think anyone who sleeps in actual bed with their baby is risking their childs life. How can you say for sure you won't suffocate or roll over on them while your sleeping? To each is own but IMO a risk I would not be willing to take no matter what. You have a valid concern, but there are steps you take to make co-sleeping safe. They were listed earlier on this thread. As long as you follow them, co-sleeping is safe. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? I totally understand everyone's point. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? I don't believe in co-sleeping. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 3:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by pmpkn087 I totally understand everyone's point. The people in the article were all reluctant co-sleepers. However, they had to start somewhere and I'm sure that was with their infants and I'm sure it was willingly. So, how/when do you draw the line with a child that co-sleeping is no longer acceptable? Actually, I think you are wrong about how they started -- the way I read the article, the children began coming into their parent's room, not refused to leave their room. These children were likely in cribs as babies. I would say co-sleeping is no longer right when it stops working -- either the child or the parent is no longer sleeping well or feels they have outgrown the arrangement. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway?
|
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by monkeybride I'm not an expert but I think you babies and children cosleep for comfort and bonding and conveniece (when BFing). Older children want to co sleep to meet a need that isn't being met. Again all IMO and I am definitely not a child expert by any means. I agree. I think most stable children move easily into their own beds -- if they don't then they probably have other needs that should be addressed. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? I don't see how sleeping with your child- no matter how old- is disgusting.. it is your child! How can YOUR child ever be DISGUSTING to you? I don't get that. There is a point where a child is going through puberty and developing and I just don't think it is healthy for adults to sleep with their grown children.... What if its a single dad and his 12 yr old daughter? That doesn't seem strange to you? Or a single mom and a 14 yr old boy... where do you draw the line? I think its icky. Its one thing if they are little, but at the tween to teen age, its time to establish some serious boundaries..... |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by lipglossjunky73 I don't see how sleeping with your child- no matter how old- is disgusting.. it is your child! How can YOUR child ever be DISGUSTING to you? I don't get that. There is a point where a child is going through puberty and developing and I just don't think it is healthy for adults to sleep with their grown children.... What if its a single dad and his 12 yr old daughter? That doesn't seem strange to you? Or a single mom and a 14 yr old boy... where do you draw the line? I think its icky. Its one thing if they are little, but at the tween to teen age, its time to establish some serious boundaries..... I don't think parents look at their children as sexual beings and visa versa so I don't really see it as disgusting. Like I said in my previous thread something else is probably lacking if a child of that age still wants to sleep with a parent but I don't think it's disgusting. I do think the parent needs to explore why a child of that age isn't seeking out the normal independce a child of that age would. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by 5ofClubs I don't believe in co-sleeping. I don't believe it either! |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by lipglossjunky73 I don't see how sleeping with your child- no matter how old- is disgusting.. it is your child! How can YOUR child ever be DISGUSTING to you? I don't get that. There is a point where a child is going through puberty and developing and I just don't think it is healthy for adults to sleep with their grown children.... What if its a single dad and his 12 yr old daughter? That doesn't seem strange to you? Or a single mom and a 14 yr old boy... where do you draw the line? I think its icky. Its one thing if they are little, but at the tween to teen age, its time to establish some serious boundaries..... Do you think your husband would molest your child? Seriously. I slept with my dad when I was 12 when we are on vacation- I don't see how that is disgusting- he certainly didn't molest me.... Normal parents don't see their children as sex objects... |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? I'll admit that I co-sleep, although it's not really by choice. When I was working the two jobs and coming home at 10:00/11:00 at night, she would stay up so that she could see me. About a year ago, she started having horrendous night terrors. They were so bad that I HAD to sleep on the floor in her room just so that I could be close enough to her to calm her down when they started. Otherwise, I was getting up two to three times a night (and I was barely surviving on four to five hours sleep). Since I was suffering with a bad back, the floor sleeping wasn't lasting long. I started pulling her into bed with me and the terrors stopped. I tried putting her back soon after and the terrors returned. She won't fall asleep unless she's being cuddled. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by Sassyz75 Posted by lipglossjunky73 I don't see how sleeping with your child- no matter how old- is disgusting.. it is your child! How can YOUR child ever be DISGUSTING to you? I don't get that. There is a point where a child is going through puberty and developing and I just don't think it is healthy for adults to sleep with their grown children.... What if its a single dad and his 12 yr old daughter? That doesn't seem strange to you? Or a single mom and a 14 yr old boy... where do you draw the line? I think its icky. Its one thing if they are little, but at the tween to teen age, its time to establish some serious boundaries..... Do you think your husband would molest your child? Seriously. I slept with my dad when I was 12 when we are on vacation- I don't see how that is disgusting- he certainly didn't molest me.... Normal parents don't see their children as sex objects... I think that this conversation and discussion has totally derailed... People have their own opinions and parenting skills and we really have to respect them either way. Bringing up "icky", "cruel" and "molesting" iwhen talking about how someone may parent sn't nice. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? Posted by mommy2bellabean Posted by Sassyz75 Posted by lipglossjunky73 I don't see how sleeping with your child- no matter how old- is disgusting.. it is your child! How can YOUR child ever be DISGUSTING to you? I don't get that. There is a point where a child is going through puberty and developing and I just don't think it is healthy for adults to sleep with their grown children.... What if its a single dad and his 12 yr old daughter? That doesn't seem strange to you? Or a single mom and a 14 yr old boy... where do you draw the line? I think its icky. Its one thing if they are little, but at the tween to teen age, its time to establish some serious boundaries..... Do you think your husband would molest your child? Seriously. I slept with my dad when I was 12 when we are on vacation- I don't see how that is disgusting- he certainly didn't molest me.... Normal parents don't see their children as sex objects... I think that this conversation and discussion has totally derailed... People have their own opinions and parenting skills and we really have to respect them either way. Bringing up "icky", "cruel" and "molesting" iwhen talking about how someone may parent sn't nice. I agree- that is why I said in an earlier post that the way we do things in the States isn't the way it is done in the rest of the World and we have to realize there are many different ways to parent and raise healthy, successful children. |
|
Posted 3/5/07 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Whose bed is it anyway? I think that this conversation and discussion has totally derailed... Ya think? Sorry - Didn't mean to offend anyone... If this is a belief system I am not aware of, I will have to do my research. It has nothing to do with sex at all, or molesting, or anything like that. If parents and teens and preteens all feel comfortable sleeping in bed together, then go for it.... Sorry I used words that offended anyone - its not something I'm familiar with. All I know is if I had an 11 year old student tell me he/she still sleeps with mom/dad every night, it would sound a little strange.... but what do I know.... I'm just another opinion in a chat room, really - I'm not the parent of your child, so don't go by my opinion!
|
|
Posted 3/6/07 7:01 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Another Poll... Do you make your bed in the morning? | randella | 12/21/06 | 70 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Right, going to bed now and am going to stop these long titles because its late and I am very tired. | yankinmanc | 8/26/06 | 0 | Parenting |
| 1st Trimester and Exhasted!! I am sitting at my desk dreaming about bed | Janice | 4/28/06 | 8 | Pregnancy |
| What time do you go to bed and what time do you wake up in the morning? | calendargrl | 3/14/06 | 71 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Moms... what do you do after the kids go to bed?? | JennChris | 2/18/06 | 24 | Parenting |
| if u were advising the opposite sex on how to make a woman/man feel good in bed..what advice would u give.. | Michi | 12/29/05 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |





They are so vulnerable and helpless and need a ton of touch and compassion and comfort and IMO at 17 months I still feel the same about my daughter and I probably will at 2 and 3. Maybe when she's 4. 5, or 6 I may not feel as strongly about her vulnerablility and certain needs but IMO now is the time we need to give our children all the sense of safety and security we can and if that means sleeping in the same room or bed with mom and day then so be it. It's not forever. They are only little and needy one. Independence comes with age. 

but greeneyes hit the nail on the head when she pointed out the fact that the true issue here is that the article is referring moreso to parents that are reluctantly co-sleeping.



