Who is right about spoiling babies?

Posted By Message

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Who is right about spoiling babies?

DD is 1 month old and in the last week she's been getting antsy. The minute you pick her up, she falls asleep. The minute you put her down, she wakes up and starts screaming bloody murder. Dh and my parents say I'm spoiling her by picking her up so much, but I don't agree.

What do you think and if you agree with me, at what age do you think it would be spoiling DD?

Posted 2/10/11 12:10 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

You cannot spoil a 1 month old.. Now is when they are building TRUST in you!!!
"THEY" SAY that babies who trust their caregivers and knwo that they are there when they cry actually end up being better sleepers b/c they aren't "worried" that no one is there for them!!

pick up your baby and much as you want!!!Chat Icon

ETA: I think about 4 months.. they say 6 but I'd started letting them soothe themselves earlier.

Message edited 2011-02-10 12:13:05.987000.

Posted 2/10/11 12:12 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

You are not spoiling her at 1 month old. She was so close to you for 9 months and that is what makes her feel safe now.

I'd say around 3 months+ she should be able to fall asleep without being held so often.

DD is 8 months old and I still hold her sometimes when she is going to sleep. You only get to hold them sleeping when they are so small for so long, soak it all in, they grow up fast!Chat Icon

I agree with the PP, at 6 months, that is when CIO can be effective, not sooner than that.

Message edited 2011-02-10 12:15:22.240000.

Posted 2/10/11 12:13 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

They are wrong and you are right. Maybe "wrong" is harsh but that's an outdated and disproven old wives tale.
You simply CANNOT spoil a baby this young. I basically spent the first year picking DS up every time he cried longer than 30 seconds. He is not spoiled.

Posted 2/10/11 12:13 PM
 

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

She's a month old... she's an infant. I got the same thing... I think DS was about 3 months or so that I said I would stop picking her up as much. And I made it less and less as the months went on. Now, he's pretty independent at one year old. Do what YOU think is right... Chat Icon

Posted 2/10/11 12:13 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

Posted by colette

They are wrong and you are right. Maybe "wrong" is harsh but that's an outdated and disproven old wives tale.
You simply CANNOT spoil a baby this young. I basically spent the first year picking DS up every time he cried longer than 30 seconds. He is not spoiled.



ITA to every point (except I have DD instead of DS)

Posted 2/10/11 12:14 PM
 

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I always think I'm right, but it's nice to hear everyone agree with me Chat Icon

I'm going to show this to DH. Chat Icon

Posted 2/10/11 12:15 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

I HATE when people say this to me!!! Chat Icon
If my 2 month old is screaming... I'm going to pick him up. At such a young age, they NEED something, that is why they are crying... they are not trying to manipulate us LOL. My MIL and Mom drive me nuts with this. If I dont hold my baby now, WHEN will I be able to hold him?! Chat Icon

Posted 2/10/11 12:15 PM
 

MeganMylo
LIF Adult

Member since 2/09

1128 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

I believe there is NO WAY to spoil a baby @ one month. That young they have no idea how to manipulate a person, and do not understand cause and effect yet.

Dr Sears on Spoiling

ETA, I picked up my dd every time she wanted me to for almost the first year. She is now a very independent child, who often will go play alone. When she is upset though, mamma and dadda are where it's at! Chat Icon Pick up your baby, it goes WAY to fast!

Message edited 2011-02-10 12:22:11.107000.

Posted 2/10/11 12:17 PM
 

fujamaga
Loves her babies!

Member since 5/10

1513 total posts

Name:
Cathy

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

Posted by neener1211
You only get to hold them sleeping when they are so small for so long, soak it all in, they grow up fast!Chat Icon



I Chat Icon holding her little body when she's sleeping.

Posted 2/10/11 12:17 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

Posted by fujamaga

Posted by neener1211
You only get to hold them sleeping when they are so small for so long, soak it all in, they grow up fast!Chat Icon



I Chat Icon holding her little body when she's sleeping.



trust us...before you know it .. you will BLINK and be posting about her 1st birthday party theme!!!

Posted 2/10/11 12:18 PM
 

Irishgrl13
Fingers Crossed...

Member since 6/09

1301 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

I don't know....my DR told us that when the babies are that young, it doesn't matter if you hold them all the time...let them sleep on you, etc...

However, my DS is now 6mos and HATES to be put down....so, if I were to do it again, I might really push using the swing or bouncer just to get him used to not being held 24/7 for the first 2/3 months...

JMO

Posted 2/10/11 8:13 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

I dont think you can spoil that young BUT I also dont think anyone knows when babies START getting spoiled. My way was to only do things I wont mind doing or the next two years LOL so I always let DD cry a bit, tried to put her down a lot, let her play on her own, hang out alone for a bit etc.

So far, it seems to be working! She can entertain herself for a good hour before whining, is STTN, doesn't scream when I put her down etc.

Posted 2/10/11 8:18 PM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

They are 100%%%%%%%% WRONG. THey call the first 3 months of life the "4th Trimester" because babies are so incredibly helpless and you need to help them make a "Peaceful transition from the womb to the world". IF that means picking up your 1 month old when the cry, then so be it. The hard part is to know when to stop!!

Posted 2/10/11 8:19 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

you can't spoil them until around 3m... at 3m they get whats going on here

But I think the "old age" "tried and true" thing, "do not spoil a baby", because YOU get into a habit. Its you who is getting spoiled.

Babies cry to communicate, listen, you can really learn to hear what a cry means, if it means pick me up, or if it means, I'm tired leave me a lone.

Look into Dunstan baby language, it was the best thing in the world around 1m for me.

Posted 2/10/11 8:21 PM
 

FaBuLoUsMrsT08
LIF Infant

Member since 11/08

192 total posts

Name:
Krystal

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

I don't think you can spoil a 1 month old. Some people kept saying "let her cry a little"...but at that age i just didn't see the need.

Posted 2/10/11 8:39 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

You cannot spoil a 1 month old!!!!

I think spoiling begins somewhere between 4-6 months.

We had the mindset that we could not spoil an infant. We definitely spoiled DS by rocking/cuddling him to sleep.

Posted 2/10/11 9:22 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Who is right about spoiling babies?

Posted by colette

They are wrong and you are right. Maybe "wrong" is harsh but that's an outdated and disproven old wives tale.
You simply CANNOT spoil a baby this young. I basically spent the first year picking DS up every time he cried longer than 30 seconds. He is not spoiled.



ITA. A 1month old baby is incapable of manipulation.

Posted 2/10/11 9:32 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
my babies footprints 6/19/05 1 Pets
I think we are all holding out for April/May babies CookiePuss 6/14/05 14 TTC
Dear God: out of the mouths of babies HarleyGirlFLA 6/12/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
People who keep on having babies with no college funds Janice 6/9/05 22 Families Helping Families ™
my 2 babies maybride2004 6/2/05 6 Pets
Babies and sunblock JennChris 6/1/05 12 Parenting